◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
Easton Carmichael may not be the loudest name in the Pirates farm system, but his first full professional season is becoming impossible to ignore. Jim and Anthony Murphy break down the top 10 prospect’s advanced defense, quick release, contact skills, surprising athleticism and power at Greensboro. Could Carmichael be the most complete catching prospect in the organization, and how soon might he earn a promotion to Double-A Altoona?
Watch or listen to Bucs On Deck.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Will Easton Carmichael's power hold up in the upper minors, or is he a contact-first catcher?
From Jim Rosati’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Anthony Murphy.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Easton Carmichael's game will be contact over power: his power isn't expected to play much at the higher levels, despite double-digit homers in Greensboro.
Jim Rosati
2
Carmichael is a more well-rounded catching prospect than Omar Alfonso, Axiel Plaz or Richard Ramirez, even though each of them beats him in a single tool.
Jim Rosati
3
His defense is good enough that backup big-league catcher looks like his floor. FanGraphs' Eric Longenhagen says he'll be a major leaguer if he hits even a little.
Jim Rosati
4
There's no scenario where Carmichael doesn't finish 2026 in Double-A Altoona. The Pirates may wait for the complex league season to end so they can move catchers up the ladder together.
Jim Rosati
5
His 11-for-14 base stealing won't be a big part of his game. At best it's a back-pocket weapon worth a handful of steals a year.
What's going on, everybody? Welcome to the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. We've got another episode of Bucs On Deck this week. I'm Jim with me on, this is going to be released on the 4th of July, Murphy. We've got Anthony Murphy from Bucs On Deck. Murph, happy 4th.
Jim Rosati
Happy 4th, man. Ready to grow some ribs and cook some burgers and, live it up, right?
Jim Rosati
Yeah, we're recording this on Friday, July 3rd, and we were just talking about how hot it is. I'm just going to immediately leave this podcast and go straight to the pool. And I don't think I'm going to get out of that pool all day long, because I think the heat index today was like 115. So I'm not going anywhere.
Jim Rosati
I'm going to have to fight my father-in-law to keep him from going outside and doing yard work, because he's already trying to find some work to do outside. And I've been like, yeah, nah, man, it's, nah.
Jim Rosati
Nah.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, nah, that's not happening today.
Jim Rosati
But yeah, speaking of hot, though, Murphy, the Greensboro Grasshoppers are pretty hot right now.
Jim Rosati
And, we're going to take the time today to talk about, their catcher, 2025 third round draft pick Easton Carmichael.
Jim Rosati
he's putting together, his first full season of pro ball.
Jim Rosati
lots to like here about Carmichael, catcher, out of the university of Oklahoma.
Jim Rosati
And, yeah, let's dive into this.
Jim Rosati
I'm excited.
Jim Rosati
Carmichael's one of those guys in the system where, you just see a lot of good stuff from him.
Jim Rosati
And I feel he doesn't get like a ton of fanfare, but he's having a really good first season of pro ball.
He was actually one of the guys, I jumped on the live show that you guys do for the, for the draft.
Jim Rosati
And he's one of the guys that I've mentioned as someone that was still available, like in the early rounds that I like really liked the bat.
Jim Rosati
Ironically enough, the defense was like a question during the draft process, but they're saying like he was, he was athletic enough to where he can like kick to the outfield.
Jim Rosati
If like behind the plate wasn't going to work and you we're seeing the athletic athleticism play a little bit, double digit stolen bases right now, but he gets the pro ball.
Jim Rosati
And like, he's quickly emerged as like one of the best defensive catchers in the system, strong arm, quick release, good framing or Steven skills, just a mix of all of that.
Jim Rosati
There, saw a really nice power jump in, his last year of college, he went from seven home runs as a sophomore to 17 as a, as a junior.
Jim Rosati
Junior and a double digit home runs already this year, for Greensboro, in the first half.
Jim Rosati
So we'll see how much of the power plays in the upper levels.
Jim Rosati
I think that's like the big question for him now at this point, see how much the power is legitimate, but just an all around solid hitter with really good defense.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, I feel like, universally, praised for that defense, on your website, you guys have them slotted in at number nine baseball America just did theirs.
Jim Rosati
You've got him as a top 10 prospect at number 10.
Jim Rosati
So it's like, there's a, there's a lot of people who like Easton Carmichael when it comes to what he's doing right now.
Jim Rosati
I want to, I want to start with the defense because, you guys listed that as his best tool and, I'll say this about Carmichael.
Jim Rosati
I haven't gotten to watch him a ton.
Jim Rosati
I saw him a little bit in Greensboro last year, but, and I've seen him, the spring breakout game also this spring, he looked really good.
Jim Rosati
Like he stood out in that game.
Jim Rosati
and that's when you saw the athleticism and the hit, like, I think he homered and stole a base in that guy.
Jim Rosati
Like he was, he was showing out.
Jim Rosati
but defensively, I want to tell a story.
Jim Rosati
The first time, first time I saw Easton Carmichael this season, cause I saw him in Greensboro last year, but this season, I'm on the backfields of pirate city.
Jim Rosati
And they're, they're doing a drill with all the minor league catchers where they take a pitching machine and they just point it straight up into the sky.
Jim Rosati
And they're just launching baseballs.
Jim Rosati
Murphy, these are major league foul balls.
Jim Rosati
They're launching up in the sky.
Jim Rosati
and the catchers are like, all right, go catch them.
Jim Rosati
And if you know anything about Bradenton, if you know anything about pirate city, it can be a little tricky.
Jim Rosati
There's a lot of wind.
Jim Rosati
Like it's not the best environment for, these are 300 foot pop-ups that he's just shooting in the air.
Jim Rosati
Right.
Jim Rosati
And it was funny because you saw catcher after catcher after catcher, just like struggle with these monster pop-ups.
He was the only one I noticed in the entire minor league catching group where he just, he caught them all.
Jim Rosati
And I was like, huh, that's something these are, this is obviously difficult.
Jim Rosati
And Carmichael stood out among all the minor league catchers when it came to that drill.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
if you can catch a pop-up in, especially on the backfields of Bradenton, you can catch a pop-up anywhere else, probably that you're going to play.
Jim Rosati
So that's definitely a good sign there.
Jim Rosati
And like you said, that's good.
Jim Rosati
And I think the arm was like the question in there and what he's throwing right at about like 30% of batters.
Jim Rosati
So.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Caught stealing percentage.
Jim Rosati
I'm trying to find it.
Jim Rosati
yeah, he's 22 caught stealing, in 77, 22 for 77 right now.
Jim Rosati
And attempts, which is, yeah, that's pretty strong.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
what have you seen in terms of like the, how does the athleticism help him behind the plate too?
Jim Rosati
Because again, like pop-ups is one thing that's what just stood out to me.
Jim Rosati
But when it comes to just, being athletic back there, blocking pitches, framing, what makes him, you call him in your write-up.
Jim Rosati
He's, arguably the best quote unquote catching prospect in the system when it comes to, just being a catcher.
Jim Rosati
Like, what is it about the defense that really stands out?
Jim Rosati
I think it's just, yeah, I think it's just like a well-rounded just, it's just everything just is solid on it.
Jim Rosati
Like, he's athletic enough to where like, he gets out of the, out of the position and gets a quick release on the ball.
Jim Rosati
What was it the Thursday?
Jim Rosati
I think it was Thursday night's game or one of the previous night's game.
Jim Rosati
Like he threw a guy and like the throw was so far ahead that like the guy hadn't even really begun to slide yet.
Jim Rosati
And like, it was already getting there to the runner was safe.
Jim Rosati
Cause I like, he pretty much like kicked the ball out of your Donnie's hand and your Donnie was hurt like onto play.
Jim Rosati
He needed a second.
Jim Rosati
So it like, I think it like spiked him in the, spiked him in the arm.
Jim Rosati
So, but like just super quick release, which like, maybe like the arm isn't like, but isn't like a incredibly strong arm.
Jim Rosati
But like the release is so quick that he can, he gets it out of his hand and it's just, it allows him to play, just stay athletic, stay on his feet, block, get down to block pitches in the dirt and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
It's just, everything's just so well-rounded out for someone who's in his first pro season.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
I was at defensively definitely stands out.
Jim Rosati
I know when we had, Eric long and hanging from fan graphs on earlier this year, he specifically mentioned that, Easton Carmichael's he's going to be a major leaguer just because, if he can just hit a little bit, the defense is so good that he's going to be a major leaguer.
Jim Rosati
He's going to, he's going to be like a backup catcher seems like the floor here for Carmichael, which, yeah.
Jim Rosati
And the hitting is coming around as well.
Jim Rosati
You're seeing that.
Jim Rosati
And I do want to touch on that a little bit more because yeah, like the defense is outstanding, but let's talk about what brings the upside to Easton Carmichael.
Jim Rosati
And we'll do that right after we talk to Cody.
Jim Rosati
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration sponsor IQ bar protein.
Jim Rosati
IQ bar, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel.
Jim Rosati
You need to win your day.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
Jim Rosati
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks and four IQ Joe sticks.
Jim Rosati
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Jim Rosati
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
Jim Rosati
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
Jim Rosati
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
Jim Rosati
It's just really full of flavor.
Jim Rosati
I love starting my day with it.
Jim Rosati
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Jim Rosati
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
Jim Rosati
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
Jim Rosati
That's MLB 64000.
Jim Rosati
Message and data rates may apply.
Jim Rosati
See terms for details.
Jim Rosati
All right, Murphy.
Jim Rosati
So let's talk about the bat a little bit.
Jim Rosati
He's hitting 300, 349 OBP, slugging over 500 right now.
Jim Rosati
It's good for a 110 weight runs created plus.
Jim Rosati
But yeah, you look at the other stuff, too.
Jim Rosati
Just, he makes contact.
Jim Rosati
He doesn't chase.
Jim Rosati
He doesn't swing and miss.
Jim Rosati
He doesn't strike out.
Jim Rosati
It's just overall a solid hitting profile.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
And I think it's going to be a lot more, like, contact over power.
Jim Rosati
I don't think the power is going to play too much in the higher levels.
Jim Rosati
But I think, like, if you look back at his numbers last year, like, when he, I think it was, like, 10, 11 games that he played.
Jim Rosati
Like, the numbers didn't look great.
Jim Rosati
But if you like, dug underneath on that, he made a lot of contact.
Jim Rosati
He wasn't swinging and missing a lot.
Jim Rosati
So you saw pieces to where, like, maybe, it's just an adjustment period for pro ball.
Jim Rosati
And, like, he's come out and shown that was the case there.
Jim Rosati
So, but it's, like, I love the setup.
Jim Rosati
It's very clean.
Jim Rosati
It's very easy.
Jim Rosati
There's not a lot of movement going on in it.
Jim Rosati
It's just like, hands are ready to go.
Jim Rosati
Pitch comes.
Jim Rosati
And I'm just going to make contact, put the ball in play.
Jim Rosati
And uses all fields.
Jim Rosati
It's just a very advanced approach.
Jim Rosati
Like I said, again, for someone who is in his first full pro season.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
I remember I got the chance to talk to Easton last year for a little bit and just really talking about, like, hey, like, what's the what's the biggest difference you've noticed, going to pro ball?
Jim Rosati
And he talked about just, like, there's no, there's just, there's no bad pitcher, right?
Jim Rosati
Like, everybody's pretty good.
Jim Rosati
Like, the fourth bullpen arm out of Winston-Salem's bullpen is throwing 97 miles an hour.
Jim Rosati
And that's just not something that you see, in college.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, he's, I think he's done a great job of adjusting to the level.
Jim Rosati
He got a little taste of Greensboro last year.
Jim Rosati
He's there right now.
Jim Rosati
And, yeah, everything just looks good.
Jim Rosati
The stolen bases, too, stand out to me because you, don't really see catchers running like he has.
Jim Rosati
But he's stolen 11 bases and 14 attempts.
Jim Rosati
Is that something that you see also maybe even being a little bit part of his game?
Jim Rosati
Or is that just he's facing lower level catching pitchers right now.
Jim Rosati
So he's taking advantage of it.
Jim Rosati
Like, how much is that going to translate?
Jim Rosati
Like, there's definitely some speed there.
Jim Rosati
And I think that plays into, like, the reports where they're talking about, like, he could probably fit in, like, left field or something like that if, catching didn't work out.
Jim Rosati
I don't think it's going to be, like, a big part of a game, his game.
Jim Rosati
But it's something that certainly can that he'll have in his back pocket that, like, if he picks his pick the moment right and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
And like the pitcher and the catcher aren't expecting it.
Jim Rosati
Like, he can still, he's not going to put up big numbers and stuff like that.
Jim Rosati
But he could sneak his way into short double digit numbers potentially thing.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Where do you where do you stack him up against the other cat?
Jim Rosati
I know you said, like, arguably the best catching prospect.
Jim Rosati
But, like, there's this is a position that is stacked, especially, like, right here in Greensboro.
Jim Rosati
you've got him.
Jim Rosati
You've got Plaz.
Jim Rosati
You've got, Richard Ramirez not too far behind him.
Jim Rosati
Right ahead of him, you got Omar Alfonso in double A.
Jim Rosati
Like, where is he in the pecking order there for you?
Jim Rosati
Well, it's funny with, like, Carmichael, because I feel like if you like, you put all the catchers in a group and then you go tool by tool.
Jim Rosati
Maybe he doesn't he's not going to be one of the guys who has, like, the best of every tool.
Jim Rosati
Like, power.
Jim Rosati
That's Omar Alfonso.
Jim Rosati
Omar Alfonso has the best power of any of it.
Jim Rosati
But, like, he's he'll be up there.
Jim Rosati
He'll be continually in that conversation.
Jim Rosati
the power.
Jim Rosati
Alfonso, maybe you can make a case for Plaz.
Jim Rosati
Like, the arm, like, Richard Ramirez has a double plus arm.
Jim Rosati
So it's not going to have to.
Jim Rosati
But, like, he's up there to where, like, he's throwing out.
Jim Rosati
He has the same around the same cot stealing rate as, like, Richard Ramirez.
Jim Rosati
And Ramirez has, technically a stronger arm.
Jim Rosati
So, like, it's the tools aren't going to be, like, the best out of the group.
Jim Rosati
But, like, he's going to be consistently up there with the rest.
Jim Rosati
He's just, it's, he's more well-rounded of a catching prospect than I think any of the other guys.
Jim Rosati
The Pirates, to my knowledge, have not promoted any 2025 draft pick past Greensboro yet.
Jim Rosati
Doesn't look like it.
Jim Rosati
Matt King was.
Jim Rosati
Oh, Matt King.
Jim Rosati
You're right.
Jim Rosati
Matt King's up there.
Jim Rosati
Okay.
Jim Rosati
Matt King's an L2.
Jim Rosati
I believe so.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Matt King's an Altoona.
Jim Rosati
How, and there's a few, there's a few candidates, to be the next guy.
Jim Rosati
you can throw Carmichael in that mix.
Jim Rosati
I think you can throw Murf Gray, obviously, in that mix as well.
Jim Rosati
Is, do we, do we see an Altoona promotion at some point before the end of the year just to push him a little bit more?
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
I don't, I don't see a scenario to where, like, he doesn't finish the year in Altoona.
Jim Rosati
I can see something like maybe they're waiting for the, like the complex season leak to end to, so then that way they have some backfill to get some of the catchers up there to so that way it's like just one big line that they're moving everyone up.
Jim Rosati
So that way there's some catchers covering at each thing.
Jim Rosati
But yeah, I definitely see Carmichael finishing the year in double A at some point.
Jim Rosati
Okay.
Jim Rosati
If you could, if you, if there was one reason why Pirates fans need to just, every week, make sure you check out Easton Carmichael and see how he's doing.
Jim Rosati
What's the main reason for that?
Jim Rosati
I think it's just like, he's like the old school, all do it, do it all catcher thing.
Jim Rosati
And like, he's a catcher that hits in the middle of the lineup for one of the best hitting teams in all of minor league baseball.
Jim Rosati
they, what is it?
Jim Rosati
They put up 20, 23 runs the other, the other night they've put, they've had several games to where I believe they've scored 20 runs this season.
Jim Rosati
And I think they scored more runs than any other non triple A team in the first half as well, as well.
Jim Rosati
So like you're looking at a run producer and one of the most potent offenses in minor league baseball.
Comments· 0
Will Easton Carmichael's power hold up in the upper minors, or is he a contact-first catcher?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.