In Friday’s OffBeat mailbag, Alex Stumpf tackles a tough Pirates offseason question: Is Brandon Lowe worth a significant investment when Pittsburgh has several other needs? Alex explains why he’d prioritize keeping Lowe, examines potential third-base trade targets, and discusses why Alec Bohm doesn’t appeal to him. He also revisits Hunter Barco‘s disappointing 2026 season, the differences between his development and Bubba Chandler‘s, and what Barco must do to earn another opportunity in Pittsburgh’s rotation.
The Pirates Should Overpay for Brandon Lowe

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Brandon Lowe is too important to let walk: the Pirates should overpay for him and fill their other holes with cheaper alternatives.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Stumpf is not optimistic Lowe comes back, and expects the Pirates to pivot to the trade market for a third baseman if he signs elsewhere.
Alex Stumpf - 3
Isaac Paredes is the wrong fit despite past links to the Pirates: his batted ball profile would turn out horribly at PNC Park.
Alex Stumpf - 4
Alec Bohm is worth only a one-year deal at $4-5 million to rebuild his value, not a multi-year deal or eight figures, after a sub-.700 OPS season.
Alex Stumpf - 5
Hunter Barco shouldn't be penciled into the lefty reliever spot: he can still start and provide more value there, but his fastball needs to climb back from 93-94.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript190 paragraphs · show
Happy Friday, everyone. We made it through the week. And Fridays here on Offbeat are mailbags. I asked you questions here in the YouTube comments section or on Twitter. Got a handful here. We're going to go through it. Thank you for those who submitted a question.
If you would like to be a part of our next mailbag, leave a comment down below this video or any other video over the course of the week. You might appear.
We've got four questions to go through today. The first and maybe most controversial, would the Pirates be better off spending the money they would on Brandon Lowe elsewhere?
Good morning, and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine. My name is Alex Stumpf, and this is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
That question came from Italian Bucks on Twitter, who asked, Wouldn't that money trying to re-sign Brandon Lowe be better spent on bringing in a third baseman?
And then he alluded how Gonzalez could go to second base.
Gonzalez could go to second base.
They could also add a second baseman and keep Gonzalez at third.
I know the defense was rough last year, but I believe an actual proper offseason of working on the position could do him some good.
It just opens up the possibilities.
And it's not the...
Brandon Lowe, slash third base or second base, however you want to look at this infield position, isn't the only need this team has.
They need another solid lefty reliever.
I think they could use some outfield depth.
You have to look at catcher as an area where you could potentially upgrade.
You need to add a right-handed bat to this mix.
So, Brandon Lowe is, and should be, the top priority in my opinion.
He's a really good player.
He's a Silver Slugger winner and a Gold Glove nominee.
He's a great guy in the clubhouse.
But there is this unspoken knowledge that whenever you do sign him, you're not going to be getting three or four years of that 2026 Brandon Lowe.
You might not even get 2026 Brandon Lowe in 2027.
That might have been his career year.
Now, I think even 90% or whatever, the output is of that 2026, having that in 2027 would be huge for this team, would make this team a lot better.
But it is a genuine question.
If you're not going to get that same level of production and you're going to be paying him more, well, if you have 15 to 20 million to potentially play with, wouldn't you be better off shoring up a couple holes and finding a third baseman elsewhere?
I can't stress the importance that Brandon Lowe brought to the clubhouse in terms of his leadership.
He was one of those guys who was setting examples, was setting the pace.
People had someone to look up to.
Someone that this team didn't have on the hitting side in 2025.
They could have it in Paul Skenes's in 2025.
Even if he wasn't, the huge rah-rah guy.
But it was like, look, he's got his stuff together.
If I try to do what he does every day, I'll probably get better.
You need those type of guys.
And yeah, Bryan Reynolds can be that type of guy.
Ryan O'Hearn can be that type of guy.
But Brandon Lowe just brought so much.
Brandon Lowe brought so much that wasn't registered on the back of the baseball card.
And that's part of the reason that if I have 15 to $20 million to spend, I'm spending it on him first.
I'd rather try to find a lefty through minor league free agency or the waiver wire.
I would try to look at a right-handed hitter through trade or some other market.
I'm not exactly the most optimistic Brandon Lowe will come back.
There's still time to be had.
There's still a little less than two weeks before the lockout.
Maybe something happens after the lockout.
I think a lot of the top guys are probably going to have deals in hand going into that lockout.
But it's an interesting question.
It's not a bad thought if you have limited resources.
And with the amount of money that they already have committed, the amount of money of players who are now going to arbitration, they don't have as much presumably to spend as they did last year.
I think he's just too important to let walk, though.
I would rather pay too much for him and try to fill up some holes with cheaper alternatives elsewhere.
JohnJ6187, while we're on the subject.
There have been several names floated whose teams are looking for pitching and could trade their third baseman or drop cash.
He lists Casey Schmidt, Jordan Westberg, Zach Galoff, Isaac Paredes, Josh Young.
Who would be your top target and how likely do you think they are, or how likely do you think acquiring one is?
If the Pirates don't re-sign Brandon Lowe, I do think they are going to pivot to the trade market.
And third base is, like you mentioned, there could be a market there.
The guy I wanted was traded earlier this week.
I like Marqueo Garcia.
I like his contract.
I thought he, good defender at third base, offensive upside, was an all-star in 2025.
Really reminds me of like, hey, what if the Hayes contract, you got a mulligan there, but he had a better back end, better offensive profile.
Maybe not the same defender, but in a lot of ways, you could redo that contract.
Reroll those dice.
Of these guys here, Westberg comes to mind.
The Orioles are going to be looking for pitching.
They have an infield surplus.
I don't think it's just him.
Casey Schmidt, I would like to see him play more than like the hundred-ish games that he seems to play every year.
See what he could do over 162, but if that's a buy low risk, I don't hate it.
The Pirates have been connected to Isaac Haredes in the past.
I don't see the appeal.
I think his batted ball profile would turn out horribly at PNC Park.
It's not the right type of fit.
So I don't think he would be a good fit, even though they have been connected to him to the past.
But to answer your question, yeah, I do think they are going to pivot to the trade market if Brandon Lowe goes elsewhere.
And especially at the hot corner, there are some options that I don't think these guys are going to cost an arm and a leg prospect-wise.
Or major league pitcher-wise.
We've got two more questions here, but first, I'd like to thank today's sponsor, Larenco.
We all know nicotine pouches are popular, and part of it isn't so much nicotine as it is the routine.
Larenco pouches swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
It works like the pouches you've seen before.
Just tuck one in and go about your day.
Each pouch has a half cup of coffee's worth of caffeine, plus L-theanine and alpha-GPC for a smooth, steady focus with no energy crash.
And it gives your teeth daily enamel support in between brushings.
It comes in mint, cinnamon, and mango, and it's nicotine-free always.
It's doing something good for your teeth, and it gives you smooth energy and focus without those jitters.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designed to do both, and it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Larenco a try.
Right now, Larenco is offering our listeners up to 50% off at bylarene.com slash northshore.
That's bylarene, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash northshore for up to 50% off.
Norman Pirates fan asked on YouTube, how about Alec Bohm?
Rounding up our tree of questions on the hot corner.
And Boehm is someone who, yeah, they were interested in the past, at least preliminary.
Kick the tires.
Yeah, he's a right-handed third baseman with perceived offensive upside.
But I've never seen it really all come together.
Outside of his cameo in 2020, in the COVID-shortened year.
He has never posted, outside of that shortened year, where even then, he only played 44 games.
His career best OPS is 779.
He has hit 20 homers once.
He's coming off a year where he had a sub-700 OPS.
87 OPS plus.
Only 15 home runs over 155 games.
He was below replacement level, according to baseball reference.
And I get maybe a change of scenery would do him good.
I get there are underlying traits that are desirable.
But then I see these reports or speculation going into the winter that he's going to be sought after.
And if I was a general manager, I don't think I'd be among them.
I'd be willing to do a one-year deal worth $4 million or $5 million.
Here's a chance to platform a 30-year-old guy.
Rebuild your value.
Show that these skills could actually translate well.
I knew he had some off-the-field issues that he was dealing with this past year.
You're a year removed from that.
Just show what you could actually do.
But no, I'm not giving him a multi-year deal.
I'm not giving him eight figures.
I just don't like the fit.
Even though he is probably one of the more desirable right-handed infielders on the market.
And that's something the Pirates could use.
And I got one more here from Kenneth Kalenik9280.
Have the Pirates completely given up on Hunter Barco as a fifth starter?
They talk about the lack of lefties.
And then mention, I also find the difference in the ways they handled Barco and Chandler to be interesting.
First part of the question, no, they have not given up on Barco.
2026 was a bit of a disappointment.
He made the opening team, but in the bullpen, it was a different role.
Didn't really take there.
Went down the AAA.
Only posted okay numbers.
For someone who was a top 100 prospect briefly in 2025, it's admittedly disappointing.
For someone who was considered to be one of your better pitching prospects going into the year.
But no, they haven't given up on him.
I just don't see how he forces his way into the rotation right now.
Unless, like, who does he usurp?
Keller has the contract.
He's not going anywhere.
Jared Jones, Bubba Chandler, Braxton Ashcraft.
Those guys are all more established and have accomplished more so far.
Or, at least in Chandler's case, has a higher pedigree.
He was once the top-rated prospect or pitching prospect in the game.
And then you even got Carmen Mlodzinski, who has started more major league games.
He has some seniority.
He has some experience.
They haven't given up on him.
He has to show more.
But I want to touch on the last part, how they handled him compared to Chandler.
And I think they did the same, though.
A lot of these young pitchers come up, and now they go into the bullpen, and then they are in their starting rotation spot.
That's what Chandler did in 2025.
That's what Luis Ortiz did in 2024.
Barco never really pitched his way to do that in 2026.
Wilber Dotel did more for that, even if it was just openers.
I'm not giving up on him.
I would like to see the fastball velo stay up, stay firm.
But there's still upside there.
I also don't hate him as a trade ship.
I think he could get something back in return.
But like you said, this is a Pirates rotation in Stafford General that doesn't have lefties.
I don't want to pencil him into the lefty reliever spot that the Pirates could use some help in.
Because I think he could still start, and he could provide more value, provide more wins, innings, as a starter.
You have to see more.
I saw that fastball one sit at 96-97, albeit briefly in 25 spring training.
And it was averaging like 93-94 in AAA.
He needs that extra zip.
It needs to be his out pitch.
If he does that, then yeah.
See what he can do.
There's no reason to think they're giving up on him yet, though.
He still has options.
I think he's going to be going into 2027 with a chance to earn opportunity.
But like any pitcher, he is going to have to earn it.
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat this week here on North Shore Nine.
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe to Revue Pine Podcasts, or check us out on YouTube if you want to see my smiling face, or be part of the next Mailbag episode.
Thank you so much for listening.
We will talk again tomorrow.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.


Comments· 0
Should the Pirates overpay to keep Brandon Lowe instead of spreading that $15-20 million across several roster holes?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.