The Pirates are playing better baseball, but the NL Central isn’t making anything easy. In the latest OffBeat, Alex Stumpf breaks down how teams like the Brewers, Cubs, Cardinals, and Reds are all presenting real challenges. From stars like Oneil Cruz and Bryan Reynolds to the division-wide pitching depth, this race feels different. If you’re trying to figure out where the Pirates actually stack up, this is worth your time. Go watch or listen now.
The Pirates Are Better… But So Is the Entire NL Central

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Stumpf thinks the NL Central can produce three playoff teams this year, and that third place in the division is good enough for a playoff spot.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Despite Jordan Walker's MVP-level month, Stumpf is writing off the Cardinals. He says the roster is too young and inexperienced to stay an 85-win wild card contender after their winter sell-off.
Alex Stumpf - 3
Stumpf argues the Reds didn't really earn last year's playoff spot so much as the Mets fell out of it. He doesn't think their weak offense and quiet offseason make them a team that can run the division.
Alex Stumpf - 4
Stumpf still has the Brewers as division favorites regardless of injuries or depth. He says Milwaukee's culture and system matter more than any single GM, manager or player.
Alex Stumpf - 5
Stumpf says the Pirates are just as likely as anyone in the division to make the postseason if they fix middle relief and stop giving away runs on defense, even with an offense where only the 1–4 hitters have produced.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript192 paragraphs · show
The Pittsburgh Pirates finally got competitive, had a good April, and so did the entirety of the National League Central.
Figures, doesn't it? Good morning. Good Friday morning. welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
My name is Stumpf. This is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates. And yes, we are still in Globe Life Field.
And yes, I'm still wearing the same clothes as yesterday because we recorded this back-to-back.
Yeah, this is what we call in the industry cheating. Sorry, I didn't want to fly home and then have to record an episode late at night.
So we're doing two tonight instead. And it's all right because I am looking at this National League Central and it has to be addressed here.
We've been talking just about the Pirates and their goal to make the playoffs, period, full stop, and how they are playing better so far.
They're still not in first place in this division. This is a very tough division, to say the least.
Obviously, a long way to go.
But everybody in the National League Central so far has an above 500 record.
And for those of you wondering, well, how rare is that?
Since the start of divisional play, there have only been two times that every team in a division finished 500 or better.
It is the 2005 National League East and the 1991 AL West, which had seven teams back then, which is just wild.
Wild. That's one of the teams that made that jump.
So good for the 1991 AL West in your seven-team division.
And sorry to America's team that finished 500 that year and in last place.
So, let's just do the doomsday scenario here.
Let's say this isn't just a small sample-sized fluke.
And everyone in the NL Central has come to play this year.
I think this division can produce three playoff teams.
And now, obviously, I'm saying this on April 22nd, 23rd, where the Mets had just snapped a horrendous losing streak.
The Phillies had a horrendous losing streak.
The Braves seem to have, like, a real cakewalk to the division right now.
obviously, a ton of ball still to be played, but they are in the driver's seat.
Like, the Nationals aren't going to compete this year.
The Marlins, they're young, they're scrappy, maybe.
So, NL East might be a one, playoff team division this year.
The West, Dodgers obviously have a stranglehold there, but the Giants look like an absolute mess.
The Rockies are the Rockies.
So, it's like, okay, maybe the Padres, maybe the Diamondbacks.
Count a two there.
This is a division where I think third place in the National League Central gets you a playoff spot.
It did last year.
It did for the Reds.
They got that last ball of card.
So, okay, how likely is it then?
Let's just look at the four other teams in the division and rank them up on how concerned I would be if I was a Pirate fan of that team being in the division mix late in the year.
And we're going to start with number four, the team that I would be personally the least worried about, the St. Louis Cardinals.
Yeah, Jordan Walker is having an insane start to the season.
There's a reason why he's the little dude right here.
He's the graphic for the day.
He has been outstanding.
I will admit, I wrote him off a little.
Just because he had struggled in the big leagues.
And it's like, well, okay, that's someone who's not going to be able to reach his immense potential.
It's been only a month.
He looks like the best player in the National League.
Like, if it wasn't for that Shohei Ohtani guy who pretty much has MVP on lockdown, his month would be an MVP phase.
He'd be on pace for an MVP.
He's got a shot at player of the month.
I'm not discrediting him.
I think he is going to be a real problem in this division this year and potentially for years to come.
One fly in the soup.
I don't think these Cardinals are built for 2026.
They had an aggressive sell-off this winter, making multiple trades, making multiple trades with the Red Sox in particular.
And a lot of the veteran leadership, it's gone.
They don't have as much of that high upside veteran-ness that we had seen the last couple years.
This is a team that it's rebuilding.
And they're probably well overdue for a rebuild.
But they're off to a good start this year.
I don't think it's sustainable.
I don't see this team being like an 85 win competing for a wild card right now unless they drastically supplement the roster at some point.
This team is just too young.
It's too inexperienced.
I don't know if they have as much major league talent as they need to compete.
So, for those reasons, I'm writing off the Cardinals.
They're number four here.
Number three in this impromptu power rankings of the other National League Central clubs, I've got the Reds.
Who really remind me of what the 2025 Reds look like, which was the idealized version of the 2025 Buccos.
They have this young pitching, and it's just going to carry a weak offense.
And maybe someone like Suarez picks up, or Eli De La Cruz, just takes control, or whatever.
But that offense, I've just seen it too much.
I've seen too much of that Reds offense for me to feel like, yeah, they're going to get significantly better.
They did not have a big offseason.
I don't think they improved their roster that much.
And last year, they didn't so much make the playoffs as it was the Mets falling out of the playoffs.
There's a lot there in that pitching staff, and that could potentially carry them.
The Reds' path to the playoffs is remarkably similar to the Pirates'.
Let your young starters take the ball, control the game, and then hope that your offense can be average-ish.
And I will say, Reds' pitching is generally a year or two older than a lot of the Pirates' young pitching.
Mitch Keller notwithstanding.
So, I can see that being a problem, that they just have a little more experience, that they're able to do a little more.
I still don't think that they are in position to run this division.
Could they compete for a playoff spot?
Yeah, but I would view that as more of a wild card if they do that.
Number two team in this power rankings, Chicago Cubs.
And they've got a lot of pitching injuries to go through.
Losing Horton, I think that was a blow.
That was a blow.
They were going to count on him.
There's a lot of pitching injuries that they are dealing with right now.
They will get Justin Steele back, presumably, at this point this season, even the first half of the season.
So, if they do that's good for them.
But they don't have him right now.
And they are doing a great job keeping their head above water through these pitching injuries.
And, you know what, if they do get healthy, theoretically, would keep them in a good spot.
But I don't know if they have the death.
They struck me as a team that would have benefited from signing a Lucas Giolito.
But he's going to the Padres instead.
So, Cubs, obviously, they have that high upside on offense.
bringing in a Bregman.
Having a PCA who is remarkably streaky.
But whenever he gets hot, he is one of the best players in the National League.
They have impact young players.
Nico Horner.
I need to give him his flowers, even if, he doesn't seem to get it all the time from the analytics community.
He is a darn good baseball player.
So, they have impact players around the diamond.
I don't know if they have the pitching.
Which is ironic.
Because, number one, on this power ranking still, and I don't care about what their record is right now.
I don't care about how many pitching injuries they're also dealing with right now.
I don't care if they don't have as much pitching depth as the Cubs seemingly have.
I will not assume that the Brewers are going to win the division whenever there's an E next to their name.
That team is a death star.
Ruthlessly efficient.
That is the meme, the power of friendship team.
And I know that's, a joke online.
But, like, this past postseason, I got to cover Brewers and Cubs.
I assisted for my old outlet.
And I got to really observe how the Brewers operate for a little over a week.
And it clicked for me why they're so good always.
Why they could trade a Corbin Burns or a Peralta or whoever is on an expiring deal.
How they can let a Domus walk.
How they can let these players, every year they seem to lose a player that a lot of other teams, that would be it.
But they're able to keep on chugging.
And it really is a culture thing.
In my opinion.
It is just pure culture.
People who buy into what they have.
People who believe in what they have.
My conversation with Quinn Priester last October, where we talked a little bit, where things went wrong with Pittsburgh, but it was more where things went right with Milwaukee.
And some of it was, analytical coaching.
Or, the old school coaching of, like, hey, why aren't you throwing this more?
Stop throwing that pitch.
Throw this pitch.
that type of stuff.
A lot of it was just them getting him to believe in himself again.
Like, it is a pure culture thing there.
And it's why I don't care about their injuries.
I don't care about their depth.
I don't care about anything.
That team is forever a scary team.
That team is, in perpetuity, going to continue to compete for divisions.
They lost their GM.
They lost their manager to the Cubs.
And I don't want to sound like I'm taking anything away from Matt Arnold or Pat Murphy, who are two good baseball men, two great baseball men.
But they also fit the system perfectly.
And it is the system.
It is just everything they do there.
And that's why I still think they are the favorites to win this division.
I don't think this division is all going to finish .500.
And I think a third-place finish does give any of these teams a pretty decent chance of making the postseason.
And candidly, looking at this Pirates team, they might not be quite as talented on paper as, like, the Cubs.
But they are playing as well as anyone in the National League right now.
They have a very high upside anchored by that pitching.
And this offense that is extremely top-heavy.
it's really just been 1-4 who's really hit this year.
And then 5-9 has not been as great.
But you know what?
That 1-4 has been outstanding.
I look at that and it's like, yeah, that is a team that if they could fix this middle relief issue and, have the defense not cost them as many runs, they could compete.
They are just as likely as anyone else in this division to compete for the postseason.
And I know that was the goal, a period full stop.
But Pirates have never won the Central.
And call it, cursed or whatever, snakebitten or whatever.
It is almost fitting that the year that they have a good start and there's all this optimism and there's signs of like, hey, this is a team that could compete this year.
The whole division locks into.
I don't think the Cub or the Cardinals will be able to hang on this entire year.
The Reds, if the pitching, gets hurt or, this offense doesn't get going, I don't think they can sneak into the postseason like they did last year.
Cubs, I always view as less than the sum of their parts and the Brewers, always more than the sum of their parts.
It is going to be an interesting race this year.
Should be some good divisional play all year.
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat this week.
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe to wherever you find a podcast.
That is Offbeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
Thank you so much for listening.
I'll have a new shirt on next week.
Have a good weekend.
We'll talk Monday.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support.
And Let's Go Bucs.


Comments· 0
Will the NL Central send three teams to the playoffs this year?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.