Nate Osler and Cody Kohlman are back for Episode 3 of Ahoy Matey!, and things get completely out of hand. After reacting to a bizarre AI-generated Pirates podcast and introducing BuccoMike’s Scoop of the Week, the guys put 24 Pirates personalities into a Hunger Games simulator. From Paul Skenes and Konnor Griffin to Bob Nutting and Ben Cherington, nobody is safe. The alliances, eliminations, and unbelievable ending make this their wildest episode yet.
The Pirates Hunger Games Had the Most Pirates Ending Ever

With Cody Kohlman and Nathan Osler.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
There is no world where Braxton Ashcraft is fighting for the fifth rotation spot: he and Paul Skenes were the Pirates' top two starters by WAR last year, so Beatline's AI podcast got it badly wrong.
- 2
AI should be a tool, not the whole business model: NS9 uses it for things like finding timestamps, but releasing hundreds of fully AI-generated podcasts a day is insane.
- 3
Bucko Mike's 'sources' tweets, like the Pirates being close to Alex Vesia for two years and $60 million, are still impossible not to get excited about: he's never wrong, only early.
- 4
Prediction with three tributes left: Ben Cherington wins the Pirates Hunger Games without a single kill, because Ryan O'Hearn and Bob Nutting take each other out.
- 5
Cherington winning the Hunger Games by doing nothing 'sounds like real life', the same dig as him sleeping through a whole day sounding like his offseasons.
Players discussed
Full transcript1000 paragraphs · show
Ahoy, matey! It's me, Cody, that's Nate, and we're here to talk about the fun stuff around the Pittsburgh Pirates. But Nate, breaking news, this was as of recording today, something happened in the podcast sphere that just has us all bamboozled, befuddled, really.
Yeah, it's not even just Pirates Land. It's the entire world of sports. There's a new podcast in the world of podcasting that we have to discuss today. We weren't going to discuss it until it came out today.
Yeah, like we had a whole show lined up. We're like, we're gonna do this, do that, do this. And we're gonna get to it. We got the Hunger Games coming up later in the episode. But, Beatline. Is that what it's called? Beatline?
Yes, Beatline Sports.
Beatline Sports, I guess, just launched.
Yeah.
And, Nate, it's interesting. It's not in a good way, though. I'll say that. It's something that I, in this world of AI, it was bound to happen. Someone was bound to do this. And I'm just, I'm shocked that it happened so soon.
Yeah, someone literally just puts in a prompt for, like, every single team. And it was all over baseball Twitter this morning. I didn't see the Pirates one until we're gonna play it in a couple minutes from now. Until DiNardo posted on the NS9 account. But I saw, like, a Red Sox one. That was the first one I saw. And they're talking about, like, how Tristan Casas and you have Contreras. They're gonna move Contreras to the outfield to be a gold glove outfielder. I was like, this is a catcher in first baseman. I don't think he's going to the outfield.
But then I'm listening to a Padres one I was telling you before the show. The AI voice, she was saying, like, they have four, we have four different MVP candidates. And it said it as Manny Machedo, Fernando Tatis Jr., Xander Bogay Arts, and Jackson Mariel.
it's no secret. We here at NS9, utilize AI. But that's the key word is we utilize. It's not the whole business model. Like, it's the whole business model of NS9 is not based off of AI content. We use it as a tool.
I don't use it. I don't use it. I don't use it to make my graphics. I don't use it.
I use it as a tool for editing to find timestamps. Because I used to just listen to the entire episode of everything. And then I'd have to be like, well, now I need a clip. And now I need to edit it. And by the time I'm done with that, I've wasted three hours of my life listening to Jim, Tyler and DiNardo talk.
Yeah.
So now it saves me from that headache of listening to those three stooges. But just the fact that somebody is like, yeah, I'm just going to release hundreds of AI podcasts.
A day.
A day is just insane.
It's not just baseball. It's like Beatline Sports Chicago Bears, Beatline Sports Carolina Hurricanes.
I saw Atlanta FC.
There was one like football or soccer.
Like the Creighton Blue Jays I saw. There's a Creighton Blue Jays one.
Oh, my God.
Basketball.
But yeah, what really befuddled me was what was said in the Pirates one.
Yeah.
And I think you got the audio for us.
Yes.
Let's just play it.
Yes.
So here we go here.
Welcome to today's episode of the Beatline Podcast Network, the home of daily deep dive baseball analysis for fans who refuse to settle for surface level headlines.
I'm Megan, and I'm here with Steve.
And I'm Steve.
We're going to break down the hot stove moves around the league, see how they impact the Pirates specifically, and finally put a stake in the ground regarding that third base decision.
Here is what we are covering today.
First, we look at the division rivals and the league-wide frenzy over ace pitchers like Tarek Skubal.
Second, we analyze how Pittsburgh stacks up against those teams if they make the right moves.
And third, we discuss what outside results mean for the Pirates' path to the playoffs.
We also have some updates on the bullpen cuts and the fifth starter role that Braxton Ashcraft has been fighting for.
Now, there's a few things there.
The blaring thing is Braxton Ashcraft fighting for the fifth rotation spot.
Hey, of course, he is.
He's out there fighting for it.
Nate, can you do me a favor?
Can you look up who had the best war out of the Pittsburgh Pirates' rotation last year?
Because I almost guarantee it was Braxton Ashcraft.
It's either Skenes or Ashcraft.
It's very – so either way, they're one and two.
There is no world where Ashcraft is fighting for the five spot, like, which is a are you even on the team spot.
Right.
Now, here's what I'll say.
Maybe whoever made this AI podcast was, like, reviewing it.
Let's just – hypothetically, they were reviewing this and said, you know what?
The AI sounds really weird when it tries to pronounce Carmen Mlodzinski.
So let's just change it to Braxton Ashcraft.
Hey, they know what they're doing.
They're getting clicks.
They're going viral right now.
Hey.
For the long reasons, but – Hey, but that's how people make money these days.
It's sad.
Heck, we just played them on our show.
Yeah, we gave them free pub.
I already forgot the names.
Emily and Steve or Emily – We got to bring them on Ahoy Mate.
It's Steve and somebody.
I don't know.
We're bringing them on Ahoy Matey.
We got to.
We got to do an interview.
We should get them on, like, NS9 Live.
NS9 Live Plus with Steve and Emily from the – whatever it is.
I already forget the name of that podcast.
Right.
The beatbox or whatever it is.
The beatline sports.
The beatline sports.
But I just – I woke up to that today, Nate, and I was just befuddled.
Oh, I was at work.
It gave me a good laugh today during, like, all my breaks.
I was like, what are we doing, people?
But – I just love seeing every single team.
It's like everyone rants about it.
It's like everyone united against one cause.
Like, let's get rid of this podcast.
And then I saw the guy – allegedly, the guy who made it was like, yeah, I made this, and it's awesome.
And I'm like, sure it is, pal.
It was a typical, like, Silicon Valley, like, Southern California tech guy.
That's literally what it was.
You can find the tweet, like, him saying it really easily.
It had, like, 50 comments to one like in the ratio, and it had, like, 35 quote tweets.
And everyone was clowning.
Yeah, and then this guy – this guy hadn't sent, like, an individual tweet.
He had a bunch of replies to stuff, but I looked at his profile.
He hadn't – he sent an individual tweet, like, recently, but then his last tweet was in, like, 2024.
Pretty sure the profile picture is not, like, really blurry.
Yeah, it's – I don't – this may be – I don't want to get confused.
Conspiracy theory, like, put tinfoil hats on, but maybe this is part of that hugging face issue that they had with the AIs creating a community.
Maybe it's leaking out and trying to, like, get people to come in.
What if this is the MLB Players Association running these podcasts, trying to silence Pirates Twitter yet again?
Oh, my gosh.
Too many conspiracies for one day.
Well, moving on to something else on Pirates Twitter really quick.
A segment on this show we wanted to do every week, but we haven't been blessed with any comments from this person on Twitter as of now.
Well, we finally got one.
Welcome – we don't have an intro for this segment, sadly.
We don't have an intro for anything yet.
Welcome to our first ever Bucko Mike Scoop of the Week.
So, Bucko Mike, of course, on Twitter.
As we see here, I'm one of the likes and saves, by the way, officially.
63,000 point – well, 63.7K views, impressions, on – over on X, aka Twitter.
Sources.
The Pittsburgh Pirates are close to signing lefty reliever Alex Vesla.
Vesla, of course.
Two years, 60 million.
He, of course, went down here and said, Vesia.
So, Bucko Mike has the Pirates in.
Now, Nate, you need to tell me, how much time was between the original tweet and the corrected tweet?
The correction tweet.
12 to 19 p.m. yesterday, and then – that was 19 hours ago, and then 21 hours.
So, like, two hours.
So, it took him two hours to realize he misspelled Alex Vesla.
Listen, Bucko Mike can do no wrong with these.
Every single one he posts, Pirates Twitter just goes along with it.
He has, like, Blue Jays fans and Dodgers fans mad at him, saying, you don't know anything.
He's good at baiting these guys.
And that's the thing, is, like, I personally can't help but to get excited when I see a Bucko Mike sources tweet.
I'm like, this might happen.
He's never wrong, only early.
Bucko Mike always says his sources are right 50% of the time.
He's gotten things right before.
He has.
Now, the Instagram accounts – like, there was one last year that picked him up.
It was, like, a Konnor Griffin leaked contract that was not even close to what he actually got.
It was, like, $150 million or whatever it was in a contract.
An Instagram account posted it per Bucko Mike.
And it had, like, 50,000 likes on Instagram.
I was like, what are we doing, guys?
That's hilarious.
This is our first Bucko Mike scoop of Ahoy, matey.
We want to make this a weekly segment.
So, Bucko Mike, we know you have more scoops.
We know you listen to this.
On the Discord, you – Listen, Cody, I don't know if you're as active.
Bucko Mike needs to get it together.
I got to get on my soapbox for a second.
I know that we want to talk about this, but Bucko Mike, if you're watching, when are we going to get these NS9 ratings back?
He used to rate us weekly to say who was where and, like, who was number one personality.
It was great.
I loved it every week.
He doesn't pay for Twitter, though.
He doesn't have to verify it.
He can't use Grok.
He would use Grok for that?
Yeah, he'd be like, at Grok.
No, he wouldn't.
Rank these members of NS9 in order of blank.
I think this was before Grok.
Now, I'll say this about Bucko Mike, too.
Bucko Mike, I don't even know if he's going to be watching by now because our first episode he put on the Discord, if you're in there as much, Cody.
He added me.
Of course, just me.
He was like, at NNO.
He knows I'm not in there.
He said, at NNO, which if you know what that means, you know what it means.
And then he said, Coleman.
Not just Cody.
He just said Coleman.
He spelled my name wrong, right?
He said, Ahoy, matey, boring.
I want Chips Ahoy more.
So we're going to rename the show Chips Ahoy.
I would love to.
In honor of Bucko Mike.
I would love to name it Chips Ahoy.
I just don't know that we can afford the name.
But, yeah, that's the Bucko Mike scoop of the week.
But, yeah, I got to say, I was excited when I saw this tweet.
I was like, oh, man, I think we might be getting Alex Vesla.
Yeah, Vesla.
Not Vesla, his brother.
But, yeah, I, yeah.
Bucko Mike, sometimes he gets the juices flowing.
And then sometimes he just really pisses me off.
Well, if you go to his, I had to be careful pulling up his Twitter account.
Because there's some stuff I can't, I don't want to show on Ahoy, matey.
If you know where I'm going with this.
He was in a Twitter Spaces during that, by the way.
He's a wild card, that one.
Yeah, he's always in those crypto Twitter Spaces.
Yeah.
But, all right, Nate, let's get into the meat and potatoes of the show.
But before we do, we've got to handle some business.
I'd like to thank today's sponsor, Larenco.
We all know nicotine pouches are popular and part of it isn't so much the nicotine as the routine.
Larenco just launched a pouch that keeps the routine but leaves the nicotine out.
Larenco pouches swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
It works like pouches you've seen before.
Tuck one in and go about your day.
Each pouch has a half cup of coffee's worth of caffeine plus L-theanine and alpha-GPC for a smooth, steady focus with no energy crash.
And it gives your teeth daily enamel support in between brushings.
It comes in mint, cinnamon, and mango.
Also, it's nicotine-free always.
It's doing something good for your teeth and it gives you smooth energy, focus without those jitters.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designated to do both.
And it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Larine a try right now.
Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at buylarine.com slash North Shore.
That's buylarine, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash North Shore for up to 50% off.
Nate, we're here.
Hunger Games is coming out this week.
I'm excited.
Are you excited?
Are you a Hunger Games fan?
Are you a big fan of the Hunger Games?
Eh.
Really?
This is wild.
Because this was your idea and you're like, yeah, it's fun.
Okay.
I'll say this.
Doing what we're about to do is a funny premise.
I've never really read the books.
I'm not a big guy.
I'm not a big book guy.
I never was.
Movie guy.
I can watch the movies.
Will I see this movie in theaters?
Probably not.
I might wait for streaming.
The next movie I'm seeing in theaters is Avengers Doomsday.
But that's a month from now.
But I might see this.
Who knows?
But we might be waiting for streaming.
But I'm more excited for our version.
But let me just say this.
I have a gripe.
Okay.
Here's something that I find really interesting.
The day, literally two days after we released last week's Ahoy Madey, where we teased Pirates Hunger Games, freaking Mr. Beast goes out and drops Hunger Games on Saturday.
This guy's copying us.
I just watched that the other day.
I watched that this morning.
I think I watched it on Saturday.
But still, like, he's copying us.
There's no way.
Like, what are the odds?
Now it's going to look like we're copying him.
How often can you say you're ahead of the curve on Mr. Beast?
My gosh.
I was talking about AI.
That's something we've got to be.
Mr. Beast, we're everywhere today.
We deserve a pat on the back.
We were ahead of the curve on that.
Mr. Beast got nothing on us.
Even though he probably filmed that video a year ago.
He's a little late, buddy.
But all right, Nate.
You're our game master.
So bring it on up.
Let's play.
Okay.
So I'll just say this.
Before we start, how it works is we can't rig it.
We did pick who was in it.
So let's introduce the tributes.
Okay.
We're going to introduce them.
If we missed your favorite player, I am sorry.
But you'll see why some spots were not given.
So here we go.
So let me just say this, too.
If you're listening via podcast, you might want to pull up YouTube if you want to see visuals because the simulator we are using will say how they die or what happens.
They could say eat loaf of bread.
Yeah.
Die to snake.
You have to see it.
But our district one.
We, of course, originally had in the plans Jim and DiNardo, but I had to replace them because I couldn't get images off of Google.
So sorry, Jim and DiNardo.
So we're doing the pitch.
We're doing the middle pitchers.
Ashcraft and Keller couldn't really think of a good name for that district.
Last second.
We go to the young rookies.
Konnor Griffin and Rafael Flores Jr.
Everyone's favorite tandem of pitcher and catcher.
Of course, Paul Skenes and Henry Davis.
The back end of the bullpen, Luke Weaver, Mason Montgomery.
The veterans, Ryan O'Hearn, Bryan Reynolds.
The Cone Hoisters, District 6, Jake Mangum and Billy Cook.
The third baseman that are very polarizing to many, Nick Gonzales and Jared Triolo.
The young hitting outfielders that with a lot of pop, Cruz and Valdez, the magician.
The young arms that are really flamethrowers right now, Jared Jones and Bubba Chandler.
Then we go to our fun ones, Districts 10 through 12 that are not players.
So if you're wondering where Horwitz is, I'm sorry he did not make the cut.
No Brandon Lowe because, of course, today he rejected the qualifying offer.
So if he's not a pirate, thank you for your service, Brandon Lowe.
We go to District 10.
And we're going to see 11 and 12, so they'll be spoiled.
The mascots, the pirate, parrot, and jalapeno Hannah.
I was against putting jalapeno Hannah in this, but we already know there's going to be a lot of fans rooting for us.
I personally wanted to put Potato Pete because he won the championship, but we gave in and did Hannah.
Greg Brown and Joe Block, the announcers.
Which play-by-play announcer will last the longest?
And, of course, the front office, GM Ben Cherington and owner Bob Nutting.
Now, on my YouTube channel about two years ago, I did this.
I'm not even kidding.
Bob Nutting killed off Andrew McCutchen to win the Pirates Hunger Games.
Can Bob Nutting...
It was insane.
Can he run it back?
That's the question.
Now, Cody, I hope this doesn't mess up because I did not hit proceed yet.
I did not want spoilers.
We're going in.
Can we zoom in a bit?
Yes, I got you.
So, if you're watching at home or listening, so here's where we can't see spoilers.
So, it all starts.
The horn has sounded.
Luke Weaver has scared Bob Nutting away.
So, I'm assuming Bob Nutting's just running into the woods.
Luke Weaver came over and said, I want more money.
No, I'm worried about it.
No, I'm worried for Luke Weaver in this.
Because if he has to run in the woods, is he going to get poison ivy?
Like...
I...
It's a strong chance.
-oh.
-oh.
We have a Paul Skenes update.
Oh, he ran away.
Paul Skenes runs away.
See, this is what will help if you want to...
Go on YouTube if you're listening on podcasts, like I said, if you want to actually see what is happening here.
Hank Davis also runs away.
He runs with his buddy.
Smart.
Smart.
KG's dead.
What?
What?
Konnor Griffin falls into a frozen lake and drowns.
Hold on.
This is something...
I have a gripe with this simulator already.
We need to know what the arena is.
Because, like, there's a frozen lake in the arena.
Are we playing in the tundra?
Are we playing in like...
I guess we are.
All right.
We're in the middle of, like, Pittsburgh right now.
It's cold.
Yeah, it's Pittsburgh in the middle of January, I guess.
Konnor Griffin appears to be the first death, and it's not even to someone.
Oh, my gosh.
It's himself.
That's...
Oh, poor KG.
That's tough.
Good.
I'm glad no one did it.
Yeah.
Well, we might...
I don't know.
We might find something out.
Oneil Cruz runs away.
A lot of people running.
That's what you're supposed to do, though.
Oh, okay.
Bryan Reynolds took a spear.
He has a weapon.
That tells me Bryan Reynolds is a career tribute.
He knows what he's doing.
He knows I need to go get a weapon and get out of here.
Okay.
I see your guy magician's eyes, so I'm nervous here.
Okay.
He ran away.
He's still alive.
Okay.
Smart.
Smart.
Go get shelter.
There's three boxes below this.
Oh.
Oh, we got a group.
Oh.
Wow.
Jared Jones, Mason Montgomery, and Jared Triolo are working together.
So, Mason Montgomery just left Luke Weaver in the dust.
He was like, you scared Bob.
I'm done with you.
Yeah.
Mason Montgomery wanted that money, but Luke Weaver scared him away.
And Jones and Tree, they left their partners, too.
Yeah.
I would assume.
Jones is with Bubba, and Nicky G had Triolo.
But now we have a little alliance here.
Yeah.
Let's see what happens.
Rafael Flores clutches a first aid kit and runs away.
I bet you he did that.
He obviously did that after KG fell in the lake.
Oh, yeah.
That's his partner.
And then he saw that he drowned.
Yeah.
And he was like, I guess this is mine now for when I get hurt.
No, Greg Brown!
Oh, Greg Brown!
No!
My sweet prince!
Greg Brown!
Sorry for your ears, everyone.
Greg Brown just fell into a frozen lake with Konnor Griffin and drowned.
Oh, my gosh.
I can't believe this.
Is that the oldest and the youngest members of this falling into a frozen lake?
Is Bob Nutting older than Greg Brown?
I'm sorry, Greg Brown, but looking at you and Bob...
What about the pirate parrot?
Is the pirate parrot older?
That, no, because Greg Brown was the pirate parrot at one point.
Oh, okay.
So, Mitch Keller following the likes of Rafael Flores getting a first aid kit.
So, rest in peace, Greg Brown and Konnor Griffin.
Oh, my gosh.
Oh, no.
Billy Cook, Joe Block, and Hal Pino Hanna might be getting into some action.
Forming an alliance?
Oh, a new alliance.
Yes, an alliance.
Billy, Joe, and Hanna work together.
Billy, Joe, and Hanna.
Let's go.
Oh!
Bubba Chandler has broken Braxton Ashcraft's nose for a basket of bread.
Oh!
Dang.
That's rough.
And then Ben Cherington grabs a backpack and retreats.
But what's in the backpack?
We don't know.
Oh, I can't wait to find out.
Parrot found water.
Good for the parrot.
Ryan O'Hearn runs away.
Nikki G gets water.
We'll go through these a little quick.
And then Jake Mangum runs away.
So, we're on...
That's...
We're officially day one.
That was the intro.
That's the first bit of action.
That was like the first five minutes of The Hunger Games.
All that happened, basically.
And we lost Konnor Griffin and Greg Brown.
to be fair...
That's not official yet.
I haven't seen it say they died yet.
So, I'm holding out hope.
I'm sorry.
I'm just looking at the sentence, Bob discovers a cave.
Bob discovers a cave.
Bob Nutting found a cave.
He got scared and ran into a cave.
So, Luke Weaver scared him enough that he was going to run into a dark cave.
Now, this sounds a lot like Ben Cherington's off-seasons.
Ben sees smoke rising the distance, but decides not to investigate.
Fair.
It's very silent.
So, Ben is being very cautious right now.
Makes sense.
Okay.
Mitch Keller and Luke Weaver are splitting up.
I guess they're in alliance now.
This must have happened.
Off-sim.
Bryan Reynolds injures himself.
Not great.
Jared Triolo gets higher ground.
Billy Cook makes a spear.
So, there's only two official weapons right now in play.
Reynolds has an actual spear.
We have a real spear and a wooden spear.
Yeah, Billy Cook made his own.
Alapeno Hanna has discovered a river.
So, we got lakes and rivers.
I think we are in Pittsburgh.
The Allegheny River has been unlocked by Alapeno Hanna.
Jared Jones tries to sleep through the entire day.
Keyword is tries.
I don't know about that.
I don't know if that will work.
Personally.
It's conserving energy.
Nicky G is trying to spear.
Spearfish.
Don't know what happens there.
Oneil Cruz is picking flowers during the actual Hunger Games.
I would say a lot of Pirates fans are like, yeah, that's what he does in center field every game.
I'm not one of the Pirates fans.
Yeah, I'm not one of them either.
I know there are Pirates fans out there that say that.
Pirates Facebook would be all over this right now.
Of course he is.
Jake Mangum explores the arena.
Oh.
Oh, Magician down.
Oh.
Braxton Ashcraft, Hank Davis, and the Magician start fighting, but Hank Davis runs away as Braxton kills the Magician.
Oh, we got some.
That's your guy, Cody.
Oh, my God.
What's your thoughts about Braxton Ashcraft?
He's being a nuisance right now.
we're looking at this experience-wise.
This makes sense, right?
KG, Ezmerlin, the rookies, they go down fast.
it's unfortunate, but I think a lot of people, a lot of people at the Capitol probably had money on that happening first.
Poor Greg Brown, too, one of the oldest competitors.
I know, but we got four names here.
We have a big four group, a five-person group.
Montgomery's being a little bit of a pest here, switching sides.
Joe Block, Rafael Flores Jr., Ryan O'Hearn, the Pirate Parrot, and Mason Montgomery are all hunting together for other tributes.
They're on the prowl.
I guess these are the career tributes.
Paul Skenes goes hunting by himself.
Now, Skenes is the only other one with a weapon, right?
Okay, Bubba Chandler is pricked by thorns while picking berries.
If that kills Bubba Chandler, I will laugh so hard.
No, I'm sorry.
B-Ray was the one with a spear, not Skenes.
Yes.
Okay.
So, the day ends, Bubba Chandler pricks himself with thorns.
We have lost three.
Three cannon shots can be heard in the distance.
And two of them were to themselves, falling into a river.
KG.
From District 2, Konnor Griffin.
From District 11, Greg Brown.
And then your guy.
And from District 8, is Esmerlyn Valdez.
You will not be forgot.
Well, we're getting some fight.
Welcome to the first night, everybody.
-oh.
Luke Weaver defeats Skenes in a fight, but spares his life.
Bold strategy.
Mitch Keller and Flores.
So, Flores is at least making some friends.
He's talking about, they're talking about people still going.
Nicky D tends to his wounds.
We got a big six-person face-off coming up here.
Yeah, so I can already see the faces.
O'Hearn, Joe Block, the Parrot, and Monty.
I think that's Billy Cook, actually.
But some of these guys are involved with each other.
Oh.
Ryan O'Hearn, Joe Block, and Bob Nutting successfully ambushed and killed the Pirate Parrot.
Jalapeno, Hannah, and Billy Cook.
Oh, my God.
We got a trio here at Cosset.
And they're still working with, like, Mason Montgomery, too.
Yeah.
That's crazy.
So, O'Hearn, Joe Block, and Bob Nutting are on a killing spree right now.
This is insane.
Braxton Ashcraft defeats Ben Cherington, but spares his life.
Rookie move.
Tree, Cruz, Bubba, B-Ray, and Hank Dave sleep in shifts.
So, I think this is a new faction.
So, yeah, we have a new faction.
Yes, I think we're getting a faction here.
Oh, my goodness.
Montgomery poisoned himself.
No, he poisoned.
Yeah.
Oh, yeah.
Okay.
So, Mason Montgomery poisons Jared Jones' drink, but mistakes it for his own and dies.
I thought Montgomery was going to be a main character here.
I know.
He was progressing well.
Jake Mangum gets a sponsorship, a hatchet.
I know who it was from.
Yeah.
Who gave Jake Mangum a hatchet?
It was from ABC News because of the Jake Mangum kid.
It is from ABC News.
If you understand the Discord, you know my thing about that.
They said we can't let America's sweetheart go out there without a weapon.
America has voted they have sent Jake Mangum a hatchet.
Okay.
Rafael Flores goes to the higher ground at the start of day two.
Nicky G has decapitated Luke Weaver with a sword.
Where did he find a sword?
On the ground, I guess.
I don't know.
That's crazy.
It's getting graphic.
Okay.
Joe Block and Ryan O'Hearn still working together.
So we have that main trio of Joe Block, Ryan O'Hearn, and Bob Nutting.
So far.
Montgomery was part of it, but he just drank the poison himself.
Braxton Ashcraft thinks about home.
That gives me something.
I might jinx this.
I think they might be making Braxton Ashcraft to be this main character.
He's from Texas, I can tell by the way.
-oh.
He got a hatchet.
Oh, no!
He just got the hatchet, but the frozen lake has again claimed its third victim.
Jake Mangum has drowned into the frozen lake.
Oh, Jakey.
He's a mayor.
R.I.P.
So, Jared Jones, of course, friends with Paul Skenes, has diverted Hank Davis' attention and runs away.
I don't know what's going on there.
Mitch Keller searches for water.
Bob Nutting fishes.
Oh, maybe something's going to happen with these two.
Ben Tens.
Ben Cherington tends to Paul Skenes.
Ben said, hey, if I help you out here, do you think you're going to sign for a small deal?
How's that arbitration case going to go next year?
Right.
Oneil Cruz makes a slingshot.
B-Ray questions his sanity.
Jared Triolo makes another wooden spear.
And then Bubba bleeds out to untreated injuries.
Is that from the fight?
The fight earlier?
It was him and Ashcraft, right?
Oh, that makes sense.
So, we've lost seven people.
Or five animals.
The Pirate Parrot, Jalapeno Hanna, all of District 10 is now gone.
Billy Cook, Mason Montgomery, Luke Weaver, Jake Mingo.
All of District 4 is gone.
And Bubba Chandler have all fallen.
And all of District 6?
Am I right?
A lot, yeah.
A lot of people, yeah.
The Cone Hoister's gone.
The back end of the bullpen, gone.
The mascots, gone.
It's not looking good.
Not looking good.
Ryan O'Hearn quietly hums to start night two, humming to himself.
Hey, you gotta soothe yourself in the arena.
Oneil Cruz has died to dysentery.
Oh, my gosh.
He just made a slingshot.
That's not good.
Rafael Flores destroys Nicky G's supplies while he falls asleep.
So, a young player is screwing over another young player here.
Jared Jones lets Braxton into the shelter.
How kind.
Henry Davis sets up his own camp.
Bryan Reynolds receives clean water from a sponsor.
Again, Ben Cherington defeats Paul Skenes in a fight but spares the light.
I think they did it opposite.
Didn't he just tend to his wounds?
I think they, I think they were fighting and then they spared each other last time, too.
I think they're friends.
Yeah, I think they're just having spats.
They're like, ah, screw you, screw you.
Let me help you.
Let me help you.
Screw you.
Screw you.
It seems like Ben Cherington and Paul Skenes really want to fight before this lockout happens.
They just don't want to.
They're trying to get something done here.
Mitch Keller receives fresh food from a sponsor.
Spoiler.
Spoiler.
The sponsor was me.
Oh, okay.
Sorry.
Jared Triolo has convinced Joe Block to snuggle with him at night.
To be fair, we did figure out this is a cold weather climate arena.
So they gotta stay warm.
Makes sense.
Bob Nutting starts, sees a fire, but stays hidden.
So not a lot of action night too.
Day three, Joe Block is on the hunt for more tributes.
Bryan Reynolds receives medical supplies from a sponsor.
Flores attacks Mitch Keller, but manages to escape.
Skenes and Jared Jones finally working together.
It seems like they weren't wanting to, but they're finally doing some stuff together.
Hank Davis is practicing his archery.
Hopefully they don't go 180 degrees foul, like his pole balls he hits.
Bob Nutting and Jared Triolo, which I think Jared Triolo was part of that original group.
It was like the five.
Ryan O'Hearn, Bob Nutting, Montgomery, Triolo, and Joe Block.
Ryan O'Hearn searches for fire ward.
Nikki G receives clean water.
Ben chases Braxton.
Not a lot of action on day three.
And we only lost one.
Oneil Cruz did the dysentery on.
Oh, I wanted to see the status of everybody.
Here, we'll check that after.
We'll check that after.
Bob Nutting tries to sing himself to sleep.
Jared Jones, meanwhile, cries himself to sleep.
Fair.
Skenes fends Jared Triolo, Joe Block, and Ryan O'Hearn away from his fire.
So, Paul Skenes just 1v3'd the entire team and said, get out.
Well, minus Bob.
Bob wasn't there.
Bob Nutting's hiding.
He's humming.
He's singing to himself.
Right, but he's part of that group.
Yeah, they lost Mason Montgomery a couple days ago.
They're feeling it right now.
Bryan Reynolds looks at the night sky.
Braxton Flores and Mitch discuss the games and what might happen.
Nikki G and Ben just talk about the tributes.
It seems like there's a lot of talking right now.
Not a lot of action.
Let's get this action going.
Yeah, they're all like, whoa.
There's been a lot of death.
So, I think Hank Davis might be in trouble.
He has an infection, and I think that might be an issue.
Oh, Robert V. L. Flores is stalking Paul Skenes.
Mitch Keller practicing archery.
Braxton Ashcraft is camouflaging himself.
B-Ray and Ben work together.
Jared Jones is bleed-blood out.
There's our first death.
Oh, no.
We lost a pitcher.
Nikki G thinks about home.
Joe Block discovers a cave.
Bob Nutting's still hunting for tributes.
Triolo has injured himself.
Hank Davis gets water.
Ryan O'Hearn constructs a shack.
Let's check the status as we lose Jared.
Yeah, we lost Jared Jones, man.
So, here's our first three districts.
There we go.
We still have Braxton Ashcraft, Mitch Keller, Rafael Flores Jr., Paul Skenes, and Henry Davis.
Ryan O'Hearn has three kills right now.
Wow.
The only people with kills are Ashcraft and O'Hearn.
Nick Gonzales with a kill.
Jared Triolo is still alive.
Joe Block, three kills.
Ben Cherington alive.
Bob Nutting as well, three kills.
It is the group of Bob Nutting, Joe Block, Jared Triolo, and Ryan O'Hearn destroying everybody.
If Mason Montgomery was still here, there would be some problems for everyone else.
Any thoughts?
It's really feeling like Bob is trying to situate himself to be the victor here.
If he's surrounded himself with other killers, and he's like, he's just going to outsmart them all.
So, we'll see how it goes.
Joe Block, Braxton Ashcraft, Bryan Reynolds discuss the games and what might happen.
Ryan O'Hearn fends Nicky G.
Flores and Ben away from his fire.
Mitch bashes Hank Dave's head against a rock several times.
But it's unclear if that kills him.
Wow.
He already had wounds that he was bleeding out from, too.
Yeah, that is true.
Skenes and Triolo, of course.
There's a lot of talking.
My goodness.
Bob Nutting's getting medical supplies, though.
This is the owners.
The owners.
The owners are sending him stuff before the lockout, everybody.
Okay.
Ashcraft goes hunting.
We're already at day five.
I'm not even kidding, Cody.
One of these I was messing around with when we were meeting for the podcast meeting or whatever.
It only lasted three days.
We're at day five.
Ashcraft goes hunting.
Bob goes hunting.
Triolo collects fruit from a tree.
B-Ray and Ryan O'Hearn finally working together.
Working together.
Took him long enough.
Mitch Keller attacks Nikki G, but he manages to escape.
Ben Cherington sleeps the entire day.
Sounds like the offseason for Ben Cherington.
Flores overhears Skenes and Joe Block talking the distance.
Boring day.
Hank Davis did pass.
Oh.
The Rock got him.
Poor Hank Dave.
Okay.
D-Ray has lost sight of where he is.
Interesting.
Bob Nutting gets more medical supply.
That's that war chest that the owners have.
Ryan O'Hearn has set off an explosive, killing Rafael Flores Jr. and Nikki G.
That is five for Ryan O'Hearn.
Wow.
That's insane.
Mitch Keller screams for help.
Things are happening.
Day five is picking this up.
Paul Skenes climbs a tree to rest.
Ben Cherington and Jared Triolo hold hands.
Fair.
So Jared Triolo has cuddled Joe Block.
Or was it Bob?
It was either.
I think it was Joe Block.
Yes.
And then Ben Cherington is now holding hands with Jared Triolo.
Hey, you got to comfort each other in the games.
Braxton sees a fire, stays hidden.
Joe Block tries to sing himself to sleep.
Oh.
Ben and Joe Block get into a fight over raw meat, but Joe gives up.
Wait.
You're missing the.
It says the feast.
The cornucopia is replenished with food, supplies, weapons, and memoirs from the Tribute's families.
Yeah.
That's interesting.
Joe Block runs away from the feast.
I think something's going to happen here.
Oh, boy.
Mitch, B-Ray, and Tree unsuccessfully ambush Ryan O'Hearn, Bob Nutting, and Skenes, who kill them instead.
That is six for Ryan O'Hearn.
That group is bloodthirsty.
Well, Paul Skenes isn't part of the group.
And Tree, wasn't Tree a part of Bob's group?
At the beginning.
So Tree was a traitor.
You know what I think happened?
I bet Paul Skenes is the one that took out Tree.
It was just a casualty in the fight.
So Ryan O'Hearn, Bob Nutting, they're killing it right now.
Paul Skenes seems to be in for now.
And Braxton Ashcraft steps on a landmine.
Oh, come on.
Not great.
Ryan O'Hearn defeats Bob Nutting in a fight, but spares his life.
You know?
They're fighting over who's the leader here.
Because Ryan O'Hearn has all these kills, but Bob's trying to call the shots.
Now, I think Ryan O'Hearn spared him because of what the money Bob gave him last offseason.
Fair.
And Bob has a lot of supplies.
He's just holding.
He's hoarding it.
Yes.
Two medical, two med kits, by the way.
Ben Cherington tries a spearfish.
Skenes tends to Joe Block's wounds.
We're getting to the nitty gritty here.
Yeah, we lost a lot of people.
We lost six people.
Yeah.
Flores, Nicky G, Mitch Keller, Bryan Reynolds, Jared Triolo, Braxton Ashcraft.
Let's check the status because we are missing a lot of people.
So, Paul Skenes, three kills.
All from what just happened, by the way.
Ryan O'Hearn, eight kills.
I'm shocked that he spared Bob's life.
And then, of course, look at the three down here.
Joe Block, Ben Cherington, and Bob Nutting.
I'm not even kidding, Cody.
If Bob Nutting wins this, goes two for two in my Pirates Hunger Games, I will laugh so hard.
Oh, my gosh.
I hope he does win.
Oh, no.
Never mind.
Bob Nutting has passed out from exhaustion.
Oh, my gosh.
Six lives was just too many.
Yeah.
Ben Cherington tries to treat infection.
Skenes and Joe.
Okay.
Nothing much.
Seems like they're all teaming up a little bit.
ROH questions his sanity from killing so many people.
Joe Block has did what Montgomery did.
Joe Block poisons Ben Cherington's drink but mistakes it for his own and dies.
If I'm not mistaken, we are at a final four.
Four?
Okay.
It should be Ben Cherington, Bob Nutting, Ryan O'Hearn, and Paul Skenes.
No, Bob Nutting just died of exhaustion.
Well, he didn't say he died.
He just said he passed out.
Oh, he passed out.
Ryan O'Hearn practices.
Yeah, here he is, Bob.
Constructs a shack.
Okay.
Okay.
And then Paul Skenes.
Livvy Dunn sends him medical supplies, everybody.
And we've lost Joe Block.
RIP Joe Block.
We have made it to the final four.
Paul Skenes, Ryan O'Hearn, and District 12, Ben Cherington.
The fact that Ben Cherington has made it this far without a kill.
He's done nothing.
Sounds like the option.
He can wipe his hands and be like, I have done nothing wrong here.
And Bob Nutting, still trucking along.
Wow.
Ben Cherington lets O'Hearn into the shelter.
Bob Nutting thinks about home.
Paul Skenes stays awake.
Ryan O'Hearn diverts Bob's attention, runs away.
Ben Cherington thinks about home.
Paul Skenes dies.
Oh!
Didn't he just treat his wounds?
Or was that somebody else?
Livvy Dunn legit just sent Paul Skenes to the med kit.
It was too late.
She sent it too late.
She's too busy.
Ladies and gentlemen, we have a final three by the way.
We got a final three.
Ryan O'Hearn, Ben Cherington, and Bob Nutting.
You cannot make this stuff up.
Now, Cody, do we have any predictions?
I, somehow, I think Ben Cherington wins without a kill.
Honestly, I think he might win because of the fact Ryan O'Hearn might kill each other.
Him and Bob.
Right.
Okay.
I think we're both going Ben Cherington here.
Ryan O'Hearn cooks his own food.
Bob Nutting receives water.
Ben Cherington looks at the sky.
Bob Nutting hunts.
He's on the prowl.
Ben Cherington goes hunting.
Ryan O'Hearn thinks about home.
Really boring day.
My gosh.
No cannon shots.
There's only three left.
There's only three left.
Bob and Ben are teaming up.
They're huddling.
Of course.
Finally.
They're like, we're in this together.
We're from the same district.
And Ryan O'Hearn is awoken by nightmares.
Yeah.
He's already got PTSD from killing eight people.
Ben Cherington sees smoke rising the distance but decides not to investigate.
Ryan O'Hearn strangles Bob with a rope.
Oh!
Oh my God!
Now, I'm assuming that means Bob is done.
Yeah.
I'd assume.
Wow.
Wow.
Wow.
It comes down to Ben Cherington and Ryan O'Hearn for the Pirates Hunger Games.
Wow.
Wow.
I think that's nine.
You've got to be kidding me.
Fall into a pit and die.
No, I told you.
What did I say?
I caught it.
I caught it.
We got it right.
I caught it.


Comments· 0
Is Braxton Ashcraft a lock as the Pirates' No. 2 starter behind Paul Skenes, not a guy fighting for the fifth spot?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.