The Pirates finally moved on from Dennis Santana, designating the reliever for assignment after acquiring Ron Marinaccio. It was a disappointing ending for one of Pittsburgh’s biggest success stories and clubhouse leaders from 2025. Alex Stumpf looks back at Santana’s impact, including the role he played in Yohan Ramirez’s turnaround, before addressing the larger problem. With Santana gone, the Pirates still do not have a reliable group to protect late leads.
How It All Fell Apart for Dennis Santana
With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
The Pirates botched the Bednar trade: for about $1.25M more than Santana plus Soto cost, David Bednar should still be a Pirate. Santana should have been the one moved.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Picking up a Marinaccio-type reliever should have been the 10th bullpen move of the year, not one of the first. The Pirates rode the same arms all year and never tried to get better.
Alex Stumpf - 3
Nobody has gotten better under pitching coach Bill Murphy the way pitchers did under Oscar Marin, so the front office no longer gets the benefit of the doubt on fixing arms.
Alex Stumpf - 4
When Spencer Horwitz comes back, Tyler Callihan should be the one sent down, not Marcell Ozuna. Callihan 'can't hit a fastball' and isn't a major leaguer.
Alex Stumpf - 5
Giving up a top prospect like Edward Florentino is easier to accept for a team that is sure of a playoff spot, not one fighting just to maybe make the wild card.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript1000 paragraphs · show
Yo, welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel.
Well, this is NS9 Live, and I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo, and with me, we have Ty.
Ty, how are you doing tonight, buddy?
Just another show where Tyler's here, and one of you two is off gallivanting the world.
Don't worry, boys, I'll hold it down here.
I'll hold it down, it's fine.
It's usually Jim, and this time it is Jim.
Hey, to be fair, Tyler, when I missed the show, it was Bucco Brew, and when I missed the show, it was NS9 Live.
And both times I missed that show, it was because I missed a flight, or it was delayed.
It wasn't my fault.
It wasn't my fault.
It is your fault.
Like, you just heard it.
No, I'm completely absolved of all.
You just said it.
No.
You missed the flight.
No.
No.
But it's not my fault that I missed the flight.
No.
Anyways.
It is.
Yeah.
We're back.
You and I, from last night.
I'll say this.
Last night, we were in our feelings.
We were in our emotions.
That was a very emotional time in events that took place when the Pirates lost the game.
But, hey, we're back now with some reason.
We have a Pittsburgh Pirates trade that happened today.
Dennis Santana's been DFA'd.
The Pirates are still above .500.
They're going to play the Cubs.
They still have a tough series.
They're coming into the trade deadline.
We've got a lot to talk about, Tyler.
We're starting that climb of the mountain of a lot to talk about here very soon.
There's a lot that's going to happen here within the next two weeks, week and a half, whatever it is.
We're starting here in the first move of hopefully many, DiNardo.
And by many, just give me every reliever that you can find, and let's figure out if they can get anyone out.
technically speaking, this is the second move.
They already got the first one.
That was I certain.
Yeah.
True.
But I'll say this to that.
Jacob Gonzalez has been playing well.
I know I poo-pooed a little on him.
So far, he's playing well.
Iser's doing essentially what we thought he was going to be doing.
Gonzalez has been fine to this point.
He's filled in nicely, I think.
I'm still not a fan of that trade.
Not a big Jacob Gonzalez believer.
But so far, he's helped him out a good bit.
I just, I didn't like the trade.
Still don't.
Mm-hmm.
And there's still plenty of time for it to go either way.
It's been like, what, a week?
So, sure, there's that.
But so far, again, I'm going to say so far, I poo-pooed on him.
And it's more or less because, like, he's a rookie.
There's a lot of unknown with him.
Is he going to produce this year?
This year is what matters.
And so far, he's helped out this team offensively with a bat.
Now, as much as he has helped, Brandon Eisert has dishelped.
And it's a net-zero trade.
But at any rate, like I mentioned, today there was another trade that happened for another reliever.
Ben Cherington strikes a deal with the Padres.
And they bring in another reliever.
So, things are voting well for the Pirates' bullpen, correct?
Throw it all at the wall.
Let's see what sticks, DiNardo.
Would you say that's what this deal is?
And again, let me announce the trade that happened.
So, the Pirates are going ahead and sending $500,000 of international bonus pool money to the Padres for Ron Marinaccio, who is a reliever, a 31-year-old reliever from the San Diego Padres.
And let me just clarify something as well.
I know that's typically how you hear of it.
That's how people say it.
Yes, there's no money actually exchanged.
The Pirates did not gift the Padres $500,000 of international pool money.
What they essentially did was they allowed them to take $500,000 of their credit limit and give it to the Padres.
So, the Padres now have $500,000 more that they can spend.
The Pirates now have $500,000 less that they're allowed to spend.
Just keep lowering the amount that they have to spend, DiNardo.
This team is incredibly cheap.
They traded the 34th pick so that they wouldn't have to spend more money in the draft.
Now, they're trading away this money so they don't have to spend it in international free agent.
This team will never change.
There's some truth to that.
There is some truth in there.
Now, I'm not – again, this was a team that had the most money in the draft.
This had a – that draft pick was certainly a piece that they could dangle to get better with.
And they – instead of using it for the future, they used it for the future, but closer future, maybe now.
That's our struggle with the trade, right?
It wasn't like, here's a slam dunk move for 2026.
It's, this guy has some control.
Maybe they'll help out this year.
But at any rate, it goes towards the present.
And making this deal, yeah, it takes away from the international bonus pool money, right?
It takes away from the future, the prospects they can add to this system, and it adds to now.
I think what we're all coming together with is that neither of those three pieces they acquired in using those two tools are slam dunks like, oh, yeah, this is going to help.
Yeah.
Yeah, pretty much.
the trading of the 34th pick was just used in a way to fill that Konnor Griffin void and, I guess, help the team towards the future, depending on how you feel about Jacob Gonzalez.
I think there's arguments that can be made both ways about whether it was the right move, because I think you could also argue that money would have been, or that pick would have been better served trading for reliever help.
Or, like, packaging it to, maybe adding a prospect to certainly get that relief help.
Right.
Which, they did.
Well, yeah.
They did add, yeah.
Yeah.
Thanks, Mr. Woods.
But, yeah, it is just funny, like, you see the trade be made, or the money be sent, and everyone thinks the Pirates are handing over money.
No.
They're saving money.
Yeah.
Go Nutting's wallet.
That is what it is.
Now, again, yes, visually, that is how it appears.
And, yes, technically, that is what's being done, right?
They've now been, they now lower the amount of money they can spend in the draft, and they now lower the money they can spend in the international market.
However, good things can come from this.
Like, you can certainly, I'm a proponent of, both ways.
for rebuilding teams, or even if there's a team that, has some prospect they really want, and they just need to add capital so they can go out there and get them.
Like, that's what I do like about the international draft.
There's a lot of science, but there's interesting things to it.
I shouldn't say draft, but, the international signing period.
Like, the Padres, maybe there's someone out there that they really want.
it's late in the game per se, but maybe there's someone out there they need some more money with, and this is their opportunity of doing it.
And they really give up no one of crucial need or help, right?
And for the Pirates, you can certainly get something with international dollars.
like, that's not just like a nothing move, a nothing burger.
And I guess what I look at this, too, is like this, not that you're expecting like $500,000 of international bonus pool money.
It's not going to get you like a Raul to Chapman.
It's not going to get you like a mainstay reliever, but this guy here, a little over two years of service time, you really look deep into him.
Like, I know the ERA isn't anything good right now.
it's a 479 ERA, a 532 FIP, a negative 0.3 war, according to fan graphs.
Like, nothing this year is looking good.
He has like a little bit of a track record to him, especially when he first came up.
but like what worries me right now is the strikeouts are way down.
He's always had a walk problem.
The changeup's always been terrible, but it's like he's regressing.
Now, I want to put this out there to you, Tyler.
This team has had the MO of being able to fix guys, make them better, make them serviceable.
I think for some time we gave the team the benefit of the doubt when they get someone, because you look at this, the believer right now that they have.
And again, like there's nothing that stands out and says, oh, this guy is good.
one thing you always joked about, I was like, well, does he have a slider or sweeper?
And if so, they can fix him.
Well, he does have a sweeper and it's terrible, but I'm at a point.
And I want to hear, I want to talk first about this, right?
I want to hear your viewpoint.
I'm at a point now, though.
I don't know if this team has truly afforded the opportunity to have that mindset anymore.
Things have changed pitching wise.
in-house guys have regressed.
There's a reason why this move happened.
Dennis Santana is no longer a pirate.
So do you afford to this team the benefit of the doubt anymore with pitchers?
No.
No, but at the same time, just to push back a touch.
I don't think the changeup's terrible and the slider's terrible.
Has it been hit?
Yeah.
But like, if you look at stuff plus, changeup's been bad this year for sure.
It was 108 and 102 the last two years on the changeup.
And then the slider, 103, 110, 117, 110, 121.
Stuff plus has it as a, has it as an above average pitch.
The fact in general, though, like again, using stuff plus the it's everything's down this year.
Went from a 104 last year to a 94.
So there's something off.
Don't know what it is.
He could just be cooked.
Yeah.
Never know.
Could be.
Well, and like, when I get like, historically, even to go when he first got called up, he had a really good.
His debut, right?
As a reliever, half a war numbers are pretty solid.
He's been four seam heavy.
The four seam has always been good.
But this, like the sweeper that year was good.
Like the batting average is 240 expected 181.
The changeup at that time, 141 batting average expected 140.
It's just like every year.
It just seemed like those all regressed to like the past.
Last year, he had like what?
10 innings.
I don't want to really count last year at all because it's so small sample.
So like when I revert to the previous, it's this year.
And then 2024, they'll look back to.
And then 2024.
Yeah.
Like the four seamer, once again, solid changeup though.
Batting average 367 hit against, and you look at this year, the changeup 263 against the sluggings 474.
Like it hasn't been.
Ooh.
Ooh.
You look so much better.
Thank you.
It hasn't been great.
And like the sweeper this year, 308 batting average, 348 expected slugging 538.
It's like those things have really regressed for him as the four seam is still solid.
Now I know that's down this year as well, but it has been solid up through this whole time for the most part.
Yeah.
And I, do I have much belief here that this is going to work out?
No.
I think there's a decent chance that he might be cooked.
He might just, or he might just not be a good pitcher.
He might not have the ability to get major leaguers out.
That's very possible.
I'm also being a touch cautious because when Dennis Santana arrived here, I wanted him to hell out of town after like maybe two outings.
And that did turn out to be a decent, well, not decent.
That turned out to be a great move.
I think there's an equal amount of chance with Marinaccio that he is off this team within the next few weeks as he's on it.
Like, I think it's 50-50.
If he blows up into outings, you, I don't know how long you hang on to this guy, but this is a move that I think they should have been making more of over the last two months.
I don't understand why it's been a year of just continuing to ride what they have in the bullpen and not even try to get better throughout this year.
Like these are the kinds of acquisitions they should have been making all year.
I agree with that.
And like, I'm glad you brought that up because again, like when we talk about like this team being afforded opportunity to prove themselves and give them benefit of the doubt, like, yeah, like Dennis Santana is a perfect example of that.
He's the guy that they DFA today, but he was the same guy.
Actually, probably even worse when he came in, you were just like, what the hell?
This guy is awful.
And what did he do?
He turned himself into having a fan.
a fantastic, like.
I understand Dennis Santana has been DFA today.
He's been bad this year.
But with that said, I want us all to still recognize and understand he was one of the better relievers in baseball for that year and a half timeframe.
Hands down.
Hands down.
One of the best relievers in baseball.
That happened.
And that was from a guy who, when the Pirates landed him, you were just thinking, what the hell are we doing, Ben?
So that's partly why it's like, you know what?
They should be given the benefit of the doubt to some level.
But that's also why I'm cautious because this year is different than what they've had previously.
So I don't know how that's going to go.
But again, it has always come down to, more or less, does that pitcher have a slider or sweeper?
And if so, in the Pirates brass, we trust.
And that's what this guy has.
Hasn't been great, but he has it.
In the Pirates brass, we did trust when they had a sweeper.
Oscar Marin ain't here anymore.
Right.
I know.
And that's what I struggle with.
Like, that's the elephant in this room, DiNardo.
I haven't seen Bill Murphy make it, or I haven't seen anyone under Bill Murphy get better.
I haven't.
Correct.
I saw a lot of them do it under Oscar Marin.
Show me, Bill.
Show me that you can at least mold this into something useful.
Right.
Haven't seen it.
Agree.
Shout out to Michael B for the $5 super.
Once again, Michael B, you're the best.
He says, I'm tired of these bums for, I'm tired of these bum for bum swaps.
DFA one bum for another.
This guy, Marinascio, has an over nine plus ERA in the seven outings.
Watch BC do nothing.
it has not been good.
And this is one of the, I was, I was actually about to tweet this today and I didn't because it's been negative a lot.
And we'll talk about tonight on the show anyways.
But I had that tweet about there of Gregory Soto's like last 13 innings.
Santana's last 17.
I searched last 17 and all of them have like 18, 17, 13 earned runs.
Like it's been bad.
And then we would go back to this dude.
It's like in the past 12 innings pitch.
He has like eight earned runs.
Like it's not been good either.
It just adds to like, these guys have been problematic for the most recent part.
But so was Santana.
I don't, I don't know.
Like this guy does have a pitch mix.
Says the four seamer has a changeup has the sweeper has a sinker that he stopped throwing.
But I also want to say this, he also added a cutter and the cutter is not faring too well either.
Mitch Keller, what helped Santana?
He simplified things.
I'm not here to tell you this guy can be good.
He has been bad.
I'm also not here to tell you this trade will be bad and it's going to be awful.
I'm just cautious that how they've done a fair job of turning pitchers.
into having better seasons.
I'm very cautious on that, but he does come in with some.
Well, a mindset of this guy is probably just not going to be good and be part of the problem that already exists.
He's a warm body that can throw a baseball, maybe at a major league level.
Right.
Real quick.
I do hand up.
MLB front office.com.
Here's I did miss Montgomery here.
Yes, he has been better with Bill Murphy, I guess.
He's had a fine year, pretty good year.
Evan says look better as well.
So, yeah, I was.
I guess an overgeneralization there, but at the same time, it's that's there's nobody.
I don't think that you can rubber stamp by Bill Murphy.
I think the rubber stamp for Bill Murphy is that everybody now throws a change up and everybody's change up sucks.
Well, guess who throws a change up and it sucks?
Well, yeah.
I think there's something there with it, though, I would say, like, I like the separation he gets on it, throws the fastball 94, the change up to 81.
It's not one of these new age change ups that sits at like 88, 89 is basically a sinker.
Oh, it's probably underperformed in Nardo as well, because you look at the Woba on and it's 349, the expected Woba, 298.
If I had to look at this, just glance at it real quick and guess why they acquired him, I'm going to guess it's a change up because Bill Murphy loves his change up.
Yeah.
Could be.
It could be.
And maybe that's the thing.
Maybe, again, we've talked about the previous regime and it was always like the sweeper or a slider.
Do they possess that?
And if so.
And Oscar, we trust.
And maybe with.
This regime, it's it is the change up.
But again, there's not much that.
Gives you a whole lot of confidence that this can be a turnaround and this guy can be someone who's at least serviceable in this bullpen.
So, again, I don't want to go like too deep in into this guy.
The splits.
Versus lefties this year, 253, 352, 396.
Versus righties, 297, 347.
However, slugging 571.
He's also a decent extension guy.
Well, yeah, that used to be a calling card on the Pirates.
That was the Bailey Falter thing.
there are little things I think you can find some.
Things to like about him.
I think it's a it's a completely fine move.
He's a he's the guy that you turn and burn.
If he ends up sucking, you move on from him real quick.
Again, I'm more probably frustrated that this is like the first time they've done it all year.
It's just been.
Trot out the same eight to 10 guys in the bullpen and watch them blow saves.
They should.
This should be like the 10th move they've made in this bullpen this year.
Well, it is.
And that's real.
That's like where I'm alluding to at this point.
By no means is this like, OK, we've made two moves in this bullpen.
I search and Marascio.
You're the Italian one here.
It's not that I can't pronounce name.
It's that I don't remember his name.
I don't know what letters are in there unless I'm reading it and I have it up.
So I don't know this guy.
It's not as if I'm this is a mainstay in major league baseball that like everyone should know this name.
I need it in front of me to read it.
Your last name is DiNardo.
You should know how to pronounce this name.
I had to help you pronounce this name before the show.
It's not that I don't know how to pronounce it.
It's that I don't remember the letters unless I look at them.
I forgot there was an R and an I in there or an A and R or whatever I said.
You just look at it and see Marine and go, oh, I miss you.
This blank gray face.
No.
What I'm alluding to is like these two.
These aren't the boobs like Ben's not done.
But what I'll say to this is Dennis Santana needed to go.
He absolutely needed to go.
We are all fine with Dennis Santana being DFA today.
Correct.
Yeah, we're good.
Okay.
So in doing so, is there a guy internally that you like are looking at right now and saying, let's use him.
They've exhausted all of those.
So you're probably looking externally and not that this guy's great, but it's like you said, let's just throw him at the wall next and find out until they do make the real moves.
And even if they do, it's not that this guy can't still be part of the bullpen because there's plenty of guys that still can be DFA.
But maybe, like if he's at worst, the second to the last or the last bullpen guy compared to what's there on this bullpen right now, it might not be the worst thing in the world.
No, your other option is Noah Murdock.
That's basically what you have left.
And to be fair, like Noah Murdock's put together a nice little stretch in AAA, but he's Noah Murdock.
I would say the only other one is like Khristian Curtis, but, you could say like, hey, you know what, that guy's like, screw the development part, screw the starter.
We're just going to put you in the bullpen because we need you there.
That's something you can certainly discuss, but I think that's pretty much where it also ends.
Like that's it.
And that's a guy that has four starts in AAA, he's been in AA this whole time.
Yeah, that's your other option.
And again, I want to keep going back to it, DiNardo.
This should not have been like the first, it's not the first, but it's one of the early external moves they made in the bullpen.
This should have been happening a long time ago.
This should have been happening early May.
Guys that are on the waiver wire, you go get them and just see if they can get people out.
Save yourself from having to get three relievers this deadline, because God knows they need like three of them.
We're going to end up settling for like two, but they need like three or four.
Yeah.
Again, it's fine.
It's a move.
I don't have a complaint about it.
I have more of a complaint that you can't pronounce his name.
Marinascio.
There we go.
Nailed it.
Because now I'm reading it and remember, I don't have to remember what his name even was.
I'm not going to lie.
I wanted to call him like Marasini at one point.
I do just want to talk about this now.
Talking about the bullpen, Dennis Santana being in DFA.
I don't want to go too deep in this, but it's just another reason why I'm pissed off they traded David Bednar.
I don't know how you feel on this.
I don't know if we really should bring that back up, but it's just like they made the decision last year.
I didn't have a whole enough time.
I want to go back and clip some things because I know we certainly talked about like if you're trading one of them, trade Dennis Santana, keep Bednar.
And the decision they went was trade Bednar, keep Santana obviously cheaper, same control, but going to be cheaper.
And David Bednar right now playing very good baseball for the New York Yankees, basically two and a half ERA, two and a half FIP, 18 saves, I believe.
And for three and a half million dollars, they lit it on fire to keep Dennis Santana.
So that sucks.
Now, again, did any of us think Santana was going to be doing this?
No.
Like, I'm not here to tell you that.
Oh, yeah, I envisioned this.
That's also why we said keep Bednar is because you had probably a lot more faith that Bednar would be able to pitch well this year, oppose Santana.
And, well, here we are.
What was that amount you said they saved?
They, so Bednar was nine million.
Santana was three and a half.
And then how much was Gregory Soto?
Seven.
Point seven.
Or seven.
Seven point five.
Seven point seven five.
Seven point seven five.
Okay, boom.
Now, what I'm saying there is for one point, one and a quarter million dollars, David Bednar should still be here.
Dennis Santana should have been moved.
Gregory Soto shouldn't even have been a thought.
And David Bednar should be a Pittsburgh Pirate.
They booted that one.
Plain and simple.
Should have been extended to begin with.
Yeah.
They just straight up.
It would have been nine million dollars.
Probably been like seven million.
Yeah.
They blew it.
They straight up blew that move.
Because everything they got for it looks like shit, too.
Well, I was going to say, at least they're reaping the benefits of it, right?
Yeah.
Flores, I can't catch a cold.
Can he catch a flight?
Because I need a traveling partner if he can at least do that.
Well, you're going to lose because I think they're, what, one and four with him as a starter?
Someone that had that breakdown of, like, every pirate and what the record is with him.
Flores was down there at the bottom.
They don't win when he's behind the plate.
Granted, those days are usually afternoon games where they play crappy liners.
But continue.
Right.
Okay.
Well, no, I think that's pretty much it.
There's nothing really else I want to talk about in regards to him.
Really, the bullpen in general.
I think we all understand it still stinks.
There still needs to be done.
However, Dennis Santana won't be the one that's blowing saves.
Or leads.
Or whatever he's blowing.
He's not going to be pitching anymore.
So that's good.
Okay.
Whatever he's blowing.
It's addition by subtraction a good bit here.
Mm-hmm.
Dennis Santana.
Good point.
It is.
This guy's bad, but he's better than Santana.
You basically just took away Don Kelly's toy so we don't have to watch him try to play with it.
Getting rid of Santana is a good thing.
Yeah.
Hopefully he doesn't turn it around somewhere else.
Because sorry, Dennis, I don't want to watch that.
Yeah, I don't care.
No, I don't.
Let it be with a team like the Angels.
No.
So it doesn't matter.
Zero implications.
No.
All right.
Well, sorry, Dennis Santana.
He can turn it around next year.
Yeah, he can do it next year.
Okay.
Do we want to move on?
Yeah, we're good.
I think that's going to be the most negative of everything.
But let's talk about some good rational things.
Before we do that, let's go ahead and kick it on over to Cody, our boy Cody, the puppy dog.
And then we'll be back.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe Sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
So, Ty, again, yeah, this trade's whatever.
We poo-pooed some things on the trade.
We had our postgame yesterday where Don Kelly blew the game, and things were bad.
And the Yankees took the series 2-1, even though we weren't even sure they played three games already.
We thought there was one today.
But we're not going to talk about that.
But I do want to put some perspective on things because, again, I know yesterday was doom and gloom because of the way they lost.
And that's what's most frustrating about this team is not that they're losing when they lose games because it is baseball.
And you're not going to win 90% of your games or 80% of your games.
It's not like it's in the NFL or whatnot.
But it's just the way that they lose is very frustrating.
But, again, like, this was the team that was going into the Brave series, the Brewer series, the Guardian series, the Yankee series.
Like, things was kicking off this brutal, crucial almost month of games being played heading into the trade deadline that I don't want to say could make the season.
But I do want to say could absolutely break the season, especially with the news of Konnor Griffin going down.
You already have Horwitz down.
There's Oneil Cruz that's out.
Who is he these days?
This could be a crucial time frame where, yeah, Mitch Keller, that the Pirates find themselves out of it and are even talking about buyers.
With that said, 7-5 in the first four series.
Like, I understand some of the losses are frustrating, right?
And we vent out our frustrations on the postgame and such.
But they are 7-5 in one of the most crucial parts of the season right now when they're down people.
Let's be rational about this.
They're taking care of business.
They are.
But they're winnable games and they should be better.
That's the frustrating part.
They lost.
Oh, I know.
I know.
And, like, they're doing a good job of keeping their head above water.
But at the same time, they've wasted.
So many things that should have pushed them to evict.
Like, they've wasted Esmerlyn Valdez is just ridiculously hot stretch.
The guy has, like, 13 homers in a month.
You should win a lot of those games.
Like, the stretch he's on is stupid.
Bubba Chandler is lights out in Yankee Stadium.
You lose.
Like, they have the Guardians on the ropes of what should be a sweep.
And the bullpen blows it.
Like, they're just – there's too many games that they should have won that just leaves a sour taste.
Yes, they've done a good job of keeping their head above water.
If you look at it ahead of time and you ask if they're 7-5 in this stretch, are you cool with that?
We're probably going to say yes.
But, sorry.
Looking at hindsight here, you still have to do that.
They should have won even more.
Well, then I take everything back.
I was like, we're going to – it's going to turn more positive in my head.
I was like, no.
I should have won more.
Not enough.
It wasn't good enough.
No, it wasn't good enough.
Because there's going to be a downstretch, too, where you're not winning games.
And you're not getting bailed out.
But I guess, like, this is where I come back at you.
And, again, like, you're down Konnor Griffin.
You're – O'Neal's coming back.
Spence is coming back.
And they're coming back very shortly.
And, yes, I see you're super up here.
We're going to bring it up here.
We'll transition into that.
But, like, you're having reinforcements come back plus a trade deadline where you have the ability to now absolutely bolster what needs to be bolstered.
And that's the bullpen.
What you need to do is find a way to at least tread water to get there.
And they've not been treading water.
They've been actually gaining games in doing so.
And that's why I do want to put that perspective out here because I do know there's frustrating losses.
And they are absolutely frustrating.
And there's – they could – I'm talking they're 7-5.
And the easy could be, like, 10-2, or 9-3.
Like, I agree with that.
I agree with that.
But heading into this, knowing that they're down Conor, they're down O'Neal, they're down Spencer Horwitz, those are three big parts of their offense.
That's a third of the offense essentially every night.
And it's not that they maintain what they were doing beforehand.
They actually did better than what they were doing with those three guys.
they're playing at, like, a 58.3% pace.
Small sample, but, like, that's what they're doing.
I don't think you could ask too much more in this stretch whether it's some really good teams that they're playing.
these are all playoff-caliber teams.
And they're doing more than just holding their own.
Seven wins, five losses.
But the losses are avoidable.
That's the problem because you ignored the bullpen for so damn long.
And I'm tired of treading water.
DiNardo, I'm tired of treading water.
Some of these wins they got could have been avoidable from the other teams as well.
But their offense is just that good.
Like, the games they've won, they've been in control and we're just waiting on the bullpen to blow it.
They just didn't that night.
Well, now Dennis is not here to blow it.
I'm glad they've been able to, as you say, tread some water and maybe put a life jacket on a touch.
Not even a life jacket.
They put floaties on.
One floatie.
To gain a touch of ground.
Well, they only need one floatie.
And that's, they need that on the right arm.
Because they can't hit lefties.
But the issue and what's annoying, just as a fan, what's annoying here is that if you go nine and three in this stretch or you have that really hot streak here,
put yourself in real contention.
Get in, like, get on solid ground with the wild card spot and then you can really go after it at the deadline.
What they've done here is just treaded water so long that...
See, I disagree with that.
Not enough.
I want to be comfortable going forward here.
If they're in the Cubs' shoes right now, five and a half games up on the wild card.
I don't think they're approaching the trade deadline differently than they are right now, being just one game out of it.
Like, I guess that's where I'm pushing back.
If they so happen to do what you're saying, Tyler, are we going to say, well, you know what?
They don't need to do as much at the trade deadline because they're up five and a half.
Or are you saying they still got to go all in?
You're right.
They might just be like, no, we're good.
So I guess that's where I'm pushing back is I don't think the approach at the deadline is any different right now if they are where they're sitting with the Cubs or they're sitting where they're currently right now.
It's the same approach they need to do.
Yeah, because if anything, Tyler, just like what you said right now, it doesn't give them an excuse of why they didn't go all in.
They know they need to.
Ben's job is probably counting on it.
He can't sit here and say, well, the simulations told us we'd be fine with one reliever.
I'm just saying, I don't think it's any different.
That's fair.
That's fair.
But at the very least, you know what, DiNardo?
I would just feel better.
I'd feel better giving up an Edward Florentino if I know that I'm talking about a team that's going to be in the playoffs and I can confirm it.
I'm more comfortable giving more up because I don't want to give up top-flight talent to maybe make a wild card.
That's the spot they're in right now.
And that's a position that, it shouldn't matter to Ben Cherington.
He should be going after it right now because if he doesn't, he's out.
Should be out.
I'd feel better in that Cubs spot myself.
But I think what you're saying has some merit to it as well.
So, instead of bringing it up, I'm a Pitt fan, 66.
Thanks for the $5 super.
Horwitz played second game at Bradenton tonight.
Do I anticipate he'll be activated for the Cubs series?
If so, who does he replace?
Ozuna?
So, again, this is why at this current spot that they're in, I don't think you can ask for too much more because they've been without a lot of players.
Reinforcements are coming.
Spencer Horwitz, I think, is the first.
Oh, no.
Cruz, we know, is going to be out until August 6th, I believe the date is, because he was put on the 60-day IL for the move that happened with Khristian Curtis.
And we know it's not Connor.
Connor's out for a bit of time.
So, Spencer Horwitz is probably going to be the first to come back.
Yes, tonight was his second game.
His last game was June 24th.
So, essentially, he's been out for a whole month.
I don't know, again, I don't know what the plan is for him, if he will be back for the Cubs series.
It's only been two games.
I feel like if he would be back for the Cubs series, maybe his rehab would have just been in Altoona, so he's close.
So, I'm not anticipating that he is, but I'll say this.
Like, it's been said he'll be back before the end of July.
He would have been back before Cruz.
I think, if anything, he'll probably just miss the Cubs series and then be back.
But, at any rate, he's coming back.
I don't know what he's doing tonight, but the night before, he went one for three with two walks, no strikeouts.
I'll look up tonight now.
He would be a very welcome addition, though.
he was having a hell of a year.
And, Jake Mangum's he's filled in pretty admirably up there at the top of the order.
And, I think Nick Gonzales has done a good job as well against lefties up there.
But, man, having Spencer back would be nice.
It helps your lineup out.
You can get Ryan O'Hearn more days at DH, I think, with what Valdez has done.
That really helps O'Hearn, I think, as well, because you can play him in right field.
Then you can give Valdez some days down where he's DH-ing.
It's just another good bat in the lineup.
Obviously, that's a good thing.
Yeah.
But, to be fair...
Well, as I say, first off, yeah, to be fair, this has been a lineup that has not struggled with any of the guys being down.
So, you talk about Jake Mangum, and he has, again, the rise of Jake Mangum is not making me trade Oneil Cruz.
But, I will say, with Oneil Cruz being down, Jake Mangum has filled in very well.
Again, it's one of those things, like, you can't ask for anything more out of Jake Mangum, more or less, in that time frame.
Nick Gonzales has stepped up.
with Esmerlyn Valdez, how well he's played.
So, guys have stepped up.
This offense has been very good.
But, yes, getting Spencer Horwitz back, who has been...
he was outstanding last year.
He's outstanding this year.
It only helps solidify things.
So, yeah, who do you get rid of?
And, like he said, is it Ozuna?
I don't think the time of Ozuna is yet.
Is it just...
Is it Billy?
Is it Ozuna?
It's not Jacob Gonzalez.
I know my answer.
That's for sure.
Who is it?
Okay.
That's it.
I...
It was a fun first week.
Since then, he's had...
He's had some hits in there.
This guy's not a major leaguer.
One, the...
Adding Horwitz in here is going to create a logjam where I don't know where you really play him.
Because your outfield's pretty full there.
You're not playing him at first base anymore because you have O'Hearn and Horwitz.
You mentioned it's not time for Ozuna.
Callihan can't hit a fastball.
Plain and simple.
The guy cannot hit a fastball.
He's got options.
Someone's got to go off the 40-man, but I think you can figure that out as things go.
And it might be around the trade deadline by that point.
So, who knows?
Mm-hmm.
Shit, it could be both.
Ozuna and Callihan.
Ozuna might be the guy off the 40-man with Callihan going down.
Who knows?
But Callihan, if Horwitz was back tomorrow, Tyler Callihan's the guy I'm sending down.
And throw a dart in DFA.
Someone don't care.
Or throw Evan Sisk on the 60-day.
I don't know.
Somebody's...
I don't know where he's at in his injury progression, but you can find someone.
Wait, why am I lost?
Why has someone got to go off the 40?
Oh, no, you're right.
Nobody has to go off the 40.
Horwitz didn't hit the 60, did he?
No.
Okay, never mind.
I was thinking he hit the 60 there.
My bad.
I was thinking they put him on the 60.
My bad.
He ended up on me.
Because I'm like...
On me.
Wait a minute.
But either way, okay.
So, Tyler Callihan, and I want to ask this to you in the sense is if you're GM, you're also making that move, like this is you saying that's what you think Ben will do, this is you saying this is what I would do also?
100% what I would do.
So, you're also keeping Ozuna?
No.
What do you mean no?
No, but that's just not the move I'm making for...
I was like, I want a 25-man active roster.
Screw this position.
No, I'm not keeping him.
I'm getting rid of him.
But I'm going to do that for something else.
We're talking about this move.
So, your first move, though, is Callihan, not Ozuna.
Yes.
Yes.
I didn't like Callihan when they got him.
I don't like him now.
Yeah.
Well, I would say that's a debate.
And people are going to say, that's crazy.
Get rid of Ozuna.
And, I don't think it's that easy as well.
I think Callihan will be the person.
I think they're going to hang on to Ozuna, like, almost as long as they can.
Also, I don't know if they're going to try to attempt to trade prospects with him for some people to eat his salary.
Like, I don't know what their intentions of how the exit plan of Ozuna is going to look.
I hate you.
Well, I'm just saying, I don't know if they're looking for a straight DFA and eating all the money.
I could maybe anticipate.
there's contradicting reports about how the payroll has to look if they're going to make a trade or not.
I think Mackie went out there and said, like, that's not, what's his face said?
Nightingale, right?
Nightingale said that if they're going to make moves, it has to be no increase of payroll.
And Mackie made the rebuttal and said, that's not true.
again, not like Nightingale has a great track record.
So, put that out.
No, DiNardo, but, like, I'm sorry, I don't mean to cut you off here, but talked about trading the 34th pick.
You talk about trading this $500,000 of international money.
They didn't add anybody throughout the year as bullpen help, so they didn't have to pay anybody extra.
Like, at some point where there's smoke, there's fire here.
And how much money is available?
We'll find out.
Right.
But I think there might be a touch of truth.
It could.
But it's also Nightingale.
So, who knows?
But, again, like I'm saying, we'll find out.
But that's why.
So, I'm talking in regards of Pirates' viewpoint.
Ben Cherington.
I think it's going to be Callihan as well, because, again, I'm not sure what the exit for Ozuna looks like.
And we do know that they do like him in the clubhouse.
They certainly look at him as an asset there because they are willing to have him on the roster and never play him.
So, yeah.
You know what?
I think it's going to be Callihan.
I'm okay with it being Callihan.
Spencer Horvitz comes back.
This offense just gets even better.
But, like, they have the Cubs series coming up.
They have Arizona Diamondbacks.
They have the Cincinnati Reds.
And then it is the trade deadline.
And, again, that caps this brutal stretch we're talking about.
I'm not really putting the Reds in there anymore as, like, the brutal team.
But that's still in-division.
Like, it's still a tough series in the sense of it.
Still baseball.
They got the first half of this brutal stretch coming out 7-5.
Now they take on the Cubs.
That is a team.
Like, these games really count because, unlike the Brewers, you weren't really chasing the Brewers, most likely.
It still is baseball.
But the Brewers are sitting on top of the division.
There was such a gap.
I think it was, like, a 10-game gap at that point in time where they swept them.
Like, you're not really chasing the Brewers.
You're just trying to climb and get up to the standings in the wild card.
But the Cubs are a team you're chasing for that wild card.
Like I just mentioned, they're five and a half games up.
You're one out.
You can make a big difference in this series coming up here one way or the other.
So, this one is pretty crucial in the sense of a three-game series in the middle of July.
Biggest series of the year.
It's always been a big series of the year.
But that's, yeah.
Like, at this point, pretty much any NL opponent is the biggest series of the year.
And this one is big.
In division.
It's the Cubs.
They've played well against Central this year.
I want to go.
I want to go to the games.
You said you want to go.
Yeah, I want to go.
Like, these are big games.
Yeah, they can make up some ground here.
Diamondbacks after.
Right now.
Like, there's.
These are some big games.
So, the Pirates will be at home.
The Pirates are up 4-3 in the season series.
Like you said, the Pirates have done a good job taking care of business at home.
Beating the teams in the NL Central.
They've done a very good job of that so far for the most part.
So, they have so far one game up on this series.
Season-long series with the Cubs, right?
They've beaten four times out of seven.
The Pirates have a run differential of plus 51.
Cubs is plus 65.
In the last 10, the Pirates are 6-4.
Cubs are 5-5.
Again, they'll be at home.
At home, the Pirates are 27-24.
The Cubs on the road are 27-23.
Like, I just say this, too, because in all the numbers and the sense of things I'm putting out here, like, they're very evenly matched.
And there's not a whole lot of difference.
The bullpen is, of course, the biggest difference.
But, like, when you look at the two teams, I know Pirates get a lot of flack.
they're not a real team and stuff.
But they're a playoff contender.
Like, they absolutely are, in all sense of the words.
They are.
And going into the series, you look at the pitching matchups, and the Pirates have Jared Jones, Paul Skenes, Braxton Ashcraft.
Like, at this point in time of the year, those are three guys you're comfortable with in a series that you need to win.
Am I right or wrong on that?
Or indifferent?
Well, before I answer that, can I just do a shameless plug?
Because you're able to rattle off who's pitching in that, those three games.
If you go to MLB.com and try to look up any of this stuff, they'll just take you to try to sell you tickets.
So, NorthShore9.com, you can actually see stuff and figure out who is throwing every day.
MLB.com, awful.
What a terrible web.
They just tore that thing apart.
Not us.
Not us.
There you go.
Also, I pulled all those numbers off of our website.
Yeah.
It's much easier to find stuff.
Yeah.
It's a good website.
It's garbage.
I actually have to break the habit of going to MLB.com and remember that we have a website.
We're in the trust tree here.
I do.
We're in the trust tree as we're on a podcast.
It's for the best.
Trust tree here.
But, like you said, the Pirates have their horses going.
Like the way Jared Jones has been pitching.
Skeen's after that and Ashcraft.
I'm not worried about Ashcraft yet.
And I was encouraged by Skeen's last start against the Guardians.
It's one you really need to get two out of.
That's my analysis.
You're welcome.
Boom.
But with that said, again, Jared Jones going against Matthew Boyd.
Paul Skenes's against Shota Imanaga, who historically has given the Pirates a lot of problems.
However, if I recall the last time that he pitched this year against the Pirates, they lit him up.
I think so.
I believe so.
Of course, it's me.
Could be wrong.
And then they finish it up with Braxton Ashcraft going against Jameson Tyone, who has not been having fun this season.
So, like you said, like we look at the pitching matchups.
both teams, I think, have pitching staffs you assume were going to be better than what they're doing this year.
Like everything I'm saying about the Cubs pitching staff right now, the Cubs 9 podcast is looking at the Pirates and saying the same thing about our pitching, if that makes sense.
So, like, I feel like both staffs are underperforming than what they thought they're going to be doing.
So, with that said, both teams could take out their pitchers.
But, again, this is a very good offense.
The way Paul is pitching recently, the way Jared Jones is pitching recently, and Braxton Ashcraft is not pitching well recently.
Neither is Jameson Tyone, but Braxton has had a really good season.
Like, this is a series, especially at home, that they could take two out of three.
Like you're saying, they need to, and this will just keep on going.
You take two out of three, now you're nine.
I'm sorry.
Were they seven and five?
So, now you're nine and six, in this brutal stretch.
And you've gained another one, but you also knocked down the Cubs a couple.
Yeah, that makes me feel better.
There you go.
Now, you talked about the matchups.
First two games of the series, you're facing a lefty.
We know the issues that the Pirates have had.
This is such a great opportunity for Esmeralyn Valdez to really just put himself on the map.
Like, he can endear himself to this city even more than he already has.
And, like, he has really well.
And he's played really great baseball.
Yeah.
But if I'm looking at this lineup here of, like, who can do damage against lefties, it's that guy.
It's that guy.
Yeah, do it.
So, before, if you go to a website or the app, before every game, you can select the winner.
Of course, it's the gamification of the app and website.
You can earn points.
The top three points getters of every month gets a free NS9 t-shirt.
But, anyways, before every game, you can select the winner.
You can select who's going to, have the most strikeout or what strikeouts you're going to get.
The runs, all this stuff.
It's this cool stuff you can pick.
But one of them is also who's going to hit a home run.
And any time they're facing a lefty, the only person that's an option for me that I will ever select is Esmeralyn Valdez.
If there's a lefty, it's Esmeralyn Valdez.
Every time.
Could be a Marcell Ozuna series as well.
It can't be.
It cannot be.
It won't be.
He's not going to play.
No faith.
They're not playing.
Right.
But, anyways, it's still, it's, yeah, it's a winnable series.
They hopefully need to.
But, like, again, if they go one and two, technically speaking, like, it's not the end of the world by any means.
It's not the end of the world by any means.
You want to see them do better.
But, they go to Arizona.
They could sweep the Diamondbacks.
You're looking like, okay, well, then it's now a three and three split or whatever.
Or four and two.
And it's like, okay, well, now it's like they're still right there.
So, that's why, like, there's not one series that's so impactful in this world like that.
But, when you're playing individuals, especially a team like this, the Cubs were battling for the wild card.
Like, there's definitely some meaning to this one.
You think?
And, like, right before the deadline as well.
Yeah, I'm telling you what.
We really brought it today, Dardo.
We brought all the analysis.
Well, Jim's not here.
Yeah.


Comments· 0
When Spencer Horwitz returns, should the Pirates send down Tyler Callihan before moving on from Marcell Ozuna?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.