◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Andrew McCutchen is back in the spotlight as he prepares to face the Pirates, and Alex Stumpf breaks down the legacy, emotion, and baseball reasons behind the split. It’s a thoughtful look at how a franchise icon reached this point.
Watch on YouTube or listen now on North Shore Nine.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Were the Pirates right to let Andrew McCutchen walk instead of bringing him back as a DH for 2026?
From Alex Stumpf’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Apart from Roberto Clemente, Andrew McCutchen is the most important Pirate ever. Without his 2013 MVP season making baseball matter again, Stumpf isn't sure what state the franchise would be in.
Alex Stumpf
2
McCutchen's Hall of Fame case rests on 2011–2015, when he was clearly the best position player in the National League. Stumpf puts him in that era's top tier with Trout, Kershaw and Miggy.
Alex Stumpf
3
Bringing Cutch back for 2026 would have meant keeping him around just to have him around. He'd be a 39-year-old DH only, coming off a .700 OPS, on a team that badly needs more offense.
Alex Stumpf
4
The Pirates still needed veteran leaders on the hitting side even with McCutchen on the 2025 roster. Ryan O'Hearn has since filled that role 'impeccably.'
Alex Stumpf
5
Reunion tours that stretch past two or three years rarely end well. Stumpf compares it to Ken Griffey Jr. staying one year too long in Seattle, which forces fans to choose between loyalty to the player and what's best for the club.
Andrew McCutchen is going to be facing the Pittsburgh Pirates again for the first time since he was a Milwaukee Brewer.
Alex Stumpf
He came back to Pittsburgh in 2023 with a goal and aspiration to bring the Pirates back to being a winning club and retire a Pirate.
Alex Stumpf
Neither happened.
Alex Stumpf
And now he's going to be facing the most exciting Pirates team since probably 2015.
Alex Stumpf
Good morning and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
My name is Alex Stumpf.
Alex Stumpf
This is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
Alex Stumpf
And today and at least tomorrow, we're going to be talking to Andrew McCutchen.
Alex Stumpf
I'll be traveling down to Texas for that press conference.
Alex Stumpf
This is going to be one of the biggest road series of the year.
Alex Stumpf
I had to find a way to get down there.
Alex Stumpf
I'll be down there.
Alex Stumpf
I'll have questions for Cutch.
Alex Stumpf
I'll give my response to some things.
Alex Stumpf
React here.
Alex Stumpf
Have an article on Book Rule Bucs that day.
Alex Stumpf
But before that, I wanted to talk a little bit about how we got here.
Alex Stumpf
Because Andrew McCutchen, in my opinion, and probably in the opinion of many others, is on the Mount Rushmore of Pittsburgh Pirates.
Alex Stumpf
It's Clemente, it's Stargell, it's Wagner, and it's Cutch.
Alex Stumpf
And with the exception of Clemente, he is the most important Pirate of all time.
Alex Stumpf
Because I don't know where this organization would be right now if Andrew McCutchen was never a Pittsburgh Pirate.
Alex Stumpf
If he didn't come and win the MVP in 2013 and make baseball matter in Pittsburgh again, that team doesn't do it without McCutcheon.
Alex Stumpf
God forbid, could you imagine if the losing season streak was at 30-something right now?
Alex Stumpf
People in their 40s having no real recollection of the last time the Pirates played winning baseball.
Alex Stumpf
I don't know what the state of the franchise would be right now.
Alex Stumpf
PNC Park's lease is technically coming close.
Alex Stumpf
And you know how some people occasionally throw on Twitter, oh, the Pirates are going to move because they have no idea how the economics of baseball work.
Alex Stumpf
I wonder if that would have been the case if there was no Andrew McCutchen.
Alex Stumpf
If there was no winning baseball in Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
He is one of the most important figures in the history of the franchise.
Alex Stumpf
And whenever he came back in 2023, we were all excited and that I put myself in that we because I was in high school whenever Andrew McCutchen came up and started providing a little help.
Alex Stumpf
And it's like, wow, baseball might actually matter in Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
I was there.
Alex Stumpf
I was in college whenever this team made the playoffs.
Alex Stumpf
I'm a Pittsburgh kid.
Alex Stumpf
I'm a Pittsburgh kid who grew up loving baseball.
Alex Stumpf
Those were important teams for my love and understanding of the game.
Alex Stumpf
Andrew McCutchen was the center of that.
Alex Stumpf
He was the face of that.
Alex Stumpf
And then they go to the playoffs again in 1415 where he's an all-star and he is the best hitter in the National League.
Alex Stumpf
If he has a Hall of Fame case, it is going to be that from 2011, 2015, a five-year stretch, he was unquestionably the best position player in the National League.
Alex Stumpf
And the big five of that time are, again, without question, it's Trout, it's Kershaw, it's Miggie, and it's Cutch.
Alex Stumpf
That's the Mount Rushmore of that five-year stretch, that awkward teen, tween period from the steroid era to where we are right now.
Alex Stumpf
Cutch was a face, a caretaker of the whole league, and especially the Pittsburgh Pirates.
Alex Stumpf
And then he's traded after the 2017 season because he has one year of team control.
Alex Stumpf
And it was a tough trade.
Alex Stumpf
And Bob Nutting was the last person to sign off on the trade.
And we can say now, yeah, that was a good trade for the Pittsburgh Pirates.
Alex Stumpf
But it still stung.
Alex Stumpf
And that's what made 2023 feel special.
Alex Stumpf
Because even though we all knew, yeah, Cutch, he was going to be remembered as a Pirate.
Alex Stumpf
For him and the club to reaffirm their love for one another.
Alex Stumpf
And that this was special.
Alex Stumpf
That meant a lot.
Alex Stumpf
And you know what?
Alex Stumpf
This was a team that was young.
Alex Stumpf
It was on the upswing.
Alex Stumpf
McCutcheon talked about how he saw promise in that group whenever he was with Milwaukee in 2022.
Alex Stumpf
He didn't want to come back just to come back.
Alex Stumpf
He wanted to come back to win.
Alex Stumpf
And the Pirates didn't.
Alex Stumpf
They took a big step forward in 2023.
Alex Stumpf
And he was a big reason why.
Alex Stumpf
2024, he had another good offensive season.
Alex Stumpf
They stagnated.
Alex Stumpf
2025, that year was a mess.
Alex Stumpf
And McCutcheon didn't really hit.
Alex Stumpf
And there were frustrations throughout the year.
Alex Stumpf
At my old job, I didn't ask me anything on Reddit.
Alex Stumpf
And I was asked, like, what do you think?
Alex Stumpf
Will McCutcheon come back?
Alex Stumpf
And I said at this time, I didn't think so.
Alex Stumpf
This was like in December.
Alex Stumpf
And I cited that there were frustrations on both sides.
Alex Stumpf
that Cutch had with the organization, that the organization had with Cutch.
Alex Stumpf
In a now-deleted tweet, North Shore Nine had a graphic made of that.
Alex Stumpf
And in a now-deleted tweet, Cutch said, news to me.
Alex Stumpf
As the offseason continued to progress, showed his hand that there was at least frustration on his side.
Alex Stumpf
How Pirates Fest went on.
Alex Stumpf
And he wasn't there.
Alex Stumpf
And during Pirates Fest, he, or at the tail end of Pirates Fest, he put out a tweet that was tough to read.
Alex Stumpf
Because you could see him being like, you know what?
Alex Stumpf
This isn't how I wanted it to go down.
Alex Stumpf
I wanted to be able to shake fans' hands.
Alex Stumpf
if I meant something to them, I want to be there.
Alex Stumpf
In this tail end of my career.
Alex Stumpf
There are more instances on social media of him posting, of going through a breakup.
Alex Stumpf
You never want to post through a breakup.
Alex Stumpf
He did a couple times.
Alex Stumpf
It never crossed a line.
Alex Stumpf
But you, at least knowing all the context of it, I looked at it like, yeah, this isn't fun to watch.
Alex Stumpf
You don't want to see, a breakup like this.
Alex Stumpf
And the nail was pretty much put in the coffin in late January, early November.
Alex Stumpf
Early November.
Alex Stumpf
Had to get my timeline right there.
Alex Stumpf
Whenever the Pirates signed Marcell Ozuna to be the DH.
Alex Stumpf
And there was no path back for McCutcheon re-signing.
Alex Stumpf
All of 2025, McCutcheon was asked, do you want to keep playing?
Alex Stumpf
And he kept saying, yeah, he wants to keep playing.
Alex Stumpf
And he is still playing in 2026.
Alex Stumpf
But in a lot of those conversations in 2025, the follow-up was for the Pirates.
Alex Stumpf
And towards the end of the year, he was like, yeah, I want to stay here.
Alex Stumpf
But for a lot of the year, not really.
Alex Stumpf
Now, is it fair to ask a question in May, June, July of saying like, hey, do you want to come back next year?
Alex Stumpf
Run it back, especially whenever that team is having a May like it was?
Alex Stumpf
That's a tough ask.
Alex Stumpf
That's probably an awkward spot for him to be in.
Alex Stumpf
I fully respect and get that.
Alex Stumpf
But in 2024, he talked about how it didn't sit completely right with him to be in that discussion of the franchise greats with Stargell, with Clemente, with Mazeroski, because he's
Alex Stumpf
like, those guys spent their whole year, whole career with Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
And he didn't.
Alex Stumpf
Again, he was traded.
Alex Stumpf
He didn't leave as a free agent.
Alex Stumpf
This time around, Pirates really just didn't offer him anything.
Alex Stumpf
And there really wasn't a whole lot of intent, it feels like, for them to bring him back.
Alex Stumpf
Was that the wrong thing?
Alex Stumpf
Because McCutcheon said the entire time he didn't want to come back just to be here.
Alex Stumpf
He didn't want to be here just to be here.
Alex Stumpf
2026 firmly would have been, you are here just to be here.
Alex Stumpf
Because I have talked at nausea, it feels like, how Marcell Ozuna having a DH only really limits how Don Kelly can deploy the outfield defense.
Alex Stumpf
McCutcheon would have been defense only, or DH only.
Alex Stumpf
He can have the opinion that he feels like he can still play the field.
Alex Stumpf
I saw a lot of plays in that brief sample size in 2025, where he did not.
Alex Stumpf
He might have made the play, but he made a play with like a 95% catch probability that he's sliding for.
Alex Stumpf
A ball that it's like, a lot of outfielders would get this without breaking stride.
Alex Stumpf
They wouldn't have to hit their high horse.
Alex Stumpf
It was not pretty.
Alex Stumpf
He hummed a few bars in the outfield.
Alex Stumpf
He wasn't exploited for it.
Alex Stumpf
He got away with it.
Alex Stumpf
But the Pirates didn't feel comfortable playing in the field regularly.
Alex Stumpf
You know who they did feel comfortably playing in the field regularly?
Now I get 2021, especially at the end of that year, they can say, screw it, we'll just put the bat, we need the bat in the lineup.
Alex Stumpf
We don't care where he is in the field.
Alex Stumpf
In 2023, Henry Davis, it's like, look, we got a rookie here.
Alex Stumpf
We need the bat.
Alex Stumpf
Let's just call him up, see what it is.
Alex Stumpf
But if they felt comfortable putting them in the field regularly and not catch, I think that indicates that they don't think he's a fielder anymore.
Alex Stumpf
So he's a DH only and only as a DH only, he had a 700 OPS last year, like 700 on the nose, removed from the final game of the season to make sure that his back of the baseball
Alex Stumpf
card didn't have a OPS that started with a six.
Alex Stumpf
I don't know what he really brought potentially to a 2026 Pirates club other than if they don't sign Ozuna, he's like the short side platoon for a DH.
Alex Stumpf
That's not a lot.
Alex Stumpf
Like it was even in 2024, whenever I started hearing from within the organization, yeah, he probably should be only playing like three or four times a week.
Alex Stumpf
Now he wanted to play and that's good.
Alex Stumpf
I do not fault a player at all for wanting to play.
Alex Stumpf
You show me a player that is, doesn't want to play, then I don't see a major league player.
Alex Stumpf
He also wanted to win.
Alex Stumpf
And you know what?
Alex Stumpf
Texas is outside of Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
This is probably the best landing spot for him potentially of a team where he can get some playing time and the team could potentially contend.
Alex Stumpf
Like I know the Rangers are, they're about 500 right now.
Alex Stumpf
it's a week A all West, maybe low 80s gets you into the post season and then anything happens there.
Alex Stumpf
But I don't think anyone really looks at the Rangers as, the front runners in this division.
Alex Stumpf
It's the Mariners.
Alex Stumpf
It's the, if the Astros pitching ever, gets together, there's still enough there.
Alex Stumpf
if the A's ever get pitching, maybe they could be in the mix.
Alex Stumpf
Like there are more exciting teams in the AOS than the Rangers.
Alex Stumpf
But I see why he landed there because he wants to win and he wants to play.
Alex Stumpf
And this was the closest on the Venn diagram to being able to accomplish both outside of Pittsburgh.
Alex Stumpf
And in Pittsburgh, they were just those frustrations.
Alex Stumpf
I talked a lot this off season about how the Pirates needed to add veteran leaders on the hitting side.
Even Marcell Ozuna has talked to Oneil Cruz, has talked to Konnor Griffin.
Alex Stumpf
The Pirates were able to self-diagnose what I had seen and what I had heard and whatever I presented it to people.
Alex Stumpf
Nobody ever pushed back on me saying they needed leaders on the hitting side.
Alex Stumpf
They had Andrew McCutchen last year and I was still saying they needed leaders on the hitting side.
Alex Stumpf
I didn't see what I think a lot of people hoped from Cutch in that regard.
Alex Stumpf
So it was a player who's production was not what it was, even in the recent years.
Alex Stumpf
2023, great OBP.
Alex Stumpf
2024, 20 home runs.
Alex Stumpf
And if you believe in the batted ball data, probably should have hit about 25.
Alex Stumpf
Both of those years, it's like, yes, that is someone who is contributing to this offense.
Alex Stumpf
But then in 2025, the offense is the worst in baseball and he has a 700 OPS.
Alex Stumpf
The team desperately needs to improve the offense.
Alex Stumpf
And I don't know how bringing back a 39-year-old DH only, who is coming off of the worst offensive season he's ever had outside of, a year where he's coming back from ACL surgery.
Alex Stumpf
I don't know how that impacts, how that makes that positive impact.
Alex Stumpf
I don't think anyone wanted to be here though.
Alex Stumpf
Because McCutcheon is on the Mount Rushmore of this franchise's history.
Alex Stumpf
Regardless if 2026 is his last year, regardless if he's already played his last game of the Pirate, he is a pirate great.
Alex Stumpf
But there's a reason why a lot of these reunion tours, whatever it gets into two, three years, it's not exactly always the happiest ending.
Alex Stumpf
It's why Ken Griffey's last year in Seattle, he probably stuck around one year too long.
Alex Stumpf
And that's not the only example.
Alex Stumpf
It's You don't want to be in a position where you have to have fans have to choose between loyalty to a player and loyalty to what is best to the ball club.
Alex Stumpf
This was an awkward divorce.
Alex Stumpf
I am personally happy to see that McCutcheon is still playing baseball.
Alex Stumpf
I hope that whenever he does hang it up, it is on his own accord.
Alex Stumpf
This isn't how I think a lot of people hope that it was going to go down though.
Alex Stumpf
And you know what?
Alex Stumpf
It is what it is.
Alex Stumpf
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel.
Alex Stumpf
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe wherever you find a fine podcast.
Alex Stumpf
We'll be here too.
Alex Stumpf
Or if you want to see me on YouTube, I don't know what section I'll be in at Globe Life Field, but I'll find a nice one.
Alex Stumpf
Record from there this week.
Alex Stumpf
Thank you so much for listening.
Alex Stumpf
We'll talk again tomorrow.
Alex Stumpf
All right.
Alex Stumpf
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Alex Stumpf
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Alex Stumpf
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
Alex Stumpf
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
Alex Stumpf
It really helps us grow.
Alex Stumpf
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Alex Stumpf
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
Alex Stumpf
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
Alex Stumpf
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Comments· 0
Were the Pirates right to let Andrew McCutchen walk instead of bringing him back as a DH for 2026?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.