◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
North Shore Nine went live from LECOM Park in Bradenton with Anthony DiNardo and Doug bringing the on-the-ground Spring Training energy (yes, with Bob Nutting lurking nearby). With the Pirates getting closer to Opening Day, the guys focused on what actually matters right now: pitching roles, roster fits, and which storylines feel real after the first couple weeks of camp.
The conversation starts with Mike Clevinger getting the ball and the question that follows him everywhere in March: what’s the role? Rotation depth? Multi-inning bullpen weapon? As a non-roster invite, he’s a name worth tracking, and this outing was a good checkpoint. From there, it turns into the broader pitching picture — the fifth starter battle, Carmen Mlodzinski’s usage, and why the “starter vs. bullpen” debate is going to define a few key arms as the Pirates narrow decisions.
They also run through a lineup that looks a lot closer to “regular season mode” than a typical spring card: Jake Mangum setting the table, Brandon Lowe and Bryan Reynolds in the middle, plus Ryan O’Hearn and Marcell Ozuna adding thump. Spencer Horwitz gets a mention with the WBC looming, and the guys touch on what they want to see from Henry Davis and the bottom-half pieces as opportunities shrink.
Watch/listen now and drop your biggest Spring Training takeaway in the comments. More Bradenton recaps are coming before Opening Day.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the bullpen instead of competing for the fifth starter job?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Carmen Mlodzinski shouldn't be a starter. He's lights out in the bullpen, the Pirates need that, and his numbers drop off after the second or third inning.
2
Mike Clevenger will probably pitch for the Pirates this year. They used 29 pitchers last season, and a cheap veteran who was good as recently as 2023 is the kind of depth they need.
3
Oneil Cruz's approach this spring makes him look like a 100-run, 50-steal player. He doesn't need to be the MVP, but he has to be better than he was last year.
4
Bryan Reynolds will DH at least once a week and O'Hearn will play some first base, which opens up a lot of playing time for contact hitter Jake Mangum to grab.
5
Take the under on 8.5 runs against the Rays: the wind is blowing in and was killing fly balls in batting practice.
this starting lineup – or that portion of the starting lineup, we expect to see a lot this year.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And, so, yeah.
it's – again, it's starting to feel more real.
I'm sure they're only going to play, four innings, five innings, what have you.
But, baseball is right around the corner.
And, the Pirates are getting ready.
Yeah.
It absolutely is.
So, kicking off, as you mentioned, Jake Mangum is going to play center field.
But, you have Mangum.
You have Brandon Lowe, Bryan Reynolds, Ryan O'Hearn, Marcell Ozuna, Spencer Horwitz.
Potentially, maybe his last game or one of the very few before he goes off to the WBC as well.
So, it's nice to get some action from him this week.
And, then, yeah, Henry Davis at catcher, Emmanuel Valdez, and Alika Williams at shortstop today.
So, like you said, it's very top-heavy.
The last two, probably – they're funny for a roster spot.
At least Valdez to some degree.
Alika, probably not.
But, he's going to have a lot of play time with, the WBC coming up.
Yeah.
He's going to get opportunities.
We're going to see a lot of them.
Hey, look.
the kid's a great fielder.
There's always a room for him.
He can't hit a lick.
But, you can always – it's always nice to have someone that could be a slick fielder.
especially, like, somebody goes down.
you can't replace that bat necessarily.
But, if you can replace the glove and make the plays and help the pitching staff out, there could be a spot for him.
I'm sure he'll be up at some time.
Maybe.
He didn't see the field any time last year.
this year they definitely improved the roster.
But, again, he could be some depth there.
But, I do want to go to the pitching.
So, again, it was starting off today.
With Mike Clevenger.
And then Carmen Gizzy's coming in.
Before we do so, of course, to tell you all, this episode is brought to you by IQ Bar.
Our exclusive snack, hydration, IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix Hydration Mixes.
Our delicious low-sugar brain body fuel you need for a day.
So, all IQ Bar's are clean label, certified, and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
All IQ Bar products are packed with clean, delicious ingredients that keep you physically and mentally fit, like Magnesium, Lion's Mane, and more.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their busy lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body-based bars and hydration mixes.
So, as of right now, IQ Bar is offering our special podcast listeners 20% off IQ Bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, just text MLB to 64,000.
Text MLB to 64,000.
That's MLB to 64,000.
Messages and data rates may apply.
See terms for more details.
So, again, Clevenger is going to start today, which I do find a little bit interesting because, with Carmen Genzy coming in there, it was told that the Pirates are interested in seeing what he can do as a starter again.
So, again, the roles are reversed today.
Not that it mean much to the spring, but is Clevenger going to get the start today?
Right.
yeah, they're both probably going to pitch three innings.
I don't think it matters who's starting, who's coming in next.
I know that the Clevenger signing didn't really move the needle, and if it did, maybe it was in a bit of a negative way.
But two years ago, he was a pretty good pitcher.
He's had a pretty good career.
Pirates used 29 pitchers last year, right?
You're not – whatever 13 go north are not going to be the only 13 pitchers that pitch all year.
it's so funny when we'll claim some reliever and everyone, oh, why are they making these bums?
Because you need 30 pitchers to get through a season.
And if Clevenger can, do the Andrew Heaney role, like if he makes six starts, and, six somewhat, effective starts before he falls apart or something, he'll probably be needed, and he'll be good to have that.
I don't know.
I'm not expecting him to put out a Cy Young campaign.
If he pitches, it's most likely going to be Andrew Bullperner as a fifth starter.
But, he's had a pretty decent career.
He's up like 66 and 40 or something in his career.
We might be able to do this with him.
With the Pirates scoring more runs, he might not have to be perfect.
That'll be a refreshing change.
So I want to see what he does.
Because, the Pirates obviously, Benjamin at least has enough faith in him to bring him into camp.
Let's see what happens.
Yeah, and I think you hit the nail on the head there as far as, like, depth.
you need pitching.
29 pitchers, that's a lot of guys, right?
So, when you find, you always see on Twitter, right?
Some candidates, I was like, oh, we're also retired.
I'm going to be in chief.
Well, no, you need these guys.
Every team does.
And, like you're pointing out with Clevenger, it's not often you get a guy that cheap who, it wasn't that long ago he was really good.
he came up with Cleveland, was a son of a pitcher.
injuries really derailed his career.
But you go back just as recent as 2023, he had 131 innings with the White Sox, a .377 ERA.
this was a guy who was hovering right around a .3 ERA every year with Cleveland in his prime.
So, like, you know the talent is there.
There's no expectations.
He's coming in.
He may make the team.
He may be a starter.
He may be a bullpen guy.
We don't know.
But he could be a part of this team that helps, like you mentioned.
Right.
it's more than likely he will pitch for the Pirates this year.
Yeah, absolutely.
More than likely he will pitch.
How much, how effective, time will tell.
But let's see what he can do.
Let's see.
let's see if he looks healthy.
That's the important thing, obviously.
When the guy has been healthy, he's been a very good pitcher.
Pirates can, and, the Pirates traded pitching depth.
And we lost Mike Burroughs and Yohan Obieto.
I'm not sure that Antwone Kelly and we were talking about this morning are quite ready to ride to the rescue.
I don't know what Erkiti has.
And I don't want Matinsky as a starter.
That's my personal thing.
He lights out in the bullpen, and we need lights out in the bullpen.
And so, yeah, again, there's a very good chance that he gets, has multiple appearances for the Pirates this year.
For sure.
So let's see what he has.
Let's see what he can do.
For sure.
And though you don't get too much funkier on the mound, then, well, it's going to be interesting to watch him regardless of how well he pitches.
But, next up is Karamudzinski, and like you mentioned, there's definitely some, I'm not going to say controversy, but it's split.
this guy, should we even entertain him being a starter?
Should we just say, hey, this is what works, being the bullpen?
I'm fine with him entertaining at this point in time.
Again, if he's a starter and he's good, it only helps even more.
Oh, yeah.
the people that want to talk on Jared Jones, like, oh, he's a bullpen arm.
his value comes in the rotation.
If he can give you that type of production in the rotation, he'll be very valuable.
And, like, the same thing exists, obviously, for Karamudzinski.
Like, if he's going to be a good pitcher, the value's most, productive in the rotation.
I'm just not so sure he will be.
Right.
what we've seen so far is that he's not very good after his second or third inning.
Right.
If he, look, if he can stretch himself out, if he can be a five-inning pitcher, because that's what you need to be in today's baseball, especially as a number five starter, if he can be a fifth at that, I'm happy to see him in the starting role.
But from what, we've seen his splits.
It's, as a starter, not so good, as a bullpen pitcher, lights out.
But he deserves every opportunity.
I don't want anybody being handed jobs.
If he can compete, if he can win the job.
And then if he can produce, fine.
Have at it.
We can find somebody else for the bullpen.
Yeah, absolutely.
And again, we've talked about this morning.
Since it's a level of degree, then we add a splitter.
He worked on his pitch sequencing, the curveball the second half.
So, there's a different picture in karma.
At least that's how he feels.
Maybe the Pirates are viewing him this year opposed to last year.
So, with the battle of the five starter, with a battle of depth, and just in the sense of, like, maybe that he could be used in both ways.
Maybe he's a real, in some sense.
He has a bullpen, he's a ball guy.
But at any rate, he will be, unlike Clever, right?
Like, he will be a part of this team.
In a big way.
He's going to be counted on this year.
He'll be on the roster opening day.
Look, I'm thrilled that he wants to start.
I'm thrilled that he wants to start.
I, you know.
What you're saying, Doug, is, you want dogs in your team.
You guys, you want people that want to do things.
Right.
He's like, I don't want to be the sixth and seventh inning guy.
Right.
Exactly.
I get it.
He's been a little moxie.
Right.
If he, to me, it's simple.
If he could do it, have at it, Carmen.
But, let's find out for sure.
Let's, man, let's not give out any jobs.
Let's, this isn't, no orange slices, no jobs.
There, I was going to say that.
We know you're a lot, right?
No orange slices.
But, obviously, they might not be that great here anyway.
Yeah, so it's all good.
But, anyways, no, so getting to the lineup, as we mentioned, it's a pretty solid one with Mangum, Brandon Lowe, Reynolds, O'Hearn, Ozuna, Horwitz.
And, actually, all of them pretty much producing this spring as well.
From what you've seen now, this is a second time seeing some versus others.
Right.
my favorite thing to see this spring is Oneil Cruz get to first base, walk or single, and then steal, and then get knocked in by other guys.
It's happened a couple times.
And, I love Oneil Cruz's approach so far this spring.
I don't know if that's what it's going to be doing all year.
But, right now, he looks like a guy that's going to score 100-plus runs.
He's going to steal 50-plus bases.
And, yesterday, he did catch a home run.
That's still in there, too.
But, I want him to get away from only focusing on blowing up stack cast.
Right.
And, for two, if you need actual production, he doesn't have to be the MVP, but he's got to be better than he was last year.
Yep.
So, with Cruz playing for the Dominican and the WBC, we're not going to see him at all anymore this week.
So, again, like, with these comes opportunity.
Right?
So, Jake Bingham will be in center field today, and, obviously, he's a big part of that trade.
And, yeah, he's going to be a big part of this team as well.
Probably more like the fourth outfielder, but the fact that he can play all the different positions.
I'm also, like, I'm very interested to see what Jake Bingham can do.
Yeah.
We understand some training stats don't matter too much, but I want to know what that bat really can be.
Listen, he hit .297 last year.
I don't know if he can replicate that, but he is a guy that gets on base.
He's not swinging.
He is a different look.
He doesn't strike out a lot.
We have a lot of big swingers, a lot of strikeout guys.
Today's baseball is filled with strikeouts.
So, it would just be nice to have somebody that's focused on, I love what he said when Tyler interviewed him, I touch the ball and I run.
Yes.
And we've seen that, and he's been a fun guy to watch.
He's been a great guy to talk to, watch him interact with the fans.
But he's going to get a ton of playing time, right?
You were going to, like, Bryan Reynolds, I see Bryan Reynolds DH-ing at least once a week.
Comments· 0
Should Carmen Mlodzinski stay in the bullpen instead of competing for the fifth starter job?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.