◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
Bucco Brew rolled on from Bradenton with Jim and Doug digging into the Pirates’ fringe roster picture — led by newly acquired outfielder Jhostynxon Garcia (aka “The Password”). After an encouraging spring look (hard contact, good approach, solid defense), they debated the most realistic path: regular AAA at-bats now, with a quick call-up if an outfield/1B injury opens a lane. The guys also checked in on Nick Yorke, Enmanuel Valdez, and Endy Rodriguez — and why each has a big spring ahead.
Watch/listen now on YouTube or wherever you get podcasts — and fuel up with De Fer Coffee & Tea: use promo code NS930 at defer.coffee.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Jhostynxon Garcia open the season in Triple-A instead of as the Pirates' fifth outfielder?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Jhostynxon Garcia shouldn't be the Alexander Canario-style fifth outfielder sitting five days a week. His swing-and-miss needs everyday Triple-A at-bats, and he's first in line if an outfielder gets hurt.
2
Jake Mangum is 'squarely on this roster' as the fourth outfielder. His tough at-bats, speed and defense across all three spots are something this lineup lacks.
3
Pushback on the idea that Enmanuel Valdez is a long shot: as things stand he's the 26th man and gets the last bench spot over Garcia as a lefty bat. If he flops this spring, the Pirates should grab an out-of-options cut from another team.
4
The Pirates mishandled Endy Rodríguez. He raked while moving between catcher, second, first and the outfield, then stopped hitting once they made him catcher-only, which may be too much for his smaller frame.
5
Esmerlyn Valdez (26 HR, .520 slugging, a spring grand slam) is the first Cherington-era international signing to break out. If he keeps hitting 'nukes' in Triple-A, he could debut in 2026.
What's going on, everybody? This is North Shore Nine presented by FanDuel, and I'm Jim, and with me this morning in Bradenton is Dougie Fresh.
Dougie Fresh, this is your first ever Bucco Brew powered by Defer Coffee and Tea. I think I feel like I just hit the upgrade button on my laptop.
Well, I don't know if I'm an upgrade, but we're on time because it's me, right? It's not ish. We started at 7 a.m.
That's true. We were here ready to roll at like 6.55, and I'm just thinking, like, I don't think, if DiNardo were here, he would be getting up at that time, and he would be like, hold on, I gotta hop in the shower.
And then we'd be scrambling, and we'd be probably starting this at like 7.10.
So, yeah, I appreciate the punctuality.
Yeah. But no, we're here in Bradenton. We're at the Airbnb, and yeah, we put out a lot of stuff yesterday, put out some fun things yesterday.
We did a live show from Lee Com Park. Jim Trudinich was on the show to talk about Bill Nazarowski a little bit. We did a recap of the day back here. You and Tyler handled that, but we had interviews with Deuce Gorson in there, who had a base hit yesterday in two walks, and a Don Kelly press conference in there as well.
So, make sure you check those two things out at some point today. But yeah, we've got a whole lot of stuff for you.
This is our second full day here in Bradenton, and as a crew, North Shore Nine, we've got me, Doug, Cody, and Tyler here this week, and then we're doing a line change.
And then we've got DiNardo, Neil, Ryan, and Nathan coming in for week two. So, we're going to be giving you a ton of stuff over these next two weeks. I'm pretty excited about it.
I am, too. I'm going to be here for week two as well.
That's true. You're sticking around the whole time.
I'm a glue guy.
Yeah.
I'm at ease with the transition.
Yeah.
You know? So, yeah, I'm looking forward to it. the minute you get down here, you feel the spring training vibes, and it's hopeful and optimistic. It's just a great setting.
I'm, two days in. I'm enjoying myself immensely. It's a lot of fun. I'm looking forward to what we're going to see today, and, for the rest of the time we're here.
So, our theme of today's show, because we're doing so much stuff around here, we didn't really want to talk too much about, what we already talked about yesterday, what we're going to be talking about later today.
We're going to make sure we're giving you just, like, new stuff every show here.
So, theme of today's show is those guys on the fringe of the roster, and we're going to talk mostly about newly acquired outfielder Jhostynxon Garcia, a.k.a. The Password.
We got our first look at him yesterday, and, it was pretty positive.
So, that'll be the main part of this show is, like, what's he look like, and is there a path to Jhostynxon Garcia to make this major league team?
The roster resource on FanGraphs currently has him on the team, on the bench.
I'm not quite sure about that.
We'll talk about that more in detail, but what we're also going to talk about is some of those other fringe roster guys where they may or may not be on there now, but, like, if, but they're very close, like, if something falls their way or something falls a certain way, like, they could make it.
But, yeah, we're going to talk about some fringe roster candidates right now.
Yeah, there's a lot to cover, but we don't want to spend the whole two weeks talking about Konnor Griffin, right?
he's exciting, and we're all really enthused, but there's these other guys, and every year somebody comes out of nowhere.
last year was Isaac Mattson, right?
We didn't expect much.
When he came up, we didn't expect much.
Two weeks after he was here, we didn't expect much, and, now we're like, this guy's pitching the seventh and the eighth inning.
And these guys, they're that close.
They're just, an inch away from being in the major leagues.
If things break right or break poorly or just anything could happen, these are the guys that would be immediately either called up or, get more time from, slide into a starting role from being a bench role.
Yeah, so we're going to talk about that today.
We probably won't have a full hour-long show just because we've got another live show coming to you in, let's see, five hours.
So we're going to be short and sweet this morning.
But before we get to all of that, let's talk about our sponsor of today's show, Defer Coffee & Tea.
So Defer is a family and employee-owned and operated business.
They believe that coffee and tea are one of life's simplest and most accessible pleasures, and when enjoyed thoughtfully can open your eyes to the here and now.
They've got five locations across the city of Pittsburgh, including their flagship in the heart of Pittsburgh Strip District.
Don't forget to stop by their new location downtown on Penn Avenue.
It's right across from the Benetton.
Grab a cup of coffee and fuel up on your walk to PNC Park from downtown.
Mobile ordering is available.
Check out their Instagram for more details.
And, of course, the website is Defer.coffee.
That's D-E-F-A-R.coffee.
And, yeah, if you go to that website, load up your car, enter promo code NS930 on Defer.coffee.
You'll get 30% off your entire order, Doug.
We love them.
You will, too.
Yeah.
Unfortunately, there's no Defer coffee in Bradenton, so we're just drinking straight out of, whatever this is.
You're going to have Ryan O'Horn in right field most days.
Jake Mangum has some value to this team because of his versatility as well, can play all three outfield roles.
He's also just a different type of player that this team is lacking, one of those guys who's a super tough at bat.
He's not going to strike out.
He's going to put the ball in play.
He's going to steal some bases and he can play really good defense.
So I think Jake Mangum is squarely on this roster, barring he looks like the fourth outfield barring him looking like just awful this spring.
I just don't see a way where Mangum doesn't make this team.
So you look at Garcia and he's that fifth guy.
So you ask yourself, do you want him to be the fifth guy where he's getting a start here and there is pinch hitting against left handed pitchers?
Or do you want him to get every day at bats and triple A so that he can continue to refine his swing?
Because that's that is the one thing like it.
He's got a ton of power.
That's that is 100 percent.
The contact rate's a little iffy, right?
He swings and misses quite a bit.
But when he hits the ball, he can hit the ball hard.
I don't think it's good for him and his development to just be sitting on the bench five days a week.
So I don't think that's a good role for him.
What I do think, though, is that if one of those outfields, if something were to happen to one of those outfielders, like he's the next guy.
Like I like the upside that he offers you and then you can give him some more regular playing time.
I think that's where he sits right now.
So I want to see if you if you know what you think about that.
But also, like, is there a way for him to change your mind on that this spring?
Like, is there actually a way that Garcia can make this team?
I believe the only way really is through injury.
And that would include Horwitz, right?
If Horwitz gets hurt and O'Hearn, is playing full time first base, that thing.
Joe Stinson could have a great spring.
But let's face it's it's Hearn.
Oh, I'm sorry.
It's O'Hearn.
It's Reynolds.
It's Cruz to start.
I don't care if those guys have a bad spring there.
You're starting out.
Right.
And you got to play them every day.
Right.
And then, right.
These are, three of the bigger, hitters that we're expecting the most production from in the lineup.
So I.
anything short of an injury to one of those guys or Spencer Horwitz, and it just doesn't make sense for Garcia to be on the roster, because again, Mac Mangum looks to be the fourth outfielder.
He'll get some defensive replacement stuff in.
Pinch hitting again, offers a different look than these other guys do.
So, yeah, I hope he has I hope he hits 400, but I don't even think that's enough to get him in a lineup barring some injury to, you
know, or Marcell Ozuna or somebody like that.
If one of these big new acquisitions or Cruz Reynolds Horwitz can't play due to injury, then I think this guy gets the first shot at it.
Yeah, again, he's just 23 years old.
He just turned 23 two months ago.
He has 81 games above double A in triple A.
And then I said the five games in the major.
So 86 games total above double A.
I think he could use some more time at the upper levels, but he absolutely could be ready to.
And it could be one of those.
It could be one of those things where it's like, hey, we've got this guy.
He's ready.
But there's no room for him.
And that's and that's a good thing.
I said, that's what's that's what I like about this team this year, because I feel like forever.
Garcia would be one of those guys who like on a past Pirates team.
It's like just play him.
Oh, yeah.
this was last season.
Right.
And they were playing Swinsky and Bay and said, oh, Garcia, I'd be screaming, losing our mind.
Right.
It's like, let's see what this kid has.
it's he might very well be ready.
But being ready isn't, the only factor, but we're definitely going to ride out with those guys we've already mentioned.
And, we'll see what happens.
It's a long season.
Lots of things can go wrong or right, depending on your perspective.
I think it's safe to say that at some point we're going to see him this year.
And at some point we're going to hope he can be a rather big contributor.
Yeah.
let's hope that, come May, we're he's knocking down the door.
Right.
He's just crushing it at Triple A, waiting for his opportunity, doing everything he needs to do.
He'll if that's the case, he's going to get his chances.
So we'll see what happens.
But I'm really looking forward to watching him this spring and paying attention to what he does at Triple A.
He looks he's an interesting player.
All right.
So let's shift gears to another guy also from Boston, also acquired via a trade, also 23 years old.
Still, I feel like we think he's maybe not as young as he is, but he still is.
Last season in Triple A for Indianapolis, he played 103 games.
He hit 287, slugged 406.
He had a 104 weighted runs created plus.
So just like a slightly above average hitter in Triple A last year, he started off really cold and then heated up as the season went on at the end of the year, got the call up, played 22 games in the majors.
So Nick Yorke is someone who I don't want to say he's forgotten because I actually think if we're building a team right now with who's in camp, like Nick Yorke is probably on your bench right now.
But I feel like his luster is certainly lost.
I don't think people are as excited about Nick Yorke as they were maybe a year ago.
I know this time last year, I remember being in a car with Anthony Murphy, our friend from Bucs On Deck, and we were in the car driving from Bradenton up to Clearwater for the spring breakout game.
And we were listening to some, I think it was a, I think it was Fangraph's podcast, but we were listening to a podcast and the guest who was on that show was talking about, Nick Yorke being there, a sleeper top 100 guy.
You had Keith Law ranking Nick Yorke in his top 100.
So like you had, you had a lot of hype for Nick Yorke going into last year's camp and you don't have that this year.
Yeah.
Yeah.
The shine is definitely off what we picked him up at the trade deadline in the 24 season.
We they didn't bring him up.
We were, clamoring for him.
We wanted to see him last year.
his start at AAA last year was just dreadful.
it was like, oh my gosh, he's a bus type thing.
You know how quick we are to judgment.
He's, again, he's another versatile player.
He started at first base yesterday.
he can play, I think, third, second, third, and first.
He can play the corner outfield positions.
He makes sense.
you could see him in that canario role where maybe he starts once a week or, gets some pinch hit at bats, that thing.
he obviously has to hit better at the major league level.
He needs a better start than how he started last year.
But you're right.
We've moved on from him with the new acquisitions and getting guys like Mangum and Garcia in.
Nick Yorke is going to have to fight and carve out a role.
He's going to have to seize his opportunity.
he just, he cannot, he cannot come at you with another 59 WRC+.
He's going to have to be productive.
And, again, he's still young, right?
Like, if you would have asked me, I would have guessed he was at 26 and he was at that cut age.
Yeah.
and the kid's still just 23.
And, again, was once highly thought of.
So, but, we're quick to move on.
It's what have you done for me lately.
Yeah, this was a 17th overall pick in 2020 right out of high school.
So, to speak on the versatility a little bit, just to talk about, talk through this, but just last year between AAA and Pittsburgh, he played first base, he played second base, he played third base, he played left field, and he played right field.
So, like, there's, that's valuable to be able to play five different positions.
And those are, those sorts of players tend to be what you'd like on your bench, right?
So, yeah, I think Nick Yorke's got the inside track to making the bench as we sit right now, especially if, a lot of it depends on Konnor Griffin, right?
And we're not going to make this a Konnor Griffin episode, but, like, if Konnor Griffin somehow makes this team and it bumps Nick Gonzales to the bench, then maybe that changes some things for Nick Yorke.
But, as of right now, if the plan is to have Konnor Griffin start in the minors, and Nick Gonzales play shortstop, and Jared Triolo play third, then I think Nick Yorke has to be that utility guy off your bench who can play in the infield if you need him to.
He can play a corner outfield spot if necessary.
He doesn't necessarily need as many upper level at bats, I think, as Garcia, because, as you said, it's not that he's much older.
He is eight months older.
But, Nick Yorke has played 143, 181 games in AAA now in his career.
So, like, he's seen plenty of upper level pitching.
Right now, it's just a matter of, like, can you be a major leaguer?
Yeah, absolutely.
I guess he offers a little more versatility than Nick Gonzales does, I suppose.
So, if Konnor Griffin were to make it, and, he's, I would think he's battling with Nick Gonzales.
And it seems to me that Pirates management has soured a little on Nick based on the moves they made.
Again, he's going to have every opportunity this spring, too, to establish himself.
But, they want more.
That's for sure.
And, if Nick Gonzales or Nick Yorke looks better than Nick Gonzales, and then some of these other roster things happen, again, Nick Yorke has a good opportunity of breaking camp with this team.
I think he does, too.
And I think there's four bench spots, too.
So, like, there's still that third non-catcher bench spot where, like, if we're assuming Mangum takes one, and let's say Griffin does make the team and Gonzalez takes the other one, like, there's still another spot.
So, it's like York's got some opportunity to make this team.
So, it's going to be a big spring for him to show that, one, he can handle all these positions, and, two, he can swing the bat a little bit.
And he can hit.
Yeah.
Right.
Specifically, like, if he can hit against lefties, like, be able to hit against lefties, because that's where you're going to probably get the bulk of your playing time, is against lefties.
Or just, yeah, he's got to be able to, he's got to look good this spring.
Let's move on.
Let's talk about another infielder, Enmanuel Valdez.
Another guy who's just, we haven't talked about Enmanuel Valdez at all offseason.
I forgot he was still on the roster.
He was, they had that dreadful start last year where just no one did anything.
Valdez wasn't good.
Like, let's make sure that we put that out there.
Like, he wasn't good.
He had 209, he had an 82 weighted runs created plus.
He was not a good hitter.
But I guess he was one of the few guys who didn't look completely lost at the plate.
Yeah.
He had a few moments, right?
He had a few games where, he was playing first, I think.
Like, because, yeah, Horwitz was still hurt with the wrist injury.
And, I think he had a big home run at one point.
Yeah.
He had two homers.
Yeah.
Two homers.
He didn't do much.
Nobody did much.
But, yeah, he looked like one of the few guys, like I said, everybody seemed to have a 50 WRC plus and he had 89.
So, when you were looking at him through that prism, he looked good and interesting and then he got hurt.
And nothing can make us forget a player more than, inactivity.
And, yeah, I forgot that he was still with the organization and, him staying on the roster or him being released would not make a bunch of headlines.
But he's still here.
He has some ability.
Again, can move around the field a little bit, a little bit of pop.
in opportunities here, a lot of things would have to happen and he would have to really shine, I think, to get any chance at making the 26-man roster.
But, again, baseball is a funny game and a lot of things can happen and who knows.
Yeah, I'm actually going to disagree with you a little bit.
I think as things stand right now, like if they don't bring in anyone else, I think Valdez is like my 26th guy.
And the reason for that is you've got Mangum, you've got your backup catcher, you've got York, and then there's still that one more bench spot.
And I'm not giving it to Garcia.
Like I don't want Garcia to have that role.
So, like, I think Valdez gets that job.
Now, versatility, he can technically stand in multiple spots on the field.
Defensively, he just, the month or so that he played last year, he didn't impress me at all.
He looked quite bad everywhere that I saw him.
But he can technically play.
But that's our move.
We have quite a few guys that look bad.
He can technically play first.
He can play second.
He can play third.
He can play left.
He can play right.
Those are all places he's played, in his pro career.
So, similar to York in that aspect, he hits left-handed as opposed to York hitting right-handed.
So, it offers you that left-handed bat off the bench, which you have a left-handed heavy lineup right now.
But you do probably want, like, one lefty bat off the bench, I think.
And that's where he can provide that for you.
I don't know.
I think it's a big spring for him because I think if he goes out there and he just looks terrible this spring, then maybe you do have to go and look outside the organization to fill that last spot.
Because let's not forget, a lot of teams are going to be cutting people in about a month.
So, you're going to have this plethora of fringe roster guys.
And those are just the type of guys.
Yeah.
Right.
You're going to have a plethora of fringe roster guys who are out of options, but they didn't make their team.
And so, they're semi-interesting, but they just weren't good enough to win a job.
But maybe those are the guys that you want to give that 26th spot to.
So, the guys in camp, and like I said, Canario.
Canario was that.
at this point last year, we had no idea that Alexander Canario was going to be on the Pirates for 180 days last year.
And he somehow made it because you're going to have guys like that who are available in about a month or so.
So, I think it's a big camp for Valdez because if he shows you something, then you maybe feel comfortable giving him that 26th spot.
If he doesn't, then I think you've got to look outside the organization to fill that last bench spot.
It's actually nice to be talking about a 26th man who's actually a 26th man.
Right.
Right.
Right.
last year, I whined non-stop about how we had a roster full of 26 men.
And that's not the case right now.
So, we actually have some major league hitters on the team.
And, yeah, there were times last year that I forgot Canario was on the 26th.
And all of a sudden, he'd come and make a start or a pitch at performance.
And certainly, Valdez could take that role.
But, yeah, he needs to show it.
He needs to have a good spring because, like you said, there'll be options.
And the next guy we talk about could possibly be one of those options.
I don't think so because we'd want him getting more at-bats.
But, Andy could be vying for that role.
And he offers the ability to catch as well as play some of those other positions.
He was a minor league player of the year for the Pirates a few years back.
Tore, just tore up the lower levels of the minors.
And when MVP in two consecutive seasons, Joe Block mentions that every single at-bat.
Yeah.
I just tore through the lower levels.
He hits AAA and just doesn't hit as well up there.
We've seen him in the majors now.
He has 261 major league plate appearances.
He's hitting .246, slugging .391.
It's a 59 weighted runs credit plus.
He's hit .210.
He's slugging .311.
Sorry, 59 weighted runs credit plus.
That is not good.
No, not for the hype that he had.
he was just a hitter.
Yeah.
Right?
It was, if he doesn't catch, he can play first base.
He can play second base.
He can play corner outfield positions.
I've thought here recently he should be taking grounders at third base.
It seems like they want to use him at catcher and still see what they have there.
But, yeah, this guy has to hit only because we etched in stone that he was going to hit.
He's just, again, the catcher position, he certainly has got opportunity there.
Henry has certainly established himself defensively, but not at all with the bat.
Joey Bart, outside of one good, half a season, maybe a little more than half a season at the plate.
And, he's awful defensively and, is ideally more suited as a DH.
And we have a pretty good DH in Marcell Ozuna who's going to get the bulk of the bats.
There's not going to be as much rotating guys through there as, you would had you not signed him.
So, and he just needs to show he can hit.
I think the best thing for him this year would be to start at AAA and just tear it out.
He needs at bats.
He's had two lost seasons.
he, I don't know if he's got it or not, but I imagine they're not, you're not going to want to put him in a position where he's, getting two starts a week.
If you want him playing every day and you want him to get back to looking like he did when he was winning, MVPs and player of the year and that thing.
And then, depending on what's going on at the major league level, make a decision about bringing him up.
But, again, he does offer, in a lot of ways, it'd be great to have a third guy that can strap on the catching gear and, really be effective.
That gives you some, especially some in-game options.
you can pinch hit somebody, you can, move somebody around that thing.
I've been a fan of Indy.
I want to see what he can do, but man, he has not hit since AA and he has not hit what now three years or something.
So he has got a lot to prove.
Yeah.
He really hasn't hit since 2022, which was four years ago, 2023.
He was an average hitter in AAA, but along your points, he's played 36 games in the last two years across all levels, 36 games.
he, if you rewind back last year at camp, pirates broke with Henry Davis, Joey Bart and Indy Rodriguez.
So all three of those made it, then as well.
so yeah, it's interesting to see how they're going to play this.
I don't think Indy Rodriguez makes this team at all, but stuff could always happen.
Right.
I don't think he does.
I agree with you.
I think he just needs to get some at bats.
He needs to get some regular playing time, have him catch in AAA when he's not catching, have him DH have him and Flores go back to back in those roles.
Like just flip flopping, catch your DH every day, every day.
I think that's probably what's going to be best for him.
I'm just disappointed with how they've handled Indy a little bit too, like going through the minors.
I loved the fact that he was versatile and he was catching, he was playing second and he was playing in the outfield and he was doing all this stuff because like, there's so much value in having a guy like that on your roster who can also hit a little bit.
And then once he got closer to the majors, they were like, no, you're a catcher.
Right.
And that's when he stopped hitting is when he just started catching all the time.
And I wonder how much of that has to do, cause he is a, he is a smaller guy.
He's a small guy.
He's a smaller guy.
Like, is he built to catch for a full season?
Like, was it almost helping his body to get out from behind the plate, half the games and then not having to squat back there, 200 times every single game.
So, and also like that affects your hitting, like you're hitting all comes from your lower body.
It comes from your legs.
So the more you're, the more you're using your legs, the worst hitter you're going to be.
That's why it's so tough to be a catcher in major league baseball.
So I was disappointed with how they handled it.
It seems like this year he's a catcher and that's what they're set on.
Last year, they were also set on that.
And then some things happen and they were like, oh, Andy grabbed your first base glove.
Yeah.
So it's, he's been that guy where they've just thrust him in the situations.
I don't know if it's been best for him.
I'm not a huge fan of the way that they've developed Endy Rodríguez once he hit the upper levels.
You know what?
Two, three years ago, I was really excited.
I thought, hey, we're going to play Andy and Henry.
they're going to switch back and forth between catcher and first base.
It's going to keep them fresh.
they're not going to be squatting in a hundred degree, temperatures in a game in Texas.
all three games, that thing.
And like you said, it was working for Henry.
I'm sorry for Andy.
He played, he played catcher.
He played first base.
He played second base and he played left field.
And, it was just hitting like crazy.
And then we, like you said, the pirates just, sometimes you just wonder what they're thinking.
The guy's been doing so well doing this.
So now we're going to force him into this exclusively.
And he is, he walked by us yesterday, gave us an ola.
And he's not a big dude.
He's not, the size of Henry.
So with that versatility, it just seems like, he'd be the perfect like backup catcher that, gets two other starts at, first base and second base, throughout, you rest up Henry or Joey Bart or whatever.
And yeah, and just let him focus on hitting.
It's in there somewhere and the pirates have suppressed it.
So hopefully, but yeah, like you said, now when we have four catchers.
It seems like we're going to force him to exclusively be a catcher, but we say that, and then, he could be strapping on the catcher gear and they're going to be like, oh, by the way, Henry or Andy today, your first base.
do you have a first base was bit thing.
And then, sometimes they just don't seem to make a lot of sense.
And, then you're throwing, you're not putting people in a position to succeed and, you're setting them up for failure a lot.
So hopefully they can get, Andy on the right track that he can start hitting and they open their mind to the possibilities of what he could add to the roster.
Yeah.
I think at the end of the day, he's got to hit though.
Like he's got to hit.
that's, we're going to get redundant, but that is for every one of these guys.
If they hit, what is the bat will play.
And if you hit, they'll find a spot for you type thing.
Some of these old baseball cliches, but it's true.
And we've done a nice job of adding to the roster, but we still need other guys to hit any homered on Saturday in his first spring game.
So, yeah, we'll keep an eye on Andy.
And then just to round out these guys, someone who I think a lot would have to happen for him to make the roster, but we got to mention him here.
He's on the 40 man.
He had a great game yesterday in Clearwater, had two hits.
He had, I'm sorry, he went, yeah, two for four with a walk.
And a grand slam.
This dude is just, he had 26 homers last year.
He slugged 520.
Then he went to the Arizona Fall League, tore it up.
Esmerlin Valdez, his first, I said, second spring game.
I guess he played in that first one, but just grand slam.
Like right off the rip here in spring training.
And I don't think he can make this team.
Like it's going to be very difficult.
he's really similar to Konnor Griffin's shoes right now.
Like he's 50 game, 51 games in double a, like it'd be quite a jump for him.
I think he needs more time at the upper levels, but man, this guy just keeps hitting.
Yeah.
To make this roster, he'd have to hit all spring.
Like he did in the Arizona Fall League where he had like eight home runs in the first seven games.
I don't know if he, like, even if he does that, I don't know.
And that's probably not enough.
You're right.
it makes sense, but I'll tell you what, it's exciting because in the Ben Cherington era, we've not had any of our Dominican signings make any impact, our international signings.
And this guy has come up and, we keep looking for reasons to dump on it.
Like, oh, well, he only, but man, he just keeps hitting.
And he's got, he's got a great vibe, great enthusiasm.
He's fun on social media, that thing.
And he's hitting.
And if you keep hitting, like he's hitting there, he's going to force his way onto this roster.
Right.
He's not, it's like, he's not the highly highest rated prospect or anything.
there's like Florentino's rated higher, rated higher than him.
But again, you keep producing, you hit 26 home runs and we're going to find from space for me that he's the if he keeps doing that's the guy that will force them to trade somebody that do something because his bat has been really exciting.
The enthusiasm and the flares is just a lot of fun.
We could use that personality on the team.
You always can.
And yeah, it's again, he's going to be fun to track in the spring and whatever he's doing in the minors, because he just a breakout season last year was outstanding.
And we've mentioned it before where like, if you can hit, like they're going to find a spot for you.
I do want to see him get a little bit more comfortable in the outfield.
I think he is a lot more use if he can play a corner spot, if instead of just pigeonholing him into a first base slash DH role.
If he can play corner outfield every once in a while, then that gives him a ton of, a ton of versatility there and a much more value than he offers you as a first baseman.
So looking for him, how he looks in the outfield.
I know when I saw him in Arizona fall, he was just a little iffy out there, like didn't get a great read on balls.
He didn't make any mistakes, but it was just, it wasn't super smooth.
So just continue to refine out there.
But yeah, like the dude just mashes baseballs and so just keep mashing baseballs.
If he goes to AAA this year and just keeps hitting nukes at some point, we might, like we might see Valdez this year.
I think that would be aggressive, but I think it's possible that we could see him at some point this year.
Yeah, I agree.
again, if he hits like he did last year at AAA, it'd be hard, when it's time to, when someone gets two weeks on the injured list or whatever to over, overlook him to pass him over.
It's if, sometimes you just want to bring up a guy cause he's hot, right.
And see if it can translate.
but you're right.
it's a real long shot for him.
but if he keeps doing what he's doing again, works on that outfield defense.
And a lot of that's just reps, right?
It's just getting reps.
you, and they need to coach him up, right?
It's the outfield coach at AAA or whatever really needs to work with him.
He needs to put in the work, but if he keeps hitting like that, we'll be clamoring and it'll make sense to get some spot on the roster for him.
Absolutely.
So that's, yeah, that's what we got for you today.
we're going to be live from Lee calm park in about four hours or so.
so stay tuned for that.
it's a cold one today.
I think the highs in the fifties, it looks like it's the wind I was looking yesterday was a 20 mile an hour winds today, Doug with 60 mile per hour wind gusts.
So that sounds fun.
If you haven't been down here and you've watched spring training games, we all know, like I intellectually knew that when that wind really blows Bradenton and it blows the bot, you're standing in a wind tunnel, man.
And there is no, there was no place.
I looked, I wandered the stadium yesterday looking for a spot to get out of the wind.
It did not, it did not exist.
And that wind is just blowing and it's cold.
And so I'm probably going to whine a lot on air today.
I apologize in advance, but I left 80 degrees in Alabama to come down to be in 50 degree Florida with a wind shell.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So that's where, so we're, once we wrap up here, we'll head over to Lee come, watch some batting practice, watch some practice.
And yeah, we'll be live at noon from the ballpark.
So make sure you join us.
If you're going to the game, come say hi to us.
A bunch of people, came up to us yesterday, said hi.
It's always great to talk to you guys.
So make sure you say hi if you see us.
But yeah, that's shout out to Sean from Pelham, Alabama.
I ran into him yesterday.
It's one of my, a neighbor of mine practically.
There we go.
Shout out Sean.
But yeah, guys, as I said, thanks for watching.
Thanks for listening.
Like the video, subscribe to the page.
If you're not, we're going to be putting out again, a ton of stuff over these next two weeks.
Not only are we doing live shows from Lee come park, every single home game, we're going to be doing recaps every single day.
And hopefully if you saw last night's recap, you'll see, we had Don Kelly's press conference in there.
We had a player interview.
We're going to try to like mix and mix some things into those.
So it's not just us talking the whole time.
So we're going to try to mix some things into that.
Those recaps.
So make sure you check those out at the end of every day.
YouTube, anywhere you get your podcasts.
But yeah, like the video, subscribe.
If you're listening, leave a leave a comment, leave a review.
Make sure the review is a five star review.
No notes.
No bad reviews.
Only good reviews here.
But yeah, all of that helps us out.
Helps other people find us.
We didn't, we haven't mentioned ABS yet.
We'll, and the reason is because it just went really smoothly.
It didn't, it didn't do anything.
It was great.
So we'll, but we'll talk about that more in the two weeks to come.
Yep.
Yep.
Yep.
All right, guys.
So yeah, continue to follow us, continue to follow us along.
Follow us along, follow along with us.
But yeah, we'll be live here in another four and a half hours or so.
But yeah, from Bradenton, I'm Jim.
Thanks everybody.
We'll see you, see you at the ballpark.
That's Dougie Fresh.
See you guys later.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up and don't forget to hit that subscribe button.
If you haven't already, it really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support and let's go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Should Jhostynxon Garcia open the season in Triple-A instead of as the Pirates' fifth outfielder?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.