Alex Stumpf examines the Pirates’ upcoming Rule 5 protection decisions, including Termarr Johnson, Lonnie White Jr., Mitch Jebb, and Derek Diamond. With a potential MLB lockout threatening the draft itself, which prospects are actually worth a 40-man roster spot?
Which Pirates Prospects Are Actually Worth Protecting?

With Alex Stumpf.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Stumpf doesn't think there will be a Rule 5 draft after the lockout. If spring training is only three and a half weeks long, he expects the draft to be an afterthought, so he'd be less eager to add players to the 40-man roster.
Alex Stumpf - 2
Protecting Termarr Johnson would be a tough sell. The 2022 first-rounder struggled at the plate in AAA, is coming back from a significant knee injury, and may not help the 2027 team much.
Alex Stumpf - 3
Derek Diamond is the candidate Stumpf likes most. He was the organization's minor league reliever of the year, throws a 95 mph fastball and two breaking balls with whiff rates in the mid-30s, and could become an up-and-down arm for a 2027 bullpen that needs depth.
Alex Stumpf - 4
Mitch Jebb might have the best odds of being protected because he has fans in the organization. If the power he showed in Indianapolis is real, that would help his profile a lot.
Alex Stumpf - 5
Stumpf is skeptical of Lonnie White Jr.'s .866 OPS and 19 homers in Altoona. AA baseballs were very bouncy in 2026, and Endy Rodríguez had a big Altoona year without hitting as well in Indianapolis.
Alex Stumpf
Players discussed
Full transcript188 paragraphs · show
It's been a quiet off-season so far, but we are guaranteed to get Pirates news on Tuesday. Rule 5 decisions are due. It's not exactly the biggest, splashiest move, but this is an interesting year for Rule 5 decisions.
Because every other year, at least since I've been covering the team, there have been one or two slam dunk, you have to protect this guy, he will be taking in the Rule 5 draft.
There really isn't that guy this year.
Furthermore, we don't know if there is going to be a Rule 5 draft in 2026 or 2027.
Good morning, and welcome to OffBeat here on North Shore Nine.
My name is Alex Stumpf, and this is a daily look at your Pittsburgh Pirates.
Players can only be protected in a minor league system for so long.
Depends on if they were drafted or signed by the time they were 18 or not.
They have to present opportunities.
And if you're not going to have an upward path for them, after a while, other teams can claim them.
So, like a Seth Hernandez is not going to be Rule 5 eligible this winter.
But another former first-round pick, Termarr Johnson, is.
And normally, you would think, yeah, Termarr Johnson, 2022 first-round draft pick, has been a very highly rated prospect within their system ever since he was selected.
He'd be a slam dunk to take.
We don't know.
If anything, I think he'd probably lean towards no.
For a variety of reasons, the one, just to address the elephant in the room first here, we don't know if there's going to be a Rule 5 draft.
The last time there was a lockout, the Rule 5 draft, or at least the Major League portion of it, was canceled.
Players didn't seem to, make too big a fuss over it.
But it is taking away potential opportunities, or Major League, 40-man opportunities for some players.
And those just weren't created that winter.
Now, there has been talk that when there is a new CBA agreed upon, whenever that will be, they will sort out when the Rule 5 draft will be.
But I'm skeptical.
Let's just say they agree to a new CBA on tax day, mid-April.
It's like, okay, we've got to get spring training going.
We've got to get the regular season started as soon as possible.
We have to figure out if we can make up any of these canceled games.
There's going to be a hundred things going through the air.
I can't imagine that Rule 5 draft is going to be of the highest priority.
That is going to be an afterburner thought at best.
Maybe it could happen.
Maybe they do it mid-season.
Maybe they do a variety of different things.
But like, I just have a hard time believing that if there's going to be like a three and a half week spring training, like there was in 2022, that they're going to squeeze in a Rule 5 draft in that time.
It's a real question.
I don't think there will be a Rule 5 draft.
And therefore, I am personally not as motivated to add players to the roster.
Now, adding players to the roster doesn't prevent you from making other moves.
The Pirates had a big Rule 5 class, or players protected from the Rule 5 class last year, and they still made plenty of moves.
Some players ended up being traded.
Some ended up making the majors this year, some didn't.
But I look at this list, and there's no one here that I'm like, yeah, you absolutely have to give him this opportunity.
Because another team will snatch him up.
I do think there could be good major leaguers in this bunch.
But we talk about how maybe this farm system is a little top-heavy right now.
This, I think, might be an indicator of that.
There are some good players here.
Some players who I think could make contributions at the major league level.
Some that, if you really do think there is going to be a Rule 5 draft, you absolutely have to protect.
But, and it's not like, the Pirates are absolutely jam-packed roster-wise right now.
There are 38.
I could see some non-tenders, some players who could easily be DFA'd.
There's a little fat on the roster.
Every team carries some fat at this point.
But enough about, will there be a Rule 5 draft?
Who are the big players who could be candidates?
And the way I view it, there are four that I think are worthy of some serious discussion.
The first being Termarr Johnson.
Who did not have a good 2026 campaign at the plate.
And then finished with a pretty significant knee injury.
Farm Director Michael Chernow said earlier this offseason that, well, don't take his word as gospel.
He is personally optimistic that Johnson could be ready to play by opening day.
We don't have that as an official medical report, but my takeaway for that is there's an expectation that he will play in 2027.
Which, whenever you saw the knee injury, I didn't know if that was 100% guaranteed at the time.
That's good news if he could play in any capacity in 2027.
But it's also going to be a tough year.
It's going to be a year where he has to rehab back, where he has to get his footing back.
And on top of it all, he did not do well in AAA at the plate.
He has been a slow starter, figure it out as the year goes on guy in his journey through the minor league system.
And maybe he would have had that type of year again in AAA.
But he didn't really...
The OPS didn't sink as low in Altoona as it did in AAA.
He is a first-round draft pick.
He has a high pedigree.
If I was a team that had truly no hope for 2027, like if I was the Angels, I would consider, if there is an actual Rule 5 draft, especially if games are canceled in 2027,
that would just mean that the guidelines that you have to meet, the boxes you have to check of him being on a roster the entire year, become a little easier.
He doesn't even have to be on the active roster the whole year.
You can start him off on the I.O., slowly ease him back, and then just plop him on the bench for two or three months.
There is a path towards, taking a player that if you really do believe in him, could be an impact player in the Rule 5.
But where the Pirates are right now, I just don't know how much Termarr Johnson would improve the 2027 team.
And with the injury question, I don't know, it'd be a tough sell for me.
Not necessarily a hard no, but it'd be a tough sell for me.
Three other guys who I think have more compelling cases, we're going to get to those in a second.
But first, I'd like to thank today's sponsor, Larine Co.
We all know nicotine pouches are popular, and part of it isn't so much the nicotine as it is the routine.
Loreen just launched a pouch that keeps the routine, but leaves the nicotine out.
Larine Co pouches swap out the nicotine and give you clean focus and support your enamel the whole time they're in.
Just tuck one in and go about your day.
Each pouch has a half cup of coffee's worth of caffeine, plus L-theanine and alpha-GPC for a smooth, steady focus with no energy crash, and it gives your teeth daily enamel support in between brushings.
It comes in mint, cinnamon, and mango, and it's nicotine-free always.
It's doing something good for your teeth, and it gives you smooth energy and focus without those jitters.
Every other pouch out there makes you pick between something that helps you focus and something that's actually good for your teeth.
This is the only one designed to do both, and it comes from a brand that's leading the way at supporting your oral health.
Give Loreen a try.
Right now, Larine Co is offering our listeners up to 50% off at ByLoreen.com slash North Shore.
That's ByLoreen, L-A-R-I-N-E dot com slash North Shore for up to 50% off.
Three players who I think are worth considering also.
There are other guys like Johnny Severino.
I know he had 31 home runs, but he hasn't played a game in Altoona.
Personally, I'm in a spot that there's no one on that Greensboro roster.
If you haven't at least touched dirt in Altoona, I can't consider you right now.
I have to focus on the 20-27 team, and none of these guys are top 20 prospects or anything like that.
So, if a team wants to roll the dice on a guy who has only played at the lower levels of the biters, good luck.
All the best.
But the three who have played at the upper levels are Lonnie White Jr., Mitch Jebb, and Derek Diamond.
Now, of those three, I am highest on Derek Diamond.
Derek Diamond is someone who I think could be a contributor in 20-27.
He is someone who could be an up-down guy for this bullpen, and if he makes the most of his opportunity, he spends more time up.
Maybe he doesn't go back down.
He had a .248 ERA between Altoona and AAA Indianapolis, with most of that being in AAA.
He was the organization's minor league reliever of the year.
And there's some stuff here.
95-mile-per-hour fastball with good spin.
23% whiff rate with it.
Slider, curveball, those whiff rates are in the mid-30s.
I'm not sold on the change-up, but I see a good three-pitch mix with two different breaking balls, a fastball that sits in the mid-90s.
I feel a little higher on him if he could, bump up that velo another mile-per-hour or two, but I don't think that's out of the realm of possibility.
We're going to have to see if he can execute it enough for it to be like a reliable out-pitch.
But I see someone who could make an impact in this bullpen, and this bullpen needs depth.
He is of the guy, of all these guys listed, that, yeah, I see how he could make an impact for the 2027 Pirates.
Mitch Jebb is someone who, I will admit, whenever he was in Altoona, I didn't really see the vision.
He never homered in Altoona.
So, of course, whenever he gets promoted to AAA in Annapolis, he homers twice in his first game.
Because that's baseball.
This beautiful, stupid sport.
This year, as a whole, between the two levels, 76 games played, 8 home runs, 14 stolen bases, 274 batting average, 784 OPS.
Like, it's a pretty decent offensive profile.
Someone who used to play middle infield, now outfield primarily, has speed, could be versatile out there.
I know the organization really likes him.
He has his fans.
And he was someone who stole 43 bags in 2024, stole 33 in 2025.
Injury-shortened year, just 14 in 76 games.
But that's within reason to think that he could have stolen 30 again.
So there's a decent speed profile.
I need to see if he can continue to hit.
I don't know.
If I would personally.
But, like, he is someone that, if I had to take a guess, maybe his odds are a little better just because he has fans within the organization.
And if what we saw in Indianapolis was true, I know it's different baseballs between levels.
I know there's a lot that could go into it.
But, like, if there is any power to that profile, I think it does impact him very positively.
And the final guy here, who is a name, is Lonnie White Jr., who was in the Henry Davis-Bubba Chandler draft class.
He and Chandler were these bonus babies that were able to be signed because Henry Davis signed for less.
And he had a big year in Altoona.
Like, he got off to a good start with Greensboro and then Altoona, 91 games played there, 19 homers, 12 stolen bases, 866 OPS.
It's one of those you look at and you're like, okay.
Okay.
I will say, though, like, he's not the first person to have, like, a big monster year in Altoona.
Like, I look, I remember the days of Matt Frazier and how he teetered off after that big year in 2021.
Endy Rodríguez had a huge year with Altoona, but then he never hit as well with Indianapolis.
There are question marks.
I get that.
I get the hype.
I get the pedigree.
If you think that, yes, this is the guy that we drafted in 2021, he was finally healthy.
We finally saw him reach his potential.
This is what we always thought he could be.
I'm just skeptical because AA's baseballs were very bouncy in 2026.
They flew.
And he is someone who has not hit at a high level or ever played for this year more than 90 games in a season.
I have my question marks, but I also get the pedigree.
I get if you think this was a breakout at age 23, which is unreasonable to think.
But it's another tough question.
None of these guys, I think, are a slam dunk, yes or no.
I can make a case either way for them.
And I think this is going to be an interesting question the Pirates need to answer tomorrow.
It doesn't necessarily mean if they protect all these guys, oh, that means they're punting the rest of the winner.
No, they protected a ton of guys last year, had a great winner.
If they don't protect these guys, that doesn't mean, oh, they're going to use these roster spots on major league spots or major league guys.
Don't know that necessarily.
All we're going to find out is either, A, the Pirates don't want to risk losing these guys under any circumstance.
Or, B, if the Pirates think there actually is going to be a Rule 5 draft at some point.
Thank you so much for listening to OffBeat here on North Shore Dine.
If you haven't already, be sure to subscribe to Revified Podcasts or check us out on YouTube if you want to see my smiling face.
Thank you so much for listening.
We will talk again tomorrow.
All right, that wraps up this episode of North Shore Nine.
Thanks so much for tuning in.
Whether you're listening on the podcast or catching us on YouTube, if you enjoyed the show, please give this video a thumbs up.
And don't forget to hit that subscribe button if you haven't already.
It really helps us grow.
And if you're listening on the podcast, a quick review goes a long way in helping others find the show.
Plus, be sure to tell a friend about us.
There's always room for more here in the NS9 community.
And for those looking to support us a little more, consider joining our Patreon, become an MVP member, and get exclusive perks while helping us continue to bring you more of the Pirates content you love.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.
Thanks again for all your support, and let's go Bucs.


Comments· 0
Should the Pirates add Termarr Johnson to the 40-man roster to protect him from the Rule 5 draft?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.