After the Pirates’ 5-0 loss to San Diego, Alex Stumpf digs into a bigger concern than one bad night: the outfield defense. He breaks down Bryan Reynolds’ costly misplay, the growing questions around Oneil Cruz in center, Bubba Chandler’s uneven outing, Konnor Griffin pressing at the plate, and how Marcell Ozuna’s presence affects the lineup’s flexibility. If you want the real takeaway from Monday night, this episode is worth your time.
The Biggest Red Flag on the Pirates Right Now

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
The Pirates' outfield defense is even worse than Stumpf expected, and he already expected it to be bad.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Bryan Reynolds should have caught Jackson Merrill's fly ball. Keeping it a one-run game instead of 3-0 would have changed how San Diego used its bullpen and let Pittsburgh be more aggressive on the bases.
Alex Stumpf - 3
Without the Marcel Ozuna signing, the Pirates could have played O'Hearn at first, used Horwitz at DH and as a backup infielder, moved Reynolds to right and given left field to Garcia or Mangum. Ozuna locking up the DH spot takes that flexibility away from Don Kelly.
Alex Stumpf - 4
A -2 fielding run value one-sixteenth of the way through the season puts the outfield on pace for -32 runs. That's more than the 16 to 20 runs people once hoped Ke'Bryan Hayes could save on his own.
Alex Stumpf - 5
Ten games in, Stumpf's top reason the Pirates would miss the playoffs is holding up: the starting pitching isn't getting enough help from the defense.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript146 paragraphs · show
- It's a frigid night in Pittsburgh. The five game winning streak is snapped. It was one of those nights at PNC Park Monday. Good morning. welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel. My name is Alex Stumpf. This is a daily look at your Pittsburgh
Pirates. The win streak was snapped last night. Pirates fall five to nothing to the Padres. One of those games. Let's just get that right out in front. It's one of those games. Anyone who acts like it's anything more than the 10th game of the season. Don't believe it. All right. It's one game out of 162. No reason to overreact. There are some reasons for some reddish flags, though, like
Bubba Chandler didn't get the command quite right. And he's still very fastball heavy, something that I talked about it after his last start would like to see more change ups and sliders from him.
Konnor Griffin now has been hit list for three straight games way too soon to be worried about him, even though it does look like he is pressing a little bit.
The big thing. The big thing for me. My big takeaway is this outfield defense is not very good.
Actually, it's probably even worse than what I anticipated. And actually, I anticipated the south field defense to be not very good.
Not very good. On Monday, Bryan Reynolds couldn't track down Jackson Merrill fly ball, a ball that he really should have had.
In my opinion, he really should have had that ball. But it sails on him. It bounces into the stands. It ends up being a two run mistake.
And Pirates, you can't win without scoring a run. But it's a very different ball game, in my opinion, if you're able to keep that a one run game instead of a three nothing game.
Maybe you force the Padres to use the bullpen differently. Maybe it gives you a chance to be more aggressive if you do get a man on base, the type of stuff that you expect small ball to be.
That was a costly mistake. It is far from the first mistake this outfield has made. And I get a lot of them have centered around Oneil Cruz.
That game opening day against the Mets was bad. He's had bump ins with both of his corner outfielders, because he's either not projecting or they're not listening well enough or whatever the case may be.
He's not doing a good enough job to call people off. But this is now multiple times in 10 games where there is a play in left field.
It's like, yeah, that's on Bryan Reynolds. And that's a play he needs to make.
That's not good, especially whenever you have Oneil Cruz in center, who is, trying to work out some stuff through by himself right now, trying to work through his own problems right now.
And then Ryan O'Hearn, who has made some great catches, this is not going to be a slight on Ryan O'Hearn, but he is at the end of the day, a first baseman first and an outfielder second.
He's doing it for the good of the team to build the best possible lineup right now. And he's working hard at it.
I remember opening day in the lights are going off. This is the fun part of doing it in the stands here at PNC Park of opening day whenever I wanted to talk to him like, hey, can I catch you after batting practice?
He's like, no, I'm not hitting. I'm going out to shag fly balls. He's working to try to get as many reads, as many opportunities in practice to try to see how the ball goes with the with the upper deck, track the backspin, all that type of stuff.
I like the effort there. And that's not implying that, Cruz and Reynolds aren't putting effort there, but like, that's what he needs to do right now.
And that's what he's doing. And he is working to be the best version of himself, which is good because this outfield can has little wiggle room right now.
Had the Pirates not signed Marcel Azuna, I think this would be a lot easier to just map out.
Like I said, opening day, they're married to Cruz and centerfield because it's it has to work or it's not going to work.
There is really no other option for him. He can't go to third base because of the footwork was so bad at shortstop.
That's why they moved about to the outfield and footworks paramount important at third base.
I can't put him at shortstop. You can't really put him in a corner, in my opinion, because tracking fly balls, tracking line drives, tracking slices, that's only going to get worse at the corners. And that's what he's really struggled with.
It seems like in the field. So that's not really an option for him.
He has to. But the rest of the outfield could have been a lot more flexible.
Had they not signed Marcel Azuna, I think they could have had Ryan O'Hearn get a lot more reps at first base and had Spencer Horwitz be that first base, second base backup infielder and a DH primarily.
That would have let Reynolds play right field and then left field could have either gone to Garcia, could have gone to Mangum, could have, they'd have some flexibility there.
And that's not to say that we won't see Garcia at some point this season.
That's not to say that Mangum isn't getting a decent amount of reps right now for a fourth outfielder, but Marcel Azuna having him in the lineup doesn't give Don Kelly a lot of flexibility.
If you have someone who is in trunched into that DH spot, you don't have as much flexibility to use the rest of your position players.
So that leaves the Pirates with this scenario where you got Bryan Reynolds and left who has not graded well defensively the last couple of years.
And Oneil Cruz in center who is struggling defensively and we have seen multiple times that a young starting pitching young starting pitcher has struggled has had a crooked number put up because an outfielder couldn't catch a ball.
This is two starts in a row for Bubba Chandler where fairly routine fly ball was hit out to left center and in both times a run unexpectedly scored.
Bubba's going through his own stuff right now with command and trying to just get outs.
He can't really be giving away the defense can't be giving away outs for him.
They need to execute those types of plays.
Because if you give a team like the Padres those extra opportunities, they are going to take advantage.
And that is a big reason why they won Monday night.
Now, I'm not going to sound like I'm overreacting because like I said, it is one out of 162.
But the defense has been an issue so far.
We're going to take a quick break here.
We'll be right back.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
I don't know how this defense gets better without just that internal improvement right now.
Because like I said, bar an injury, I don't know how you make Jake Mangum an everyday player.
I don't know how you call up someone like Garcia.
And through nine games entering Monday, the Pirates outfield defense had negative two fielding run value, according to Baseball Savant, which put them in the bottom five of all baseball.
I imagine that number is going to be worse by Tuesday morning.
If it even stays at just negative two.
The season is one 16th done.
That is a pace for negative 32 fielding runs from the outfield.
Negative 32.
If you threw like 160 innings in a season, that's once every five innings, allowing an extra run.
That's like 1.8 ERA added extra.
Now, it's not that drastic because that'd be all going on one pitcher instead of it.
But 32 runs is significant, especially since for years we talked about like, oh, could Ke'Bryan Hayes just save 16, 20 runs defensively?
Oh, negative 32 fielding run value pace.
And that's assuming it doesn't go to negative three.
it could be, they could be on pace for like almost negative 50, but tomorrow if they dock Reynolds, like I suspect they might dock Reynolds here.
Whenever I listed my reasons why this Pirates team wasn't going to make the playoffs and those yin and yang, optimist pessimist videos, number one for me for why they wouldn't make the playoffs was this defense.
And so far, some of the question marks have looked pretty good.
Brandon Lowe has looked pretty good at second base.
Granted, a lot of his issues defensively and why his fielding run value was so bad last year came after some injuries that he had midseason.
So that's two pronged here.
One, he's healthy.
Two, it's real early.
But if he can maintain this pace, great.
This is the first almost a mile.
We're almost at the first mile marker, for the 10th of the season.
We're getting close to there.
And so far, Brandon Lowe has done basically everything that you could reasonably expect.
Jared Triolo's hurt at third base, but he is a former gold glove winner.
I would expect good stuff from him.
Konnor Griffin, bats still working there.
But, the glove has looked solid so far.
The outfield was the big wild card here.
And Oneo Cruz in 2025, I thought he made good strides defensively.
I wrote a newsletter because he had like a two-month stretch where he was a positive fielder.
He was graded positively by outs above average.
He's regressed.
I don't know what's going on really there.
Bryan Reynolds, he was a gold glove finalist in center field in 2021.
Now he's having a hard time tracking fly balls left center.
Don Kelly, when asked about it, said that he thought that he didn't expect the ball to travel that far.
Don didn't expect the ball to travel that far.
So maybe it just sailed on Reynolds a little bit.
But it's a ball that, when you look at it, probably should have had.
It's a ball that he got lucky that it bounced into the seats.
Because if that rattles around in the notch, that could have been more than just a double.
Especially considering he fell.
I don't know what the answer is, but this was one of the paramount concerns that I had about this team.
And through 10 games, they have shown that concern was justified.
That if they were going to be missing the playoffs this year, it would be because the starting pitching did not get enough help from its defense.
And whenever someone like Bubba Chandler is struggling to find the zone consistently, he can't have outs, not be recorded.
But that's what happened on Monday.
Played a big part in one of the, probably the biggest nothing burner loss of the season.
There will be worse losses.
Every team will have a worse loss than this.
But, riding a five game high winning streak and you're bringing in a team that is, perpetually in the playoff discussion.
A team that is starting their number five starter who I did a hit on San Diego radio and the host was very like, maybe her mom Marquez isn't here for that long.
It's like, okay, well, starting pitcher who has struggled.
Let's see what happens.
Offense can come through in some key spots with runners in scoring position.
That happens.
Outfield defense could be controlled better.
So we're going to see what happens there.
Because this is a team that cannot cost themselves 30, 40 runs from their outfield.
They have to do better than that.
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat.
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe wherever you find fine podcasts.
Or if you want to check out the YouTube video and see whenever they start shutting off the lights here at PNC Park, click there.
Thank you so much for listening.
Stay warm.
We'll talk again tomorrow.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon.
Become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support.
And Let's Go Bucs.
Let's go Bucs.


Comments· 0
Was signing Marcel Ozuna a mistake, since it took away the Pirates' outfield flexibility?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.