◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
◆NEWSPirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Plaz◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSFive Players Reject Qualifying Offer◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆NEWSPirates, Chas McCormick Agree To Minor League Deal
Colin Beazley of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette joined NS9LIVE to sort through the Pirates’ biggest roster decisions heading into 2027. The group debated Bryan Reynolds, Henry Davis, Carmen Mlodzinski, Endy Rodriguez and Mitch Keller, then mapped out Pittsburgh’s infield with and without Brandon Lowe. They closed by naming the three moves they would make to turn an 82-win team into a playoff club, including possible trades and left-handed pitching targets.
Watch or listen to the full discussion on North Shore Nine.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Would you trade Mitch Keller and his $18M to free up money to re-sign Brandon Lowe?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Trade Mitch Keller and his $18M. It's the easiest way to bring Brandon Lowe back, or to pay for starting pitching, bullpen depth and a right-handed bat instead.
2
It's "mind-boggling" that the Pirates went two years without giving Hunter Barco, a top-100 prospect last year, a single big-league start. He should have started game 162.
3
Carmen Mlodzinski should be moved: "Two years in a row of you being a whiny baby. Get out."
4
The Pirates have to make Brandon Lowe a real offer before the December 2 lockout, because he'll want to know where he's playing.
5
Sign Trevor Rogers for about three years and $60M. The Pirates badly need a lefty starter, and 11 MLB teams were as bad as or worse than Pittsburgh against left-handed pitching by wRC+.
Welcome to the North Shore Nine podcast presented by FanDuel.
This is NS9 Live.
I'm Jim.
With me, as always, is Tyler.
And filling in for DiNardo today, again, we hit that upgrade button again, from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Colin Beasley.
Colin, welcome to NS9 Live.
How are you doing tonight?
Thanks for having me.
I'm doing well.
I'm just hoping to be better than DiNardo.
That's my only goal for tonight.
I just want to be better than DiNardo.
It's a low bar.
Yeah, bars on the floor, my man.
I'll do my best to dig underneath it.
No, but yeah, we're about, we're what, like two and a half weeks now into the offseason.
Post-season's well underway.
ALCS tied at one after two games.
NLCS, the Brewers pushing around.
The Dodgers up 2-0.
I think they're up 1-0 tonight.
The game started about an hour ago, which means, amazingly, I think both teams haven't made a bullpen move yet.
So, both starters are still in the game.
But I'm anticipating that game will last another four or five hours once we get the 14 or 15 bullpen changes that those two managers are going to do before the end of the night.
But, yeah.
How are you guys enjoying the postseason so far?
Tyler looks like he's responding.
Brother, I've paid, like, no attention to the postseason.
I have checked out of it.
As long as the Cleveland Guardians are in this thing, I'm not paying attention.
I don't.
Boycotting.
Boycotting.
I don't want their fans to have happiness, the whole thing, whole nine yards, not watching.
But I forgot about your hatred of Cleveland.
I forgot about that.
It's deep.
Yeah.
So deep.
I went to, what was it, game, I think it was game two of Guardians White Sox, just for the heck of it.
Like, my offseason slows down a lot.
I've got the time to go to playoff baseball at 5 p.m. on a Monday.
So I did that.
I took Aiden Stepanski of LB.com with me.
And, I don't know, it was fun to see it, fun to be part of it.
Eh, game.
Cleveland's ballpark was decent.
No PNC Park, but it was fine.
As for the actual postseason, I'm a baseball nut.
I've watched most every game.
I really enjoy seeing it.
And it's fun to see that the Brewers are exactly as good as we thought they were.
Like, by following NL Central Baseball, you know that this is actually a good team, and they're showing it against the Dodgers here.
Fun is certainly a word, I guess you could use.
I don't know.
As a card-carrying Milwaukee Brewer hater, I'm not enjoying.
I'm not enjoying that series at all.
The Dodgers, they have, what, four Hall of Famers in that lineup probably, and they're just doing nothing.
Shohei Ohtani is in the slump of his life.
Like, what's going on here?
It's killing me.
It's absolutely killing me watching this.
I like watching good, clean baseball, but I'm with you on the, that there are too many pitching changes and the games are taking too long.
We need to reemphasize the starting pitcher somehow.
The ALCS is great.
Like, these Rays-Guardians games have been awesome, in my opinion.
But the Brewers-Dodgers games have been rough.
But, yeah, we'll see how it goes.
As I said, they're playing right now, so we'll keep an eye on there.
Some other news that came out today.
Brandon Lowe, Gold Glove finalist, which was well-deserved.
He made a huge, just a huge step forward in his defense this year.
Jared Triolo, Gold Glove finalist for the utility position.
Third time in a row he's been a finalist for that.
He won that award in 2024.
Real quick, real quick, Tyler, do any of them actually win the award?
No.
No.
Colin?
No.
Neither of you are any fun.
But I'm also going to agree with you.
I don't think either of them are going to win it.
Still pretty cool honors for both of them.
Well-deserved, especially for Brandon Lowe.
Seeing a year-to-year reversal, unbelievably impressive, but probably not the best second baseman defensively in the NL.
On that note there, Colin, did the Pirates do anything in particular with him that just improved him the way he did?
Because I remember when Neil Walker went to the Mets, his defensive metrics shot through the roof, and I think a lot of that had to do with positioning.
Was there anything in particular they did with Brandon Lowe that might have pointed to that?
Positioning is a little bit of it.
Another big thing for him is the Pirates are pretty high on taking a bunny hop before every single defensive rep.
That's something that Truby likes and something that they believe in throughout the organization.
They had him doing that.
It worked.
Taking a bunny hop isn't good enough for the swing of, what was it, 25 or 26 defensive runs saved that he was this year.
So I think it's maybe a little bit of the Pirates doing something right positionally and defensively, but I also think it's a lot of just he was moving better and healthier throughout the year.
He wasn't dealing with the ankle stuff he dealt with last year.
Yeah, it certainly helped contribute.
the offensive numbers were there, but the defense certainly propped him up too.
And that was a good time to have that a season going into free agency.
So that's going to be one of our topics tonight too.
But I want to start off with Colin.
Yesterday, you wrote an article on Post Gazette, PittsburghPostGazette.com.
You can go ahead and find it there.
It's in the link of the description here if you haven't read it yet.
But make sure you check that out.
But you went through and you ranked all 41 players in the, on the Pirates roster by their likelihood of being on the opening day roster next year.
So obviously there's the people who are, clearly going to be there.
You named them the untouchables, right?
You've got 10 of those.
You've got a tier two or you've got like pretty virtually certain guys.
And then, probably back could be moved and then likely elsewhere.
Those are your, those are your tiers.
So I guess just real quick, we'll dive into this here, but who was the hardest player for you to rank out of that group?
I think for me, the hardest guys to figure out where to put them were Spencer Horwitz and Nick Gonzales, just because I feel like they're both just in an interesting spot where Horwitz didn't have the season he was hoping to have this year.
Gonzalez struggled defensively.
And there's some unknown because yes, they're up for arbitration decisions.
I don't think either of them is actually at risk of being non-tendered, but it's, you think about it briefly, like it's, I don't think they're actually at risk of anything, but it's not one that you can say 100% they'll pick it up the way that a Jared Jones
And then there's also just uncertainty with other stuff we'll get into tonight in terms of moves they could make and re-signing Brandon Lauer, not re-signing Brandon Lauer, all that thing.
Because Nick Gonzales, he's 100% a major league baseball player, 100% will be on a 40-man roster next year, probably the Pirates.
But if you bring back Brandon Lauer, what happens to him?
Is he someone you try to flip for right-handed bat?
How exactly do you view him?
And both of those guys, they're not at any risk of not being in the majors.
They're both quality major league baseball players and guys who the Pirates like having.
It's not like they're shopping either of them.
But they were tough to figure out where 1 through 41 their likelihood of being back on the Pirates because they could go either way.
And then how easy was it to put Gregory Soto in the likely elsewhere tier because he will be likely elsewhere as much as Jim wants him back?
That one was pretty easy.
I remember it was – I'm with Jim a little bit in that he has been someone who I think gets a lot more hate than is warranted.
Like, yeah, there's six blown saves and it's tough to look past that.
He's been on the mound for some of the ugliest moments of the season.
But he also had a pretty dang good year if you look at ERA and strikeouts and all that thing.
So I remember back in August on one of Ben Cherington's radio shows, he just talked about how Gregory Soto was going to do well in free agency.
And it sounded to me like a pretty clear won't be back.
So that's why I put him at 40.
I don't think the Pirates will be spending the 7, 8 mil that would be required to bring him back, assuming that there's no CBA stuff and trying to read a floor.
But, yeah, I think he gets more hate than he deserves, but I don't see him coming back.
I don't think that answer.
I'm sorry.
Yeah.
You could have quit after.
He won't be back.
That's all.
You could have stopped that.
You could have quit there.
So I want to attack some of these just, like, names that you put on here, starting with Bryan Reynolds.
You've got him, as the first player in the probably back, but category.
you mentioned, obviously, the payroll situation means that a trade can't be rolled out.
But, when it comes to Reynolds, we put out a quote card the other day where all I said was, like, if somebody gives you a really nice package for Reynolds, you've got to listen to it.
And people got mad at me.
They were like, how dare you want to move this guy?
So I guess my question to you is, if you were to move Reynolds, because of just where this team is right now, like, what would that trade have to accomplish for the Pirates?
Because I don't think you could just trade Reynolds for prospects.
Like, there's got to be more to it than that for it to make sense to this team, just where they're at right now.
Yeah, I think if you got that right-handed bat that would go in the middle of your lineup and would hit lefties and would be an established guy for the next four or five seasons, replacing Reynolds in that way, then you think about it.
And the other part of it is just getting some payroll flexibility.
If it would be – if the Pirates were dead set on bringing Brandon Lowe back but weren't willing to go over $110 or $115 million in total payroll, then that's why you'd consider it.
But I put him at 19.
I put him below some guys like Jacob Gonzalez and Khristian Curtis and Antwone Kelly, not because I think that he's going to get moved, but just because I think that the Pirates would listen.
Just because if you only have a certain amount of money to play with and he's taking up a big chunk of it, then you have to at least listen if you think that's one of the ways to make your team better.
But I wouldn't move him.
He's not someone I'm particularly interested in trying to deal.
It's just always going to be a conversation.
I'm with you.
I think I'd have to be blown away.
I would have to receive something that I can immediately use and be really comfortable that they would be a really good fit.
And then at the same time, you'd have to take that money and go use it elsewhere, whether that's resigning Brandon Lowe or whatever that may be, right?
But it's going to have to be the perfect package, I think, for it to happen.
But Tyler, what are your thoughts on that?
No, I was going to ask you guys, do you think that maybe trading Bryan Reynolds would be dependent on bringing Brandon Lowe back?
Or are they not mutually exclusive or mutually exclusive here?
I don't think that's mutually exclusive.
I think we're going to get to another player here where maybe moving him is the thing that you have to do if you're going to bring Brandon Lowe back.
But I don't think Reynolds and Brandon Lowe necessarily need to be like a hand-in-hand type thing.
But I'm generally agreeing with you guys that I'm not moving him unless it's actually making the 2027 Pirates better.
I will say real quick that with making – for sure making the 2027 Pirates better, and it would have to be part of a package, not a one-for-one salary dump play.
It would have to be that right-handed bat and – and I don't know that he has that value.
I don't know exactly what other teams would offer for him.
That's just in this hypothetical.
If I were to move him, I would need that bat and the flexibility to do some other things and improve some other holes and or bring Brandon Lowe back.
But you had him in the last – like the last slot there.
Arbitration eligible for the first time.
Obviously the defense is nice.
Just the offense just still not coming around to where it needs to be.
But, you look at him and he seems like a perfect backup catcher really.
It just sucks because that's not what you're hoping to get out of your 1-1.
Yeah, exactly that.
He's a perfectly fine, perfectly productive backup catcher.
And you could even say backup catcher with upside.
I don't think it's going to happen.
I don't – I believe that this is what Henry Davis is.
But you can be like, oh, if he hits or if whatever.
I don't think it's going to happen.
But you could make that argument.
Yeah, I don't think he'll get non-tendered.
I don't think he's prohibitively expensive.
I think that he's a fine backup catcher.
And you want someone to be – you need to have a defense-first backup catcher somewhere in there.
Especially if you go in with Rafael Flores as your number one catcher next year.
So, I think there is a spot for him.
I think that he's probably back.
But he's not one that I can say with 100% certainty will be back.
I would probably say that it's a spot, if he's in your backup catcher position, you can upgrade pretty affordably.
True.
You can get a guy who can at least touch a Major League Baseball.
That'd be sweet.
He can.
He's got to find someone who hits it fair, though.
But then at the same time, like I read Cullen's article here, and it says – and I remember, yes, Henry Davis did have some looks at the trade deadline.
My question here is why?
Why did anybody want him?
Defense-first catcher with upside.
He's well-regarded and – yeah.
But I – and I've talked about it a little bit on the radio, but I didn't hear that there was – they got particularly close on a deal.
And it sounds like the Pirates still wanted a good bit for him.
So it didn't seem like Pirates particularly wanted to move him, but there were conversations.
I would say, like, I'd be interested in seeing him and Skenes broken up a little bit here.
Like, break Skenes away from that.
Maybe see what happens there.
I know it had success two years ago, but, like, I don't need – if it's down to a wild card game or a wild card series next year, I don't need Henry Davis starting behind the plate that game.
I guess my counter to that would be, if Paul Skenes is on the mound, really anybody like that who's just a dominant pitcher who also relies on, balls in play, things like that.
Like, I do like having my best defense behind my best pitcher, right?
Like, you've got to just think that my best pitcher is going to beat their best pitcher and I'm going to help my best pitcher out the best I can when it comes to run prevention.
So that's where I think Davis comes in.
They obviously have really good rapport.
I'm with you, like, maybe have, like, a start or two every now and then where Flores, catches him.
But I think for the most part, if it's not broke, don't fix it, right?
Like, I don't think the issue – I don't think the issue this year with Paul Skenes, though, was Henry Davis.
Like, it was clearly a Paul Skenes issue and a rest of the defense.
Like, it was – there were a lot of issues in play there.
I don't think Henry Davis was necessarily the reason for the slide.
But he's not a solution either.
Pirates were also four games over .500 with Henry Davis this year.
And they had a winning – pretty meaningfully winning record with Davis last year, too.
So he's hitting .172, but something's going right when he's in the game.
That's a good point.
Let's keep up the Henry James' propaganda.
No, we're – This Louisville propaganda is getting a little bit much here, guys.
We're all about the Henry Davis propaganda on this show.
I wouldn't say Henry Davis propaganda and certainly not Louisville propaganda after you beat the crap out of my Villanova Wildcats in a football game I definitely care a ton about.
Definitely all in on Villanova football this year, 2-4 in the FCS.
There you go.
Didn't Villanova have, like, a brutal loss week one, too?
Like, just a brutal loss?
I think it was, like – blew a 13-point lead in, like, 40-something seconds.
I don't know.
Yeah, it was – It was bad.
Yeah, I remember it was bad.
Add a position in there somehow.
Bad.
It was bad.
Always got basketball.
So the tier, though, I want to spend the most time in while we talk about this is your fourth tier, which is the could-be-moved tier.
And I want to do like, a little exercise here with all three of us.
So your options are – this is going to be your options.
Keep, move, whether that's trade or non-tender or whatever that is.
Or it doesn't matter.
Those are your three options.
All right?
So let's start here.
You have on this list, you've got Hunter Barco at 25th on the list.
Like, I felt like Hunter Barco should have started game 162 this year just because.
Like, the dude was a top 100 prospect last year.
And, like, you look at his triple-A numbers, and they're not bad.
Like, he's had success in Indianapolis.
Sure, he's looked terrible in the limited time that you've let him pitch in the majors as a reliever.
Let him start one game.
That's all.
I don't understand why they haven't let him start a game yet.
Makes no sense to me.
But I'm keeping him.
He's a lefty starting pitcher.
He's optionable.
He's – in my opinion, there's no reason to get rid of this guy at this point.
I will say he was put into some brutal spots this year.
And when you think about the times that he did pitch, there were a couple times when he got to the airport – got to the ballpark after the game had already started and then was put in for multiple innings.
So, I see where you're coming in there.
But I assumed that there was some decision why he didn't end up coming in for a spot start.
I assumed he'd get one, especially late in September, and didn't.
I assumed there's something there, but I don't know.
I haven't heard anything either way.
I'm going to go with the answer of him not being very good.
But, like, let's find out.
Let's find out.
I don't think we know.
They haven't even – how?
How do they know?
They haven't actually tried.
So, I don't know.
Especially when it didn't matter.
Like, now you can't try.
You can't go ahead and put him in the rotation to start next year or anything.
Like, he's going to be in Indianapolis to start the season.
But you had meaningless baseball games the past two years.
I want to keep him, but in all reality, it just doesn't matter.
You can find another utility guy if you have to.
And he just hasn't done enough to really be in that keep category as much as I want him to.
Yep.
Just doesn't matter.
I'll say keep.
I don't think you're wrong with anything you said there, but I think that he is probably about a million dollars better than a Deuce Corson or a Jack Brannigan at this specific time.
And I don't think he's significantly worse than, or, yeah, significantly worse than the two or three million you'd have to spend to get a comparable utility player on the market.
So, keep him.
Can I follow up on that and just maybe, like, why do you have Jacob Gonzalez ahead of a Triolo?
I don't think Jacob.
I have a choice.
I'm getting rid of Gonzalez before Triolo.
I'm with, I'm actually with you on that.
I wasn't that impressed with what I saw out of Jacob Gonzalez this year, but they just traded draft pick to get him.
He's got a lot more options.
He's younger, under control for longer, and he's a left-handed hitter.
If that clicks at PNC Park, there's more upside there.
Plus, again, he's under control through 2031, somewhere in there, if it does click.
So, like, I put a lot of young guys up high on that list just because I think that there's not really any reason to trade them right now.
Not necessarily because I think that they're untouchable the way that guys I put in that top category are.
But just because there's not really a reason to trade a Jacob Gonzalez or a Khristian Curtis or something like that when they're so young and under control and you don't know exactly what you have in them quite yet.
Yeah, I'm with you there.
They have a lot invested in Gonzalez, too, at this point.
Like, I think if you immediately were like, hey, you know what?
We're giving up on this guy who we just traded the 34th pick for, which we could have used for someone to address our bullpen need right away.
And instead, we went with this guy who we felt was the better overall value.
I just don't see that happening yet.
But with Triolo, Tyler, I'm more with you.
Like, I'm leaning towards keep just because I like the glove and the versatility.
But I think at the end of the day, it doesn't really matter.
Like, if you can go out there and find a Jared Triolo replacement, maybe not someone who can do everything that he does.
But I think you can find somebody that does some things significantly better than what he does that make up for all the stuff that he does.
So, yeah, I'm going to be in, like, the doesn't really matter camp.
Like, if they find someone better than Triolo, I'm not going to be too concerned.
But, yeah, it doesn't matter for me.
I'll also say with the young guys, what I was just talking about there is the guys up top, they're not going to be non-tendered or DFA'd the way that guys in this category have.
Might not be what Carmen Mlodzinski wants to be, but he's someone who, if I'm the Pirates, I want to keep him.
I'm only moving him if he's, like, demanding a trade or if some team sees him as a starter and is willing to trade starter value for him.
Tyler?
Tyler?
Get him the hell out of town.
Go away.
I don't need him in the clubhouse.
I don't care how good he could be.
If he's not going to buy in, and he can pretend he will all he wants.
Two years in a row of you being a whiny baby.
Get out.
Oh, you know what?
I am on the keep train with Mlodzinski at this point.
I think with the way the bullpen looks right now, it's in a really good spot, and Carmen is a big part of that.
So I'm going to keep Mlodzinski for now, and hopefully he just comes around to understanding that, yeah, hey, this is who I am.
I can be a really good reliever, and I'm going to be really good at this role.
And if I'm really good at this role, I'm going to get paid a lot of money.
So I think that's where we're going to roll with Carmen.
All right.
Here's another interesting one.
Endy.
Endy Rodriguez.
You got him number 30.
Tyler?
I think you have to keep him.
You got to find out.
It's a tough keep, but I think you have to keep him.
Okay.
Colin?
Keep.
You get one last basically free roll of the dice at Endy Rodriguez.
He's going to be cheap this year.
He's got a minor league option remaining.
Who knows how he'll come out of this injury, but it's worth finding out for at least one more year.
I'm with you guys.
You need three catchers anyways on the 40 man, and are you going to find a third catcher that's better than Endy Rodriguez?
Probably not.
So, yeah.
I'm going to keep him.
And this is his last shot, though.
He's got to be healthy this year, or else next year it's a get rid of.
All right.
And then, last but not least in this category, Mitch Keller.
$18 million man.
Colin?
Trade.
I think that's the easiest way to make a whole lot of things work with that $18 million.
I think that if you do it right, you can get Brandon Lowe back if you want to go that route, which that's the route I'd go.
I want Brandon Lowe back, and the guys in the clubhouse badly want him back.
That's how I would make that happen, other than, the simplest answer of simply raising payroll.
But that's the way I'd make that happen.
And the other thing is, if you do trade him, and if you don't get Brandon Lowe back, then you can go and address the other issues with this team.
You can go out and get more starting pitching depth, bullpen depth, and maybe a right-handed bat if you play your cards right.
You can fix all three of those things with $18 million, or you can have Mitch Keller, who, as nice as it would be to have a 4-2 ERA in 170 innings next year, that'd be great.
But that's the easiest way to make this work, in my opinion, is a trade.
I'm with Colin.
I think you have to.
The money's too much here.
You just can't have him eating up 15% to 20% of your payroll.
Not with what he put out last year.
And I think his production can be replaced for a fraction of that cost.
So, unfortunately, as much as I love Mitch Keller and love everything he's done for this team, it's probably time now finding the partner for that and being able to offload that's a different question.
For what it's worth, you said that it's too much here.
And I think that's the right way to put it.
Because his contract isn't inherently that awful a deal.
Yes, he was not good this year.
But someone like Mitch Keller on the open market coming off of a better season probably gets something relatively similar to where he's at.
I don't know if he'd get 240 or 238 like he gets in the next few years.
But he could probably get somewhere in the 230, 232.
Like, yes, this year was not good.
And he knows that.
The Pirates know that.
Everyone knows that.
But it's not as bad of a contract as many think it would be.
And it's more palatable in places other than Pittsburgh where it's not 15% to 20% of your overall salary.
I'm with both of you.
As much as I'm saying with Tyler, like, I love Mitch Keller.
as a fan of this team, we've been following Mitch Keller now for 12 years.
He was a 2014 draft pick.
There's no one on this team right now that we've been paying attention to as long as we've been paying attention to Mitch Keller.
So it sucks.
But I think if you're looking at the 2027 season and the roster and the way it's constructed and the limitations that this team has, they can do more without Keller than they can with him.
So, yeah, I'm in the move camp as well.
But, no, definitely some interesting decisions that need to be made this year.
If you haven't checked out that article, again, it's on Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, post-gazette.com.
What's it?
Post-gazette.com.
So make sure you check that out.
Read the full thing.
But before we move to our next topic, let's tell you guys about Larine Co
A lot of people use nicotine pouches, and sometimes the routine itself is a big part of it.
That's where Larine Co comes in.
They've created a pouch that keeps that routine but leaves the nicotine out.
Each pouch has 50 milligrams of caffeine, which is about half a cup of coffee designed to give you smooth, steady focus.
And because it's Larine, the pouches also support your enamel while they're in.
They come in mint, cinnamon, and mango, and it's nicotine-free always.
So give Larine a try.
Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at buylarine.com slash North Shore.
That's buylarine, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash North Shore for up to 50% off.
Okay, so let's do another, I guess just another exercise here, right?
Let's go with two different scenarios, right?
Scenario A is Brandon Lowe does not come back.
He's gone.
Scenario B, Brandon Lowe comes back.
So, I want to know if it's scenario A and Brandon Lowe leaves, which, Colin, you've got Brandon Lowe is the 38th most likely pirate to return.
So that's not very good.
There's not too many people more unlikely to return, according to you.
First base being manned by Ryan O'Hearn, Spencer Horwitz, whatever that looks like.
But what does second base and third base look like?
Tyler, let's start off with you.
Are you just moving Gonzalez to second and then attacking third base with what you got?
Are you going out and getting somebody?
What's the plan here?
Yeah, I think Nick Gonzales is getting moved to second base.
And you're running that back again, putting him more in his natural position and seeing if that will help him defensively.
Just focusing on one spot.
If that doesn't work, I think similar to like we talked about with Andy, this is your shot here.
You got to figure this out defensively.
And then I'm attacking third base.
And I think you have to do that in the trade market.
I did like what you guys talked about on Bucket Brew with Nolan Aranato.
I think Paredes is in that mix.
Like, I think you have to attack it through trade, though.
Not sure there's a ton on the open market you can go after.
But that's where I'm basically allocating the resources at that point.
You're going after third base.
What do you think, Colin?
I don't know exactly who would be out there on the trade market.
I think that those names are interesting.
I'm not super excited by Isaac Paredes just being such a pole hitter and going from the most pole happy park in Daikin Park to one that's not very pole friendly in PNC.
So I worry about that.
I think I agree with Nick Gonzales going to second base.
But for third base, I would go out and I'd sign Alec Bohm.
I'm not thrilled by that.
If there's a better name on the trade market, then by all means, go for it if there's someone there.
But I think Boehm would give you some of what you need in terms of a guy who can be in the middle of the lineup, drive some runs in, has a little bit of slug and hits lefties.
I think that works there.
The thing I worry about is them not addressing it, just saying Gonzalez at second and waiting for Murf Gray.
I think that Nick Gonzales would be better at second base if he knows that's the position he's in and he has the whole season just to focus on that spot.
But if you go out and you don't address either of those positions and you just simply go with internal options to try and replace the guy who was your best player this year, that's when I really start to worry about what these 2027 Pirates will look like.
Yeah, this one would be injury.
this is obviously the most likely scenario, right?
And it's going to attack it.
I'm in agreement.
I think if Brandon Lowe is gone, Nick Gonzales is your second baseman.
It immediately takes care of the issue where Gonzalez was borderline unplayable at third base at times, right?
Moves him into a position he's a little more comfortable with.
He's not necessarily great at second either, but he's passable there and the bat plays just fine at the position if he does even, close to what he did this year.
Third, like, and I'm with you, Colin.
I think this is where I get scared, right?
Because I could see the Pirates just saying, you know what?
Colin, you go so I can think up of something different, because I don't want to say the exact same thing.
I'm going the exact same route.
I'm going slightly differently with how I'll get there and a little bit less sexy, unfortunately.
But I'll start with the Keller trade to make some payroll work.
I'll go immediately to re-sign Brandon Lowe.
And the third one I'll go to, and I'm not 100% confident on the money in this.
I haven't looked up contract projections, so I don't know for 100% fact that it would work.
But going after just a token fifth starter lefty, a Jordan Montgomery type, would be exactly where I would go to with that third and final move.
If there's some lefty in there in that general, a little bit less than $10 million range, I think is where I would go.
I don't know for a fact that it works.
I don't know whether that put our payroll at $130 million in our hypothetical exercise, but that's the type of player that I would target with my hypothetical third move.
Of course, I could get really funky and say trade for Hunter Goodman, but I'm only going to go for one huge swing of the re-signing Brandon Lowe.
All right.
So I like both of those.
Tyler, I obviously like yours the most because that was exactly what I was going to do.
The only difference, I will say this.
So I'm going to say what I would have done, but I'm going to give an alternative.
Like Florentino would be my headliner, and I would trade him to the Angels for Reed Demers and Sammy Natera.
Left-handed reliever.
I think you need a left-handed reliever.
So like that takes that away too.
He was a rookie this year.
He's only pitched 31 innings, but the stuff looked really good.
The numbers look really good.
Everything looks like he's a good pitcher.
So I feel comfortable with him being like my number two lefty out of the bullpen.
So an Edward Florentino headlined package for Reed Demers and Sammy Natera.
And then obviously re-signing Brandon Lowe, trading Mitch Keller for basically nothing.
I don't think you can really get much for him at all.
Like that's just a pure salary dump.
And if you need to add something to Keller to make that happen, then I think you do it too.
Nothing too crazy, but if you have to, you do it.
But let's go ahead and I guess redo this.
So I'm going to say I'm going to stick with trading Mitch Keller.
I think trading Mitch Keller is something that they just have to do in order to get some stuff done.
I'm going to go a little bit different route here.
I'm going to use the majority of the money that I freed up for myself to sign a left-handed pitcher, but someone quite a bit better than, say, Jordan Montgomery.
I'm going to take that money and I'm going to give it to Trevor Rogers on like a three-year, $60 million deal.
That shores up your rotation, gives you a lefty that just pitches well at PNC Park.
The other thing too that I just want to mention with left-handed pitching this year, I think the Pirates just desperately need a left-handed starter.
Like we saw how bad the Pirates were against lefties this year.
Do you know how many teams in Major League Baseball were as bad or worse than the Pirates against left-handed pitching this year?
Take a guess.
One.
One.
I would have guessed they're in the bottom three.
Okay.
The answer is 11.
There were 11 teams in Major League Baseball that were as bad or worse than the Pirates against left-handed pitching.
So you know what that just tells me?
By OPS?
Weighted Runs Created Plus.
By Weighted Runs Created Plus.
The league just sucks against left-handed pitching.
Like they're terrible.
If there were 11 teams as bad or worse than the Pirates, they suck.
So go ahead and get yourself a left-handed starter so you can just take advantage of all the shitty teams who can't hit left-handed pitching.
Right?
Let's do that.
Let's become a part of that gang.
I'm tired of being the only one seeing it happen to my team.
Let's see it happen to other teams too.
All right?
So I'm signing Trevor Rodgers.
And then that brings my payroll up to roughly $102 million or so.
My third baseman is a Jacob Gonzalez-Edmundo Sosa platoon.
And I don't know how sexy that sounds.
But I think it's not the worst thing in the world.
And I don't know if this team is going to be any good.
But, Tyler, you took my first answer.
So this is the best I can do.
Just coming up with something.
You had the worst offseason of all of us.
Yeah, I'm just coming up with something on the top of my head here.
You gave me like two minutes to do some research.
You waited too long to make your move.
So that's what I'm going with.
Gives me like a payroll of right around 108.
I do think Trevor Rodgers is interesting.
Wouldn't hate it.
I feel like you could never spend too much on starting pitching.
So wouldn't hate it.
As we're talking about dumping money.
Yeah.
That's true.
But what Jim said, though, I think you have to find a lefty.
And Detmers does that.
Rodgers does that.
You mentioned Montgomery.
Like, they got to find a left-handed starter.
Yeah, I'm with you.
I'm with Miles Saltman, too, saying that three moves is nowhere near enough.
Yeah.
There's a couple of tweaks you can make to this team.
there's a – I don't think you need a full rebuild.
I don't think you need to tear everything down.
But there's a lot of moves around the margins I think they can make.
Yeah, I agree with that.
Just for the sake of time and this exercise, I think three was the right number.
Maybe deeper in the offseason we'll get on here and bring our 15-step plans.
Yeah, we'll go – yeah, we'll do our – maybe a 10-step plan.
10 – man, 15 seems like a lot.
I don't know if Tyler wants to prepare that much.
Yeah, well, I'll just take yours.
That's true.
Next time I'm going first.
How about that?
It's your show.
You can do what you want.
That's true.
You're leadless.
All right.
Well, Colin, I told you we'd try to keep this to 45 minutes.
We're here at minute 57.
So, let's wrap things up.
Tyler, you got any fun postseason odds that we got?
Yeah, so the Brewers, I've watched them go up and down as World Series favorites right now.
They are currently at plus 125.
They've been all the way down to plus 100 as they had a 1-0 lead.
But we've crept up there to plus 125.
It was all the way up to 135.
I'm still like Dodgers plus 290s.
Probably about as good of odds as you can get there.
So, Dodgers still the heavy favorite?
Not quite.
Brewers are.
You said plus?
Oh, yeah.
You're right.
Never mind.
Yeah.
All right.
Sorry.
Okay.
Interesting.
Colin, I appreciate you hopping on here.
Where can everybody find your work?
Tell the people.
You can find me on Twitter, Colin underscore Beasley, or read all my stuff at post-gazette.com.
Thank you so much for both having me and for plugging my article.
It was fun to talk about it and go through it.
And it's been cool to see emails and comments and all that thing about it.
It's been good to have some conversations about the article.
It was fun to do and good to hear people's thoughts.
There we go.
Love it.
Again, thanks for coming on here.
Again, check out Colin.
Make sure you're following him on Twitter.
If you've got Twitter, make sure you're subscribed to post-gazette.com.
It's well worth, what is it, like $2.99 a month, something like that?
I believe we're running a special for 99 cents for 12 weeks right now.
Yeah, it is.
Giving it away.
It's a good deal right now.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Basically, it's all off-season.
Hopefully, it's worth a dollar.
All right.
Well, to wrap things up here, make sure you're checking out Offbeat every morning featuring Alex Stumpf.
Next one's already up for members only, but it'll be released tomorrow at 7 a.m.
We're also releasing all of our interviews with the Arizona Fall League players.
We've already come out with Carmichael, Sanford, and Meath, so make sure you check those out if you haven't yet.
Brandon Cain and Michael Walsh will be out soon as well.
And then this time next week, so NS9 Live next week, DiNardo and I will be in Glendale.
So I'm assuming we'll have an on-location NS9 Live.
There's a day game that day.
The Glendale Desert Dogs are at a day game that day.
So we'll probably be back at the Airbnb doing an NS9 Live from Arizona.
So make sure you check that out.
We'll have a ton of stuff for you next week from Arizona, too.
So make sure you're following along.
You got any last words, Tyler?
Love you all.
I'm here every week except for next week.
All right, guys.
Thanks for watching.
Like the video.
Subscribe.
All that good stuff.
Tell a friend.
Let's go Bucs.
See you guys later.
Peace out, Agro Scouts.
All right.
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Would you trade Mitch Keller and his $18M to free up money to re-sign Brandon Lowe?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.