◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
The Pirates fell behind twice tonight to Minnesota, and managed to rally back to take the lead twice. The night was capped off with a 2-run walk off home run from Bryan Reynolds. Despite Jared Jones struggling mightily in his return to the big leagues, the offense picks up the pitching yet again and wins a major game. The Pirates manage to stave off falling to .500 and continue to stay in the Wild Card chase. The Pirates have also hit the 30-win mark, and it took the 2025 Pirates until June 21st last year to hit the same win total. Watch Jim and Tyler breakdown the win here on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti’s Bros:
Can Bryan Reynolds make you facepalm repeatedly with his defensive antics? Yes. Was 2025 a disaster year for him? Also, yes. But those who want to claim that he has been a waste of money should be ignored because he continues to deliver for this team. Reynolds was already productive before winning the game, walking twice and scoring two runs. Despite the offense doing nothing against a poor Twins bullpen, Bryan Reynolds proved to be a winner and delivered the winning blow. His OPS now sits at a pretty .834, with a 136 wRC+. Bryan deserves his flowers not only for his performance in this one and this year, but also for sticking with this project and wanting to be here. Reynolds has lost a ton of baseball games here in Pittsburgh, but he has stayed and is starting to reap the benefits from such a decision. The constant criticism online of Reynolds needs to stop, because he is a Pittsburgh Pirate through and through and is going to be a major part of the first playoff push in nearly a decade.
Home Runs Are Good, Actually
Going into the season, the constant (correct) narrative is that the Pirates just need to be hovering around average. Coming into Friday, the Pirates were 13th in baseball in home runs hit. Even the playoff teams of old were usually bottom 10 in this stat, and being above average has been massive for this current team. The Pirates needed every bit of power they could get their hands on, as the last three runs to win the game came off of moonshots from Oneir Cruz and Bryan Reynolds. Continuing to hit the ball over the fence needs to keep happening, because with the bullpen collapse always imminent, home runs can be the difference between winning and losing by singular runs. The Pirates are aiming to have six players hit at least 15 home runs, which is a luxury the Pittsburgh faithful are not used to seeing.
Wilber Dotel had pedestrian numbers in AAA as a starter, and has been called up to help save the right-handed arms in the bullpen. He has responded by being a shutdown arm capable of going 3–4 innings when the pen is in desperate need of a rest. Tonight, he steadied the ship and dealt three shutout innings where he only allowed one baseman runner and struck out four. Dotel is someone who needs to remain in the bullpen this year, but if he keeps having outings like this, he will be knocking on the door of the rotation next season. His four-pitch mix was making Minnesota batters look foolish, and he was especially effective with his cutter tonight. With a gaggle of right-handed pitchers continuing to leak runs in the bullpen, Dotel ensured the Pirates remained in the game. I wonder if he’s going to be asked to make more frequent appearances for 1-2 innings a piece, so the Pirates get to pitch him in more games. Mlodzinski and Dotel could be the answers to our prayers that fix the bullpen problems.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Second and third, nobody out, down one in the eighth: should Don Kelly have pinch-hit Marcell Ozuna instead of Jake Mangum?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Tyler Sweeney and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
With runners on second and third, nobody out in the eighth and the Pirates down one, they should have sent up the $12 million bench bat Marcell Ozuna instead of pinch-hitting Jake Mangum. That's what you're paying him for.
2
The bullpen is the reason the Pirates keep losing comebacks. The offense can claw back, but the relievers haven't kept games within reach. Tonight they threw 4 2/3 scoreless innings and the team won.
3
Bryan Reynolds is fully back after a down year, with a career-best .395 OBP, a 138 wRC+ and a walk rate near 16%. He is carrying the lineup without O'Hearn and could be an All-Star again.
4
Jared Jones' return was cautiously encouraging. The stuff was all there (101.5 mph, 99 mph fastball average, 15 whiffs). Walking the bottom of the order in the second inning is what sank his line.
5
The bulk-relief role is the perfect use of Wilber Dotel. He threw 3 scoreless innings on 38 pitches at 99.3 mph, and the role is good for both the club and his development.
What's going on, everybody? Welcome to the North Shore Nine postgame show powered by Primanti brothers. This is the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. I'm Jim. Tyler is supposed to be joining me at some point. I was waiting and waiting and waiting for him to hop on here.
He texted like seven minutes ago saying his computer just shut off and is restarting. And I was like, we can't wait any longer. Like I gotta go live. These people are going nuts in the comments. The Pirates walk off the Minnesota Twins six to five tonight. I was ready to hop on here and just talk about how brutal of a game this was. You had Jerry, like everything was lining up for a pretty fun night, right?
Jared Jones first major league start after 609 days, making his 2026 debut. So he's on the mound. Then, the bullpen does an outstanding job. Like we've been, this has been the issue with this team is the bullpen. The bullpen just keeps the Pirates in it. The entire game, they go four and two thirds scoreless.
They only give up one base runner the entire game. And meanwhile, the Pirates just can't do anything after getting the Taj Bradley really early. They just can't do anything off of this twins bullpen.
And it was just like chance after chance after chance when they didn't score in that eighth inning. I thought that was it. I was like, that was their chance. That was the one chance this team had to win.
And Gregory Soto pitches a scoreless ninth.
And then Bryan Reynolds comes up huge with a walk-off homer in the ninth inning, raise the Jolly Roger, get your hashtag raise. It's in there.
We're going to be giving away sandwiches today. Tyler, it's good to see you.
Ooh, I'm sweating, but I've, I came in here fully prepared to complain tonight.
Like fully compared.
Is my mic working?
You're, everything's working. You're good. You're composed. You seem, you seem like you're 100% ready for this post game show.
Tell you what though, that felt good. That felt good to get one over on Derek Sheldon and the type of game that was.
It feels good.
maybe the best the year, like maybe the best one of the year, this team had lost two in a row.
It looked like they were about to lose a third in a row.
And then you add in the fact that, this was Jones's first start.
It didn't go great. We'll get into it, but like it wasn't, it wasn't very good, right?
He saves them with one big swing, 422 foot walk-off bomb to win this one.
So yeah, I said, we're going to get, we're going to get to all of that.
I want to start in the eighth inning though, because like, that was, that's fresh.
That's where everything's, everything we remember that again, we'll get to the bullpen, but like the bullpen does an outstanding job today of just keeping this where it was.
It was five to four after the third inning and it remained five to four until the very last swing of the game.
But let's go to that eighth inning because this was the pirate's chance.
The announcers even said, well, you expect Pittsburgh to get at least one run here.
It didn't happen.
First, I don't know if I'd throw that one on Tristan gray, like that it should have been caught.
However, neither here nor there.
but yeah, they were handed a gift and I'm with the announcers at that point.
They should be able to score a run and plain and simple.
And he just didn't get the job done in that spot.
you can't strike out there.
Just absolutely cannot do that.
You have to lift a baseball after that, where they pinch hit Jake Mangum for, your sense and Garcia.
What were you, what was your opinion of that pinch hit move?
I understood the logic at the time.
you're just looking for somebody to put the ball in play.
And in these situations, Mangum has actually done fairly well because one, he usually doesn't hit the ball very hard.
So when the infields in, even if he's putting the ball on the ground, it's usually a slowly hit ball.
If it's not right at somebody, you've got Cruz on third and you've got a pretty good chance of scoring with that said, like you gotta, I don't know, try to win this game.
Tyler, I didn't like that choice at that moment.
I would have, Garcia didn't look great at the plate tonight either, but I guess my question is down by one out bottom of the eighth runners on second and third, you've
got a guy who you're paying $12 million to on the bench.
Like, why isn't that?
I understand why, right?
Because he's having an awful season, but like, that's gotta be a Marcell Ozuna opportunity right there.
It almost has to be like, that's what you're paying him to do.
Completely with you.
And like, I'm a, I understand why you don't go Ozuna there.
And I also, I understand why they went Mangum there.
Garcia's got a lot of swing and miss in his game.
You need a ball put in play.
Jake Mangum supposed to be a guy who handles the bat very well.
And if he hits the ball on the ground, you hope that he can beat it out.
Now the infield's in there.
So a little different of a situation, but Mangum just again, didn't get the job done.
so in all in all there, I'm okay with everything Donnie Kelly did.
The guys just didn't do their jobs.
Yeah.
ND not making contact, right.
Is the first big error there.
you've got to put the ball in play.
Like you have to, and ND didn't do that, which puts them in a little bit of a, of a precarious situation.
Like, honestly, I'd rather, I don't know if I'd rather have Tyler Callihan up there, but like, I don't know if I would have put, I don't know if I would have put Mangum in there.
I probably would have gone to Ozuna, honestly.
Like that's probably what I would have done.
I think that's fair.
And then, so Mangum grounds, hits a grounder to the first baseman.
It's just like a one hop right to him.
Leads him in easy out at home.
And, yeah, Cruz is out.
And also I, like, I thought for a second there, Cruz was going to be hurt.
Like the way he slid with his hand in there.
And so thankfully he wasn't.
and then there's two outs running around first and third and Jared Triolo's up.
And I just, you had no confidence right there.
He lines out to end the inning and yeah, it was just very deflating at that point because you had to, you had to score there.
Like that was the feeling that I had was like, you had to score there.
That was your shot.
Yeah.
Again, that's where my brain is starting to go.
And I'm going to complain about this.
I'm going to complain about this.
I'm going to complain about this.
I don't have to complain tonight and it feels good.
Yeah.
That's the thing.
Like all of that, I was ready to get really upset about and yeah, like it, who cares?
Who cares at this point?
They ended up winning.
I'll give Don Kelly some credit here.
Like this was a one run game.
He goes to Gregory Soto in the ninth, which is something he typically doesn't do.
He doesn't go to Soto when they're losing.
Soto pitches the scoreless ninth inning to keep them within one.
Spencer Horwitz leads off the ninth with a single Brandon Lowe, who did not have a very good game at the plate today.
He's, I guess he's due for one of those every once in a while.
but he strikes out and then Tyler, Bryan Reynolds, I said it earlier.
He's just, he's having a hell of a season and he had a good game today too.
Just like really good plate appearances.
He had already drawn two walks in this game.
Bryan Reynolds has an on-base percentage, Tyler, of 395.
He's slugging 439.
That's an 834 OPS.
If my math is correct, just launches one into the night at a sold out PNC park.
Tyler, that's sold out 27,000 in attendance, an 80% full PNC park, Tyler on a drone show night.
and he sends everyone home very happy, biggest one of the year.
I think that's the biggest one of the year.
I would agree.
I think me and Doug have talked about this a few times that when this team loses, it feels like they just really just get beat down.
And even when they win, they don't really feel like many tight games.
I don't just anecdotally, I don't feel like we've seen the pirates really steal a game.
Outside, opening day, opening day.
They, right.
And that was two months ago.
Like it's been a while really, since you've seen the pirates just steal a game.
And tonight they absolutely did that.
It was also the first time they've won a game, Tyler, where they were losing heading into the ninth inning prior to today.
They were Oh, and 22 when trailing after eight innings.
so now they're one in 22.
So that's great.
but no, it's been, like I said, they've had this thing where once they get down, they'll claw back into games.
Like they'll tie games up, but they're not able to finish it because ultimately what happens is the bullpen blows it right.
Like that's when they get down early, it's not that the offense isn't capable of coming back.
It's just that they're not capable of keeping it within reach that's been the issue up to this point today.
You saw the bullpen do an outstanding job in the offense.
It took them longer than we wanted them to, but they did ultimately end up, getting that lead with the last swing of the game.
but yeah, just, I can't say enough about Bryan Reynolds right now.
He had a really down year last year.
And I think a lot of people were ready to like write them off.
he's on the wrong side of 30.
He's 31 years old.
Last year was his first year with a sub 100 weighted runs created plus since the shortened COVID year.
he was a, he was not a good baseball player last year.
And he's currently at a one 38 weight runs created plus this is his second best offensive season of his career.
He's seeing the ball really well.
Like you mentioned the walks he drew, the walk rate is just spiked this year.
And part of that's probably just having a little bit more talent around him.
the other part is that he's just seen the damn ball.
Well, like he's driving it.
He's doing a really good job with two strikes right now as well.
Able to work counts.
He looks like the professional hitter that we knew Bryan Reynolds as.
Yeah.
He just looks like a pro right now at the plate.
They mentioned it a lot on the broadcast too.
Oh, he crushed it.
They mentioned it a lot on the broadcast too.
How like, just having more bats in this lineup, it takes the pressure off of them.
And I don't, I don't know how much of that is the case or how much of that is just, he's just seeing the ball really well, but he's, yeah, he's putting together a really nice season.
395 OBP right now.
That's the best of his career.
He's walking at almost a 16% clip, the power, you'd still probably like to see a little bit more of it, but dude's hitting he's hitting.
So I love what I'm seeing out of Bryan Reynolds and he's stepped up here recently too with the absence of Ryan O'Hearn.
cause like without O'Hearn there, this offense is obviously a little bit limited, but this is, this is four games in a row now that Bryan Reynolds has had an extra base hit and he's now on a seven game hitting streak.
He's having a really good May and we know what happens in June with Bryan Reynolds.
I think, he was down for a bit and the last few weeks, I think he's played a lot better baseball.
Cruz and Reynolds when they're on, like, they're still major catalysts for this team.
I agree.
I agree.
Shout out Dan also for becoming a new member today.
I do want to get to, I want to get to a few things before we dive into Jared Jones.
but before we do, let's kick it over to Cody.
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64,000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
All right.
Make sure you get your hashtag raise.
It's in there.
And so we're going to be giving away some for many brother sandwiches at the end of this, but I want to, I want to go back to the beginning of this game.
it's one, nothing after the top of the first, the pirates got some good news about Konnor Griffin today.
we were a little bit concerned last night.
He sat, he was out of the lineup.
the news today was a minor strain in one of the flexors in his forearm.
Tyler, I'm not a doctor, so I'm not entirely sure what that means.
but basically they said he's cleared to hit.
He is not cleared to throw right now.
They'll assess it later on.
so he gets to start at designated hitter today, Tyler, and he made a pretty big impact in today's game, Brandon Lowe with a walk at the first, Bryan Reynolds with his first of two walks, Nick Gonzales with an infield single.
And that started the offensive onslaught here in the first inning because there was an error by Brooks Lee that allowed a run to score there.
Oneil Cruz drives in a run and then Konnor Griffin with a big RBI single two out single up the middle to score Nick Gonzales, give this team a three, one lead.
it was nice having Griffin's bat back in the lineup.
He goes two for four today, steals two bases.
He was a big part of the game.
Yeah.
When isn't he like when this kid gets the hit and his name's penciled in the lineup, he makes a difference every single time.
Like the way he's been able to swipe bags has been really impressive.
And obviously we knew we had it in him, but the way he's able to get jumps and read pictures has been really impressive.
again, two hits today.
Like can't say enough about just watching the growth of Konnor Griffin.
First inning, it just felt like the pirates might be on cruise control mode today.
I really felt like this was, this could be a blowout type of game.
Didn't turn out that way.
Maybe I'm happy it didn't because it ended up being enjoyable, but no, jump on teams early and you end up winning games.
So let's dissect Jared Jones to start a little bit.
his first game back since 2024, his final line, four and a third inning, seven hits, five runs, all earned two walks, six strikeouts.
He gives up two homers, throws 77 pitches, 53 of them for strikes.
and he's, gets a no decision in this game, but he did leave with a five or deficit in the fifth inning.
I thought there were some positives in this start.
I thought there were some negatives in this start, but I let's go through this.
what was your, what was your assessment of Jared Jones for the first time in 609 days today?
I think I was encouraged by it.
some good, some bad.
Most of the bad came in that second inning where it just lost all of his command for two batters basically.
Mm-hmm.
And then a couple pitches that he just left up in the zone and the twins are able to punish him.
First, the first inning, he gives up that home run to Clements.
it's a hundred, that's a hundred at the top of the zone inside.
Not a bad pitch.
I'm okay with him hitting that out of the park.
Yeah.
Not a bad pitch.
I'm fine with that.
I will say this.
What made it, I guess, a bad pitch is I think that was his seventh consecutive fastball to start the game.
So, if you're Clements, you're maybe just sitting on that.
I don't know, and then we can get into that in a little bit, but he was very much just pumping fastball after fastball after fastball.
Clements was sitting on it, obviously, and got a hold of it.
But at the same time, how many days has it been again?
Nine days.
I get it.
You want to get your fastball command.
It's early in your first start back.
I'm fine with it.
He did damage to something.
Hitters win sometimes.
What I was encouraged by, honestly, was the changeup to that.
He used it well against lefties.
I thought, and like, what a weird time in baseball where a 92 mile an hour pitch is a changeup, but it had some really nice movement on it.
I thought the slider looked tight today stuff wise.
I think it looked really good.
There were just some parts that, you got to knock off the rust.
Some of the command things he's going to end up shaking that off.
All in all, it was a mixed bag, but I was encouraged, cautiously encouraged by the start.
I think that's a good way to put it.
I think what I was very happy about was the stuff, like the stuff was 100% there and it was exactly how you remembered it, right?
Like the velocity was there.
He threw his hardest pitch of ever in this game, actually through one, 101.5 miles per hour and the velocity was there.
And not only was it there early, but he, it, he maintained it.
he averaged on that fastball.
let's see average fastball velocity today was, where am I seeing it?
90.
No, that's exit velocity.
I can't be right.
99.
Yeah.
It was 99.
So like he held that velocity throughout the start.
I'll say this to like, yeah, like the, I thought the changeup looked really good.
I would like to see him just mix in a little bit more.
I think that was, I said, I think that was the issue with that first inning Homer is that he was just pounding fastball after fastball, after a fastball, after a fastball.
And eventually Clemens was sitting on it and he got to it outside that second inning.
And I agree with you.
Like the second inning is what did him in.
If you don't walk those two batters in the second inning, right?
He goes single walk.
He loads the bases with nobody out.
You can't walk Austin Martin.
You can't walk Victor Carantini.
That's the seven, eight hitters in this lineup or six, seven hitters in this lineup.
you can't do that.
You can't do that with nobody out.
And he paid for it.
He was able to get key shawl.
He was able to get the big double play from Byron Buxton.
So he was able to limit damage.
But if you don't walk those two, let's face it.
Like not great hitters.
He's only allowed three out of three runs and he goes five innings.
And all of a sudden you're like, I'm pretty encouraged by that first time back in two years.
so I'd like to see him just clean that up.
But I thought there were some really encouraging signs here.
I said, I don't really blame him on the Clemens Homer.
I do blame him on the Larnock Homer.
That was a meatball right over the middle of the plate.
and Larnock just destroyed it.
just absolutely crushed it.
but overall, I think there's a lot of good to take from this and there's a lot of, oh yeah, just a couple things to tighten up.
But it was his first game back.
Right.
Hasn't pitched in Major League Baseball since 2024.
And I thought he did a decent enough job of keeping the ball on the ground as well.
the two home runs happened.
Yeah.
But even when the twins were able to get base hits, they were some balls that had some eyes just sneaking through.
All in all, I don't have that many complaints about it.
Yeah.
he only gave up three fly balls.
Yeah.
The whole game.
And two of them went over the fence.
Yeah.
That's a problem.
You can't let two of them go over the fence for sure.
But two of them went over the fence.
Yeah.
that can't happen, but again, first game back in two years, he'll be fine.
I think like it wasn't a disaster right now, it wasn't a disaster.
It was, it was very much, there were some positives.
There were some things that we need to work on.
I'm looking forward to seeing his next time out.
I was a little, I guess they're going to be a little careful with them early on here.
the, what 75 to 80 pitches, they said was the pitch limit.
He threw 76 in his last rehab starts.
I was thinking they'd push him a little bit more than that.
but I'd like to see him obviously go a little bit longer into games.
but overall I see there's some, there's some good signs here.
He also, I said the stuff 15 swings and misses right in this game, 50% whiff rate on the, on the changeup 50% whiff rate.
On the curve ball, and the fastball, I said, the fastball wasn't really put in play all that often either.
So yeah, I think there's, there are things to be encouraged about in this Jared Jones start for sure.
And also only two walks.
Like we talked about the command not being great, but I'll live with two walks, two walks.
He had a little bit extra on some stuff today, huh?
Yeah.
I think Bryan Reynolds gets the MVP award in this game just because of the walk off, but the walk off, you may not have the opportunity to get the walk off.
If not for Wilber Dotel three innings, he faces 10 batters in those three innings.
He gives up only one hit four strikeouts.
Tyler, his stuff out of the bullpen.
It just plays so well.
It plays so well.
The cutter was dancing today.
That's what he actually got his most swings and misses on was his cutter.
But in terms of exit velocity and hard hit rate, no one was hitting the ball off of him.
Average exit velocity off of Dotel today was 86.6.
And when you're forcing hitters to hit the ball off of you at 86.6 miles per hour, you're not going to give up any damage at all.
And yeah, he's been, he's been really good.
He had a little extra, a little bit of extra, VLO today.
I'm trying to think of a good word to use, but he was a little bit amped up today.
It seems like, we saw triple digits.
He held the velocity.
three innings.
I know it's not a ton, but held it through there.
We saw separation.
We saw the changeup play.
It's amazing what happens when you have good stuff and can throw strikes.
That's really just all this comes down to with the bullpen.
Dotel today had probably his best stuff and he was able to throw it in the zone and he was awesome.
He was absolutely awesome.
Yeah, he was at fastball average 99.3 today, which was a full tick higher than his season average.
Everything was up in terms of velocity today.
He only threw one through five changeups.
He mixed in all four of his pitches quite nicely.
yeah, it was a really good outing.
He seems to be very comfortable in this bulk inning role so far since his recall.
he gave up the one run against the Cardinals in his inning of work back on May 21st.
but three scoreless innings last time out against the Cubs, three scoreless innings this time out, against the twins.
And again, a huge part of this game because he kept this at five to four that, and gave the offense an opportunity to come back.
Comments· 0
Second and third, nobody out, down one in the eighth: should Don Kelly have pinch-hit Marcell Ozuna instead of Jake Mangum?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.