The Pirates surprised plenty of people by selecting LSU outfielder Derek Curiel with the fifth overall pick in the 2026 MLB Draft. The NS9 crew reacts to the selection, weighs Curiel’s elite contact skills and center field defense against his limited power, and debates whether Pittsburgh passed on players with more upside. Anthony Murphy also joins the show to break down the pick and what it could mean for the rest of the Pirates’ draft. Watch or listen now.
Pirates 2026 MLB Draft Live: Pirates Select Derek Curiel 5th

With Anthony DiNardo, Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Derek Curiel is a fine prospect at picks 10–12, but at No. 5 the Pirates passed on more upside. He's an elite contact hitter with no real power, and a 6'2", 193-lb frame that doesn't suggest he'll grow into it.
- 2
By home-run rate, Curiel ranks around 48th of roughly 52 college hitters taken in the first round over the last decade. That makes him one of the least powerful first-round outfield bats in that span.
- 3
Drafting for a player who will 'move quickly' is the wrong approach. With that mindset in 2024, the Pirates probably don't end up with Konnor Griffin. Take the best player available.
- 4
Curiel's realistic outcome is Alex Verdugo who can play center field: a .280–.300 hitter with 6–13 homers and about 2 WAR a year. Just fine, but not a top-five-pick impact player.
- 5
The Pirates' two second-round picks will decide how this draft is judged. Expect high school arms, possibly signed over slot, in a draft that's deep in prep pitching.
Players discussed
Full transcript797 paragraphs · show
How it's supposed to feel
Yo. Welcome to the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel. This is the 2026 NS9 Draft Show. Folks, I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. With me, we got Jim. We got Ty-Ty. Pirates pick number five today. How y'all doing?
Great. As we go live, Esmerlyn Valdez homers to give the Pirates a 3-2 lead.
Let's go.
The magician! Let's go, baby!
How about that? What an intro. What an intro. Yeah, it's weird. We're doing this show. Usually, like, this show is just a standalone thing. We're watching the draft. We're watching the Pirates game. It's a doubleheader. The magic man, the magician, Esmerlyn Valdez goes deep, as we go live here. that's just good fives.
Good vibes to start today. Magical vibes.
And for the record, I just hit on my bet for us, Esmerlyn Valdez. Two hits today, plus 328. Gotta love that.
Okay. Okay. Yeah. Guys, get your Merlin Magic shirt on our merch store. Go to northshornine.com right now. You can buy the shirt. Thanks to Cody. Cody designed it. Cody's dubbed him the magician. That thing has taken off.
Everyone's caught. I saw Tony Diggs talking about the magician earlier today. He had a two RBI. No, sorry. One RBI hit earlier today. Now he don't run. Dude is just dominating.
He's raking. He's raking. Love it. Yeah. This show is going to be fun because I think, like, while we're doing this, we're also going to have, like, instant reactions to the Pirates game, too, which is something that we're not really used to doing.
So, yeah. I'm looking forward to this. It should be. I have no idea. The picks are all over the place. No one really seems to know exactly what the Pirates are going to be doing here.
So, it's going to be cool to see it unfold. The draft starts, I believe, right around 1.30 or so. And so, the Pirates pick should be, 1.55-ish PM.
If we're lucky.
And that's when we know who it'll be.
Yeah.
It seems like 1-3 is assumed, at least. After that, though, it could definitely get interesting. It seems like number four is going to be a big determination on what the Pirates do.
Yeah.
Yeah. Like, this year. Like you said, like, 1-3 seems it. we had, and again, we've been plugging this, but of course, if you guys haven't watched or heard yet, we had Jim Callis on for, like, the draft preview.
And, hey, there he is on Peacock right now. So, like, we had Jim Callis on for the preview.
went in depth. And that was his mindset, too. Like, 1-3 is pretty much a lock, unless someone gets, like, really cute.
After that, though, like, you just don't really know.
He nailed the last three years of the Pirates' picks. And this year, he just said, like, guys, I am not confident it could go either way after this.
So, yeah, like, it's going to be interesting to see where the Pirates go.
Now, also, the Pirates, hey, they traded their comp pick last night. So, that changes things a little bit as well.
And I don't know if that changes their plan. Like, I put out there to you guys earlier, maybe just to talk on this.
they had the highest draft pool in the draft this year. they had a lot of money because, they drafted Cervantes last year.
He didn't sign. So, they get that comp pick. Of course, the money involved with that.
So, they had the largest pool. They traded that pick last night. So, now, they no longer have the largest pool.
Does that change the way they're going to draft this year? Or do they have intentions of drafting differently?
like, I guess, put out there, we talked about who they could pick at number five.
Do they maybe go lower slot to get some money back, save some money because they made that trade?
I don't know. But, again, that changes the draft this year.
Yeah, we'll see. I don't think trading that pick will affect their choice at number five all too much.
They do have, the 44th pick and the 51st pick.
So, they still have, like, three of the top 51 picks where, if you needed to find a little bit of wiggle room somewhere with some slot money, like, it's there.
So, yeah, they still have a $16.2 million draft pool.
They're still picking fifth.
And there should be, like you mentioned, Tyler, the top three guys are not going to be there.
Rock Chilowski, Grady Emerson, and Vaughn Lackey are not going to be Pittsburgh Pirates.
But I think there's a chance pretty much anyone else in that top tier could be.
So, yeah, it's going to be interesting to see what the Giants do because I think that is going to play a pretty large part in things.
going into today, Baseball America was pretty dead set on it's going to be Flora.
Baseball America has put out seven mock drafts, and Jackson Flora has been the pick in all seven.
MLB Pipeline has Flora going to the Giants.
And then their split where, we had Callis on last week, and he wasn't really confident in his pick, but he said Booth.
Mayo says Booth, Callis says Derek Curiel, which we haven't really talked much about Derek Curiel.
Definitely a name that most people are familiar with just because he's been, this mega superstar prospect for a while now, ever since he was in high school.
But just that's another name thrown in the mix there.
You have Kylie McDaniel over on ESPN, where yesterday he projected Drew Burris going fifth.
Today, he says, I think yesterday he had Burris.
I think he had Burris yesterday, but either way, he's got Burris going to the Pirates again today.
He's got Flora going to the Giants.
And he's saying the same thing as Callis, where, if Flora's there, it's probably Flora.
But if Flora's not there, it's Burris or Curiel.
So the one name we're not really hearing at all is Jacob Lombard, who's in that tier.
We haven't really heard his name being associated with the Pirates in any way.
But like Flora, Burris, Booth, Curiel, we've heard all those names.
So, yeah, we'll see who it is.
All right, well, the Pirates are picking Derek Curiel fifth overall in the Major League Baseball draft as DiNardo is fixing things.
And you know what's funny is, here you go, he did at least make this.
So that's a shocker, Tyler.
I'm not expecting Derek Curiel to be this high.
I'm very surprised.
Yeah, definitely surprised.
And we were all wrong here.
And Jim, you said this is the one that might be a little bit disappointing to you.
Feeling a little disappointed.
Yeah.
Again, like I like Derek Curiel as a prospect.
Like if, again, if the Pirates were picking like 10th, 11th, 12th, give me Derek Curiel.
I'd be happy with that pick all day.
but at five, I just, I don't see the upside with Curiel as I do with the other guys.
He's really solid, like across the board with everything like contact.
He's, if you're, if you're looking for someone who can put the ball in play and hit it hard and hit for average, like that's going to be Derek Curiel.
He's an elite contact hitter.
and he's got plus tools with speed.
He's plus in the field.
He can play center field, his arms average, for the position.
but like just not really any power.
And the frame also doesn't suggest that he's going to necessarily grow into it either.
he's six, two listed at one 93 right now, just as just a small guy who I don't think is ever going to hit for the power that we want out of a number of five pick.
he strikes me as a, without saying like, he's a, he's a good pure hitter, but just a little underwhelming for five.
Yeah.
And then you look at the frame, if you bulk up a little bit, you probably don't stay in center, which is going to be a bit of his value here.
especially without the power.
Yeah.
I think he will stay in center.
Like I do.
I'm saying if he were to bulk up, if he were to bulk up, then yeah, you gotta, you gotta maybe make a switch there, but I don't think that's even possible for him.
But maybe they like the lefty bat a little more and how it plays in PNC, or maybe they think that there's something in the swing that they can make an adjustment with and unlock some power, but time will tell, I guess, guys.
Yeah.
I was, I was watching a baseball America podcast earlier and they talked about, college hitting outfielders over the last 10 years.
And they threw like where Curiel would be in that group in terms of power.
I think there were 52 or 54 college hitters taken in the first round over the last decade.
And from a, just like home run percentage standpoint, Curiel would rank around 48th on that list.
So like he's in the last 10 years, Derek Curiel is one of the least powerful outfield bats ever taken in the first round is essentially what that means.
Yeah.
So my fear.
Did they just go under slot here to save money?
Like, is this what they're basically doing then?
Right.
you're not taking him because you feel he's the best option.
Right.
Opposed to other guys.
He's safe.
Like, I feel like there's a, there's a level of him being safe as a pick, but he's not the fifth best player on the board.
Like, even if you have a debate.
So is this, is that situation?
Is this the sense where it's like, we trade that pick, we have less money.
Let's go ahead and take him.
He's safe.
And maybe there's some options later in the draft that we really want to get.
And again, it's not like the Henry Davis situation, but like you look at that draft, that was the point of taking the Henry Davis because then you get your Bubba's and whatever.
And that's the only way I look at this.
We don't have as much money as we did.
We still like, you still have a lot of Curry.
Well, then why are you taking Curry?
Now I will say this, like they'll probably be able to get Curry L under slot.
They, right.
I would, I would imagine they will.
I don't think it's going to be that far under slot because Curry L also has a little bit of a little bit of leverage in here and that he's a draft eligible sophomore.
Like Curry L plays for LSU, the best and biggest baseball program in the country.
If Curry L wanted to, you could probably go back to LSU and make a million dollars next year.
Like that's where he's sitting at.
So like, I'm not necessarily saying that he's going to be like that far under slot.
It should be an under slot signing.
and then also just by the way, Eric Booth jr going to the Royals at number six.
but I think, I think they will save a little bit here to use later on in the draft.
I, maybe they just really liked Curry L.
we heard Kylie say this morning that like, if it's not Flora, it's Burris or Curry L.
And I, again, I said it before in the lead up to this, Derek Curry L is a, is going to be pretty good.
Like he's, he doesn't do anything poorly except hit for like the power.
The power is the one thing he doesn't have.
But like when I, when I say like elite contact skills, I'm saying like elite contact skills here, like this is a guy who could hit 300, but hit seven homers, right.
And played average defense above average defense of that.
He's left-handed outfielder.
Nick Gonzales, I think is a pretty good way of saying it.
Yeah.
I think that's, yeah, that, yeah, it's fine.
It, he's fine.
Like, I think, I think Derek Curry L is a two war outfielder.
Is he, I'll say the fact that he plays center field.
Yeah.
Helps it again.
Helps with the floor that we're talking of.
Be a four war outfielder.
Probably not.
But he'll be a two war outfielder.
And it, I've said, I think this is a, it's a high floor pick, but I'm not, I'm not thrilled because it, they did pass on some upside here.
Mm-hmm.
just to, it is a, I want to say just take me with those in there.
And I did open the show.
Well, I guess with what I say in saying this, Jim Callis said, don't quote me.
He's unsure.
He's not going to get this pick, right?
Technically speaking, his last mock this morning did have Curry.
Oh, and that's why I said, I'm getting a little worried here about the underslot because Callis did say, so Callis is technically as common here says, John six 70 four for four in the pirates last four dress.
I know he didn't say it on our show, but our show was a week before his last mock did have this pick.
So Jim Callis, the Wendy's value meal.
I can't give him credit for this one.
No, I can't.
No, not in a mock.
You have to say it on our show.
Yeah.
He does have to say it on the show.
Yeah.
Four for four doesn't count.
He's three for four.
He said, you're on the, on the show.
And I'm pulling here.
So I did ask Jim Callis about Curry L and he says he likes him as a player, but see, but he said that taking him fifth quote unquote, wouldn't make sense.
There you go.
That was, that was the quote from Jim Callis on our show.
He likes him, but taking him fifth quote unquote, wouldn't make sense.
Which is that's it.
that's exactly what I said before.
Like I like them.
I wouldn't take them fifth.
Well, we saw the, shift from the high upside side guys that we were talking about earlier.
And it's a shift towards what we saw previously with Ben Sheraton's drafts with the Nick Gonzales picks.
So tomorrow Johnson picks.
I guess that makes sense.
Yeah.
this is a very safe pick.
I think there's a very safe pick.
I'm looking to see if we've got any press conferences or quotes yet from Ben.
I'm not seeing him yet.
The pick hasn't even been in yet or no, it just got in.
Oh, it just came in.
Yeah.
Technically it's well, actually the Royals are drafting now.
Nevermind.
But still hasn't been in that long.
But also, I was wrong on Eric Booth jr.
Yeah.
Zion Rose is six to the Royals.
Holy crap.
How does it, how does he go before Tyler Bell?
Zion Rose from the university of Louisville.
Sixth overall pick to the Royals.
That's wild.
Well, let's say, go check out the website.
It's in the pinned comment here live.
You can watch our show on the website as they're tracking all the, all the picks coming in too as well.
But yeah, the website's looking good.
We've got the new draft hub there.
You can go past all the, every single draft in the past is for this pirates picks go and such.
So check that out.
Yeah.
I'll say just to show everybody what that, like it's pinned, it's pinned in there, but just to show you guys what this looks like.
If you go to North shore nine.com slash pirate slash draft.
You've got our show right here, which you can watch live, right?
So we've got our show right here.
You've got the chat, you got, the picks right here, and then you got every pick down here too.
Look, Zion Rose is already there.
Zion Rose at six is crazy.
That's the first, you'd look at these two picks, Curry L and Rose, both pretty big reaches, I would say actually.
and the high school bats still out there.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That's wild.
Like back to back.
So these other guys, you figure it'd be going four or five range or now sitting at seven plus like Zion Rose was picked before drew Burris.
Yeah.
That's wild to me.
Maybe they'll possibly get him in the second round.
All right.
let's do this.
Let's do this.
We've got our guest.
He just arrived.
Let's shoot this thing over to Cody for just like 90 seconds.
And when we get back, we'll bring on our, we'll bring on our guest.
We can't.
We don't have Cody's video loaded in the, in the thing, do we?
No.
Unbelievable.
It's been a year since we've done the draft.
On the label.
You know what I can do right now?
let me see if I can find it.
And I'll just change the overlay.
Let's do this.
Jim, why don't you do that?
It's in our Google.
Why don't you do that?
And we'll bring on Murphy and then we'll cut the Cody after Murphy.
How's that?
Let's do it.
So welcome to the show.
Mr.
Anthony Murphy from Bucs On Deck.
Welcome back, buddy.
How you doing?
What's going on guys?
I stepped out after the pit and then I came back and I see Zion Rose on the screen.
And I'm like, well, let me go ahead and just jump on real quick.
Cause I know Jim's going to be, so I missed Jim's reaction to it.
So I don't, I don't know how that went.
It was actually shocked.
Yeah.
Yeah.
the Louisville propaganda has to stop.
So how bad was that Zion for before we get to the pirates?
How bad was that pick Murph?
he's a guy that's been like gaining steam like the last couple of weeks.
Right.
But like, I would imagine like if someone took him like in the middle teens, that's probably, that's what I was thinking.
Like it's highest, the highest he would go like top 10.
That seems they know, the Royals are known for this stuff.
Right.
Like they took that high school pitcher that was like way off board a couple, a couple of years ago.
It was like Frank Mozzie out of my, they took that, took him.
So like, I guess this is right up like their alley.
We see how it's worked out so well.
Yeah, exactly.
I don't think he, I don't think he made it out of a ball.
I'd say you like them or the angels.
He got drafted by the angels.
They'd be in the majors.
What?
Next week.
That's true.
He'd make his major league debut tomorrow.
Yeah.
All right, Murphy.
So shocked at Derek Curiel.
with the way that they, yeah, I would say, yeah, I'm a little shocked.
They went Curiel, but they, I posted this on like on the box.
We have a draft tracker going on right now.
I said like surprised, but maybe not really because like when you think about it, like, and you guys talked about like Justin Horwitz being here and then like the strategy for those couple of drafts.
And then now it feels like a shift back to maybe like a, like a, another focus, maybe like a little safer with, higher floor thing.
So you see things aligning back a different way.
So maybe it's not as much as surprise, but I would say it's surprised to see him go fifth overall.
Yeah.
By the way, Eric was junior selected next to the Orioles.
I've heard this before.
Jim was wrong.
What was I wrong about when you said he was going to the, Oh, never.
I said Zion.
Well, I did say, I did say, booth original, but you know what?
That was me getting bad information from somebody.
So I'm going to blame, I'm going to blame the source.
There we go.
Jim passed the bluff.
Buck Rosati.
Exactly.
Oh, but so with Curiel.
Yeah.
Murphy, certainly a name that really didn't get into like my radar until just earlier today.
I, like I said, we mentioned him on our draft show, but it was extremely brief.
I basically was like, does, I asked Jim Callis on our show, would someone like Curiel make sense here?
And his quote was, again, I'll say it, Curiel.
he likes Curiel, but said that taking him fifth quote, wouldn't make sense.
End quote.
so like, does this, does this make sense?
Because I think Curiel, as I was talking before, like really high floor, I think there's a really high floor on this guy.
I think he's a good outfielder.
I like a lot of what he does.
It's just, I don't think he's ever going to hit for power.
And I don't think anyone really thinks he's ever going to hit for power.
So taking him fifth, just when there's a lot of upside around you available, it's just, it's surprising to me.
Yeah.
I, you saw how things were going to where like the pirates wanted, how it was worded, someone who's going to move quickly to try to make an impact early.
I'm, I've always been one that's against that thing.
Cause like, if you take that mindset into the 2024 draft, like you probably don't end up with Konnor Griffin then.
So, that's one example that's probably, that's, that could be like an outlier with it and whatnot.
But I just feel like you take, you take the best player available.
You don't take a guy who's look for something specific like that.
Curiel, he was, he was a guy like, I remember him back a couple of years ago, going to the draft.
Like he was a guy that was probably going to be like, could have been like a first round pick out of, out of high school and decided to go to college.
And it paid off, paid off for him cause like, top five pick.
So.
So what should we like with him?
Well, I think the big thing that he answered was cause like his freshman year, he played left field.
So obviously there's questions about like, is he like a corner field?
He answered those questions to the point where it looks like he should be able to stick in center field.
So I guess the value you lose with not having the, any like much power, you get back with the fact that he's going to be, at a premium position in center field.
So like a solid center fielder that hits 10 to 15 home runs a year.
it's better than a corner outfielder.
That's going to hit 10 to 15 home runs a year, I guess.
So I think that's where my hesitation with Curry L is can he get to that?
Can he even get to the 10 to 15 home run mark?
Or are we talking about a guy who's going to hit two 80, hit 10 homers and steal 10 bases and play above average defense?
Because again, that's a good player.
It's just not like super impactful.
Yeah.
Not a top five pick.
So I think you hit it on the mark with the, like, he's probably gonna be like a two war player, a very solid, consistent two war player and someone you can, you're going to be able to count on to get there.
He may have like that one year to where like, everything just comes together and, it gets an extra winner, win or so, but like, it's just going to be a very consistent like, okay player, decent player.
Yeah.
So I guess the two things I have to ask here is, so like, how strong do you see the defense being center field?
Because again, like there's one thing in this defense and it's not like you see anything coming up to change it.
The defense on the Pirates is bad.
So, and you would maybe envision if, Oneil Cruz is going to move off center.
It's going to be like a corner.
That'd be fine.
So, but we know left field is spacious, center field spacious.
How good is the defense itself for him?
That may be like, again, it's an asset for this team on this ballpark.
And then also how quick do you think he moves, through the minors?
I feel like that second question is always like very dangerous to ask answer because like, there's, and then especially for someone like him, we don't have that at least like summer league with the wood bat to draw from to see like
how he, how he handled it.
Like, obviously he did stuff on the showcase circuit in high school, but obviously that's like high school level players he's facing against.
So it's something different.
So we don't have that sample size to go on from there, but like if the bat, the ball skills translate to what it was like in college that, we're looking at someone who could probably move pretty quickly through the system here.
Like, I'm not going to say like next year or something like that, but it's advanced enough to where like, I'm not like, if he goes straight to Greensboro, it probably just doesn't surprise me at all.
And like, maybe with like a, at that point we'll let things play out.
There and see how it goes.
As far as the defense, like, I think it's definitely good enough to where it's gonna translate to playing at PNC park with all that space, that space out there should see an improvement.
you can make a case that like, it's not hard to make an improvement with how the outfit defense has been, but I think it'll be like a noticeable defense, defensive improvement there.
Not just like by default, but like an actual, would him starting off in Greensboro be a disservice to Pirates fans when they see him hit 30 home runs there?
Possibility.
Yeah.
Possibility.
I thought home runs was a problem.
He's in Greensboro.
He has 30 now in 15 games.
What's the problem here?
Very much could happen.
Let's kick things over to Cody real quick.
Now that we've got it up and we'll come back.
We'll finish this up with our final thoughts and go from there.
Cause we've got a post game show coming in probably about 45 minutes.
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack, hydration, and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients with over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration
mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Right now IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack plus free shipping to get your 20% off text MLB to 64,000.
That's MLB 64,000 message and data rates may apply.
We'll see terms for details.
All right, Murphy.
I know it's hard to say.
I know it's hard to give a, give like a, like a grade of a single pick without knowing what the rest of the draft goes, but I'm going to put you on the spot here.
You, what is your, what is your grade?
Draft grade of Derek Curiel at number five.
Can I, can I go into it knowing like who the next like three or four picks have been?
Cause like I saw AJ Grassi, I got taken by the Braves and like, yeah, maybe I'm a little biased to the UVA guys, but like, I almost feel like I would have rather had him.
It's a good point.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So, like at the lowest B you can probably have at that point, that's maybe teetering on a C.
So just looking at this.
Yeah.
Looking at the, look, just looking at this pick, looking at this.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Okay.
I do have the feel, I do, I do feel like it could turn out a lot better because you're clearly going to save some money on this pick.
And there's a lot of good prep guys that should be around in the second.
Is there anyone that could have picked here that would have been an A for you right off the bat?
Like what would have been the A pick?
Like when you saw that Flora went to the Giants, you obviously had someone in your mind where it'd be like, I would pick X player here.
Who would that have been?
Eric Booth.
That was, that was the guy that I was leaning to.
I get the, there's some swing concerns with him.
Like if you look at it too, apparently he's tweaked on it, but like there, it's a little bit of a chopping action.
So they're wondering how much he's going to get the ball in the air.
But even if he doesn't like you're talking 70, 80, great speed, great defense.
And then if by chance he does, they do something where the ball's in the air, that's 20, 25 home runs with how he, how hard he eats the ball.
So that was my guy at that point, at this point.
And Booth went seven, Burris went eight.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I'm with you, man.
Like I would have gone, I would have, I would have been fine flipping a coin between Booth and Burris to be honest with you, Curry L again.
I'm not, I can't really get mad at this pick because I do like him.
Yeah.
But I just feel like there was more upside available.
That's my stance here.
And I think if you go back in the group chat that I have, with the, on the site, you can probably find a point to where I made some comment about the pirates taking Curry L at the beginning of the college season.
Like, I don't know.
I like, so yeah.
Heading into this year, I remember, I remember there was either, there was, I think there was like a baseball America way too early mock draft.
Like it wasn't even an official mock draft of theirs and Curry L was the pick at five.
so like he was a guy who was in this mix at the beginning of the year.
But I think when, you saw a second straight college season where like, he really didn't overwhelm you with any power.
He just did the same thing he did as a freshman, which was being a good hitter.
Like he was a good hitter at LSU at the best, in the best conference in America.
but it's just, where are we looking at 116 college games?
No, 126 college games played, 13 homers with metal bats.
Yeah.
So yeah, we'll see.
he had three 53 follow up, followed up his three 45.
Freshman year.
Again, he's been incredibly, he's been on the radar for a long time because even when he was in high school, he was a top prospect and was essentially just like, I'm going to
go to LSU and really just performed right off the bat.
So he's the new version of Dylan Cruz in that aspect, I think where like everyone, like Dylan Cruz was really good forever.
Didn't go, didn't go where he wanted to out of high school, went to LSU, played really well, but less power than Cruz, obviously.
Like I'm not comparing the two players.
I'm more comparing like their story.
like Derek Curiel is someone who, if you follow prospects, you've known Derek Curiel's name for three years.
So what is your Curiel comp?
What player is his comp?
I like the, what is it?
I saw, well, obviously there's one like a Christian Yelich, except they don't think Yelich is going to, they don't think he'll grow into the power.
Like Yelich did.
I saw another one too, where they said like, he's a six foot three, Steven Kwan.
So you want mine?
Now I would not, I wouldn't be mad about either of those guys.
Like what are we complaining about?
But like, is it Steven Kwan because the defense also like, is this defense on Steven Kwan level?
Cause I feel like that's where Steven Kwan also makes his bread and butter.
I think, I think that was probably leaning more towards like the hit, just like the hitting, the hitting tools and stuff like that.
So less, I think he's, but I think he's Alex Verdugo who can play center field.
That's who that like, that's my comp here.
Like, and hold on, like, let's be real.
Like you look at Alex Verdugo's prime, way to runs created plus one 12, one 25, one Oh six, one Oh two batting averages, two 94, three Oh eight, two 89, two 80.
It's just the home runs, six to 13.
It was this range.
Like he just, the power never really came, but he was a good hitter for a four to five year for a five year stretch.
Alex Verdugo was a league average outfielder.
And I think that's who I think that's who you're getting.
You're getting Alex Verdugo who plays center field.
It's rough day.
Yeah, that's not that.
Alex, are you saying, but like, that's who we've been saying to our player this whole time, right?
Do you go in his prime at 23, 2.2, 24, 1.6, 25, 1.9, 1.1.5.
Like that's, we've been, we've been saying this guy is Alex Verdugo the whole time without saying Alex Verdugo's name.
That's who I see here.
And you know what?
Alex Verdugo is just fine, but that's it.
Yeah.
And he was just fine for five years.
He's just never like, he never hit the ball over the fence.
The career 270 hitter never hit the ball.
And we just jokingly chatted about Nick Gonzales and the similarities just with the hit tool.
When Nick Gonzales was starting in the minor leagues, the swing and miss was ridiculous.
Do you think there's any concern that it might be that type of situation?
Or is there something in there that might take a while to develop?
Because it did take Nick Gonzales to a long time to come around to this version of what he is right now.
I think you always run that risk with anything, making the switch to like wood and stuff like that.
That's why I think so many teams value like those summer leagues, like the Cape and whatnot, because it gives them a good, at least, even if it's a small sample size, a couple of games, how they, how they handle spin with the wood.
And so, yeah, there's a possibility, but it's one of those things.
Let's get them in here and we'll find out.
like I saw, what is it?
Overslot baseball, Joe Doran, he, they had like an 80 grade, he had like an 80 grade or a 70 grade hit tool for Curiel.
So like just about everyone's feeling pretty confident about the bat to ball skills.
I feel like I've heard this before.
Yeah.
Oh no.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I'm seeing these like baseball America, 60 hit tool pipeline, 60 hit tool, fan graph, 60 hit tool.
So like everyone's pretty on board with, he's going to be able to hit.
Yeah.
What was Nick Gonzales's?
At draft time.
Yeah.
Let's take a peek here.
Nick Gonzales at draft time.
We'll just go baseball America since I'm here.
That's not how you spell Gonzalez.
While he's looking at what are you guys instant grades on it?
I don't go ahead.
I think the thing is this type of pick is one where you have to defer your grade to see what happens later.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Well, I got put on the spot.
So that means you guys get put on the spot for the same.
No, it's our show.
We can put you on the spot if we want and not for us if we want.
Okay.
but I guess if you're taking it like pick for pick, just as what it is, I'm a, I guess I'm a little more down.
I'm probably a C plus.
That's right.
I think that's fair.
But again, like I do think this is the reason you do this pick is because something later.
So it's like once the draft is complete, you can have a better grade of what this allowed later on for.
Yeah.
I'll give them, I'll give it a B minus just because I think they got a major leaguer out of it.
And that's half the battle with this whole thing.
I'll get.
Oh yeah.
Oh, Esmerlyn Valdez do it, Esmerlyn Valdez do it, the magic.
He did it.
Did he hit a grand Esmerlyn Valdez?
Oh my God.
Two runs.
Want to be in a grand slam?
Oh, get your t-shirts now.
Yeah.
Piss on the draft.
Oh my God.
I bump up the grade to a B plus now.
That's fair.
God, what a swing.
Wow.
Down six, three.
Faces loaded.
God, I love that.
I love that kid so much.
Hell yes.
Yeah.
Again, why I wasn't so concerned about the development part of these other guys, like a booth or whomever.
I think, I think he's probably, Valdez is probably like the, if you want to showcase, Hey, this is what we can do.
Like he is like the guy because like the progress he's made over the last couple of years, watch, watching him from like, I was down there watching him in Bradenton and I've seen him every year since then.
And it's just how he's progressed.
It's just been incredible.
I love Esmerlyn Valdez.
What did it, Pat?
Dude is a dude.
And also how stupid are you putting, like you're letting him face, dude just rakes versus lefties.
Like what a managerial malpractice letting a left-handed pitcher face Esmerlyn Valdez at this point in a big spot.
How dare Don Kelly do that for the Brewers?
He didn't really even get all of that.
No.
God, I love that.
Love him.
Okay.
So what were your all's grades?
So Murphy, your B minus.
Yeah.
DiNardo, your C plus.
Tyler, your B minus too.
Yeah.
I think they got a major leader out of it.
And also Valdez.
Can I say this without being like judged too hard?
Partially, I'm going to say it's a C plus.
Like it's passing, like it's a passable pick.
I get it.
I don't think it's bad, but like I'm, I don't think it's good either.
I think that's fair.
I think, I think in my head when I was like the lowest B, I was thinking like in number sense, like what's the lowest number grade you can give before it's a C plus.
And that's where I was at.
Yeah.
Yeah.
If this were a test, it's, they got a, they got what a 70.
I got 79% on it.
Yeah.
78.
Why did you preface that the way you did?
You're like, can I say this?
I'll be in general.
And you gave a grade that basically aligned with everybody else.
I'm waiting for you to say an F.
Every time I don't, like, I'm not positive.
People think I'm whining.
So like, I don't want to go off as a whiner here, but I'm, I'm disappointed.
You need to be more negative than that way.
They don't call you a whiner.
It's expected.
What I wanted to say to this without, again, you're going down that path.
Let's open up that Pandora's box.
Is this, is this pick the equivalent of last night's trade?
See, I like Jacob Gonzalez quite a bit.
I don't, I would put last night's trade above a C plus just because like without knowing the construction of the lineup, I think it was a good trade.
It was surprising.
Like this was, they did surprise.
Hey, give it to the Pirates.
They've surprised me twice now in the last 14 hours.
Well, I also apparently surprised, yeah, a lot of people that's why like I said last night, like I wouldn't be opposed to having those players in this system.
I'm just underwhelmed with the return because of that pick.
And it's like, you have the fifth pick and I'm just very underwhelmed in this draft pick.
Yeah.
I think equally underwhelmed in both.
if you're, if you're watching here, put your comment in your, give us your grade.
Gold Kings is saying this is a C plus.
I know that we were going through grades and then all of a sudden Esmerlin Valdez, went off, but yeah, throw your grades in the chat and we'll put them up on your screen on the screen.
thinking about it and seeing how like the first start, the rest of the top 10 like unfolded because it looks like it was a Tyler Bell went to the Rockies.
it just feels like everyone is taking, no one really felt confident with this top 10, top 15.
Like there's just so many names there and it was unclear that it's like, let's see what we can do.
This draft for a lot of teams is going to be judged by what they do with their next couple of picks.
Cause it looks like everyone's going to be saving a little bit on these picks here.
So what they do, the, they got the two second round picks, what they do with those two second round picks is probably going to determine how we look at this draft.
And it's seems like that's the approach overall with everyone too.
Cause you look at the Royals with Zion Rose and so don't, they weren't confident with that.
No one else stood out after those top three guys.
Nobody stood out after those top three guys.
So let's just go with, who's going to take that a little bit less and then we'll load up with the next pick or something like that.
I'm with you.
the one thing that this draft does have going for it is it is deep, especially if you want to look at like high school arms, like that's something that we haven't seen any high school pitchers taken yet, but like, this is a deep draft
when it comes to that.
And that is a, that is a demographic that the pirates have historically performed well in.
So yeah, I wouldn't be too surprised to see the pirates go high school arm, high school arm here with these next two picks, maybe go a little bit over slot on both of them to make sure they get them in the system.
And then all of a sudden you're like, okay, I understand what they did, but I also think like, was anybody, was any pick at five going to be like, you probably could have gotten any of these guys under slot at five.
What is it going to be on?
The first pick is getting like almost 2 million under slot.
So yeah.
So we'll see.
We'll see how the rest of the draft goes.
we're on pick what?
12 right now.
Chris Hacopian.
Angels are up.
So next week's starter.
I hope.
Yeah.
to go back to Nick Gonzales, he had a 60 hit tool court in the pipeline.
Okay.
I don't know if Jim ever found best baseball America.
Oh, baseball America had him at 70.
Okay.
Yeah.
He was the number five player in that draft, according to baseball America with a 70 hit tool.
Angels took a prep kid.
So I don't think, yeah.
don't put it past them.
Yeah.
Well, this is a two way kid too.
All right.
Do we got anything more to add here?
Or we want to, we want to go watch the rest of this game.
It's the eighth inning.
Pirates are up by one.
See if the bullpen can hang on here.
Are you leaving Carmen Mlodzinski in for the rest of this game?
He's a 50 pitches.
Yes.
Yes.
Burn him for me.
I'll have to pitch for another break.
As long as he remains effective.
Yeah.
Go ahead and keep him in.
Yeah.
Burn him.
He hasn't really been that effective though.
He can't pitch.
He can't pitch again until the, till next week.
Anyways.
Yep.
You want to start his workload?
Here you go, buddy.
Yep.
All right.
Let's go.
I'm putting on grades here.
B minus C plus we've got a D.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I'm probably going, actually, I'm probably going Soto in the ninth.
I'm letting Mlodzinski finish off this eighth.
I'm going Soto in the ninth.
It depends where I haven't watched him, but yeah, like he has two hits.
I'm sorry.
Three hits, two walks, only one strike out in the 2.1.
He's also given up six hard hits in the 2.1 innings.
Yeah.
He's already over 50 pitches too.
Yeah.
Let him finish this off.
Yeah.
And then if he can clean this up, you got the top of the order.
So you probably want a lefty.
Yeah.
Hey, fair enough.
All right.
Well, hey, hopefully we're giving away Primanti Brothers sandwiches on the North Shore nine post game show powered by Primanti Brothers.
Cody and Doug will have that coming up, right?
Yep.
No, Cody and Nathan, I think.
Oh, Cody and Nathan.
That's right.
Cody and Nathan.
with that, with that post game show.
And then you and Doug are game two.
Yep.
Yep.
Got it.
Yeah.
So stay tuned.
That's quick.
if you have time, right.
Game two starts at four Oh five.
Vandal has the pirates plus one 10 with Bubba Chandler on the mound.
So do what you want with that underdogs.
Yeah.
But who knows?
It could rain out.
It's there's a lot of sunshine.
Before we get off here though, Murphy, what all do you guys got going on the Bucs On Deck sub stack for today.
And really the rest of this weekend, just, up to the minute coverage on, we're going to, I'll be around watching the entire draft.
So I'll be updating the tracker.
And as I find insight on each player, maybe find some videos and stuff like that.
We have a draft tracker that's pinned to the front of the site.
You just go there and you can see all the pics and any information I'm able to find any video I'm able to find.
There we go.
Yeah.
Make sure you head over to the Bucs On Deck sub stack, check out Murphy and his team's work.
It's outstanding.
We are, I think going to wrap up here, but the pirates have picked 44.
They have picked 51 still to go today.
They're going what?
10 rounds today, Murphy.
Just four rounds.
Okay.
All right.
That 10 would have been too much, but check out the comments.
I just put their Bucs On Deck dot sub stack.com.
Check out Andy Murphy and the crew.
They do a great job.
mostly when you remember the drafts on Saturday.
Yeah.
Yeah.
No, I, yeah, that was, I had, I had to call you out there right now.
I laughed for him all week.
Yeah.
Yeah.
No, we appreciate you coming on here.
Saying, yeah, no, it's on Saturday.
And I had to redo my entire schedule for this weekend.
Now we appreciate you coming on here and, make sure you check out Murphy and I just dropped our weekly episode of Bucs On Deck this morning.
We talked about, do scores in this morning.
So yeah, check him out.
The deuce is loose.
We're ready to get out of here.
Let's get out of here.
Pirates have a 86.7% win probability.
So let's watch the rest of this game.
Let's find out what happens.
Let's go box.
Sounds like bad mojo saying.
Bye-bye.
Peace out, our scouts.
See you guys.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North shore nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up and don't forget to hit that subscribe button.
If you haven't already, it really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support and Let's Go Bucs.
Bye-bye.
Bye-bye.


Comments· 0
Was Derek Curiel worth the No. 5 pick, or should the Pirates have gone for upside like Eric Booth or Drew Burris?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.