The Pirates made their Rule 5 protection decisions, adding Mitch Jebb and Axiel Plaz to the 40-man roster. But Alex Stumpf isn’t convinced protecting Plaz was the right call. On today’s OffBeat, he explains how a potential MLB lockout could cost the young catcher valuable development time and why leaving him exposed may have been the safer option. Plus, Brandon Lowe declines his qualifying offer, keeping his future in Pittsburgh uncertain as free agency continues.
Did the Pirates Make a Mistake Protecting Axiel Plaz?

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Adding Axiel Plaz to the 40-man was the wrong call: a lockout keeps him out of minor league games, so Stumpf thinks the move is more likely to hurt the 21-year-old catcher's development than the Pirates were to lose him.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Stumpf predicts there won't be a Major League Rule 5 draft this year. With the lockout starting December 2 and a rushed spring training to follow, he says nobody will make time for it.
Alex Stumpf - 3
A High-A catcher who has never faced Double-A pitching wasn't going to be in demand. Taking Plaz would mean carrying three catchers all season or returning him, so Stumpf doesn't think anyone would have claimed him.
Alex Stumpf - 4
The Pirates need a definitive answer on whether Henry Davis and Endy Rodríguez are part of the plan. Stumpf expects the catcher picture to look very different a year from now.
Alex Stumpf - 5
Keeping Termarr Johnson off the 40-man was smart. Coming off a significant injury, he can keep rehabbing with the club during the lockout instead of losing all contact with the team.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript170 paragraphs · show
I promised there was going to be Pirates news on Tuesday, and the team delivered.
As expected, Brandon Lowe rejected his qualifying offer.
I think we all saw that coming.
Doesn't necessarily close the door of him returning to the Pirates.
But it was almost always going to have to be a multi-year arrangement.
Him taking that qualifying offer was a slim-to-none chance.
They also added some prospects to the 40-man roster.
One of them being Mitch Jebb.
I talked about him yesterday.
Talked about how the organization had liked him for a while.
And while I didn't have, the insider information that he was going to be selected, I knew how they felt about him.
They were really high on him.
Someone who, triple-A outfielder, you could use some depth there.
I saw a path for him to be selected.
They also selected the contract of Axioplaz.
And I will admit, I did not have him in that rundown yesterday, because I didn't see it as all that particularly likely.
And now that the decision has been made, I don't know if I like it.
Good morning, and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine.
My name is Alex Stumpf, and this is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
I like Axioplaz as a prospect and as a player.
This whole podcast is in no way an indictment of him.
And it's not really an indictment of the system.
MLB Pipeline has him as a top 10 prospect.
Number 7.
So he is a really good young player, and he's a catcher first baseman.
Two positions where the Pirates don't have a lot of long-term certainty.
First base right now, you've got Ryan O'Hearn.
They want him to play a lot more first base next year.
And you still have Spencer Horwitz, who's under contract for years to come.
Catcher, Henry Davis, Indy Rodriguez, 2027.
You need a definitive answer on these guys.
Are they actually part of your plan going forward?
Rafael Flores Jr. had a really encouraging rookie year, but still a lot to prove.
Still, overall, you take that mix there.
It's a position where I think whenever we sit here next year, we're going to be talking about the catcher position a lot differently.
As it stands right now, maybe not a lot of opportunity for 2027, but yeah, keep depth.
Especially after you trade Omar Alfonso at the trade deadline.
You need that next tier of depth.
And he's a good young hitter.
He hit pretty well.
In 2026, 18 homers, a 513 slugging percentage, a 902 OPS.
Those are really solid numbers.
He did it at high A Greensboro.
That's why he wasn't on my rundown yesterday.
Because I was looking at players who were in the top half of the farm system.
Double A and triple A.
And I'm sorry.
I just don't think that a high A catcher was going to be that super high in demand for a Roll 5 draft.
Even though, yes, he is one of the organization's better prospects.
Yes, he hits really well.
But you want to stash a catcher on your roster whenever he hasn't even smelled double A pitching?
You're basically forcing yourself to carry three catchers that entire season.
or return him.
He's absolutely not yet in a spot where he could contribute at an everyday level or even a backup capacity at the major league level.
That's not a real indictment of him.
He's 22 years old.
Or 21 years old, excuse me.
He's a kid.
There's a lot of growth to be had.
He's not supposed to be a finished product.
He's supposed to be a 21-year-old who has been in pro ball for four years.
Again, I'm high on him.
I think he is a good young hitter, a good young player.
Someone who, in a couple years, we could be talking about as being a major part of the Pirates' plans.
Either a catcher or at first base or hell.
He could continue to develop as a prospect and be trade bait.
But, as it stands right now, I don't think anyone was going to claim him.
And that's assuming there was going to be a Rule 5 draft.
Which is far from a guarantee this year.
This lockout is going to create a bunch of challenges.
One of them being, how do you have a Rule 5 draft if this lockout goes as long as the owners are claiming they are willing it to go?
I just don't see a scenario where they lock out the players on December 2nd and then whenever they agree upon a contract or a CBA,
it'll probably be in February or March or April or beyond and people are going to bust their butts to get to spring training.
And I can't imagine in that mad dash of getting players ready for spring training, for signing whatever free agents were still available, finishing any roster transactions you want for the regular season,
adjusting all your plans of what's usually a seven-week camp in games in spring training to three and a half weeks like it was in 21-22.
I can't imagine in all that flurry it's going to be like, hey guys, we really need to have a Rule 5 draft.
You know that thing where two-thirds of the teams just pass.
I just don't see there being a Major League Rule 5 draft this year.
If the Pirates or other teams feel differently, that's one thing.
That's one thing.
And if they don't want to risk it at all, to an extent, I get it.
Like I said, I like him as a prospect.
I like him as a player.
He still needs to grow.
He still needs to develop.
I don't think that's an indictment to say for a 21-year-old.
But I think selecting him to the roster does negatively impact his development.
We're going to get into that in a second.
But first, I'd like to thank today's sponsor, Lurene Co.
We all know nicotine pouches are popular and part of it isn't so much nicotine as it is the routine.
Lurene just launched a pouch that keeps the routine but leaves the nicotine out.
Lurene Co. pouches swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
It works like the pouches you've seen before.
Just tuck one in and go about your day.
Each pouch has a half cup of coffee's worth of caffeine plus L-theanine and alpha-GPC for a smooth, steady focus with no energy crash and it gives your teeth daily enamel support in between brushings.
It comes in mint, cinnamon, and mango and it's nicotine-free always.
It's doing something good for your teeth and it gives you smooth energy and focus without those jitters.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something and it helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designed to do both and it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Lurene a try.
Right now, Lurene Co.
is offering our listeners up to 50% off by Lurene.com slash North Shore.
That's by Lurene, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash North Shore for up to 50% off.
Axioplaz needs to play games.
That is how he is going to get better.
It is how every 21-year-old in professional baseball gets better.
Now that he's on a 40-man roster, we don't know when his next baseball game is going to be played.
The minor league seasons are still going to be happening next year.
And if you are not on a 40-man roster, you can still play.
Plaz can't.
Even though he's never appeared in a major league game, he is on a 40-man roster.
He is not going to be able to participate in minor league games.
If this lockout really is something that is going to cancel weeks or months of the 2027 season, that's weeks or months that he cannot get better
in the most traditional sense.
He's going to have to get better away from the ball.
Not only away from the ball fields, but away from the club.
Like in 2020, whenever there was the COVID year and minor league baseball got canceled, there was still the alternate training site.
There were still camps.
There was still extended spring training.
There was, there are ways that these players had contact points with the organization.
He doesn't, he's not going to have that in, what, two weeks?
That stinks.
It's why whenever I look at someone like Termarr Johnson, who, yeah, did not hit well last year.
And that alone, even if he was 100% healthy, I think would lead to some discussion of should he be added to the 40-man roster.
But that injury that he had was significant.
And if the Pirates were to select him to the 40-man roster, they couldn't be involved with his rehab anymore.
They could not have contact with him once the lockout starts.
They would have to just trust that everything was going okay.
This way, they can still talk to him.
They can still rehab with him.
Whenever games get started and he's available to appear in games, guess what?
It's normal.
Derek Diamond is someone who I thought, yeah, they could potentially add him, reliever, minor league reliever of year for them last year.
I see some potential major league upside.
It didn't.
They didn't select him.
That strikes me as a, you don't think the Rule 5 draft is going to happen.
We're going to take the risk that either this draft doesn't happen or he wouldn't be selected.
Even though I think he'd be a pretty good candidate to be selected.
Mitch Jebb is someone who I also think would be a good candidate to be selected.
You could easily stash a fifth outfielder, especially someone who's speedy and more defensive minded.
I get that.
They really like him for a while.
I know he's not on the top 30 prospect list, but the organization really likes him.
I get it.
You hang on to one of your guys.
Mitch Jebb, I think, is, missing games for anyone is going to be rough for any prospect, but he's had more time as a pro.
He has college ball behind him.
I think he could weather an absence from the game better than someone like plus, who has not played in the upper levels of a minor
league system, who is younger, 21 years old, who has a more challenging position as a catcher.
Developing there, developing as a game caller, as a pitch framer, as a defender, as everything that goes with that position.
you need games for that.
And I get, again, this is a top 10 prospect for the Pirates.
And you don't want to risk losing those guys for nothing, but I just didn't see much chance of him being taken.
The way I view the calculus, there is a better chance of his development being negatively impacted by selecting him to the roster rather than the Pirates losing him.
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine.
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe to review fine podcasts, or check us out on YouTube if you want to see my smiling face.
And leave a comment down below if you would like to be part of our next mailbag episode on Friday.
Thank you so much for listening.
We will talk again tomorrow.
All right, that wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up and don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
and let's go.


Comments· 0
Should the Pirates have left Axiel Plaz off the 40-man roster so he could keep playing minor league games during the lockout?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.