◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
Antwone Kelly has quickly become one of the more intriguing arms in the Pirates system. Jim and Anthony Murphy break down his triple-digit fastball, expanded pitch mix, recent Triple-A progress, and whether his path to Pittsburgh comes as a starter or power bullpen arm.
Watch or listen to the full Bucs On Deck episode now.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should the Pirates move Antwone Kelly into their bullpen right now, even if it costs them starting-pitching depth?
From Jim Rosati’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Anthony Murphy.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Jim thinks the Pirates could use Antwone Kelly in the bullpen right now, but he agrees the team still needs him as starting-pitching depth.
Jim Rosati
2
Unless the Pirates go all in on a late-season playoff push, they should let Kelly keep developing as a starter with his deeper pitch mix rather than make him a reliever.
3
As Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler reach new innings totals, Kelly could come up as a spot starter or piggyback behind Ashcraft for four to six innings.
4
Fans want to DFA Yohan Ramírez and call Kelly up today, but Jim says they need patience: Kelly has 49 innings so far, should land around 125–130, and will still reach the majors this year.
Jim Rosati
5
Kelly is arguably the Pirates' No. 2 pitching prospect and definitely top four, alongside Wilber Dotel and Khristian Curtis.
What's up, everyone? This is the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel. And you are locked into Bucs On Deck. It's our weekly installment where we highlight one prospect in the Pittsburgh Pirates system. I'm Jim. With me from Bucs On Deck is Anthony Murphy. Murphy, how are you doing this? It's a Friday evening, but it's going to be released on Saturday.
Jim Rosati
How are you doing this weekend, Murph? Doing good. Doing good. Excited for this episode. It's one of my favorite players in the system there, so happy to get a chance to talk about him a little bit.
Jim Rosati
I was just about to say that. One of my favorite pitchers in the Pirates system right now. So we are talking about 22-year-old Antwone Kelly burst onto the scene last year, Murphy.
Jim Rosati
And why don't you just give us a quick rundown a little bit about who Antwone Kelly is.
Jim Rosati
Yeah. I'm signed as an international free agent.
Jim Rosati
Like you said, burst on the scene last year.
Jim Rosati
Put up some, like he was one of the guys, he didn't put up like the best of numbers while he was in Bradenton a couple years ago.
Jim Rosati
But you can see there was something there to work with.
Jim Rosati
And, like credit to him. He worked really hard at working at things.
Jim Rosati
And he came in throwing a lot harder, was starting to touch triple digits, worked on his pitch mix.
Jim Rosati
And we'll get into that more, too. He's working on that even more this year.
Jim Rosati
And just a well-rounded guy, upper 90s, triple digit fastball, had a change up last year.
Jim Rosati
Looks like he's changed that to a splitter this season.
Jim Rosati
But just a power, another power arm in a system that has plenty of power arms to go around.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, I remember, you knew who Dotel was, but I remember last season, I don't remember actually seeing him in the spring at all.
Jim Rosati
And so it was really like once the regular season started, he was, he was in Greensboro.
Jim Rosati
And I think it was his first start.
Jim Rosati
And I want to say it was you who was like, Antwone Kelly's just hit a hundred miles an hour on the radar.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, I was, I was sitting there in, I was at the game and he, I was sitting next to Josh Norris of Baseball America and Josh, and he had a radar gun out.
Jim Rosati
And at the end of the ending, I looked at him and said, well, because the stadium radar wasn't working.
Jim Rosati
So I looked at him and said, how hard he was going, was he throwing?
Jim Rosati
And Josh looked at me and goes, oh yeah, that was a hundred.
He was a guy that was really interested going into the, into the year.
Jim Rosati
A hundred miles an hour was not a thing that I could remember.
Jim Rosati
So that was completely brand new.
Jim Rosati
And he just took off with it.
Jim Rosati
Like he was sitting upper nineties, touching a hundred miles an hour, almost every start.
Jim Rosati
And it was, he was doing it deep into the outings too.
Jim Rosati
So it wasn't just like a first inning thing.
Jim Rosati
He was maintaining the velocity throughout.
Jim Rosati
So like when that happened, it piqued my interest a little bit more.
Jim Rosati
I was like, 21 year old and high a ball, all of a sudden getting this velocity spike.
Jim Rosati
And like, there were like other reasons to get like legitimately excited here.
Jim Rosati
When he was signed Murphy, this was a scrawny five, 10 skinny dude.
Jim Rosati
Right.
Jim Rosati
And then all of a sudden, like at age 21, he grew two, three inches over the off season added like 60 pounds.
Jim Rosati
Like he, if you look at him now, it's like, oh, this guy is built.
Jim Rosati
Like he's a workhorse type built starting pitcher.
Jim Rosati
he's, he looks exactly like what you would want, like that prototypical workhorse starter to look like.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
Absolutely.
Jim Rosati
changed like, it felt like overnight changed like his complete like profile going from like, well, this is probably a guy who's going to throw hard.
Jim Rosati
And end up in the bullpen doing it like an ending in the time.
Jim Rosati
Now you look at him, he's grown and like, wow, like this is somebody who can actually stick as a starter now, potentially.
Jim Rosati
Well, I think that's, what's exciting here because the stuff is really good.
Jim Rosati
And I think there's a how we've seen Wilber Dotel this year in the majors, like Antwone Kelly's in that mold where, you know what, if the starter thing doesn't work out,
Jim Rosati
you're probably looking at a really good back-end bullpen arm here.
Jim Rosati
but there's enough intrigue and interest here to try him out as a starting pitcher.
Jim Rosati
and I think it's, like I said, it's interesting to keep in mind that he's still just 22 years old.
Jim Rosati
He doesn't turn 23 until like September this time last year, he was in Greensboro for the first time.
Jim Rosati
Like, it's not like he was repeating the level, like he's moved through this system really quickly.
Jim Rosati
he made 14 starts in Greensboro.
Jim Rosati
I know after you said you saw him at a hundred miles an hour, I was like, I got to see this guy.
Jim Rosati
Greensboro was playing like an hour and a half away from me.
Jim Rosati
So I drove down there to see an Antwone Kelly Greensboro start.
Jim Rosati
That was the first time I got to watch him.
Jim Rosati
And yeah, I was blown away.
Jim Rosati
I was like, this stuff is, this stuff is really good.
Jim Rosati
and then I was, I've been able to see him twice this year, once in Indianapolis and once when they visited Louisville, the first start I saw of him, the fastball command really wasn't there and he was getting hit pretty hard.
Jim Rosati
Second time I saw him looked a lot better in terms of the command looks, looked a lot more comfortable.
Jim Rosati
So got hit hard, especially later in the outing, but it just looked like he was a lot more comfortable there.
Jim Rosati
He's certainly still a work in progress.
Jim Rosati
Like by no means is he a finished product that he's not going to be like Paul Skenes or Jared Jones and be this guy who all of a sudden is a, is a top tier major league pitcher at age 22.
Jim Rosati
But there's a, there's a lot to like here with Antwone Kelly.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
And I think, I think, the fastball, you see the triple digits and everything like that.
Jim Rosati
It can get hit sometimes on there.
Jim Rosati
It's a little, it's the, I know some people, they don't, they don't like the whole analytics thing or like the pitch shape and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
They don't like the analytic thing Murph.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
But the fastball shape's been like up and down this year.
Jim Rosati
And I think that's led to the, and like you said, with the, where if the shape isn't great and then you're not commanding it well, it's that can lead to trouble and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
You've started, we started to see like the shape, look a little bit better as the season's gone on.
Jim Rosati
He's missing a little more bats here and see it starting to turn.
Jim Rosati
I think the big thing with him though, and it's what, like you sent me, how he's diversified his, the pitch mix, pitch mix.
Jim Rosati
He's throwing, like a couple of different sliders.
Jim Rosati
He's throwing like the splitter now.
Jim Rosati
So like now maybe even if the fastball isn't going to be as unhittable, maybe that you want, he has more stuff he can turn to keep hitters guessing it at this point now.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
One of the reasons, one of the things that you look at, if you're trying to determine like, Hey, is this guy a starter?
Jim Rosati
Is this guy a reliever?
Jim Rosati
It's like, can he consistently get left-handed hitters out?
Jim Rosati
Right.
Jim Rosati
And can he get them out?
Jim Rosati
Not just the first time, but can he get them out the second time?
Jim Rosati
Or the third time?
Jim Rosati
And yeah, he's definitely, he's diversified his pitch mix.
Jim Rosati
Like you mentioned, he throws five different pitches.
Jim Rosati
Now there's a four seam, a sinker, a splitter, a sweeper, and then like a gyro slider is what he calls it.
Jim Rosati
so like he's throwing a bunch of different pitches.
Jim Rosati
He's widened his arsenal a little bit.
Jim Rosati
He used to throw a cutter.
Jim Rosati
He scrapped that last year.
Jim Rosati
and so now he's got the sweeper in the, in the slider that move horizontally for him.
Jim Rosati
but yeah, overall, he had a rough start to the season in AAA.
Jim Rosati
And I wonder how much of that had to do with just him getting comfortable with all of his new pitches, getting comfortable with the level.
Jim Rosati
but he has been really good lately.
Jim Rosati
He seems to be coming on super strong.
Jim Rosati
And so I want to talk about just what we've seen out of him this season so far.
Jim Rosati
And then what pirates can't pirates fans can expect from him.
Jim Rosati
maybe even as early as this year, Murphy, before we do though, I'm going to kick it over to Cody.
Jim Rosati
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
Jim Rosati
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
Jim Rosati
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Jim Rosati
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
Jim Rosati
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
Jim Rosati
It's just really full of flavor.
Jim Rosati
I love starting my day with it.
Jim Rosati
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Jim Rosati
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
Jim Rosati
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
Jim Rosati
That's MLB 64000.
Jim Rosati
Message and data rates may apply.
Jim Rosati
See terms for details.
Jim Rosati
All right, Murphy.
Jim Rosati
So, I mentioned before, started off the season a little rocky in AAA.
Jim Rosati
His first two starts, he gave up 10 runs.
Jim Rosati
In those two starts, he walked nine batters.
Jim Rosati
But really, since then, he's started to settle in a lot.
Jim Rosati
And I think what's been very encouraging is he's pitched into the sixth inning in six of his last seven starts.
Jim Rosati
The one that he didn't was one of those times where he went like Tuesday, Sunday.
Jim Rosati
So, it was a short rest.
Jim Rosati
And the Pirates always do that.
Jim Rosati
And the minors where they limit that second start.
Jim Rosati
So, every normal start he's had in his last six of those, he's going deep into the game.
Jim Rosati
He's striking out batters.
Jim Rosati
He's getting the walks a little bit more under control.
Jim Rosati
And his last time out, didn't give up a single run against Iowa.
Jim Rosati
So, he seems to be getting a little bit more comfortable out there.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
Absolutely.
Jim Rosati
I think I saw it on, it was like the call-up podcast.
Jim Rosati
They were talking about, like, they theorized maybe it had something to do with, like, the cold weather.
Jim Rosati
he's from Aruba and, Piston-Brightington and Greensboro.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, maybe just not used to the cold weather just yet.
Jim Rosati
And it took a little bit to get going.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, it's been like a, you just see him starting to settle in and get comfortable.
Jim Rosati
And, being a lot more confident with, like, the pitches, especially in the strike zone.
Jim Rosati
And really, with guys like that, it's, they have the stuff.
Jim Rosati
You just got to remember that the stuff is good.
Jim Rosati
And that if it's in the strike zone, hitters are still going to struggle to hit it.
Jim Rosati
So, just put it in the strike zone and let it play to the good stuff that it is.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Now, what I want to ask you here is, obviously, he's a starter.
Jim Rosati
That's how the team views him long-term.
Jim Rosati
You all at Bucs On Deck, you've got him in your tier three of your rankings, which puts him as pretty much an everyday, number four-ish starter.
Jim Rosati
two-war pitcher is how you have that outlined.
Jim Rosati
Baseball America has him as the number eight prospect in the Pirates system.
Jim Rosati
He's the number two pitching prospect in the Pirates system, according to Baseball America.
Jim Rosati
But, on the flip side, we've seen another Pirates pitching prospect in a similar mold, who's had a similar path to Kelly in Wilber Dotel, where the stuff's really good.
Jim Rosati
When you put him in the bullpen, the stuff looks even better.
Jim Rosati
And he's been performing quite well at the major league level.
Jim Rosati
Is that something that you see and you've seen the Pirates do this the last couple years.
Jim Rosati
You saw them do it with Burroughs and Ashcraft last season, where you introduce your starting pitching prospects by bringing them into the majors, letting them pitch out of the bullpen a little bit, giving them a little bit of length, and then seeing where that happens.
Jim Rosati
Is there a chance that we could see that with Kelly this year, or we said on, you know what, let's let this guy cook in AAA for a bit?
Jim Rosati
I think it really comes down to what, if anything, like externally, they can do as far as helping that bullpen.
Jim Rosati
Because, like, as much intrigue as I think Kelly would be pitching, like, how Dotel has been doing, I also don't think you really want to kill all of your starting pitching depth at this point.
Jim Rosati
And right now, it feels like there's probably a good chance that if someone were to go down, that Kelly's the guy who gets the call here.
Jim Rosati
So you probably don't want to, like, if you're going all in, if you get down to, like, the last late portions of the season, and, like, you're, like, all in on trying to make a playoff, make the playoffs, then, like, maybe you go all in and just say, okay, well, here, go in here, inning or two at a time, let it rip.
Jim Rosati
We're trying to make the playoffs anyways, but I think outside of that, I would probably be okay with just let him, especially seeing the way, like, we already talked about him, like, adding to the arsenal and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
Let him grow into that starter, starting pitch role, because he has so many potential weapons now with much deeper pitch mix.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, I've heard a lot of Pirates fans, and the reason why I really wanted to talk about Kelly this week was, he's been a hot name.
Jim Rosati
The Pirates need right-handed pitching help in that bullpen, and there's not a whole lot of options in AAA, and you look at Kelly, and you're saying, eh, the starter stuff, it's getting better, but it's not exactly where you want it to be.
Jim Rosati
But then you see, like, what Dotel's doing, and you're like, eh, can we do that again with Kelly?
Jim Rosati
So I understand the enthusiasm that Pirates fans have taking a pitcher with this stuff and just inserting him into the bullpen right now.
Jim Rosati
And I think, yeah, I agree with you.
Jim Rosati
I think a lot of this is going to go into, what does this team look like in the next month or two?
Jim Rosati
Does it get to the point where, yeah, like, they're really in this?
Jim Rosati
They could really use Antwone Kelly in the bullpen right now.
Jim Rosati
And I think they could use him in the bullpen right now, to be honest with you.
Jim Rosati
But I also agree with you that, like, you do need some starting pitching depth.
Jim Rosati
So it's going to be interesting to see how this plays out.
Jim Rosati
He is on the 40 man.
Jim Rosati
They added him last offseason because he's a guy who absolutely would have been picked in the Rule 5 draft, right, if left exposed.
Jim Rosati
He's that guy.
Jim Rosati
Like, a team would have picked him and put him in their bullpen, and he would have probably done a pretty good job.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, I think Pirates fans are going to be, like, banging on.
Jim Rosati
They're going to be banging the door to see Kelly in this bullpen.
Jim Rosati
But at the same time, you got to remember, he hasn't even thrown 100 innings above high A ball yet.
Jim Rosati
All of those have been as a starter.
Jim Rosati
Is he quite ready?
Jim Rosati
Do you want him to, especially with the new pitch mix, do you want him to get a little bit more comfortable with that?
Jim Rosati
Because you don't want to introduce him into the majors while he's tinkering and working on stuff either.
Jim Rosati
You want him to be pretty comfortable with what he's doing.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, it's going to be interesting.
Jim Rosati
I do think, though, Murphy, I think we see Antwone Kelly in the majors this year at some point.
Jim Rosati
Oh, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
I can see, in about a month or so, we start talking about, like, some of the, Ashcraft and Chandler and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
As they start getting to, like, new territory as far as innings pitch.
Jim Rosati
Like, maybe you want to space things out.
Jim Rosati
Bring Kelly up for, like, a spot starter or to, like, piggyback with Ashcraft or something like that.
Jim Rosati
And, have, like, Ashcraft be, like, four or five innings and just, like, dip regardless.
Jim Rosati
And then you can throw Kelly in there to help out with innings and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
And so, like, I don't have a doubt.
Jim Rosati
He's on the 40-man roster.
Jim Rosati
It's smart.
Jim Rosati
It'd be smart to utilize all your arms on your 40-man roster to try to keep everyone fresh.
Jim Rosati
And he's one of the few guys right now that's not in the majors that's going to be able to go out there and give you four, five, potentially six innings.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, I definitely see a scenario where he pitches maybe probably a couple times in the majors this year.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, I agree with you.
Jim Rosati
He's already had 49 innings pitched on the year right now as of May 29th.
Jim Rosati
He threw 107 last year.
Jim Rosati
So, you expect that to get bumped up to, the 125, 130 range this year.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, I think there's some innings in there to help the big league club.
Jim Rosati
I think you got to be – I think we're going to have to be a little bit more patient than we want to be with him.
Jim Rosati
I know a lot of people would just call him up today and say, let's DFA Yohan Ramirez and call up Kelly right now.
Jim Rosati
I think you're going to have to wait a little bit longer than that.
Jim Rosati
But I think you'll see him this year.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
If you could turn injuries off, like if this was – that would be the show, and you could turn injuries off, then, yes, you just throw him in the bullpen like today.
Comments· 0
Should the Pirates move Antwone Kelly into their bullpen right now, even if it costs them starting-pitching depth?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.