◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)
Two weeks into spring training, NS9LIVE! took a step back and asked the big question: do the Pirates’ offseason moves already feel like they’re paying off?
With Anthony DiNardo, Doug (“Dougie Fresh”), Nate, and Pirates beat writer Alex Stumpf at The Cut Golf & Grill, the conversation centered on how different this roster looks — and how quickly the newcomers are fitting in. Jhostynxon Garcia (a.k.a. “The Password”) has flashed what the Pirates hoped for: improved at-bat quality, athleticism, and the kind of daily work that makes you believe there’s more ceiling to unlock. Brandon Lowe has looked like the middle-of-the-order presence this lineup has been missing for years, while Jake Mangum has been every bit the grinder fans were told to expect — energy, defense, baserunning, and a “do anything to win” vibe that plays anywhere.
But the biggest ripple might be the leadership layer. Marcell Ozuna’s influence was a major theme, especially how it’s resonating with the Latin players and the way it’s already showing up with Oneil Cruz. Ryan O’Hearn‘s comments about the group giving off “past Orioles” vibes added fuel to the optimism: a team that believes it’s on the verge of taking a real step.
Stumpf also broke down the trade that happened tonight where the Pirates sent Kyle Nicolas and in return landed Tyler Callihan from the Reds.
Watch the full NS9LIVE! episode on YouTube and catch the audio feed wherever you listen to podcasts, then tell us: which offseason move feels like the biggest difference-maker so far?
Comments· 0
The Debate
Should Jhostynxon Garcia make the Opening Day roster over Billy Cook, or play every day in AAA?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Anthony DiNardo and Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Trading Kyle Nicholas was the right call: great stuff never turned into production, and the Pirates have held onto too many middling players they were attached to.
2
Tyler Callihan could platoon at third base with Jared Triolo, who has crushed left-handed pitching but struggled against righties.
3
If Jhostynxon Garcia keeps raking this spring (.538 so far) and outhits guys like Jake Mangum, he belongs on the Opening Day roster over Billy Cook instead of in AAA.
4
Losing Mike Burrows hurts: he'll make an All-Star team for Houston. But you have to give up talent to get Brandon Lowe, Jake Mangum and Mason Montgomery.
5
Paul Skenes will be the biggest beneficiary of the improved lineup. No more losing 2-1 games, and he might win 20.
Yo, welcome to NS9 Live, presented by FanDuel. I'm your host, Anthony DiNardo. To my right is Dougie Fresh, and to my left is Alex J. Stump. What's up, fellas? How you doing tonight?
Doing good. We're at The Cut. This place is fantastic. We love it. So I couldn't be happier.
Yeah, I got to add to that. So again, I was jealous seeing that you guys, this is your second time. So I'm really jealous about you now, but I saw week one crew was here and the food looked tremendous. So of course I was like, hey guys, can we come back? Like, of course. So first off, shout out to The Cut for welcoming us back for the second week here. And yes, I got the experience of food and it's fantastic.
They're so nice. The service is outstanding. The food is great. It's unbelievable. We're in a world that customer service doesn't really exist anymore. And these people are fantastic.
Absolutely. What's your thoughts on the food?
I liked it.
But so we have some like breaking news, I guess, to put on here and we were getting ready for this show. I felt like all day we're talking about what should we talk about tonight? Because that's like the gift and the curse about being here for two weeks for spring training when you're doing fuck a brew in the morning and it's not live at night.
A game, a pregame show if you made before, then a wrap up. there's that time doing two, three shows a day. What do you talk about? That's different.
And, we thought about it's like, you know what, let's revisit all the moves that happened this off season.
And like after two weeks of seeing spring training, like what we think about that. But then Ben Cherington said, hold up, guys, we're going to give you some news.
So thank you, Ben. We have something to talk about. It's the winner of Ben. It is the winner of Ben. So Kyle Nicholas was traded to the Reds. And I thought, who better to bring on, right? Alex is right here. Let's talk to Alex about this trade.
So, yeah, the Pirates swing a trade with the Reds. They send Kyle Nicholas to them and they get back a second outfielder, third baseman, maybe?
Yeah, infielder, outfielder mix right there. Left-handed hitter, which has been the MO this entire offseason.
Some offensive output. or in potential to. What's his name?
Tyler Callihan. There we go. I can't remember. I'm sure about Callihan. Only 90 something percent on Tyler.
It's Callihan. You're throwing me off my rhythm here. I'm sorry there, Alex. I just we haven't mentioned his name yet.
It is Tyler Callihan. There we go. Or is it Kiahan? Kiahan. Kiahan. We get a confirmation on the last name here?
I did not get confirmation. We haven't been the best over this past week.
No, but this is someone who I think is going to factor into the infield mix, maybe even third base, which is something that, they look to add this offseason.
I think that's what I think is going to happen. I think it's going to be the best outfielder mix, but, double some pop in the mix there.
So I could see the appeal here. I would be lying, though, if I expected Kyle Nicholas to be traded right now.
Okay. Yeah. So, let me ask you my first question on this, because like when you see it now, I've never been high on Kyle Nicholas as it is.
And obviously the way this bullpen is shaping up seems like he wasn't outside looking in anyway.
So, you can understand why they're looking to maybe trade him away in some degree, like if there's something that can fill in.
But when I look at like what he was traded for, I don't know.
Again, I'm looking, of course, just fan graphs right away.
Like, what is, who is this guy? And you're not seeing a whole lot of pop.
it's 25, going to be 26 this year.
Is this what you utilize, Kyle Nicholas for?
is he true actual depth or is this just like another guy?
It's like, hey, we like this guy.
I'm not sure if it's this team.
I'm not sure the talent's truly there.
But, this is a team that does need depth at their base or around the infield for sure.
So, I don't know. what's your first take on this?
I think you nailed it with, you need depth in the infield for sure, especially on the left side.
Like, we've talked so much about, will Konnor Griffin make the opening day team?
What if he doesn't? What if he doesn't?
Like, what if he just, he's looked great so far, but if he doesn't or, for whatever reason, you don't have a lot of options before this trade.
You had like Triolo, you had Nick Gonzales, who I did not want to see every day at shortstop.
I don't think he could really do the position well every day.
So, this adds a little more depth, adds a little more either in AAA depth or if you do call up Connor to start the year.
And if you don't call up Connor, it's not as dire and thin a situation as it was before.
But there's so, like, I see the appeal there.
And also, even if he's got to play, like, third base, like, that would be a good platoon partner, potentially, for Triolo, who has crushed left-handed pitching, but has struggled against right-handers.
So, if you want to go that route, there's that option there.
I could see a couple different ways where he could make an impact with this team.
And as for Kyle Nicholas, like you said, like, I figured he was going to be on the outside looking in to start the year just because they have some other guys they like in the bullpen.
I figured he was going to be some form of up-down to start the year.
I'm not saying that, you can't just stay up at some point.
Like, someone like Isaac Mattson is a good example of an up-down guy who just showed him, like, no, he's just up.
But I think we all know the stuff is there, but the ERA hasn't been.
So, like, if you could sell relatively high to another team that values that type of arm that the Pirates do, like, you got to explore it.
Yeah, no, for sure.
And I appreciate that.
So, you make some good points here because, again, like, Kyle Nicholas, I know he has enticing stuff, right?
But he's never really put it together.
So, right, being this guy, there's some depth.
Now, you're putting this Konnor Griffin, what if he doesn't start into the egos?
I don't like that.
I don't like that.
Let's not speak it into existence, but I understand it.
You have to assume.
I get it.
There are a hundred different reasons why he could.
There are a hundred different reasons why he couldn't.
Sure.
So, again, in this world that I don't live in, that does exist in his outfit that Konnor Griffin does start off in AAA, which, again, like, you can make that argument.
I understand.
I don't agree.
But I guess this does that.
But in that scenario, what do you think transpires then?
Like, do you foresee this as, like, a Nick Gonzales at short stopping, starting off?
Or is this maybe like, hey, the situation where Jared can now take over short and maybe this is happening at third base?
just pure speculation.
I would think it would be more likely Jared plays short.
Like, we haven't seen Callihan play short in a professional game before.
And, like, even then, he hasn't played.
He's played, like, one game at third base since 2022.
So, like, I – it's just based off of what I believe and, just a couple texts shot out.
Like, it's – I think he is going to be a potential candidate for third base right there.
We don't know for sure, though, right now.
But even if he's just going to stick on the right side, that's more depth.
That gives you more flexibility on how you want to deploy, Nick Gonzales.
How you want to deploy maybe, like, Spencer Horwitz or someone like that.
So, there are ways that I could see him fitting into this team.
The positional flexibility is only a plus.
Sure.
And, again, man of the people.
Doug, what was your first thoughts on this?
Well, I had hoped that Bill Murphy could get a hold of Nick Gonzales and make something out of him.
But I really didn't expect that.
They seem to be putting together a nice bullpen.
And they've done that now the last, say, year or two.
I don't know much about Nick Callihan.
He seems like a Ben Chankton special.
We're getting a guy that played second base most of his career.
And we're going to put him in a different position because that's what we like to do, you know.
He's going to play some outfield.
He's going to, maybe play third base.
I imagine he's probably not going to have a lot of impact.
I also imagine that Nick Gonzales and Nick Yorke don't like the idea of this trade.
It's more competition for them.
And sometimes they like the shiny new toy more than what they have in front of them.
So, hey, look, the kid can run a little bit.
It's always nice to have some speed.
He does have a little bit of pomp in there.
I don't care who produces as long as they produce.
I don't want to get too attached to, we've had a lot of middling players.
And we're like, oh, this guy, how can we let him go?
Oh, we let him go because he's not very good.
And that's the situation, I think, with Kyle Nicklaus.
Right.
Great stuff.
But, there's a million baseball players that we said have great stuff that you don't remember his name anymore because he wasn't able to do anything.
Shout out to the 2021 Pittsburgh Pirates.
Right.
Exactly.
there's more to it than great stuff.
There's more to it than exit velocity.
I know you guys don't agree with me.
There's, you actually have to translate it into production.
And Nick, Kyle Nicklaus hasn't been able to do that.
And hopefully Tyler, how you had, I think he's the son of Tommy boy.
He was in the break business and got into baseball.
Yeah.
So, again, I think that's all valid.
I'm interested now.
You mentioned the kids.
Again, I don't really know much about them.
I'm setting up as this trade happened.
you talk how he got injured, broke his arm, I believe, ran into the outfield wall.
Yeah.
Arms cut short.
Yeah.
Right.
So, is there, again, where I look at it, the first glance is you look at the numbers.
They're not fantastic.
And it's 25 going to be 26.
Is this something more of like, he probably was going to see the big leagues last year and get a lot of run or something because of the injury that derailed it?
Yeah.
The injury, I think it's safe to say he would have gotten a lot longer run since he had not been for that.
Okay.
And, again, like you were talking, that was a playoff team.
this wasn't just like, the run of the mill team.
he was going to see some action.
Again, a little bit late.
But so maybe there is something there with this.
Yeah.
like I said, not to sound like a broken record.
I do see upside here.
Like I know what you said, like the numbers aren't the sexiest, but it was like a 126 WRC plus in 2024, like a 150 something in his month in 2025 before he got called up.
Like, I'm not saying that's setting the world on fire, but he wasn't overmatched at the highest level of AAA and then comes up to the major leagues and, busts his ass trying to make a play.
Like, I can't fault a guy for that.
So, and he did mention too, like he was the number 20 prospect 19 or 20.
Yeah.
Like, it's not like this is a waiver wire.
This is, I don't get Josh Van Meter vibes on this.
You know what?
That's fair.
Yeah.
That's to put it as blunt terms as possible because shout out to the 2021 Pittsburgh fire to 2022.
My bad.
Yeah.
Where's first base?
I know it's here somewhere, but okay.
And again, we're talking about a reliever probably was going to make the club anyways with the depth, though.
There is some stuff there.
Like he is a guy that I think a lot of pitching coaches in baseball will say, like, let me get my hands on him and I can fix Kyle Nicholas.
Oh, for sure.
But at the same time, you have to recognize what if he doesn't do it here?
And are you servicing your team the best just with that, hoping that he does?
Are you servicing the player the best of just hoping that all comes together?
So I do see a scenario where Kyle Nicholas would have been really good in Pittsburgh and he would have been a good part of the bullpen.
But like Doug said, we've seen a lot of guys who have great stuff that just can't bring it all together.
And at this point of his career, he fell into that camp.
So if you can cash out and get someone who could contribute at a potential position of need who has offensive upside, you have to seriously consider that trade.
And that's what they did here.
Okay. Yeah. And I guess my thought, maybe Doug, input on this too.
again, you're talking about Kyle Nicholas.
He's probably just depth, but, and you've talked about Antoine.
you've talked, what, we had you on the point, I think.
There's not a whole lot of depth on the left side of the field next, you know.
So I guess maybe you look at this like it's the depth for depth.
is that how you perceive this maybe too?
Yeah. And I also, I think how, what we've seen from our Katie and Clevenger, it's like, we may have some bullpen arms, right?
someone's a fifth starter, someone's in the bullpen.
Right. And then maybe they really like what they're seeing from Bidouin, which we've liked.
Montgomery, there are some guys there that could step right into the Kyle Nicholas role.
So, yeah, like I said, they're putting together what looks to be, could be a very effective bullpen.
And you're right, we've not been getting production from the left side of the field.
If you get someone with a little bit of upside, I think it's a good trade.
You take a chance, they don't all work out, but the idea behind it, I think, is right.
It's the winter of Ben.
Right. we've traded a name we're familiar with and a guy who, again, we've somewhat been tantalized about the potential for someone we don't know much about.
But it seems like a very low-risk move to me, right?
We're not counting.
No one said that Tyler Caroline's going to come in, he's going to start at third base, and we're expecting 30 home runs and 100 RBIs.
That's fair.
No, we've just added another guy, throw into the mix.
I wish I could stay another week and maybe see him play.
The only real risk I see is with just the bullpen depth, because whenever we talked on the point, whenever we just talk in general with this bullpen, I think a lot of people feel good about a couple pieces here.
But you're also counting on someone has to emerge and take that next step.
And, like, Cal Nicholas was one of those potential guys.
Ryan Harvin was one of those potential guys, and he's hurt right now.
So you're – you still have plenty of potential lottery tickets here, and you only need one or two to hit, to really be in a really great spot.
But it is one less one.
Sure.
Okay.
Yeah.
I guess to me, I'm counting this, too.
Like, if you see it – again, I wasn't that high on Cal Nicholas to begin with.
I don't know much about this guy.
It doesn't look that sexy.
But, again, like, it's depth for depth in my eyes.
It gave someone who had – you had some depth at, to some level, right, to get some depth out of a position you don't have.
They didn't really strike anything at third base.
So, like, it is going to be Trillo heading in here probably if Konnor Griffin starts.
And if not, it gives them options at third base still.
So, all right.
I think that's fair enough.
And I just want to say, again, before we let you go here, Alex, you are down here in three days, about-ish, right?
So, how's spring training going for you?
It's good to be around the ball club, see some players, see some coaches.
Different vibe than last year.
He's got a – we're just talking, like, the Pepsi test here.
I've seen it.
But, like, vibes seem pretty good this year.
Well, that's good to hear because, again, that's something that, like, we've been hearing.
And not even just hearing, but also, like, physically taking in as well.
you've seen – Yeah, like I said, I've been down here almost two weeks now.
I'm seeing it.
It is dramatically different than it was last year.
That does not necessarily translate into wins.
But I've become more optimistic based on what I've seen.
Baseball's a long, 162-game grind.
And if you're feeling good about it going in rather than, your head dragging, that thing, I think they can only help.
It certainly can't hurt, right?
Sure.
That people are feeling a little more optimistic.
They're feeling a little better, a little more excited about what's going on.
And, yeah, I'm buying in.
I'm getting sucked in.
Every year I try to tell myself to, dial it back and slow your roll, all that thing.
But, we added three actual hitters and a fourth in Mangum, right?
And it looks, again, we can get on with other stuff.
But Garcia, I like what I'm seeing.
I like what I'm seeing.
And the way the team is produced March 4th, and still, the guys that you want to see hit, except for maybe Henry Davis, the guys that you want to see hit are hitting, right?
Like, Jake Mangum looks like he's going to be, an impactful player.
And so does Brandon Lowe, and so does O'Hearn, and so does Azuna.
And Bryan Reynolds looks better, and Oneil Cruz looks better.
hey, I'm enjoying every minute of it.
It is much different than last year, where everybody, it was a hospital waiting room.
I think Tyler said it was a morgue, you know.
it's, yeah, it didn't seem like anybody wanted to be here last year, except us.
Sounds like Doug's Pirate's pill.
He bought into the winter.
He bought in.
Yeah.
Yeah, he bought into the winter.
Yeah, I got to trade my period full stop shirt for winter of Ben shirt.
But, no, it is nice to hear from your perspective.
Again, here's our perspective.
You're certainly in the thick of things from last year and beyond.
So, you coming back to spring training this week, seeing, feeling some different vibes, it's good to hear that perspective as well.
So, before I make the switch off and let you go ahead and enjoy the cut some more with our fantastic food and drinks, any last words you want to say?
I'm intrigued by the trade.
We're going to end with that.
We're just going to end with a very, I'm not saying good trade, bad trade.
I'm intrigued by it.
All right.
Benoit Blanc, you're like, it compels me, though.
All right.
Well, appreciate you coming on.
A little word from our sponsors, and we'll have Nate back on, and we'll talk about the vibes about spring training, and I'll look back at these trades.
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low-sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix sticks, and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
And we're back.
So, we got Nate back on with us.
Yeah, so you're making your NS9 Live debut basically right here as well, right?
I guess so.
He's like, I guess so.
But, yeah, so now you've been here for this week as well.
Doug has been here for the week and a half, almost two weeks.
I've been here last weekend, now this week, and again, I get it.
Like, it's almost two weeks of spring training.
spring training numbers don't matter to begin with, right?
And certainly, as we keep phrasing everything of like, well, it's only February 28th.
Well, it's only March 3rd, right?
I know these numbers don't matter too much, but we're starting to see some sample.
We're starting to see some production.
And, since we've talked about Konnor Griffin 38 times in the last 13 days, maybe we could talk about something different.
And, we collaborated and was like, why don't we revisit these moves?
And now that we're seeing them in motion, you're picking up on the vibes.
Let's talk about that.
And, the first move was making the trade with Boston for the password, right?
And I know we all talked about it.
I was like, well, this can't be the answer.
I don't hate the trade in itself, but it can't be the answer, which, of course, it wasn't.
Right.
But I know there's a couple of people here that want to talk about him specifically.
So I'm going to give you two the floor.
Let's start with Doug.
Right.
The biggest reason that we weren't thrilled with that trade is because it was the first move of the offseason.
Right.
And we're being told, we're going to the playoffs period, full stop.
We're trying to win this year.
We are going to spend more money this year.
And then we trade, a guy that I expected to start the, season in the rotation, Yohan Oviedo, a guy we all liked a lot, a guy who had done quite well here for a minor league outfielder.
So, and then it was a minor league outfielder that had some contact issues and, just like, oh, here we go again.
We've got another outfielder, another player who can't hit.
And so I was, I don't want to say I was down on the trade, they were, they had to add stuff.
They had to get in some people other than G1 Bay and Jackson whiskey, so I wasn't really down on it, but I wasn't that enthused about it.
And then as we made these other moves, you're like, okay, now, all right.
So now he's not just being handed the starting job.
Now he has to earn his spot, that thing.
And he has impressed me more every time I've seen him.
He is a good baseball player.
He's making good contact.
He's got some pop that he can run.
He feels the positions.
Well, he's thrown a runner out.
He couldn't do any more than what he's done so far.
And so, now my question about him isn't, can he play, he's, I don't think he's going to languish in AAA all year.
He's going to get opportunities here.
It's going to be challenging, right?
Because you, if you, he's up here, you want him having bats.
I don't, you don't want him in the Alexander Canario road and it starts once every 10 days.
And, you obviously have Reynolds, Cruz, O'Hearn and Mangum.
So, the only way that he gets up here is, probably if somebody gets hurt or somebody becomes very effective and because you want him getting really consistent at bats.
but yeah, I liked it.
I'm more on board with the trade.
I'm going to miss Oviado this year.
I know I am.
I'm going to miss, and we'll talk about him later.
Mike Burrows.
I'm going to, those are two guys that I had high hopes for this year, but on, from what I've seen from the trade so far, Jhostynxon Garcia is a good baseball player.
He seems to be putting in the work.
He's got all the raw skills and, just going to, keep working at it.
And I can see him improving and being better.
And I can see him playing for the pirates for a long time.
So let me pass it over to you.
And before I do, I think it was valid and Tyler, I felt was like the forefront of this.
he's the one that actually made the graphic on Instagram, got some reception with that good and bad, but I think it's fair to say, this trade could, of course, end up being good for the pirates.
Like it could absolutely be good for the pirates.
But I think the question is it going to be good for the pirates in 2026?
go back to Doug said, Ovieto.
I think there's a lot of hopes for Ovieto, like he was, he could be a workhorse, the injuries derailed him, but like he has the body.
He could certainly be a workhorse for a team that needs someone to give him innings.
I think there's upside for him.
And again, he is, he's in the rotation this year where Garcia, well, he was a prospect and he saw us to develop and, is he going to even start on the opening day teams?
so there was a lot of thought of like, does this team, does this trade actually even help 2026?
Or is it just a future thing?
I think you have some interesting takes.
you definitely want to talk about Garcia.
So give us your thoughts and feedback on that as well.
Yeah, I really liked the trade and I still do.
So I think Yohan Ovieto was a great addition to the pitching staff to have, but of all the pitchers you could have traded at the time, he was probably the top of my list just because the injury history.
Okay.
Something that he has dealt with and in lack of innings last couple of years because of that.
Now, just since in Garcia, when he was traded to the Pirates, the top five prospect in the Red Sox organization and a top 100 in MLB.
So I was like, we just got a top 100 pitcher player, I guess it is, for a pitcher that has been injured multiple times.
Fine with me.
Now, here's the question with Joe Simpson Garcia after all these moves, or it's like, I know Tyler brought this up and saying like you traded pitching depth at the time.
We didn't know the other moves were going to happen.
Right.
We didn't know Brandon Lowe was happening.
We didn't know Burroughs was getting moved.
But at the time, you traded probably the least of that pitching depth that you can maybe afford to move.
How dare you?
And I liked Oviedo, too.
Don't get me wrong.
Sure.
But he was the pitcher that I think I was most comfortable with moving this offseason rather than Burroughs.
Because I like the upside of Burroughs more so than Yohan Oviedo.
Okay.
But with Joe Simpson Garcia, I like his upside.
I know Jim was really 50-50 on him because he has some strikeout concerns in the minor leagues.
I personally don't care about that because he has been really fun to watch this spring training.
And my vibes on him were already very high when the trade happened.
But seeing him, he's hitting .538 in spring right now.
Now, sure, it's only two weeks.
Don't get me wrong, two weeks.
But this is also the best shape of his life here, by the way.
So, as you told me yesterday.
What about the hair, though?
Yeah, it's great.
Okay.
I got a good picture of him, too.
All right.
Sitting behind home plate yesterday.
But it was funny.
Like, you told me yesterday, like, your password pilled.
I got Cody password pilled, too.
Because here's the question I have to ask about just Simpson Garcia.
I don't want him going to AAA just so he can get the reps.
If he's good enough to be on the team, he should be on the team.
He should get that opportunity.
Because he clearly, like, the Red Sox had that outfield jam.
People were like, he's going to get more opportunities in Pittsburgh.
Right.
You had Roman Anthony.
You had Will Yerbray.
You had Rafaela.
Where was he going to play?
Now, you come to Pittsburgh, there's more opportunities.
It's a not great defensive outfielder right now besides Jake Mangum.
You have O'Hearn.
You have Reynolds.
You have Cruz.
And, of course, Mangum's your fourth outfielder.
But, per se, just Simpson Garcia hits better than your Mangum's.
Hits better than some of these guys that maybe take a bench pop.
Like, you brought up Billy Cook before we even started.
Like, I'd rather have just Simpson Garcia on the roster than a Billy Cook.
I like the higher upside.
But the question is with Garcia, and I understand the premise is, like, you want him to get the reps.
Yeah, I agree with you.
It's a very weird situation they put themselves in with him.
I'd rather have Garcia on the roster with Billy Cook, too.
But if he's only going to, get one start every 10 days, and if he's only going to pinch hit once or twice a week, I would rather have him AAA honing his crap.
And, there's all sorts of reasons why the better, more talented player doesn't make the roster.
Much to do with options.
Much to do with him getting his reps and developing his game.
So, right.
Look, they've got some tough decisions ahead of them, and I'm excited about that because they haven't had a lot of tough decisions.
They've handed jobs out to, whatever body was there and, kept running it back with the same guys who have, had 700 plate appearances, proved that they couldn't hit.
So, yeah, Garcia looks terrific.
He really does.
And, to me, again, with the age of some of the guys and, like Oneil Cruz, he could sit twice a week against the lefty.
It wouldn't be the end of the world.
So there's some at-bats right there, right?
O'Hearn is going to play some first base against left-handers.
There are ways that Donnie Kelly could find at-bats for both Mangum and Garcia.
And if they can hit, right, those are – your defense has improved.
So there's lots of ways.
I hope, I hope they find ways to play him.
I hope he continues what he's doing in the spring.
I hope it's for real.
And I hope we get to see it in Pittsburgh.
Yeah, I want what's best for Passport because I'm a big fan of what he can do.
And if it is going to AAA, it's going to AAA.
Because, like, at the end of the day, that's where definitely the reps are going to be.
But, like, at the end of the day as well, like, if he's a better – if you're stuck between Billy Cook or Garcia, I'm taking Garcia, but at the end of the day as well, that's probably your fifth outfielder at that point.
It's a very weird situation that they have put themselves in.
And I want to add to the point with Garcia, I don't like the trade just now for this year.
I like it for the future.
Because I think he could be a very big piece for, like, next year's team if there is baseball.
Or 2028's team, by the way.
Like, I think he could be a very interesting piece.
Like, I like the upside.
Sure, the swing and miss needs some adjustments.
But I like what he can do with the power.
I like he can add power.
Like Doug brought up, I'm more optimistic about the hitting than I ever have been before.
And that's without Garcia seeing much major league time.
It's not just him.
It's the other stuff they've done as well.
Yeah.
Don't we say everybody has some swing and miss issues now, right?
that's baseball now.
Yep.
Almost everybody strikes.
Pretty much.
Unless, you're like, lose our eyes.
Yeah.
it's a, there's a lot of guys.
The Pirates team is filled with guys that have some swing and miss issues.
But to your point, most teams, that's the new age baseball.
Right.
That's the way.
we had G1 Bay swinging for the fences.
If nothing ever made less sense to me than that.
Like that guy should have been forced to bunt every time he came up, but we had him swinging for the fences.
But he also couldn't bunt.
Exactly.
He had, he had swing and miss issues.
He had a lot of issues.
He had a miss issues.
I didn't matter if he had a swing or not.
So, yeah, it's again, you don't, I don't want to have a team full of 200 hitters either.
So.
Sure.
No, all fair, all fair for sure.
And, again, like, I guess to wrap this up too, like, I do agree with you.
Like, I do like this trade, especially for the future.
I think the question is, does it help now?
But like you mentioned, you want what's best for Garcia.
And like to Doug's point, I think what might be best for Garcia is to continue his development, getting those everyday at bats, maybe not getting the once or two a week and a potential like pinch hit here and there, you know?
Me personally, I think the perfect answer is Andrew McCutchen.
that's how you do it, right?
Passwords in triple a getting his reps.
You have Andrew McCutchen here on the major league team getting those at bats.
Is it not worried about his?
I believe he's on a plane to Florida, right?
He's 30,000 feet above right now.
He's on his way.
Just circling.
Just forever circling.
Waiting to land.
We saw Bob letting yesterday.
He looked like he was looking for Andrew McCutchen.
I'm not sure he was scanning the plays.
I get the feeling he was looking for Andrew McCutchen.
All right.
But let's go ahead and move over to the race trade.
so like that was the first.
That was the impact.
That was like the, oh, okay.
You know what?
They're not going to sell us on Garcia being the move.
We really like this prospect.
He's going to be the answer, right?
It was like, hey, you know what?
You got Brandon Lowe.
That's a headliner.
That's a guy who had 30 home runs last year.
Middle infield.
Second baseman.
All-star last year.
All-star, right?
But then you also got Jake Mangum, who, the best way I look at it is he's not going to be Brandon Lowe.
He's not going to help carry this offense, but he raises that floor.
he's not going to be the guy that's hitting 40, 50% below league average.
we'll hover around that.
He plays good defense, all three spots.
Some of the Pirates can use.
He just does all the little gritty things that you like on there.
And then they also get this Mason Montgomery guy who's a pretty enticing pitcher.
Everything we said about Kyle Nicholas, like to that, to the next level, he has to hone in and stuff, but there's that enticing stuff that you feel like you can work with.
So, I think we all liked that trade at the time.
Now you did give up Mike Burroughs.
And that was the other thing.
Now you're getting up two pieces in that rotation.
So it's getting a little interesting now in that sense, but all three of those guys are looking pretty good so far as well.
I love, I love Mike Burroughs.
I was, I was driving the train and this is a good trade, right?
This is a good trade.
This to me is one of Ben's better trades.
Typically, we're the one that give up three people and get one guy back.
And it looks, it looks really good now that well, now that he hasn't got a gambling problem, but, you got, simple, quite simple.
What did we get out of second base last year?
It wasn't a positive war, right?
We're going to get a positive war out of second bases here.
Brandon Lowe is good.
Brandon Lowe has power.
Brandon Lowe has played in big games.
Brandon Lowe's a hitter.
He's an all-star.
And, so yeah, he's going to help, but then, he might only be here for one year, but then you've got what looks like could be a lights out reliever.
And Jake Magum is going to impact this team in positive ways throughout he, we've watched him a bunch of times, get a hustle, double steel, throw somebody out in the outfield, run balls down.
And I'm telling you, I have new respect for anybody that can catch a ball in that outfield that way, that way in place, havoc with it.
and you want to talk about vibes.
He's captain vibes.
Jake Magum is the mayor.
There's a reason.
he was called the mayor and I was offended because Sean Casey's the mayor and he came into town and I'm like, Oh, I met him, watched him with the fans and I'm like, Oh, he's got my vote.
I'm going to, I'm ready to handle his campaign.
I'll be the campaign manager.
he seems like a terrific guy.
so this is a, this is a good trade.
At least two of the guys are going to have positive and I get the feeling all three of them that are, this is not a trade for the future, although it will help in the future with the two, the two younger guys.
but this was a trade made to help this team right now.
And I think all three guys are going to help this team right now.
It's improved this roster.
It's improved the depth in the lineup.
We haven't had hitters.
We have not had a hitter like Brandon Lowe during the venture.
And, again, there's to me, what I love about adding these guys is what it does for the guys that were here last year, how much better I think it's going to make Cruz and Reynolds, and Spencer Horwitz, that thing.
we're watching these spring training line.
It comes up and it's like, Oh, look, the first six and seven guys can hit in this lineup.
We have not seen that at all in the Ben Cherington era.
So I'm excited about this trade.
I hate losing Burroughs.
Burroughs is going to pitch.
Burroughs is going to make an all-star team for Houston.
I believe that.
but you have to give stuff up to get stuff.
You want to do a hot takes video again?
Get that on there.
Oh yeah.
All-star.
Mike Burroughs has some really good stuff too.
That change up.
That's going to be missed.
but yeah, let's kick it over to you.
Yeah.
So this was the trade of the off season for the parts.
This started at, I think this is what actually started the off team.
Password trade was great.
Don't get me wrong, but this was the trade.
They got fans excited.
Now it's definitely not a trade for the future.
It's a trade.
This is a, the first trade we've seen Ben Cherington bank.
Basically that is, we need to win now.
This is the first sense of urgency trade.
I've seen Ben Cherington do as a pirate gym.
I think all of us pirate fans can agree with that.
You're only getting Brandon Lowe for one year.
Yeah.
Cause I don't see a, like, maybe there's a world where he re-signs.
Maybe they extend them.
Who knows?
But like that might, that's probably not coming until later if it does happen.
Now he also has injury issues.
He's had some concerns in the past.
That's worrisome.
And you gave up Burroughs to get them.
You have to give to get, and you have to live with it.
And I was, like, you got, in the span of a week, around Christmastime, the Pirates brought in two All-Stars.
Now, they weren't just, like, your, oh, they were All-Stars back in 2021, like we've seen in the past.
It was two All-Stars last season that have had productive years.
Now, Ryan O'Hearn isn't probably going to hit you 30 home runs.
But he can hit you probably upwards of 20 in his best.
I don't think he's hit 20.
He hit 18 last year.
Close.
But he can definitely have that upside with the Pirates.
And he signed for two years.
Now, sure, next year, maybe we have a lockout.
Maybe that's part of it.
But, like, if there's no lockout, he's a Pirate next year, unless something horrible happens with this team and it all falls apart.
Sure.
Which I hope not.
And even at that, he still might be a Pirate.
But, like, still, they went out, gave a guy $14 million per year.
We have not seen that.
The highest before that, I think, was a Roldish Chapman.
And then Ozuna beat that later.
So, like, $10.5 was your previous high.
Then you topped that with $14 per.
And you went out and got a guy that you were actually linked to.
It was not a, oh, the Pirates are in.
It wasn't Schwarber.
It wasn't the Schwarber situation, which I didn't think they were ever getting Schwarber.
It was a fun ride, though, to go on for a couple weeks, see all the fans having fun with it.
But it was like, you see, oh, the Pirates are interested in Ryan O'Hearn.
The Pirates are interested in Jorge Polanco.
And it's like, oh, they missed out on Polanco.
Can they get O'Hearn?
Probably not.
And then you're at work and he says, oh, my gosh, they actually made it happen.
And it was that initiative.
And maybe the Brandon Loudrade sparked that.
And, like, hearing Ryan O'Hearn, he showed up to Pirates' best via Zoom and just talked about, like, the excitement.
He wanted to make sure he was there.
like, the weather was an issue, but he wanted to make sure he was present.
And he talked about, like, he was talking to Don Kelly about it, coming to the Pirates.
And immediately after, he basically called his agent and said, I want to be a Pirate.
He seemed to like the vibes.
And, like, that's like, the effect Don Kelly, I've seen, has had on this team.
You brought up yesterday with Cody.
He basically came over to all of us and said, hi.
Got a fist bump from him.
Very affirmative to, like, fist bump him.
But, like, you can tell that I wasn't here last year for Derek Shelton's last spring training.
From what you guys have said and what other fans and, like, players have basically seemed to have said about it, the vibes are a lot different with Don Kelly at the helm.
And I like the leadership he could bring to this team.
Yeah.
And, like, let's talk about leadership.
again, we've been here for two weeks, talk about the vibes and stuff.
Like, what are you seeing that Ryan O'Hearn's, like, maybe helping for this team?
Well, he's a professional hitter.
He's a professional baseball player.
He's immediately said, I'll play anywhere you want me to play.
He's like, okay, all right.
I've been a DH in the first baseman.
I'm happy to go to the outfield.
And he's looked pretty good.
he's early.
He's not had a lot of chances.
But he hasn't done anything, terrible.
But you're also the one that brought up, like, Van Gogh playing.
Like, you're going to have credit for him.
Anyone can play outfield right now.
So, like you're saying, like, you're seeing some positive things from him in the outfield right now.
Yeah.
And it just, he's, again, he's family's here.
And every time you see him, every chance he has, he's got a newborn.
He's holding that newborn.
And just like, how can you?
I know.
That's why he won't walk by and give us an interview.
Right.
It's been hard to get him in the interview.
He's using that family as a crutch.
But, no, like you said, just that's the other thing, too.
Like, cheering for that guy.
it's just, I don't know.
Right.
Like you said, he signed with us.
And it was literally, like, a week later he had the newborn.
Yeah.
And then he's here in spring training.
Yeah, he's here.
And it's, again, and it seems so silly to be talking, just about vibes.
But it's also good vibes and good production.
Right.
Right.
It's spring production.
We know, guys have had lights out springs and immediate, I think Jack and Henry both looked fantastic last year in spring.
And, then did not look very good in the regular season.
So, you just can't put any stock in spring production.
But these are, it's a little easier when it's a professional hitter, a guy who's had a track record of his success.
We get, we signed two all-stars from last year.
it's like Nathan said, these weren't guys that were, it's not Rowdy Tellez who was an all-star four years ago and is coming out four bad years.
it's not Tommy Pham who had a last season, his last good season was in 2019 or something.
Right.
These guys had good seasons last year.
And there's no reason to think that they're not going to at least come close to replicating those seasons.
Right.
Brandon Lowe might hit 27 home runs instead of 31.
That's fine.
Right.
Because that's dramatically more than we got out of second base.
When's the last time we've had that?
Right.
Exactly.
That's what I'm saying.
We haven't had a 30 home run hitter in a while.
We had one 20 home run hitter last year.
Right.
It was what, 21, 22?
Barely.
Yeah, barely.
It was on pace to hit like 40.
They thought to put that out there.
One minute was, yeah, it was like, going to lead the league in on-base percentage in home runs.
And then Derek Shelton got fired and it all went down.
So, yeah, it's, again, remember how frustrated we were last year with so many Paul Skenes's games where he would give up a run or two runs and then lose.
I don't see that happening this year.
Right?
maybe the biggest beneficiary of all this is going to be Paul Skenes's.
Paul Skenes's is going to pitch as great as he always does.
Comments· 0
Should Jhostynxon Garcia make the Opening Day roster over Billy Cook, or play every day in AAA?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.