Alex Stumpf digs into one of the biggest moments from the Pirates’ loss to the Nationals: the decision to hit for Brandon Lowe after he had already gone deep and continued his hot stretch. He also looks at Mitch Keller’s outing, the lineup ripple effects involving Oneil Cruz and Bryan Reynolds, and why the criticism should be aimed at the decision, not Nick Yorke. Watch or listen to OffBeat for the full breakdown.
The Pirates Took the Bat Out of Their Hottest Hitter’s Hands

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Pinch-hitting Nick Yorke for Brandon Lowe down 5-4 in the 7th was a mistake: Lowe is the hottest hitter on the team and had already homered off a lefty that night.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Even if the math gave Yorke the better chance in that spot, Lowe is an All-Star and the veteran voice who has earned the right to hit in the biggest at-bat of the game.
Alex Stumpf - 3
Brandon Lowe could have one of the greatest offensive seasons ever by a Pirates second baseman. He won't keep up a 60-homer pace, but he's the impact bat this lineup needed.
Alex Stumpf - 4
Oneil Cruz's breakout is partly lineup protection: with an All-Star like Lowe hitting behind him, pitchers have to attack Cruz differently.
Alex Stumpf - 5
Nick Yorke's struggles in this series are bad luck, not bad swings. He's using his whole body, not whiffing on fastballs, and hitting 100+ mph balls that the shift is catching.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript180 paragraphs · show
In the modern era of baseball, there have been four second basemen to homer seven times in a 15-game stretch for the Pittsburgh Pirates.
You have Neil Walker in 2013, Jose Castillo in 2006, Gene Alley in 1969, and then you've got Brandon Lowe in his first 15 games as a Pirate, including one on Tuesday, and then he gets the bat taken out of his hand in the biggest spot of the game.
Good morning and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine, presented by FanDuel. My name is Alex Stumpf. This is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
Isn't it funny how often, a team blows out another team one night just for the next night to lose by one run?
And you think, man, you could have saved, some of those runs, but, that's baseball for you.
That's why there's the Pythagoras and, the Pythagorean win-loss record and all that stuff.
Tuesday was a frustrating night for the Pirates, for a variety of reasons.
Mitch Keller did not have a good start.
I wrote in my sub-stack, Book Rule Bucks, how the Nationals were one of the best fastball-hitting teams.
Keller had been getting great results with the fastball.
strength versus strength matchup goes to the Nationals.
Keller was wild, put the Pirates behind early.
But in that first inning, down 3-0, Brandon Lowe homered, solo shot.
Now, it didn't lead to, a big rally or anything, but those are big runs.
Whenever you give up a crooked number early to respond and even just put one on the board, gives you some footing, gives you a chance to be like, Hey, this isn't going to be a blowout.
We're still going to be in this.
That was a big run.
And the Pirates did make it a ball game again.
To the point that in the bottom of the seventh inning, down 5-4, Brandon Lowe's spot in the order was coming up again.
And he's pinch hit four with Nick Yorke, who grounds into a double play.
And then Nick Yorke in the bottom of the ninth with two runners on.
Game-winning run on base.
Again, does not come through in that situation.
Now, I want to start before we really get into the nuts and bolts here.
I'm not throwing Nick Yorke under the bus.
He's been swinging a good bat.
I, for the same sub stack, I wrote about how he's putting the bat to the barrel.
he's not whiffing against fastballs anymore.
He's using his whole body.
Last year, he would just throw his hands at the ball and it didn't lead to some, good contact.
He's getting much better contact right now.
Like on Monday, he didn't join the hit parade.
Parts, he goes 0 for 6, but he drove a couple balls to, the gaps, balls that had like that 500 expected batting average.
50-50 balls just didn't go his way.
He easily could have had two or three hits on the night is what it is.
Sometimes it doesn't work out.
And that double play that he hit into on Tuesday, that ball well over 100 miles per hour off the bat, hit it well, another 50-50 ball.
He just, the shift got him.
The shift got him.
It happens.
I'm not criticizing the swings because he's taking good swings right now, even if, this series he hasn't had a hit to show for it.
Why was he batting?
Don Kelly talked about, he liked the matchup, and yeah, it is a left-on-left with Brandon Lowe, who traditionally does not have good results against left-handed pitching.
Last year, last year, he batted 194 against left-handed pitching, 548 OPS.
Not going to get the job done.
I get that.
That was last year, though.
On Tuesday, that first sitting home run was off of a lefty.
So it's not like, it's an automatic out.
You just need a good at-bat in that situation.
You just need a fly ball.
You just need a walk, a base hit.
there's a lot of different ways to either tie the game or give your team the lead.
And they went and they took the bat out of the hottest hitter on this team.
One of Don Kelly's big themes ever since he took over as manager, but really hammering it home in post-game press conferences, in pre-game scrums, just talking to players.
It's been earning respect.
That's been the theme.
And I will give him credit.
I think that's a good rallying cry.
That's not, we got to win in the margins.
No.
Earn it.
Earn your respect.
Earn your spot in the big leagues.
Earn your playing time.
Brandon Lowe has.
Brandon Lowe earned the playing time before he ever suited up for the Pirates.
Because he was an all-star in 2025 with the Rays.
And he was the biggest trade acquisition the Pirates have made since Chris Archer.
That was a big swing.
That was a big trade that they tried to pull off.
And he was the face of it.
And he has been excelling so far.
You want to talk about earning respect?
Brandon Lowe has earned respect for his major league career, knowing that he is someone who is going to compete for an all-star spot, who is going to compete for 30 home run seasons.
He is giving this team great at-bats to start his Pirates career.
Like I said, one of four first basemen, two homers seven times in 15 games.
And that's just his first 15 games as a Pirate.
We talked in a previous podcast how he has the potential, at least in my eyes, to have one of the greatest, if not the greatest, offensive season for second baseman in franchise history.
He's definitely on pace for it now.
I don't think he's going to keep this, 60 homer pace or whatever he's on right now.
But he's on a really good pace to be the impact bat that this team needs.
And impact bats isn't, it's not just hitting 30 home runs.
It's giving good long at-bats.
It's providing protection in the lineup for Oneil Cruz and set the table for Bryan Reynolds.
It's lengthening the lineup.
He's done that this year.
And I get it was a left-on-left, and he's not great against left-handers.
But man, dance with who brought you there.
This game could have gotten out of hand real early on.
But he put his foot down, he hit that home run, a left-on-left, a really good swing.
And that started to set the stage for, okay, the Pirates aren't just going to roll over today.
crooked number, that's tough.
Let's go try to build something.
And he just provided an instant answer.
Yeah, they were still down by two, but it sent a message to his team saying, we can hang in there.
He and O'Hearn were two really big additions this winter.
And they've talked about how, what it just takes to win.
You need to roll with those type of guys.
Even if it is a lower percentage chance.
Now, this is the analytics guy saying, you could go with the lower probability here.
I get from probably a strictly mathematical standpoint, Nick Yorke had a better chance of driving in a run than Brandon Lowe in that spot.
From a strictly mathematical, because you got the right-on-left, Nick Yorke has been doing a great job getting the bat to the ball against fastballs.
He's using his whole body.
He's putting together good swings.
And like I said, he did drive a ball well over 100 miles per hour.
It just stayed on the ground and went right to where the field was positioned.
I think if you do that at bat over 10 times, half the time, a run or multiple run score.
And I'm not necessarily dogging, like, oh, because, half the other half, it was the bad half of the outcomes there.
I'm not dogging it just because of that.
I'm dogging it because Brandon Lowe has earned that respect.
Brandon Lowe is that veteran voice.
He is providing everything that this team could have possibly asked for.
And he doesn't get the bat in the biggest f-bat of the game.
He doesn't get to bat for the final out of the game.
That's tough.
The theme this year is earning respect.
And I look at someone like Oneil Cruz and how the league is starting to view him a little differently.
And that's good.
That's great.
He's becoming potentially the hitter that we all thought he could be.
I can't ignore the fact that having an all-star like Brandon Lowe hitting behind him isn't impacting how he is being pitched this year.
Like, I'm not taking a thing away from Cruz.
He put in the work.
He's, staying aggressive at the plate.
He's doing stuff.
But if pitchers know that they have to attack him differently, that's only a bonus for him.
Lineup protection.
It's something that we've, it's 150 years of baseball theory that supports it.
Cruz is earning respect.
Reynolds is earning respect.
Those are two really important guys, at the top of the order that, Brandon Lowe is going to be sandwiched between those at-bats.
And he's going to give a good at-bat.
Even if he's going to make an out, he is usually going to see pitches.
He is usually going to give Reynolds something to Gleam or, the way that Brandon Lowe gets something from a Cruz at-bat.
Even if he makes an out.
He's going to see how the pitcher attacks, what stuff he has, how long the at-bat can go.
The type of stuff that you want, that pass the baton mentality.
That's good.
But whenever you get to the big guy in that pass the baton mentality, you've got to let him hit.
That was a puzzling pinch hit at-bat.
And to the Nationals' credit, they stuck it with the left-on-left or left-on-right matchup against Nick Yorke.
They just rolled with it.
And that 50-50 outcome, at least by math, 50-50, it worked out in the Nationals' favor.
And the Nationals were able to respond from, an 11-point or 11-run, beat down the night before, to come back, hold on to a lead, win a one-run game with a bullpen that's,
not exactly that great.
But they followed through.
It's one game out of 162.
The Pirates can still win the series.
They're putting together good at-bats.
They are putting together runs.
Keller had an off day, but he's been solid this season.
There's a lot of reasons why, you don't overreact over one game and you don't overreact over one managerial decision.
If that situation comes up again, though, Brandon Lowe was one of the big acquisitions.
One of the biggest acquisitions we have seen this organization make in years.
He's an all-star.
He doesn't have to be pinch hit for.
This isn't, the bottom of the order, just try to get, that left-on-right matchup late.
No.
This is the top of your order.
This is one of your biggest acquisitions of the offseason.
This is one of the top hitters in the National League.
He is right behind Jordan Walker for home runs.
You don't need to take the bat out of his hands.
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe wherever you find fine podcasts, or if you want to see my smiling face, check it out on YouTube.
Thank you so much for listening.
We'll talk again tomorrow.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
We'll see you next time.


Comments· 0
Should Don Kelly have let Brandon Lowe hit against the lefty down 5-4 in the 7th instead of pinch-hitting Nick Yorke?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.