◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
◆NEWS2026 Non-Tenders: National League◆ROSTERRHP Noah Murdock elected free agency◆STATPaul Skenes ranks 4th in the NL in strikeouts (200)◆NEWSPlayers Avoiding Arbitration Prior To The 2026 Non-Tender Deadline◆ROSTERSelected the contract of LF Mitch Jebb from Indianapolis Indians◆STATNick Gonzales ranks 4th in the NL in batting average (.303)◆ROSTERSelected the contract of C Axiel Plaz from Greensboro Grasshoppers
The Pirates got the bats going in an 8-3 win over the Reds, and Jim and DiNardo broke it all down on the NS9 Postgame Show Powered by Primanti Bros. Ryan O’Hearn stayed scorching hot, Bryan Reynolds delivered a much-needed homer, and Oneil Cruz responded in a big way with one of his strongest games of the season. The guys also dig into Bubba Chandler’s outing, where the stuff was obvious even if the command still came and went. From the power surge to the bigger-picture takeaways, this episode covers everything you want out of a bounce-back win.
Watch/listen now.
Comments· 0
The Debate
Was Brandon Lowe the MVP of the win over the Reds despite going 0-for-4 at the plate?
From Jim Rosati’s take on the show
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.
With Jim Rosati.
Chapters
Key takeaways
1
Bubba Chandler's stuff (16 pitches at 100+ mph, 11 whiffs, 99.1 mph average) is so nasty that if he just throws strikes, hitters will struggle badly. But he can't keep walking six and lasting only 4.1 innings.
Jim Rosati
2
The dropped fly ball in left-center was on Bryan Reynolds, not Oneil Cruz. Cruz was calling for it, and Reynolds needed to peel off. It fits a trend of poor outfield defense from Reynolds.
Jim Rosati
3
Brandon Lowe was the game's MVP despite going 0-for-4. His two defensive plays kept runs off the board, value that never shows up in the box score.
Jim Rosati
4
Using Dennis Santana, the Pirates' best reliever, in the eighth-inning jam instead of saving him for the ninth was 100% the right call.
Jim Rosati
5
This lineup's new ability to hit the ball over the fence can solve many problems that have plagued the Pirates for years.
But then you already talked about the one hit by Oneil Cruz off of a lefty.
Jim Rosati
So at that point in time, he's two for two versus lefties on the year.
Jim Rosati
Third time up against a lefty.
Jim Rosati
Second time today, he's up.
Jim Rosati
Monster homerun.
Jim Rosati
444, 111 off the bat.
Jim Rosati
Again, a lefty.
Jim Rosati
He's now three for three versus lefties at this point on the season.
Jim Rosati
I know it's still super early, but, like, that's encouraging, right?
Jim Rosati
That ball was absolutely murdered.
Jim Rosati
Just he crushed it.
Jim Rosati
I don't know if you can see how far behind me you can see.
Jim Rosati
I think the scoreboard in right field is in view.
Jim Rosati
Maybe not.
Jim Rosati
It was well, it was at least halfway up those seats in right center field.
Jim Rosati
It was an impressive shot.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
I can obviously hit it out there.
Jim Rosati
That's not that impressive, Jim.
Jim Rosati
clearly, we see the distance.
Jim Rosati
That's not that.
Jim Rosati
I could probably reach it with a pitching wedge.
Jim Rosati
Pitching wedge.
Jim Rosati
There you go.
Jim Rosati
There it is.
Jim Rosati
So, yeah, like, oh, no, Cruz has another home run.
Jim Rosati
Some added runs there.
Jim Rosati
So, you mentioned, it's, this game's, I'm not going to say it's blowing out, but, like, the Pirates are putting on some offense here.
Jim Rosati
And, again, very nice to see.
Jim Rosati
And this is coming at a time when Bubba Chandler is dealing on the mound.
Jim Rosati
he comes out the start of the game, what was it, four straight fastballs at 100 miles an hour plus.
Jim Rosati
The guy was averaging, like, 99 through the first four innings on the fastball.
Jim Rosati
I want to talk about that as well.
Jim Rosati
I know it wasn't pretty today, but that dude is just a monster on that mound.
Jim Rosati
And it's just, like, he was throwing fastballs very heavy today.
Jim Rosati
And talk about maintaining velocity.
Jim Rosati
Now, I know it was only four innings, but the pitch count was up there.
Jim Rosati
But, he was maintaining 99.
Jim Rosati
The stuff's nasty.
Jim Rosati
It's nasty.
Jim Rosati
And he was just spamming fastballs early on as well.
Jim Rosati
16 fastballs over 100 miles per hour today, 11 whiffs.
Jim Rosati
Average 99.1 on that fastball.
Jim Rosati
This was, I think we're going to see, here's the deal.
Jim Rosati
Bubba needs to just realize, and I think he realizes this, but he's got to put it into practice now, that his stuff is so nasty.
Jim Rosati
If he just throws strikes, people are going to have a really hard time hitting him.
Jim Rosati
Six strikeouts through those four and a third innings.
Jim Rosati
Like I said, that was the good.
Jim Rosati
There's some bad here, too.
Jim Rosati
He didn't give up a hit, but he did walk six batters.
Jim Rosati
He was effectively wild, one would say, today.
Jim Rosati
And it worked out.
Jim Rosati
He didn't give up.
Jim Rosati
He only gave up one run.
Jim Rosati
But, you would like to see him go deeper into games.
Jim Rosati
He can't be walking six batters.
Jim Rosati
And but today was just you saw the stuff on display.
Jim Rosati
It was it was outstanding stuff.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Like, I don't know if it's a carryover from spring.
Jim Rosati
That was his knock on spring.
Jim Rosati
But obviously, again, it's spring.
Jim Rosati
Right.
Jim Rosati
But he was walking a lot.
Jim Rosati
Six batters today.
Jim Rosati
This isn't something you want to see continue.
Jim Rosati
Like, even as good as Bubba Chandler is, you're not going to get away walking six guys in four innings to most lineups in most games.
Jim Rosati
So, he had he had a really shaky inning there in the third that wasn't really helped out by his defense too much.
Jim Rosati
Thankfully, though, the hit was taken off.
Jim Rosati
The earned run was taken off.
Jim Rosati
So no damage on him, I guess, in that sense.
Jim Rosati
So he does leave hit list.
Jim Rosati
Still is your ERA on the year.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah, it was a shaky third.
Jim Rosati
But again, like he did settle.
Jim Rosati
And then it was it was pretty bad.
Jim Rosati
It was a really shaky third.
Jim Rosati
Let's not let's not really sugarcoat it.
Jim Rosati
Walk.
Jim Rosati
And then, single turned E7.
Jim Rosati
And then, oh, another walk.
Jim Rosati
It was a really shaky third.
Jim Rosati
He got out of it.
Jim Rosati
And this is where I'm going to highlight Brandon Lowe for the first time here.
Jim Rosati
Bases loaded in that third inning.
Jim Rosati
Oh, runners on first and second in that third inning.
Jim Rosati
Sorry.
Jim Rosati
And just first and third.
Jim Rosati
Hold on.
Jim Rosati
Maybe I'm thinking wrong.
Jim Rosati
No, first and second.
Jim Rosati
First and second.
Jim Rosati
An outstanding play by Brandon Lowe on Ellie De La Cruz.
Jim Rosati
It would have been a base hit.
Jim Rosati
It would have been another run.
Jim Rosati
And Brandon Lowe saved a run right there.
Jim Rosati
Got that inning over with.
Jim Rosati
Like you said, you could tell that it was a little shaky.
Jim Rosati
And Brandon Lowe did just.
Jim Rosati
We've been harping that this defense isn't great.
Jim Rosati
Brandon Lowe typically not a great second baseman.
Jim Rosati
I believe he was the worst statistic.
Jim Rosati
Worst at second base statistically last year.
Jim Rosati
That first play in the third inning just.
Jim Rosati
It was.
Jim Rosati
You could say that was a game changer.
Jim Rosati
I know the Pirates were up like five to nothing at that point.
Jim Rosati
But without that play.
Jim Rosati
Like then it's five to two.
Jim Rosati
Bubba's still pitching.
Jim Rosati
He's just walked three batters.
Jim Rosati
He's given up a hit.
Jim Rosati
Like who knows what happens if that play isn't made.
Jim Rosati
So just an incredible job by Brandon Lowe just putting an end to that inning.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, absolutely.
Jim Rosati
just how many things could have dominoed.
Jim Rosati
that's the typical Pirates fashion.
Jim Rosati
Like that's how they lose and blow the games and leads and such.
Jim Rosati
And that could have been it.
Jim Rosati
But also like the implications.
Jim Rosati
It was just 4.1.
Jim Rosati
So the bullpen had to be used.
Jim Rosati
But the bullpen's been taxed.
Jim Rosati
so like if he doesn't even go 4.1 today.
Jim Rosati
If he's only going 3.2 because of that or whatever.
Jim Rosati
Like how much more innings that the bullpen has to cover today with another day game tomorrow.
Jim Rosati
So again, like Bubba has to go more than 4.1.
Jim Rosati
I'm not saying he did a good job and didn't allow it to fix that.
Jim Rosati
But like still, it could have been even worse.
Jim Rosati
So, but yeah, at the end of the day, like this is, I think it's just like the Bubba Chandler experience that we're going to, we're just going to have to live through this.
Jim Rosati
I think he's going to be wild at times, but at the same, at the, at the same time to go along with that, the stuff is so good that he's going to have starts like this, where it's just like, it drives you crazy.
Jim Rosati
Cause it's like, dude, if you just threw the ball over the plate, like we'd be, this game would be over an hour ago.
Jim Rosati
Right.
Jim Rosati
But he's still technically a rookie actually to say, I'm looking up, right.
Jim Rosati
Is he still, he's a rookie.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
He's a rookie.
Jim Rosati
He's still a rookie right now.
Jim Rosati
So eligible and such.
Jim Rosati
So he had a 31 innings last year.
Jim Rosati
So yeah, he still has a good run here going.
Jim Rosati
He had 31 innings.
Jim Rosati
So yeah, like he's still developing, like he's still seeing major league hitters for the first time in that sense.
Jim Rosati
Right.
Jim Rosati
He's still continuing this progression as a starting pitcher.
Jim Rosati
So yeah, I'm, again, you're going to see this, but on the other end of that, like, this is why he's also a rookie of your candidate because you see the stuff that he possesses and how good he can really be.
Jim Rosati
So again, it's almost like the karma Jinsky start for me.
Jim Rosati
Like you want to see better, but there's so much that was positive in this as well.
Jim Rosati
Like, I can't wait to see the next start and see how he builds upon this.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
at the end of the day, he didn't give up a hit, right?
Jim Rosati
He didn't give up a hit.
Jim Rosati
He only gave up one run.
Jim Rosati
Like, you got to be happy with it.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
You want to see him go deeper into games, but first start of the year, you're going to take this every single time.
Jim Rosati
I said the potential, you can see why he's the number one pitching prospect in baseball.
Jim Rosati
You can see why people are gushing about him because when he's in zone, he's like he was today.
Jim Rosati
He's unhittable.
Jim Rosati
And to be fair also, like he has to stay in zone, but when he's out of zone, he's still unhittable because that's the thing.
Jim Rosati
He was doing the fastball, the zone often too.
Jim Rosati
And they were swinging at it and missing.
Jim Rosati
So like, again, like just to show how good his stuff is, but yeah, he has to throw more strikes.
Jim Rosati
He has to trust his stuff a little bit more than what he does right now.
Jim Rosati
But also it could just be, he was amped up.
Jim Rosati
Like this is his first start of the year.
Jim Rosati
all these pitchers is the first time out.
Jim Rosati
They all can be pretty amped up.
Jim Rosati
Again, it was really effective, but I do want to go back to that third inning because we're talking about the defense.
Jim Rosati
The Oh, no Cruz experience, right?
Jim Rosati
That's what everyone's going to be talking about.
Jim Rosati
We talked about Bubba Chandler's experience, talked about the Oh, no Cruz experience him in the outfield.
Jim Rosati
There was a play that happened in right center and I know a lot of fans, I'm sorry, left center.
Jim Rosati
I know a lot of fans are pointing the fingers at Oh, no Cruz there.
Jim Rosati
Jim, you saw it live as well.
Jim Rosati
From my point of view, I think a lot of people on the broadcast also, Oh, no Cruz has had his hand up in the air.
If Oh, no Cruz is calling for the ball, it's Oh, no Cruz's ball.
Jim Rosati
And yeah, you could see it happening in real time.
Jim Rosati
You can see that Cruz was drifting over, calling it.
Jim Rosati
And Reynolds wasn't stopping.
Jim Rosati
And yeah, the ball ended up dropping.
Jim Rosati
They almost got, they almost got Noel V. Marte at the plate on that.
Jim Rosati
What a really nice relay from Oneil Cruz and then Nick Gonzales as well.
Jim Rosati
But Marte sneaked in there, but no, that's on, that's on Bryan Reynolds.
Jim Rosati
And I said, official score agreed, gave the error to Bryan Reynolds after originally ruling it a single.
Jim Rosati
But yeah, it's, I, it's one play, but it's a trend that we've seen here at his outfield defense.
Jim Rosati
It's not great.
Jim Rosati
And that should have been an out and it wasn't.
Jim Rosati
Right.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
To get them to curse, I guess, of a guy who has such range.
Jim Rosati
off the bat, I just thought that was Reynolds ball, but it's like, Oh, no, it was there.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
That's why he has all the tools to be a talented center fielder.
Jim Rosati
But yeah, again, from my point of view as well, and they're talking about, seemed like that was on Reynolds.
Jim Rosati
So let's do this.
Jim Rosati
Let's cut to Cody.
Jim Rosati
We'll come back and talk a little bit more about this game before we do.
Jim Rosati
Well, also, I just want to give a shout out to Sean Hooper for the 10 gifted NS9 memberships.
Jim Rosati
So appreciate you, Sean.
Jim Rosati
Thank you, Sean.
Jim Rosati
You're a real MVP here.
Jim Rosati
So yeah, let's go ahead and kick it on over.
Jim Rosati
This episode is brought to you by IQ Bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor.
Jim Rosati
IQ Bar protein bars, IQ Mix hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious, low sugar, brain and body fuel you need to win your day.
Jim Rosati
The Ultimate Sampler Pack is a great way for you to try all IQ Bar products and flavors.
Jim Rosati
You get nine IQ Bars, eight IQ Mix Sticks, and four IQ Joe Sticks.
Jim Rosati
All IQ Bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
Jim Rosati
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting, more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ Bar's brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
Jim Rosati
The Ultimate Sampler Pack includes all three.
Jim Rosati
My personal favorites so far have been the Almond Butter Chip and the Iced Tea Lemonade Hydration Mix.
Jim Rosati
It's just really full of flavor.
Jim Rosati
I love starting my day with it, and I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ Bar products.
Jim Rosati
Right now, IQ Bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ Bar products, including the Ultimate Sampler Pack, plus free shipping.
Jim Rosati
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64000.
Jim Rosati
That's MLB 64000.
Jim Rosati
Message and data rates may apply.
Jim Rosati
See terms for details.
Jim Rosati
So we got a real battle going on in the chat, Jim.
Jim Rosati
So let's also give a shout-out to Pierogies and that.
Jim Rosati
They also gifted 10 NS9 memberships.
Jim Rosati
Sorry, Sean.
Jim Rosati
You've been seen.
Jim Rosati
Appreciate you guys.
Jim Rosati
You guys rock.
Jim Rosati
Absolutely.
Jim Rosati
So we talked about the shaky third.
Jim Rosati
He goes out for the fourth.
Jim Rosati
Had a nice fourth.
Jim Rosati
Seemed to get back on track.
Jim Rosati
Looked good.
Jim Rosati
Then in comes the fifth.
Jim Rosati
Walk, fly out, walk.
Jim Rosati
Another big moment.
Jim Rosati
This is another opportunity where the Pirates are pirating.
He got, allowed some base runners there in the seventh with a single and a walk.
Jim Rosati
But, a scoreless seventh.
Jim Rosati
So, maybe the Pirates just got a little bit too greedy here, trying to get a third inning out of them.
Jim Rosati
But that eighth inning, yeah, started off Ellie, Homer, Sal Stewart, Homer, Suarez, single, Myers, single.
Jim Rosati
And, yeah, at that point in time, it was still just the Pirates with the six runs.
Jim Rosati
And the Reds were creeping in.
Jim Rosati
The Reds got the tying run to the plate in that inning, in the eighth inning.
Jim Rosati
And this place was rocking.
Jim Rosati
There were 22,000 people here on a Tuesday night.
Jim Rosati
And it was loud.
Jim Rosati
And, yeah.
Jim Rosati
Do we want to talk about, they turned to Dennis Santana.
Jim Rosati
After Don Kelly gets tossed, we haven't really talked about that, Suarez, ex-future pirate Eugenio Suarez, what looked like a blatant swing to me from where I was.
Jim Rosati
Very much so.
Jim Rosati
Gets rolled in no swing.
Jim Rosati
So, he gets some extra pitches.
Jim Rosati
Don Kelly doesn't agree with the call, let's say.
Jim Rosati
He gets tossed.
Jim Rosati
And then Suarez with a single.
Jim Rosati
And, yeah, that loaded the bases.
Jim Rosati
Now, that was a third hit.
Jim Rosati
And then another single once Santana came in to relieve Barco.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah.
Jim Rosati
So, we want to talk about Santana.
Jim Rosati
Also, an outstanding job getting out of that.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Yeah.
Jim Rosati
Absolutely.
Jim Rosati
the guy's dope.
Jim Rosati
That's why Doug loves him.
Jim Rosati
Still a zero ERA.
Jim Rosati
He did give up the hit.
Jim Rosati
But, again, he comes at a big spot.
Jim Rosati
And he produced.
Jim Rosati
again, like, the team was finding ways to not get themselves in that position of losing this ballgame.
Jim Rosati
Where we talk about trends, right?
Jim Rosati
So far, the trend has been runners in scoring position.
Jim Rosati
Same as 2025.
Jim Rosati
Same as 2024-23, right?
Jim Rosati
The Pirates team has also been a team mostly where it's like when they come to these spots, they find a way to lose.
Jim Rosati
Last year, not so much, right?
Jim Rosati
The pitching held up.
Jim Rosati
And so far, like, this game was a patented 2023 Pirates loss.
Jim Rosati
And they did everything they could to make sure they won.
Jim Rosati
And they also had insurance runs to make sure they won.
Jim Rosati
The offense helped out even further.
Jim Rosati
But, yeah.
Jim Rosati
Dennis Santana, big spot, also comes out of it.
Jim Rosati
Well, I'll add this, too.
Jim Rosati
Dennis Santana is your best reliever, right?
Jim Rosati
This was the eighth inning.
Jim Rosati
This wasn't the ninth inning.
Jim Rosati
It was a big spot.
Jim Rosati
And so you put in your best player to get you out of the big spot.
Jim Rosati
So I like the way that the Pirates used the bullpen here tonight.
Jim Rosati
At least the back end of that bullpen.
Jim Rosati
Like, deploying Santana right then and there ended up being absolutely 100% the right call.
Jim Rosati
And I got to talk about Brandon Lowe again.
Jim Rosati
Like, yes, that play.
Jim Rosati
Holy crap.
Jim Rosati
Again, like, tying run is on base for the Reds.
Jim Rosati
Tying runs up to bat for the Reds.
Jim Rosati
And I believe that one was Nathaniel Lowe, the pinch hitter.
Jim Rosati
Yep.
Jim Rosati
What looks like a base hit that's going to go through and extend the inning and score a run.
Jim Rosati
Brandon Lowe makes an insane catch on a, on a, like, just like a blooping liner in between first and second.
Jim Rosati
And doubles off the runner at first.
Jim Rosati
Like, just another insane play by Brandon Lowe at second base.
Jim Rosati
Like, that one also complete game changer because who knows what happens at that inning.
Jim Rosati
The Reds have all the momentum in the world at that point.
Jim Rosati
And Brandon Lowe just snatches that momentum right from them and ends the inning.
Jim Rosati
Pirates at that point were up by three runs and heading into the ninth.
Jim Rosati
At that point, you felt a lot better about the game.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, I think, and here's me to throw a little shade on some things, but, like, I think what you're trying to say is sometimes it makes sense and there is some truth to defense and, like, this whole defensive run stage.
Jim Rosati
And sometimes that matters just as much as runs scored.
Jim Rosati
like, I know he's gone, but you saw him on the end, but, like, there's so much talk about, like, a Ke'Bryan Hayes, but there's still value in that.
Jim Rosati
Like, Brandon Lowe went 0 for 4 to the strikeout.
Jim Rosati
He did nothing offensively to help this team win, but those two defensive plays helped out so much that there's so much value defensively that doesn't really show up in the box score.
Jim Rosati
Like, you don't see that on the box score today by Brandon Lowe.
Jim Rosati
You see the 0 for 4 to the strikeout.
Jim Rosati
But here you are again, like, you're talking, he was probably the MVP today because those two plays were huge.
Jim Rosati
He didn't add runs necessarily, but he made sure he kept a lot of runs off from the Reds.
Jim Rosati
Yeah, and again, like, he's not known for the glove.
Jim Rosati
That is the part of his game where, like, he gets knocks on that.
Jim Rosati
But he's been good so far this season.
Jim Rosati
I think he's a positive one defensive run save going into today's game.
Jim Rosati
And I don't know how many defensive runs saved he had today, but look for that number to go up when it gets updated tomorrow.
And then we'll be live with another post-game show.
Jim Rosati
And then we'll have an NS9 Live tomorrow night, I believe, right?
Jim Rosati
We're still going to do that, right?
Jim Rosati
Thursday.
Jim Rosati
Thursday.
Jim Rosati
That's right.
Jim Rosati
Thursday's the off day.
Jim Rosati
We'll be back Thursday with the NS9 Live.
Jim Rosati
So, all right.
Jim Rosati
You guys heard enough.
Jim Rosati
We're out of here.
Jim Rosati
Appreciate you all.
Jim Rosati
Bye-bye.
Jim Rosati
See you, guys.
Jim Rosati
All right.
Jim Rosati
That wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Jim Rosati
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Jim Rosati
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
Jim Rosati
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
Jim Rosati
It really helps us grow.
Jim Rosati
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Jim Rosati
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
Jim Rosati
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
Jim Rosati
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Jim Rosati
Thanks again for all your support, and Let's Go Bucs.
Comments· 0
Was Brandon Lowe the MVP of the win over the Reds despite going 0-for-4 at the plate?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.