Esmerlyn Valdez is getting his first shot in Pittsburgh, and the Pirates’ youth movement suddenly feels very real. On today’s OffBeat, Alex Stumpf breaks down what Valdez brings, how he fits alongside Jhostynxon Garcia, Wilber Dotel, and Konnor Griffin, and why this aggressive approach matters for a team still trying to find answers. There’s power, opportunity, and real intrigue here. Watch or listen now.
The Pittsburgh Pirates’ Future Is Arriving Fast
With Anthony DiNardo and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Esmerlyn Valdez (.326/.383/.674 vs. lefties at Indy) should start at first base against left-handers instead of Jared Triolo. That 'sounds a hell of a lot better than Jared Triolo' and stops wasting Triolo's glove at first.
- 2
Hot take: when Braxton Ashcraft is on, he's more enjoyable to watch than Paul Skenes because of his command. He's always ahead in the count and the catcher never has to move his glove.
- 3
Jake Mangum has been a disappointment, with weaker defense and contact than advertised. He's a 'bandage' who belongs in the fourth-outfielder spot, while Jhostynxon Garcia is 'an actual solution.'
- 4
The Pirates' whole plan against lefties has been to survive until the lefty leaves and then get Brandon Lowe and Oneil Cruz real at-bats. Valdez and Garcia should make those games competitive.
- 5
No more worrying about Konnor Griffin. He has about a 155 wRC+ since turning 20 and 10 extra-base hits in the last month, so he's now part of the solution and can carry Valdez and Garcia.
Players discussed
Full transcript1000 paragraphs · show
Yo! Welcome to the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. This is NS9 Live and I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo.
And with me, we have Ty. And guess what, Ty?
No Jim.
No Jim. No Jim. It's gonna be a wonderful show.
Just like old times. Just like old times. Just like new times. Just like the upcoming future times.
Jim doesn't do podcasting. Are you out of your mind?
Yeah, but we got a lot to talk about. quite the reversal from what day is it? Thursday?
Yeah, that's usually when we do a show.
Quite the reversal from Tuesday, to be fair.
True.
But Tuesday night was a dark day.
It really was.
You dropped.
We're fine again.
You got swept and you dropped the first game of the series to the Cardinals, who you've already got swept in a four game series against.
And this time you're playing them in St. Louis.
Yeah, things are bleak, man.
And then they dropped under 500 in that game.
So, like.
500.
Oh, yeah, you're right.
2,500.
Right.
So, like, yeah.
Things are not looking so well at all.
And, again, Ryan O'Hearn's already been hurt.
He's out of the picture.
Like, there's a lot of, again, it's not the end of the world by any means, but it's.
It was interesting on the other end of things.
It felt like the start of the end.
And we've had a few of those feeling like it's a start of the end.
But, again, then the last time it was against the Cardinals.
So, like, are you going to get swept again by this Cardinals team?
Yeah.
going into St. Louis, tarps off.
Bunch of dorks.
you're.
After that first game of the series, it.
It felt a little bit bleak.
It did.
And, you end up taking two from them.
Get back on track here.
You still want to continue some momentum here and create a little separation away from that 500 mark.
But.
Back to feeling, normal again.
Right.
A little bit.
Still issues, but record wise, results wise, you feel a little bit better.
You didn't take care of business before against the Cardinals.
It is what it is.
All you can do is move forward and try to take care of business, going forward and such.
And, yeah, they took two out of three against the Cardinals.
Gets them back to two games over 500.
again, at this point in the time of the season, that's what you're worrying about.
And if you're monitoring anything, like, that's it.
I understand, you can look and say that they're last place.
They're a last place team.
But, like, I feel like you don't really, you don't really care too much about, like, where you rank in the standings among the division to, like, maybe closer to the trade deadline.
Like, to me, what matters the most is, like, they're still in it.
Like, they're still two games above 500.
At this point in time, they're very much in any type of playoff situation.
if they want to be in the playoffs where they are right now, they can get there.
That's, to me, what matters.
Like, the overall record and how they're playing matters more than the actual standings.
It is unfortunate that every team in the NL Central is above 500 and playing well.
Like, that's not going to happen, most likely, by the trade deadline.
Like, then you'll get a clearer picture of, like, how the division's shaping up and who you truly need to overtake to get into the playoffs and such.
Right now, you need to stay course of where you want to be.
And, right, like, again, we keep talking about this.
But, like, if it was March 21st, and you said on May 21st, I think 21st of March out there, you said on May 21st, there are two games above 500.
Would you be content?
I'd be fine with it.
So, not much is, like, nothing's changed, you know?
Like, there's nothing to feel doom and gloom about this.
You're not, of course, excited and being like, holy crap, this team's even way better than we thought.
Like, this is, they're what you thought they would be.
And when you're a 500 team, you're going to think we're back, and you're going to think the world's over.
Basically, yeah.
like you said, you just want to hang around there record-wise, stay above 500, and good things are going to happen.
This division's not going to continue to play like this.
We're seeing the Reds fall off.
Good.
Screw them.
The Cardinals are going to fall off.
They're not a good baseball team.
The Cubs are playing very poorly right now.
They've lost eight of their last ten.
Just hang around and hang around and hang around.
Like you said, get the trade deadline.
Well, we have guys like PCA that came and filled, routine balls in the outfield.
Hey, he's too busy yelling at fans.
Not my guys.
Not my guys.
We hoist cones.
That's right.
All swear words from the stands, like a bunch of jag-off frat boys.
Right.
Yeah.
We just hoist cones, play good baseball, good ethical baseball.
And very sound defensive baseball, also.
That's what we do here.
Yeah.
That's all we do.
Right.
We want to do stuff like that PCA's doing in the outfield right now.
No.
No.
Never.
We wouldn't bleach our hair like that.
Dork does, you know.
No.
No.
We cut off our ball.
It's above board.
Yeah.
Exactly.
The Buccos play above board.
There you are.
Yeah.
This is a winning organization.
This is how we do it here.
basically just like the Yankees.
Yeah.
Pretty much without the Yankees of Appalachia.
That's what the Pirates are known as.
I do feel so much better after beating the Cardinals two out of three.
Yes.
God, I hate that organization so much.
But it's a fact too.
Like you're saying, like, this is the team that shouldn't be where they are.
again, it's early and things don't really matter in that sense.
But like part of you is just like, what are they doing up there?
Like, why are they, why are they record wise showing?
Like, why are they good?
They're supposed to be in last place.
How are the Pirates in last place?
What are we doing here?
What's happening?
Why can't the Cardinals ever just go away?
Even when they rebuild, they're just still there.
Yeah.
Like, I don't know these guys in their lineup.
I don't know who the hell they are.
I hate that organization so much.
Yeah.
So part of it is like, all right, let's bring it back.
We had fun picking at the Reds, man.
But like, the Cardinals are the ones that just bother me.
So they lose two, Pirates gain two after that.
Yeah.
They needed that.
And I don't, we have post game shows.
We talk, they talked, an extensive amount today about Braxton Ashcraft.
But like, once again, just talk about him.
Wow.
Like, wow.
We had high hopes for him.
I don't think, I'll speak for myself, not for you.
I wasn't really entertaining Cy Young votes.
I know Jim mentioned that.
I wasn't going to entertain Cy Young votes.
for one, you got to have the innings up there.
It's a lot to expect out of him.
Like, I know he's good.
I think he's going to have Cy Young votes.
He's top five in innings pitched this year.
Now, that could be a little worrisome as well, because how are you going to monarch going forward?
We'll find out.
That's going to be interesting.
But this dude is just every bit of a baller.
He is the stopper when you need him.
I know he failed the one time.
Look, every pitcher has his moments.
it's overstated.
You have 10 times you feel really good.
You have 10 times you feel really bad.
And 10 times where it's just meh.
You know?
There's your 30 starts.
So, he's had a couple rough patches.
One was coming off of bereavement.
Like, that is what it is.
Really, outside of that, there was this one game that was rough.
He's been outstanding.
And he goes deep.
I wish he would have thrown, like, 20 less innings last year.
He would win rookie of the year.
Oh.
I see what you're saying.
I'm like, that sounds counterproductive, because then we'd be even more worried about Hings this year.
like, that's...
In the majors.
20 less in the majors.
Right.
I wish he would have thrown, like, 49 innings in the majors last year.
Because, right now, he'd be leading a Cy Young race.
Or not Cy Young.
I'm sorry.
Rookie of the year race.
Well, that's what's funny about this whole thing, too.
Is the fact that it was, like, coming into this season.
You know Connor's on rookie of the year watch.
For sure.
But, there's a lot of talk.
And, of course, it made sense at the time.
But, like, don't discount Bubba.
Like, there's two rookie of the year candidates potentially in here.
one's definitely going to be starting from day one.
And he's had some time in the majors last year.
So, that catching up.
That, development.
Seeing major league hitters and such.
Like, he's got a bit of that.
You're right.
Like, everything that we were hoping Bubba to be.
Braxton has been that and more.
He's so good.
How wasn't he up there?
And, again, it's hindsight.
And, like, now it looks at.
But, like, at the time, I understand.
But, again, like, think about that.
Like, how wasn't he, like, Bubba Chandler as far as prospects go?
Seeing him.
You know?
What did they miss here?
Where did this bullpen or reliever risk title that got thrown on him at some point?
Where did that come from?
Idiots like us?
Like, I guess maybe the injury concerns might have led into that.
But, like, I don't.
Nothing about the way he pitches yells reliever.
He's an ace on most teams.
Like, he is a stud.
And it is super sustainable as long as he can stay healthy.
He's the clear-cut number two.
I think it was Jim on one of the post games, like, put that out there.
I was like, if the playoffs will start today, like, he's absolutely your number two.
Like, that's the team that's Paul Skenes.
Exactly what you're saying.
Most teams don't have a Paul Skenes.
And, like, if most teams had a Braxton Ashcraft in their rotation, as it looks right now, as he's pitching right now, like, he probably is their ace of their team.
Braxton Ashcraft is every bit of a very competent number two.
Very competent number one in a lot of rotations.
So, again, like, just shout-out and kudos to him.
Just outstanding stuff.
One more thing on him, and this might be a hot take.
When Braxton Ashcraft throws like he does today, I enjoy watching him pitch probably more than Skenes.
Because the way he goes about it and the way he locates...
Like, Skenes' stuff is off the charts impressive.
He's, like, the best in the world.
I understand all that.
But I'm just talking visually appealing of, like, watching the catcher not have to move his glove and him just be able to spot it wherever he wants to.
That's fun.
It's, yeah, like, here in the chat, like, oh, my.
Take so hot.
Like, that's, that is certainly a hot take.
Now, but what I'll say, though, is...
Talk about visually appealing.
It's, he's...
I'm not going to say he's that good.
Like, he's as good as Paul Skenes in that sense.
But, like, he's up there.
Like, I get it.
That's what I'll say.
Like, I understand it and I get it.
I think part of it, too, is we take Paul Skenes for granted a little bit.
Because you are talking about the guy who is giving you a no-hitter through, like, six innings almost every time he goes out there.
So, that's where it's certainly a hot take.
And maybe it's because, like, well, Braxton's the newer, sexier guy.
Let's take a look at this one.
Because I've seen Paul Skenes.
And right now, okay, it's a no-hitter through four.
Like, whatever.
Yeah, it's Paul Skenes.
All right.
But Braxton's got a two-hitter through five, guys.
And only one earned run.
But, yeah.
Again, I get it.
I do get it.
And I feel like he...
There's an efficiency with it.
Well, he is.
He's super efficient.
Skenes, you're...
It's impressive because he's always going at...
He's always able to get the strikeout.
Ashcraft is always ahead of hitters.
He's never behind against anybody when he's at his best.
The catcher doesn't have to move.
He's always in an 0-2, 1-2 count.
It's just...
You know what?
Like, what's the point of comparing them?
I'm just happy to have them both.
There you go.
I'm happy to have them both also.
Yeah.
Very much so.
But let's get into the meat, potatoes of the show.
Of course, before we do that...
I want to ask you a bunch of questions.
And I want to have them answered immediately.
I'm going to go ahead and get the wheel up right now.
But we have this stupid question.
We have the NS9 stupid question.
We're going to see if it gets answered this time.
Ali, you want to tell everyone what the question is?
Yes.
Today's stupid question is going to be, what condiment do you respect the least?
So let's see who gets asked this time.
We've been striking out lately.
We have.
And it's a travel day, so you never know.
Right.
Titus.
He's getting the question asked to him.
So let's get old Titus on the line here.
We'll see if he answers.
The condiment that you respect the least.
For me?
It's actually tough, but it's probably relish.
Because it's just not versatile.
No versatility with relish.
It goes on a hot dog and that's it.
Mustard plays in different forms.
Ketchup plays in different forms.
I'm not a ketchup fan personally, but you can do a lot with ketchup.
Relish goes on a dog and that's it.
I can agree with that.
I'm not a relish person, but like, I feel like that's it.
That's all you use it for.
Just not much versatility with it.
When it's good, it's good.
It is great on a Chicago dog.
That green relish.
It's really good.
Hooper.
Says that mayo is made by Satan.
mayo is elite.
It's weird.
Cause I think mayo gets more hate than it deserves.
It's like the, it's like the edgy thing to do now.
I hate on mayo.
It's like hating Nickelback.
And honestly too, it's like, how many, how many other condiments are created because mayo exists?
Exactly.
Like Aeolies are elite.
Right.
Now, if you want to go mayo alone, maybe I can understand a little bit more, but that's not what this question is.
And again, it's the anti relish.
It's super versatile.
Right.
Like, can you imagine making a relish into an Aeoli?
No.
Boom.
He says, mayo is the Kai Tom of condiments.
Just wrong.
Anyways, let's see if that ends with us tonight.
Give us his take.
But let's go ahead and talk.
Now, a lot has happened this week.
Again, Ryan O'Hearn was on the I.L.
And it sounds like it's going to be four weeks.
And we had our discussion on Bucco Brew this past Monday with Jim and I.
Who are the four options it could be?
we named the four.
We went into the two that we feel like it could be.
And then two that it might be and people are going to not like.
And the Pirates decided to go with one of the two that we felt it could be and we would like.
And that was Justinson Garcia, the password.
He got the call.
He comes up.
And the other person we thought it could be was Esmerlyn Valdez.
And again, like what I said, I can take you to the war.
Like to me, it doesn't matter.
You make a case for both of them.
As long as it's one of the two, I'm fine.
So the password comes up.
And he actually had a he's been pretty productive for the first few games.
He had a nice game yesterday.
But turns out, Tyler, that they're both here now.
Today, after the Pirates' second win in St. Louis, immediately after the game, they option Billy Cook and they call up Esmerlyn Valdez.
Valdez, the magician, Garcia, the password, the magician and the password of both in Pittsburgh.
Well, I guess in Toronto.
But they're both a pirate now.
How cool is this?
Yeah, it feels like there's a little bit of pressure on this front office right now to put probably your best 26 options out there.
At least as much as you can.
And obviously, Esmerlyn Valdez is a better baseball player than Billy Cook, who was the casualty and was optioned on the triple A.
It's interesting.
I don't know.
I don't really know where Valdez is going to fit into this whole thing.
You're going to have to find the bats for him because you don't want him wasting away on the bench.
He's still a guy developing.
He's still young.
He's only 22 years old.
Yeah.
Just turned 22, not long ago.
But in terms of Valdez, the baseball player.
I've had a ton of doubts about the guy throughout the minor leagues.
And I know a lot of you guys were all aboard the Valdez train pretty early on.
Well, how do we define early?
Actually, how do you define early?
I would say early last year.
Early in the season last year.
That's fair.
He was a cool, I think for most of us, he was a cool story up until last year.
Then it was starting to be like, okay, is this getting for real?
Yeah.
And I was always on the board of not buying it until I see it at a higher level here.
But every place you send this guy, he hits.
He hits everywhere he goes.
I doubted he could do it at AA.
He hit in AA.
Doubted he could do it in AAA.
Right now, hitting 31% above average in AAA.
Go in the spring training.
I don't know if I doubted it, but you wanted to see a little bit.
Thought he had a really strong spring training.
Arizona Fall League.
The guy's the best player out there, basically.
All he does is hit everywhere you send him.
To interject here in a second, too.
Arizona Fall League is going on in MLB playoffs.
Yeah.
This is during the MLB playoffs.
And I felt like, as Roland Valdez was almost like the story of baseball, oftentimes.
like, he was popping through the playoffs.
it was remarkable, the running out of the Arizona Fall League.
And you're seeing him grow as a hitter as well.
Like, this year, strikeout rates down.
Walk rates up.
You've seen the walk rate just creep up and up and up.
Basically, since 2024.
My question here is, how are you going to get him in the lineup enough?
Love having him off the bench.
Love him against lefties.
But he's still developing.
And I want to see him play pretty much every day.
That's the issue right now, is that he's just not going to be able to do that here.
So, I agree with you.
When I first saw, my first thing in the chat was, who the hell is going down?
Yep.
You went muted.
So, who the hell is going down?
Donato.
Do you hear me?
Yeah.
You're the one that went down.
Yeah.
I should.
I need DFA'd.
So, anyway.
Yeah, it doesn't make sense.
Like, the password coming up makes sense because O'Hearn is gone.
He's on the IL.
That's an everyday player.
And password, again, for the same reasons you want him playing every day.
That's what we talked about early on in the season.
Like, if Mangum goes down, I don't think the password comes up.
But if, like, an O'Hearn goes down, the password comes up.
And that's what happened.
Because he'll get everyday at-bats.
Well, was someone injured?
Is that why password sat today?
Like, is he injured already?
And, like, he's replacing him.
Like, it didn't make sense because you want Valdez to get everyday at-bats, just like you're saying, for the same reason with password coming up.
you're not bringing him up here to be the 26th man like Billy Cook.
So, like, it can't be Billy Cook.
It just simply cannot be Billy Cook.
I think the password's injured.
that's what I was going with.
And then it was shortly after, Jose Negrón broke it.
And it's Billy Cook being sent down.
And so I'm, like, confused on this.
But the more I think about it, though, Tyler, the more I think it does make sense.
And it's like, you don't have to have every single day at-bats.
He's proven himself, and he's proven himself in double-A.
He's proven himself in triple-A.
And we hear, the thing about the new-age prospects and development, if you can do it in double-A, you're next on the boat to get called up.
and he did it there.
He was down in triple-A this year as well, spending some time.
I think there is some playing time for him.
Let's think about, like, even with the Ryan O'Hearn situation, when Ryan O'Hearn goes down, like, yeah, that opens up Password to be in the outfield almost every single day.
But there's still a short-side platoon with Spencer Horwitz at first, and Ezmerlin's a first-base slash outfielder.
So I look at it and say, you know what?
Instead of Jared Triolo starting at first base when there's a lefty, it's now Ezmerlin Valdez.
And also, Tyler, instead of Jared Triolo starting at first base, it's Ezmerlin Valdez.
This team struggles against lefties.
I want to put this out there.
First lefties this year, Ezmerlin Valdez.
Oh, I just closed my hat.
326, 383, 674 in Indy.
Can I say that slash line one more time against lefties?
Yeah, toss it out there again.
326, 383, 674.
We witnessed this team in this lineup versus lefties.
I like that.
That sounds good.
That sounds better than maybe Jared Triolo.
Sounds a hell of a lot better than Jared Triolo.
I love Big Tree.
But the other thing it does is it does allow you to play Jared Triolo in situations and spots that are more beneficial to the team and to Jared Triolo.
Right.
he's a guy that traditionally hits lefties pretty decently.
Part of the problem with that, though, is that once that lefty gets pulled out of the baseball game, you still have Jared Triolo hitting in the top three of your lineup.
That don't work.
No.
Esmerlyn Valdez, I'm okay with him hitting righties, at least for now.
we'll see what happens with it, but I'm not poo-pooing it at all.
I actually like it.
It's just I'm interested in the usage of it.
Right.
And, again, then you don't have Jared Triolo, your best defender on this team, playing first base, which is just completely useless.
Or right field, also completely useless.
Right.
You're neutralizing his value.
I was trying to see here.
I don't know what Toronto is going to be throwing at the Pirates here.
I haven't looked that far ahead yet, but you're probably going to see some lefties here.
So, even if it's a shorter stint, like, one, on the human side, because Esmerlyn Valdez is a great dude.
I love the fact that he's at least going to collect some Major League Service time here and get a nice little paycheck out of it.
So, love that part of the whole thing.
Right.
it gives you a better team right now.
Like, if you're going to face some lefties here, which you probably will against Toronto, you're putting your best foot forward.
Right.
So, again, I think the first thing was, like, where does he play?
So, you already have the short side up against the short side, but that's still at-bats.
Like, you're still getting in the lineup here at times.
And in a situation where the Pirates have struggled, like, he could be a spark plug there.
I think he could probably play outfield, maybe spell Ozuna DH, here.
Like, there's opportunities outside.
Like, again, he'll definitely, I think, I think, definitely be playing first base when there's a lefty.
And then when there's a righty up there, maybe he'll have to share some time.
But, he might get a day in there doing something for someone.
And I also look at this, too, like you say, Tyler.
It's an opportunity.
he's proven himself.
when Connor came up, any prospect comes up.
Like, you're probably going to struggle.
It just is what it is.
And that's why I want to ask this next question.
It's just like, this is a team that is still, like, in the thick of things.
Like, there's two games over.
However pessimistic you want to be or optimistic or whatever, rationally speaking, like, they are in the thick of things.
They are in a playoff race, as much as you can be in the middle of May.
All games matter, relatively speaking.
And right now, with, you had these struggles.
You're hanging on there.
You lose over Hearn.
You already have Konnor Griffin is 20.
You already call it Password.
That's 23.
Now you have Ezra that's 22.
There's a lot of young kids on this team, like, suddenly.
Not to mention the pitching staff.
Well, true.
But I do want to focus, like, offensively.
Like, this became very veteran heavy.
You know?
So now, you have Connor.
Like, versus a lefty.
Because we didn't really talk too much about the Password in a sense.
But Password, obviously, he has better splits against lefties also.
right now, it's very short-lived.
It's only 10 games.
But his splits this year versus lefties, 455-520-909.
That's good.
But, again, that's just 10 games.
I think it was, like, 22 or 23 at-bats.
Last year, in 2025, for the whole season, his slash was 246-348-509 versus lefties.
So, again, like, he's naturally better versus lefties as well.
So he fits that mold.
So what I'm saying here is, like, versus a lefty.
You might have all three of these inexperienced kids in this lineup.
And, like, is that really what you want to do right now?
why not?
like, that's a good question, to be honest with you.
Like, do you want to toss all of these young guys out there right now and go full-on youth movement?
you have to give them an opportunity right now just because of what you have.
So, yeah, that's tough because I'd never really considered, like, you're going to have a lot of really young dudes and really inexperienced dudes in the middle of what's basically an NL Central race.
You're putting a lot of faith in Don Kelly, I think, to navigate this, which, hey, we've been part of it as well, of complaining about some of Don Kelly's managerial decisions.
But, again, they're coming off a skid.
You take two or three of the Cardinals.
Every time they've skidded so far, they've been able to bounce back.
So, that is a credit to him.
You're putting faith in him here that he can navigate these waters as well with the Young Bucks.
Literally, the Young Bucks.
At the very least here, we're talking about guys with talent.
We're not talking about tossing some raw 22, 23-year-olds.
Like, Konnor Griffin was Major League ready.
Valdez is pretty close to Major League ready.
Password, he was in the majors last year with the Red Sox.
He's pretty much Major League ready.
He was out of spring training.
So, it's not like we're talking about guys that are not quite there yet and you're pushing a little bit early.
Do the thing.
Do the thing, DiNardo.
Well, I was just double-checking.
I just saw a notification.
Yeah, I just saw the Instagram thing.
I wanted to make sure it was him.
So, the answer's in.
Titus has responded.
Pretty good.
Pretty good response time.
What, 16 minutes it took him?
Not bad at all.
Are you ready?
Are y'all ready?
Actually, I got to look here because where's...
Titus says barbecue sauce.
Garbage.
Garbage take.
What is barbecue sauce?
I...
I'm not a very judgmental person, but I'm judging you hard right now, Titus.
Barbage sauce.
That's a bad take.
Just bad take.
No, I guess it's not for everybody.
It's a bad take.
Okay.
I wasn't...
I actually wasn't sure where he's from.
I thought he was a southern boy.
I really...
I knew he was with the Atlanta organization, but I felt he was from down there.
He actually is from New Mexico.
they...
Went to school in Albany, Oregon.
Like, and there are so many good usage...
Usages for barbecue sauce.
Uses.
Uses.
That's a better word.
Like, barbecue sauce is great.
Yeah, sure.
I'll just make up for it as we go here.
Barbecue sauce is great.
And you know what else is great?
Having some prospects that appear to be major league ready, which, going back to it here real quick, took me a while to get there.
But at least, at the very least, these guys are ready to play at a major league level.
And that's what's nice about this whole thing, is we're not tossing out A-Kai Tom.
Right.
Or A-Kai Tom.
Or Callihan.
Shout out to AO513 for the $2 Super.
Like, he says, you don't miss them debuting 26-year-old rookies.
Like, that's the thing, too.
Like, these are actually legit prospects.
Mm-hmm.
And, like, they're in that...
You're talking about a 20-year-old in Connor, a 22-year-old in Ezmerlin, and a 23-year-old in Password, who actually has already debuted, but, debuted for the Pirates this year.
Like, they're young.
They're legit prospects.
And they're exciting.
And they bring things that this team needs.
Like, Password brings good outfield defense, and we've seen that.
Valdez brings some power that, especially against lefties, that they need hits lefties well.
They're able to bring things to the table, and Konnor Griffin plays shortstop.
And he's very good at baseball.
Yeah, all three of them bring things this team needs.
So, like, that's why I want to talk about this, because it's a little worrisome, because I do think, again, like, you're not bringing up Ezmerlin to be Billy Cook.
he's not maybe going to get every day at bats, but this is an opportunity.
This is a situation where it's like, we need to improve.
We need, like, playoffs are the big picture.
This makes the team better.
They're going to still find some ways to get into play, but I think versus lefty, there's a very good chance that you find all three.
Now, maybe Don Kelly does.
Like, maybe that's the day he gives the password a day off, more here or there.
So, I'm just saying this.
Trust me, it's not so much like I want to see this, but, like, I could see a situation like, all right, I'll start Mangum today.
Just because a little more, again, like, you hear me out.
I'm not trying to advocate.
What I'm trying to say is I can maybe rationalize where it's like, that might be a day, maybe password sits, and you put someone else in there.
Because, like, all right, now I just have two of these young kids in this lineup instead of three, you know?
He could have all three there, and I'm perfectly fine and okay with that as well.
Because I also do think Connor is head and shoulders above probably most of the veterans in the clubhouse right now.
And I think the veterans will tell you also, it's like, he's a leader of me.
One day, I wish I could grow up to be like Konnor Griffin, right?
Like, Roder Hearn and Brendan Brandon Lowe are probably saying those things.
So, I'm not too worried about him.
And I guess that's part of why I'm saying this, too, is like, yeah, it's three.
But you know what?
I'm really not worried about Connor in that aspect.
Now, when Connor came up, the one thing we said about Connor was, this lineup's cooking, Tyler.
Connor's probably going to struggle.
And, like, these two guys could as well.
But with this lineup, they can do it.
And I know they've lost Brendan Brandon Lowe.
But, Tyler, when you look at this lineup today, opposed to before, like, they lost Brendan Brandon Lowe.
But who has slid in?
Well, Konnor Griffin.
Like, Konnor Griffin's pretty much past that now.
think about this.
Konnor Griffin was the one that you can allow to be in this lineup to struggle because the rest of the lineup can help carry him.
Well, Konnor Griffin's now part of the solution.
He's going to help carry these guys.
so if Esmerland does struggle or if Password does struggle, whatever, like, that's okay.
This lineup can still afford it.
You have Cruz.
You have Brandon Lowe.
You have Reynolds.
You have Konnor Griffin now.
like, you have Nick Gonzales who's been doing well.
Like, they can allow, be afforded the opportunity to still develop, even though you feel like they can still probably help you.
And Connor's still on the team, even when he's struggling through all that sense.
So, I think, like, you can put Esmerland in his best situation.
that's diverse lefties, like we talked about.
Help him develop.
But he's facing pitching that he excels against, you know.
So, like, he can help his team, help him develop.
I like this.
I think this makes a lot of sense now.
I hope so.
like, just...
I'm curious how it's going to work out with Esmerland.
That's the big thing here.
I know you mentioned him maybe being on that side of the platoon with Spencer Horwitz, but he hasn't played first base all year.
They've given him all the work in the outfield.
That's slightly scary, but I think he can handle it well enough, I hope.
I look at it this way, too.
Like, that's a guy that needs work in the outfield.
So, is that fair, too?
Yeah, I think so.
Okay.
Especially, like, with what the Pirates were looking at coming into the year, where you didn't know what you were going to get with Ryan O'Hearn.
You didn't know if he could play right field.
And he exceeded expectations there.
But you play him in the outfield, in anticipation, if someone goes down here, you have Ryan O'Hearn in the outfield.
Or, Esmerlyn Valdez, the fill-in the outfield, if for some reason Password can't do it.
But that was the spot they needed help in.
They had 14 first basemen.
Right.
Right.
Though, the thing I do, like, legitimately like about this, and both of these guys being up here, and it's going to come off as a slight towards this guy, but it is what it is.
It doesn't force Jake Mangum into an everyday role.
Yes.
Because to this point, Jake Mangum has been a disappointment.
Hasn't really been overexposed, I don't think.
But defensively, he hasn't been as strong as I think we would have hoped he would have been.
And at the plate, the contact skills have not been what were sold to us.
Keeps him in that fourth outfielder spot.
Hopefully, they don't force him out there and keep Esmerlyn Valdez on the bench.
Continue to play Password.
Play Esmerlyn Valdez as much as you can.
Keep Mangum in that fourth outfielder spot.
And, again, like I said with Triolo, that's what's best for Jake Mangum as well.
You overexpose him, and it's going to be a problem.
Right.
I agree.
Also, just real quick shout-out to Nate, our very own Nate, gifted 10 NS9 memberships.
We appreciate that, Nate.
You're not getting reimbursed, though.
Sorry, buddy.
He says, he does say, though, Merry Magicianmas.
And no one can be happier than Cody, our very own Cody as well.
Right.
Who, I've got to say this, too.
Cody is the one that, he dubbed the magician.
He's been doing that.
we've all been saying it since then, too.
We asked Esmerlyn how he likes it.
He loves it.
I saw Colin actually, he wrote an article today, and he headlined it with a tweet of the magician.
Like, it's catchy.
It's sweeping the nation.
Fucko nation.
There it is.
So, yeah.
Shout-out to Cody.
I'm just, I am genuinely happy for Esmerlyn.
Like, that's a grinder.
Like, that's a grinder.
He signed a $130,000 signing bonus.
I know it's a lot of money, but, like, that's not a lot of money.
You're living off minor league salary.
But, like, getting that bump up here, grinding your way through the minors the way he did, continuing to just perform as dummies like me, just doubt you every step of the way.
Prove us wrong.
Prove me wrong.
Keep proving me wrong, man.
And still walk up to you with the biggest smile to say hi.
Yes.
That, yeah, it's just like, that's just a dude.
He's so likable.
That's the one thing you were talking about last year, especially the AFL.
I hope that Esmerlyn makes it.
I hope that's the guy you're rooting for.
I hope that he's good because it's like the city of Pittsburgh is going to fall in love with this dude.
And he's here.
He's now here.
So, I'm excited for him because, like, he earned it.
He deserved it.
And, like you said, not even just, like, just the person.
there's a lot of good people in baseball that don't make it because they suck.
Fortunately enough, so far as it stands, Esmerlyn has not sucked.
He's gotten better.
Like you mentioned, like, there was a lot of signs that it's like, as we talk about this story, like, there was a lot of power early on.
But the dude was striking out, like, 35% of the time and such.
It was like, yeah, like, that's awesome.
That's cool.
But he's not going to make it.
like, these are the signs of prospects that just don't make it to the major leagues.
And it was instantly that, he went to AA or actually high A next year and cut the down, the strikeouts down, like, very noticeably.
And he goes to AA.
And he had a little struggle early on in AA, as most prospects do when you're not Konnor Griffin.
But then quickly enough, within, like, 50 plate appearances that started clicking for him, he starts doing better.
And he goes to AAA this year.
And, yeah, like, the thing is, like, he's, as he's advanced each level, the strikeouts have gone down.
If he just maintained, we'd be saying, like, it's still interesting.
I'm not sure if it's going to translate.
And still, I don't know if it's going to translate.
But I'm more hopeful because, like, it's not even maintaining.
It's getting better.
It's improving.
And he's getting on base even more with the walks.
Like, he's just getting better to every level he goes to.
That's impressive.
And I think the prospect systems are noticing him as well.
And they noticed him last year because he did climb up the Pirates prospect rankings.
And, like, there's been guys that hit like this throughout the minors.
Like, Jordan Luplo raked in the minors.
He never really became a prospect.
And I know he had some years as a major leaguer that were productive.
But, like, there are guys that hit in the minors that just a lot of the prospect guys or a lot of guys that watch them a lot don't believe in them.
Especially power guys.
Yeah.
Like Mason Martin.
Right.
And Mason Martin.
There we go.
God.
How far we've come.
You're Spencer Joneses of the world.
Who you wouldn't give up for policy.
the dude's walking 17% of the time.
Let's see if it's real.
Let's see.
And I guess that's the other thing, too.
It's like, when Conor's coming up here, he was coming up here.
I can absolutely see Garcia and Valdez being up and down guys.
For sure.
like, when O'Hearn's healthy, like, someone's going back down.
You know?
So, like, that's also the reason I like this, too.
It's like, he's not...
There isn't a lot of pressure on, like, Esmerlyn Valdez right now.
Yeah, you want to see him get more every day at-bats.
That's fair.
But there's not a pressure, like, you need to come up here and you need to perform because we need you, kid.
It's like, all right, we're going to put you in these better situations.
To your advantage.
You'll get some days off.
Right?
Like, you're not here to save the club.
You're here to help out.
And I think that...
It is.
But, like, I think that plays well because it's also, like, he's probably being sent down at some point from now up until at least when Ryan O'Hearn comes back.
And this is good experience for him because, like, whatever he learns, all the opportunities that fail up here, right, all things that come at him that, like, oh, I've been exposed here or I've been exposed there.
Like, when it's all said and done, he goes back down to AAA.
He's seen it now.
Right?
He's experienced it.
Like, this is part of the development, too.
It's like, when he goes back down, it's like, all right, now I know what to work on.
A lot of prospects, that's what they need.
That's what happens.
And they come back up and then it's boom.
Full swing.
So, like, again, like, that's also why I do like this for his development, if that makes sense.
It's like, here, like, you have earned this opportunity.
Let's see what you can do.
We'll set you up and put you in the best case, scenario, situations.
And if you struggle, it's fine.
You're like, we don't need you to save the day.
It's fine.
And if you are struggling after some time, we'll send you back down.
And trust me, it's not a disappointment.
It's not a failure.
It was just part of your development.
It was more opportunities for you to learn on how to get better.
Take that now and get better.
For sure.
Like, how many of these prospects have been called up and been forced to be a savior?
Like, Henry Davis came up.
He was a savior.
Yeah.
Go all the way back to, like, right field.
Right.
Like, Gregory Polanco was the right field option.
The only right field option they had.
And he struggled right off the bat.
These guys don't really have that on them.
One.
Josh Bell.
Right.
Well, that was a little weird, but one, I think it helps that they're being called up so early in the year.
They're not being called up and at Super 2 deadline.
When you're in the middle of a race, you're expected to be really good or later than that.
I don't know.
I'm just, I'm excited to see our magician play.
That's all.
Same.
I don't need to keep on drumming on about it.
No, we won't.
So again, we, this part took, I guess, a little longer than we expected.
So let's go ahead and do this.
We'll cut to a break a little longer than we expected.
We'll come back in and wrap up a few more things.
But yeah, so we'll see you guys.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
If we've made one thing clear, it's quite obvious.
We can talk all day about Esmerlyn Valdez.
Mm-hmm.
Because I still don't want to stop.
But I'm recognizing this show has gone a lot longer than we anticipated.
We didn't even talk about Password.
Let's move on to Password.
Yeah, it's funny.
We didn't really even talk about him at all.
again, I think it's solidified he's going to have an everyday role.
Right?
Like, he's the outfielder.
Yeah.
He can play out there.
Yeah.
And he plays it well.
And that's something that's going to be very nice to see.
Because if we've seen anything this year, there's a lot of PCA types.
Like, not very good outfielders, obviously.
Yeah, there have been.
like, he's played well to this point, I think.
Defensively, he's been good.
Offensively, he's been good enough to this point.
He hasn't been, he doesn't look overmatched at all.
I think early, his first couple of bats, he did.
But he's settled in since then.
We'll see.
We'll see.
I'm still, again, like, you go back to the, when the trade happened, I wasn't the biggest Password fan.
But, watching him in spring, watching the way he was able to play the corners, especially defensively, it was pretty impressive.
It's carried over as well.
You saw what he did in triple-A after he came back from injury.
He's putting the ball in play.
You want to see, at some point here, you want to see the power come out, but it's only been a few games.
So far,.
No, I was going to say, I think that's the important part to put out, too, is coming back from the injury.
I know, because they had a lot of early season struggles.
It seemed like that was mostly injury-related, as they came out and said.
So, again, that's good to recognize, also.
he's a Major League Baseball player, or at least he will be a Major League Baseball player.
It's a lot more than you can say about some of the other guys we've seen come up throughout the years.
And, again, there's a ton more upside than there is with a Jake Mangum.
Jake Mangum's a bandage.
The password is an actual solution.
And, again, I have no issues with Jake Mangum as a fourth outfielder.
That's fine.
But, again, that's why this matters, because he's not being thrusted into a role of being an everyday starter now.
He still maintains that.
You have a guy like Garcia, who, like you mentioned, he can be a difference maker.
He could.
We'll find out.
Again, it's not fair to him to expect it.
He's still very raw, as far as his development, as a Major Leaguer.
He's going to come here.
He's probably going to have some early struggles.
But, like, the one thing about him, though, is he can play good defense.
We'll get to see it firsthand now.
But that's also something I want to bring up here, because, like, so could Jake Mangum.
And I'm not trying to trash him.
I'm not, but I do want to say this.
There's been times it's looked bad.
Like, there has.
There has.
It's, like, I was expected to be better than what it is.
And, again, like, it's certainly been fine.
It's certainly been the best outfielder this team has.
Now, it doesn't mean much, but it has been the best one out here.


Comments· 0
Should Esmerlyn Valdez replace Jared Triolo as the Pirates' first baseman against lefties?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.