◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
The Pirates drop a second straight game to the Phillies to drop below .500 after a 10-6 loss. Paul Skenes struggled again as he gave up eight runs (seven earned) in just four innings of work. The offense battled back to keep the Pirates in it as Henry Davis homered and Nick Gonzales had three hits, but ultimately wasn’t enough after Skenes exited down 8-2. Jim and Tyler attempt to break this one down on the NS9 Postgame Show powered by Primanti Bros. You can watch/listen to them here:
The Pirates haven’t won a Paul Skenes start since May 12 and his ERA sat at 1.98. It’s now at a 3.62 ERA. The Pirates are 0-9 in his last nine starts and he hasn’t pitched more than five innings six times out of those nine outings. He wasn’t good Wednesday night and once again, the defense let him down as well. He served up two home runs, a three-run bomb to Trea Turner and then a solo shot to Brandon Marsh. Nick Gonzales had a chance to make a play and he threw home to get the lead runner and hits the runner that allowed two runs to score. Next at-bat was the Turner 3-run bomb that made it 5-0. I swear every play ball in play that Skenes gives up that goes to Gonzales at third base ends in disaster. It’s unreal with how many there’s been. Obviously this team’s defense isn’t good and it’s especially not good at third with Nicky G playing out of position, but it’s hurt Skenes more than any other starting pitcher this season.
Jim was correct on the postgame when he said Skenes was bad, but he wasn’t eight runs, seven earned bad. That’s correct, but something isn’t right with Skenes right now. I still think he’s suffering from a bit of a dead arm and 10-day rest would do him some good. With the All-Star break coming up in a couple months, I would skip a start or two of his and build it around the ASB so he can rest the arm for 10-14 days. Oh and even if he makes the All-Star team, he can’t actually pitch in that game. You have to rest his arm.
This Team Isn’t Making the Playoffs
I’m sorry, but I’m calling it. This team is cooked. This offense is really good. Ben Cherington deserves his flowers for turning this offense around in an offseason, but he forgot a couple things—the bullpen is horrendous. There’s no one you can rely on at this point and every night it doesn’t matter who Don Kelly calls on, it’s very difficult to piece together some clean outings from this pen. And he also forgot about the defense. This team’s defense is bad. And nearly every game it comes to the forefront. The play or lack thereof by Gonzales and Davis in this loss is just a steady reminder that Cherington wasn’t able to upgrade at third base in the offseason and now we’re stuck playing Gonzales over there out of position. Meanwhile, Alec Bohm has saved about 45 runs for the Phillies this series. The Bucs scored six Wednesday night, but it could have easily been eight or more if Bohm hadn’t made a bunch of web gems over there at third.
But all that we kinda knew about going into the season, but it’s the starting pitching that lately has disappointed and nothing looms as large as losing nine straight Paul Skenes starts. That just can’t happen at any point in a season for a team looking to make the postseason. I’m just hoping they’re a year too early and can figure out a lot of things at the deadline and this offseason.
This Offense Tho
For years we witnessed good pitching, but teams that couldn’t hit their weight and that was some frustrating stuff to watch. Now, the offense is top 3 in MLB and the pitching can’t catch a break. Go figure. This offense is so good when they’re not facing pitchers named Cristopher Sánchez. In the first game of this series Monday night when down 5-0, they rallied off Aaron Nola scoring eight and ended up winning that game. In this game, they were once again down 5-0 and started to score off Zack Wheeler (who came in with a 2.03 ERA). They scored two runs and they added two more and chased him from the game after just 4.2 innings. They Pirates scored two more off the bullpen and had cut the lead to 8-6 and were back in it, but it turned out not to be enough in this one. But the offense continues to hit and score runs. They actually outhit the Phillies 12-11 in this game. Every started besides Tyler Callihan had a hit in this game. I can’t wait to see Oneil Cruz and Spencer Horwitz getting added to this lineup after the ASB too. This offense is fun to watch and they deserve better on a nightly basis.
Comments· 4
The Debate
Should the Pirates fire pitching coach Bill Murphy?
Jim RosatiAll-Star· 140d ago
All I took from this was “Jim was correct.”
Tim Dye🐣Prospect· 140d ago
Skenes needs some IL time….rest, relax, and only light throwing for the 1st 110 days. After that get back in to a routine. His arm is dead from WBC.
Ryan🐣Prospect· 140d ago
Don’t start.
Ryan🐣Prospect· 140d ago
Yeah def needs a rest. Innings high last night, ramping up early for WBC and then he had those back-to-back 8-inning starts and since then he’s looked gassed and struggles to go 5. Not good.
With Tyler Sweeney and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Skenes was bad, but not 8-runs bad. With better ABS challenges and defense he gives up maybe two runs, since the Rincones at-bat should have been strike three.
2
Since the Colorado start, Skenes has been a 'pedestrian,' middle-of-the-road starter. If he pitches like this, the Pirates won't win anything no matter who else figures it out.
3
Stop having Henry Davis catch Paul Skenes every time. His blown ABS challenges and poor target on the play at home are hurting Skenes.
4
Pitching coach Bill Murphy should be fired, because nobody on the staff has gotten better at throwing baseballs. They've all gotten worse.
5
Fans should be at least a little worried about Skenes' velocity. An average fastball of 96 just doesn't play like the Paul Skenes they know.
What's up, everyone? Welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. This is the NS9 postgame show powered by Primanti Brothers. I'm Jim. Joining me tonight is Tyler.
Tyler, Pirates lose 10-6. They drop their ninth straight start of Paul Skenes. He gives up a career-high seven earned runs. This show is going to be brutal. This is just going to be an awful show to get through. I do not want to do this show right now, but we're going to have to do it anyways.
I don't either. I got to a point where I just started watching random TikToks because I didn't want to think about having to do this show because we're going to have to say some hard truths right now, I think, and I'm not really looking forward to that.
this game was everything that you didn't think it was going to be, right? Paul Skenes versus Zach Wheeler, you were hoping for a quick game, a clean game, just a back and forth pitching duel. And it was everything but that.
So, I guess let's just start where I think everybody really wants to talk about, right? And that's Paul Skenes was bad. It was a bad start. He hasn't put together one of those, like, shut down Cy Young Paul Skenes games since May 12th, right?
In Colorado, he pitched eight scoreless innings. Hasn't really been himself since. Now, granted, there have been things that have not necessarily helped him along the way, and there were plenty of that tonight, too.
I think, you can certainly say, Paul Skenes is clearly not the dominant self that he was, and today he certainly was not. On top of that, the defense behind him today was god-awful.
Last week, we talked about how this team's terrible with ABS challenges. They were god-awful at that again today. And all those things culminated to Paul Skenes' worst start as a professional.
They did. He was plain and simple bad tonight. You mentioned everything that went wrong as well. But we have been on these post-game shows for three years of Paul Skenes now, and we have, I'm hand up here.
I've talked about he's the best pitcher I've ever seen. The best pitcher I've ever seen needs to be able to get through those things.
And right now, he is pedestrian. He's an above-average pitcher. Since that Colorado start, pedestrian's probably the right word.
He's just your middle-of-the-road, good starting pitcher. And it's frustrating. It's more than frustrating, I guess.
Yeah, like, this version's not winning this team anything. Like, this... If Paul Skenes looks like this, it doesn't matter if everyone else on this team figures it out.
They're not winning a damn thing, because you need Paul Skenes to be himself to do anything worth a damn.
And the version that you've seen lately, over the last month and a half, has been bad. Just not good enough. Not good enough at all.
Yeah, since that Colorado game, going into tonight, it was eight starts. Again, he was 0-5 in those eight starts. The Pirates lost all eight of them.
And it was a 4.40 ERA. Which, again, like, that's league average, right? You look like starting pitchers. It's a little bit below league average.
But it's nowhere near... that's more than double his ERA for his career, right? Heading into this season.
And that number, when you add in today's start, just gets even worse.
I want to give a shout-out. We'll dive into this. But I want to give a shout-out to Michael B. Thanks for the super chat.
He says, What more can we all say at this point about the team?
Paul Skenes is a shell of himself. You have to seriously look at Bill Murphy as a big cause.
Davis was awful. Let Endy catch him. I'm miserable.
And I think what's frustrating about this, at least for me, right, is it's almost impossible to have nuanced conversation about this on the internet nowadays.
Like, it's either Paul Skenes is the greatest pitcher of all time, or Paul Skenes is cooked, he's done, it's over, trade him.
Like, there doesn't seem to be much, let's look into this a little bit.
His velocity's down, he's done, like, he's hurt, he's tired.
Because I don't want people to misconstrue this, and I know they're going to, because they misconstrue everything I say.
Again, Paul Skenes wasn't sharp tonight. He was bad.
He was missing his spots.
The sweeper, in particular, was all over the place.
The command was bad.
But he also probably pitched well enough to only give up two runs in today's game, Tyler.
Like, I can't get over the fact that, yeah, he wasn't good today.
But he wasn't eight runs and seven of them earned bad.
He wasn't that bad today.
And, again, people are going to think that I'm just, like, blindly defending Paul Skenes here.
I'm not.
He was bad today.
He was inefficient.
He was throwing way too many pitches early on.
Even if he gets out of that second inning clean, Tyler, I don't know if he goes past five innings today, right?
Like, and that's not the Paul Skenes that this team needs to happen.
But I want to talk about that second inning, Tyler, because it's the second game in a row that the second inning became a disaster.
He leads it off by hitting Alec Bohm, right?
Right then and there.
Don't hit Alec Bohm, right?
That's on Paul.
Bryson Stott yanks a single.
First and second.
That's on Paul.
Paul gets himself into this situation, right?
Now it's on Paul to get out of it.
He strikes out JT Rayomuto.
A really long at-bat.
Takes him a lot of pitches to get through it.
I believe that was a 10-pitch at-bat.
So right then and there, he's already thrown a ton of pitches.
This next at-bat, Tyler, is where things unravel.
Gabriel Rincones Jr., the rookie.
Early on in the count.
Let me bring up this specific at-bat because I do want to talk about this at-bat.
Konnor Griffin just does a great job of just getting himself into scoring position.
Infield base hit.
Steal second.
And, again, Reynolds hits him in.
So, I will say this, and then we'll get to it a little bit later.
I'm still not done talking about Skenes.
But, as much as the Phillies got to Paul, the Pirates also got to Wheeler, too.
They didn't allow him to get through five innings.
I think I remember them saying a stat on the broadcast where it was, like, something like 84 straight Sanchez-Wheeler starts that went five innings or longer.
And that got broken today by the Pirates.
Zach Wheeler goes four and two-thirds.
He gives up nine hits, four runs.
He does strike out ten batters, which was a season high.
But the Pirates got to him.
that's what you needed to do here is you needed – if Paul Skenes is going to give up eight runs, you're going to have to score.
And the Pirates' offense did everything they could to get back into this game.
It wasn't enough, ultimately.
But, yeah, like the second inning there, answering that five spot with a couple runs was nice.
But it wasn't enough.
We still aren't done.
We still aren't done giving up the runs.
No.
they battled enough.
Like, I'm not mad at the bats at all tonight.
No.
I thought the bats were great.
They were good enough to win the game.
It's just that pitching and defense, once again, wasn't good enough.
Yep.
I want to continue this conversation.
Let's kick it over to Cody real quick, and we'll be right back.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack, hydration, and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
All right, Tyler.
So the Pirates get two runs back there in the third.
But Paul, leadoff homer, gives up a bomb to Brandon Marsh.
6-2 now.
He gets the next three batters.
But then the fourth inning happens.
And I think this is where I can really go in on Paul.
He just looked gassed.
Like, he was gassed for some reason here.
And hard contact after hard contact after hard contact.
The exit velos in this fourth inning.
111-104-104-98.
Granted, the quote-unquote double that Bryce Harper had to score two runs.
Like, Tyler Callihan just lets a ball go off his glove and to the wall.
Again, like, it's just another terrible defensive play.
But Tyler, this was the first time.
And again, like, the velocity concerns with Skenes.
I haven't really been too, like, it hasn't been that big a deal because he stated that it's on purpose.
But this is the first time where I was, this is the first time where I was, like, you're throwing the ball 94, dude.
Like, this isn't, this isn't going to work.
That fourth inning, his average velocity on his four-seam fastball dropped to 95.
He threw plenty of balls in that 94 range.
And again, like, he was hit hard.
It's different.
Like, if you're going to throw the ball 97, you better not be getting hit hard.
But in that fourth inning, he was throwing 94, 95, and he was getting hit hard.
Yeah, I remember, I don't remember exactly which start it was, earlier in the year where I think he went eight innings and he was throwing, like, 92 to 93.
And I remember Alex on Offbeat mentioning that.
And it just stuck in the back of my head a little bit.
And then now we're seeing Skenes with an average fastball velocity at 96.
Like, I think you have to be slightly concerned with the velocity drop that we're seeing with him.
96 just doesn't play like the Paul Skenes we know.
It doesn't.
The fastball is a lot more hittable.
And then when you mix in how just lifeless some of the off-speed looks, you have to wonder how much fatigue or something else might be, something else might be going on here.
Yeah.
There's concerns.
He looked gassed.
Like, he just looked gassed.
And I know it was, like, really hot.
But, Zach Wheeler threw, Zach Wheeler also didn't look good.
But he threw 100-plus pitches.
Skenes threw 81 pitches today.
And again, just he did not look, he did that fourth inning, he did not look good.
I want to thank Michael again for another super chat here.
Henry Davis does strike out with the bases loaded.
On a pitch that he probably should have challenged, by the way, Tyler was in off the plate.
He strikes out looking.
And the ABS disaster that was tonight continues with Henry Davis.
He strands the bases loaded.
And, like, that was your shot, I think, to, like, really get back into this.
And they got a couple, but they didn't get enough.
No, and, like you said, the Henry Davis non-challenge there.
Like, I know you don't want to be the guy that burns up all the challenges, but...
If there is a...
Right.
But also, like...
Base is loaded, two-outs.
Exactly.
And when we talked to Alex on Thursday, that's something that they, or at least it seems like they were discussing a little more, is the spots where you challenge them.
And that's the spot that you challenge it.
Two-outs.
Base is loaded.
You...
You can't just go down there and walk away.
You can't.
Like, if you burn it there, it is what it is.
I'm okay with it.
I think he's a little gun-shy right now.
That's exactly...
Like, he...
You can tell every time he goes to tap that helmet or thinks about it, he's just not confident in himself.
Yeah.
He...
He's, like, on an island right now with the ABS.
Yep.
Cam Sanders called up today.
Thought he, at least performed admirably.
he walked the batter, gave up a hit, walked another batter, but didn't give up a hit.
And he runs.
Yohan Ramirez, Tyler, comes in with a runner on first, two outs, in what seems to be, like, just, like, an easy situation.
Like, just getting out, Yohan.
Is this...
Is he, like, the most hilarious...
He's the most hilarious pitcher I've ever watched.
He immediately comes in and goes, wild pitch, wild pitch.
I...
I don't know about hilarious.
It's...
It's hilarious.
It's...
At this point, it's an 8-4 game.
I was laughing the entire time.
He just...
I...
I don't know.
I don't understand him.
I don't think he understands himself.
I don't think he knows where the ball's going half the time.
Obviously, the guy's nasty.
He's able to go an inning in a third and strike out four guys.
Yeah.
Doesn't give up any runs.
He's completely nasty.
It's just that...
Tyler, he hasn't given up a run since June 3rd.
Yeah.
He just might hit somebody in the stands while he's out there.
Since June 3rd, he's...
So, June 3rd was the last time he gave up a run.
Since then, he's pitched...
Oh, come on.
June 4th through today.
Since then, if you include today, he's pitched 13 scoreless innings.
13 scoreless innings.
He's walked 10 batters.
No, 9 batters.
Sorry.
That's too many.
9 batters.
He's walked.
He's hit 2 batters.
And he's thrown 4 wild pitches.
But no earned runs.
No, not even a run.
Not even a single...
Not an earned run.
Not a run.
He is the most effectively wild pitcher right now in existence.
Oh, it's...
I guess you're right.
Like, it's...
If I were not a Pirates fan, it would be pretty entertaining.
Like, if...
There should be a compilation on TikTok of just Yohan.
Just throwing pitches four feet outside the...
Everywhere.
He's just nowhere...
Half of his pitches are nowhere near the strike zone.
And then walking off the mound, like, giving a little mini socket.
Yeah, he does the DX.
Like, it's...
He's incredible.
Like, he didn't even go full-blown on it.
He was just like...
It was one.
He did one.
Well, because the one guy got suspended for doing, I think, three.
Three chops equal to suspension.
If you do one, I think you're good.
You only get one pump.
You get one pump, and you're good.
That's the Kringle-McKringleberry rule.
And you just can't do three, right?
All right.
Yeah, he's hilarious.
Pirates add on two more.
Jared Triolo coming off the bench with a two-run double in the seventh.
And then Alec Bohm just...
I think that was another frustrating part about today's game, is you saw the bad third-base defense the Pirates have been playing lately.
And then Alec Bohm's over there making incredible plays.
He's a terrible defensive third baseman, historically.
And this season, he's bad.
But I swear Alec Bohm has saved the Phillies, like, six runs in this series.
Yeah, the Pirates really could have cut in that thing with Konnor Griffin, and Boehm makes a great play.
And then there's also a great play by Bryce Harper.
It's just...
Yeah, I forgot about the heart.
Boehm makes a diving play.
Harper makes a diving play the next inning.
Yeah, just...
I don't know.
Again, good team versus average team.
You see the difference.
The Phillies are a good team right now.
That's for sure.
Two-run homer by Alec Bohm off of Dennis Santana in the eighth.
I thought Santana looked really good.
The first two batters, I was like, is Santana back?
It was Schwarber-Harper.
Strikeout-strikeout.
Yeah, and I think the first pitch he threw was 96.
I'm like, ooh.
Yeah.
All right, Denny.
And then, yeah.
I was getting a little excited, though.
Maybe Dennis is back, and then, yeah.
Dennis is not back.
Dennis is still Dennis.
Dennis is still Dennis.
Dennis.
Well, tomorrow, the Pirates are facing a pitcher.
There's not too many Major League pitchers, Tyler, that I've just never heard of in my life.
I have no idea who this guy is for Philadelphia.
I don't even know if I can read his name properly.
Alan Rangel.
Adam Rangel.
Alan Rangel.
He's a 28-year-old rookie.
He's pitched in, it looks like, eight games in his life, and he's never started a game.
So, he's having his first start tomorrow, and it's going to be against Jared Jones.
The Pirates are slight underdogs at plus 104 on the money line, according to FanDuel.
You know what?
If you leave Philly with a split, like, that would be nice.
So, like, take tomorrow's game.
Beat Alan Rangel, please.
Yeah, once again, like, can they continue to not drop two games below 500?
Because that's been that line they've been able to avoid.
Once you drop two games below 500, hopefully that door doesn't fall out below you.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Big game tomorrow.
Get back to 500, head to Washington, and see what you can do on the road in D.C.
But I don't have a whole lot more to add here.
I hope I did a decent job of at least not, like, I, again, I don't want to, I know people are going to say, Jim, you Paul Skenes's apologist, but it's like, he was bad today, and I'm saying
that, but he wasn't eight runs bad, but he also, he needs to be better.
He needs to be better, Tyler, and he needs to figure it out right now.
Yeah, I don't give a shit what they think about me.
I said what I think.
All right, guys.
Well, depending on if, you know what, even if you didn't like what either of us had to say, please like the video, subscribe to the page, comment if you're listening to us on your preferred podcast form.
But, yeah, that's all I got.
Win tomorrow.
And then, you know what, if you don't agree with us, jump into the chat on the app or the website and yell at us.
There you go.
Do that.
This is open all the time.
And we're in there.
All right, guys.
I appreciate you all.
Offbeat tomorrow morning.
I think Alex is actually doing that offbeat, highlighting the Futures game selection.
Seth Hernandez and Edward Florentino named to the Futures game this All-Star break.
So check that out tomorrow morning and then day game tomorrow, which means we've got a post-game show in the afternoon.
And then we'll have NS9 Live coming up at night.
So three shows for you tomorrow.
Lots to talk about.
Yep.
Four straight days of Tyler.
Sorry, people.
All right, guys.
We'll catch you later.
Have a good night.
See you guys.
Tiger Scouts.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 4
Should the Pirates fire pitching coach Bill Murphy?