FanGraphs prospect analyst Eric Longenhagen joins Jim, Tyler and DiNardo to sort through the Pirates’ system from Konnor Griffin and Seth Hernandez to Johan De Los Santos, Edward Florentino and Murf Gray. Eric explains Bubba Chandler’s early struggles, identifies the arms who could help Pittsburgh’s bullpen this season and gives honest evaluations of the system’s biggest upside plays and red flags. It’s a detailed look at where the Pirates’ next wave really stands.
Eric Longenhagen Breaks Down FanGraphs’ Pirates Top 50 Prospects

With Anthony DiNardo, Jim Rosati and Tyler Sweeney.
Chapters
Key takeaways
- 1
Konnor Griffin could genuinely be as good as Paul Skenes because an everyday player has a bigger daily impact, and a shortstop with his range makes the whole pitching staff better, Skenes included.
- 2
However you feel about the strategy, the Pirates mishandled moving Carmen Mlodzinski to the bullpen. He got angry, and the decision should have been handled so he didn't. In a playoff bullpen, Eric would rather have Bubba Chandler than Mlodzinski.
- 3
Murf Gray is a sneaky trade candidate at the deadline. If the Pirates think he's a first baseman with sketchy plate discipline, they should 'pump and dump' him while his stock is high.
- 4
It may already be time to be done with Marcell Ozuna: 'father time is undefeated.' Ryan O'Hearn alone is outproducing what the two signings cost combined, so the O'Hearn deal is a win and the Ozuna deal is not.
- 5
Khristian Curtis should be called up in August if the Pirates are in a playoff push. He goes on the 40-man after the season anyway and could give the bullpen length ahead of guys like Isaac Mattson.
Players discussed
Full transcript1000 paragraphs · show
*outro music*
*outro music* *outro music* *outro music* *outro music*
*outro music* What's going on, everybody?
Welcome to another episode of the North Shore Nine Podcast presented by FanDuel.
This is WNS9+, which means we've got a special guest with us today.
I'm Jim, joined by Tyler and DiNardo as always.
But joining us today from FanGraphs, prospect guru, Eric Longenhagen.
Eric, how you doing tonight?
I'm good.
I just got done meditating about bat speed and approach angles.
And now I'm going to coerce women into sleeping with me because of how much I know about those things.
Like any guru.
That's what...
Look at you.
Yeah.
You just have to.
I just think it's, minoxidil.
Yes, I am.
That I could use.
Well, if you've seen the gender breakdown of this podcast, I don't know how much coming on here is gonna help you, but we'll do our best.
Darn it.
That's why I got into the baseball prospect game was all the babes.
I guess I'll try magic the gathering again.
Yeah, there you go.
That'll work.
All right.
So let's first off.
Thanks.
Thanks for.
Thanks for joining the show.
This is always one of my favorite episodes of the year.
We're just diving into the fan graphs top prospect list.
you released it a couple weeks ago.
yeah, 50 names on there.
We're obviously not going to hit up all 50 players.
I think that'd be impossible, but, I do have it broken down into, the cream of the crop.
and then, who's that next wave of position players coming.
And obviously this is a pirates team that's competing right now.
They're in a, they're in the wildcard hunt.
So, who of these people can help this team out this year?
and then, maybe some long shots to round things out.
So yeah, I'm excited to dive into stuff.
I guess, I guess first off, I don't want to spend a ton of time on America, just because we've talked about him so much on this show, but I feel like we can't really talk about this list that you put out.
Without discussing Konnor Griffin, first and foremost, obviously no longer a prospect.
He's graduated off of these lists.
but when we spoke at this time last year, you were, you were turning the, you were, you were starting to be like, you know what this guy's special, right?
he's made some changes.
This is a different guy than when he was drafted.
And then when we spoke in the Arizona fall league, you had, you had a lot of really glowing reviews and then you're right up on fan graphs about Konnor Griffin heading into the season.
just floored me.
So I guess, just how special is this guy, Eric?
Yeah, I think, I guess it probably would have been in April, really spring training of 2025 is when he's on a field with big league guys and clearly stands out and getting a chance to see what it looks like with him playing shortstop.
It was just meaningfully different than high school looking Konnor Griffin on the showcase circuit where like he was playing right field.
And, but yeah, like I think that there was thought in some of the amateur scouting community that as teams made decisions about Konnor Griffin inside the top 10, there was some FOMO about like, Hey, is this Mike Trout?
But he plays shortstop like the physical tools have a chance to be on that level.
Sky's like dedicated to getting stronger and staying fast while he does.
And, or like Julio Rodriguez, but he plays shortstop type of thing.
And that's how things are looking.
some of the hit tool concerns from high school that I had personally, like had him outside that the top 100, like right after he was drafted, just because of what I perceive to be hit tool risk.
Some of the data from high school was like yellow flag ish.
it turned out to be fine.
Like he, you guys have seen what it's like with him in the big leagues.
He swings inside a lot of sliders.
but I don't think it's going to be so bad that he's Carson Williams or anything like that.
and he just has so much power.
It's playable power.
It's going to help him have a higher batting average than you guess for someone who probably is going to strike out, a little bit more than the average cat.
But yeah, it's just, it's monster power and maybe gold glove caliber shortstop defense.
I just think he's one of these guys who makes the field look so small on defense when he's running the bases.
It just seems like he wants that extra base.
He's going to take it.
It's just a few strides for him.
He's so fast.
He's just so physically different than most of the other guys that, I do think he's really special.
And I think, of some of these top of the top of the group, whether you're talking about the prospects each year or like some years, Jackson holiday is your top guy.
And some of yours, Carlos Correa is your top guy.
I think we're talking about a player on the Correa end of that scale and maybe even physically a little bit more gifted.
some of that maybe is just recency bias, like watching older beat up Carlos Correa the last handful of years, but that's, it's a franchise altering guy.
So they nailed it.
they've nailed a couple of these.
It looks like the last handful of years, especially from this player type of, risk reward, high variance guys type of player who, if you hit, it's the only way the pirates are going to get a player like that.
And, they've been doing this now for, a couple of times that seems like it's going pretty well.
I think that's the second time he's called him a franchise altering guy on our podcast.
Second time in a row.
And I think you've read that a few times as well, but yeah, I'm, it's exciting.
I think that, there are just across sports, like how many fan bases get to watch a guy like this blossom.
And just because of, injury right now is just, it's, that's still to come.
Like, it's still an exciting thing to anticipate happening and watching it unfold.
Like when he turns the corner, it's going to be, this is going to be a lot of fun.
Yeah.
Well, you mentioned like he's on the closest side to like a Carlos Correa, right?
So part of me wants to ask you, would you say Paul Skenes is better than Carlos Correa or Carlos Correa is Paul Skenes?
Because you mentioned that Konnor Griffin's about to make Paul Skenes, the second best player on the pirates.
So do you still hold to that?
Yeah, I think there's, I think there's a real chance and, some of that is just, the value of an everyday player versus the value of a pitcher.
but I've seen skeins twice this year.
I saw him with team USA when they rolled through, as they got tuned up for the WBC.
And then when the pirates were here, I splurged and sat right back there behind home plate on, Meg rally.
And I both went, to that game and he's unreal.
just his feel for location, considering how good his stuff is and how subtle some of the shape manipulation is, from splinker to change up and from sweeper to slider.
Like everything is just different enough and located exactly where he wants it to be that, it was impossible.
He was on pace.
He was, I thought that I was going to get to see his first career, complete game that day.
And then like Gregory Soto started warming up and I was upset, but yeah, it was, I don't know.
I don't know what's going to be tough because skeins is so special, but I do think it's in play that Griffin could be that good.
And the impact of a day to day guy.
And what's funny is Griffin's going to make skeins better because having a guy who can play shortstop, the way Griffin looks is going to be a force multiplier for the entire pitching staff.
Not just skeins.
What was it like outside looking in?
we're the pirates, right?
It's, we're poverty.
So how cool was it to see them also not only be like super aggressive with Connor, but also like nine year, $140 million contract, like lock them in.
There's no, there's no opt outs.
Like this is, he's a pirate Eric for a long time.
Like how big of a deal is that?
I think it's a really big deal.
I think, especially given some of the news today around MLB's CBA proposal stuff that, teams, I don't think there's a, it's a coincidence that teams are locking in younger guys.
It is, it has just been a trend with mixed results across baseball since, John Singleton and Scott Kingery and Evan Longoria really like is really, the first one where the rays were just like, this guy's off.
We're just like, this guy's awesome.
I know he's played for two weeks up here, but let's do this.
and I do wonder if some of it has to do with, if we're gonna have to reach a salary floor, why not, why not do this?
I think that has something to do with it, but yeah, I think when, I think when the front office hits on Ryan O'Hearn and Spencer Horwitz starts emerging and as soon as it's not going right.
you start to have confidence in the way they're spending your money and you get to do something like this.
And, it's awesome.
I think that, Griffin gets immediate security.
He's going to be paid pretty handsomely, within the context of everyone's lives.
if he is as good as we think he's going to be, then it's a huge bargain.
It's a huge bargain, for a guy who's maybe going to be, like a seven win player, give or take annually.
it's an enormous bargain.
So I was happy to see it.
Corbin Carroll's working out great here in Arizona.
I think Kevin McGonigle is going to be awesome.
So I think teams are a little bit more choosy about who they decide to pay.
and it's like really only this top handful of Julio and, but I think it's working out, for the majority of them.
And just the windfall of drafting a player like this and paying him, the bonus of a top 10 pick and then the league minimum.
And, it's nothing compared to what these guys are generating in terms of like dollars per war.
Yeah. absolutely. I agree with that.
And then like I said, as a fan to just knowing that like, you can go out there and buy a Konnor Griffin Jersey and it's not going to be obsolete in three years is nice to know too.
I had a drew good in Jersey, a drew good in Grizzlies Jersey.
Yeah, I know they traded him for Mike Miller, like two weeks after I, did you have the Mike Miller's great?
No, the drew gun. Yeah. What would you even call that? His haircut? It's not like quite a rat tail.
Yeah. It's like a buzz cut mullet. Yeah. Yeah. Drew good. And interesting guy. Yeah.
Yeah. I've got all kinds of, from when I was a kid, there were definitely times when it just sucked when you get a guy's Jersey and then he'd get moved or, imagine like having a wonder Franco Jersey or something like that.
don't Felipe Vasquez jerseys out there.
I'm sure. Yeah. Yeah. Moving on. another guy who's graduated, you had him as your, I want to say fifth starting pitcher on your top 100. fourth, actually. Bubba Chandler. obviously huge stuff. a little bit of,
of a rough start to the season. How concerned are you with just like the control aspect here?
This is like why he was a tier below Nolan McClain for me. but long-term, like I wouldn't worry about it. There's so many guys from, Sandy Alcantara to Skubal to Max Scherzer. Like when you have, when your stuff is this big, it takes you a minute.
It is going to be fine. if you want to find the guy who, the disappointing outcome is Michael Kopeck. When you're that big and you throw this hard and your stuff is that good, Michael Kopeck is about as mid as you can be. so I think like, I'm still very bullish about Bubba. it is pretty common for guys whose stuff is this big.
This early to take a minute. Once they start facing big leaguers, like who are just more, much more selective and able to, what you out a little bit more than the minor leaguers are, who just have no chance. Like you're seeing it with Seth Hernandez. Now, like these a ball kids, they have no chance.
but the big leaguers, they do this, like, Yordan Alvarez exists to take, Jose Alvarado deep. So, you just have to nibble more and refine. And certainly like, you'd rather, he just hit the ground running. It'd be seamless. He, be dominant right away. But, and the guys who never figured out. And there's a subset of those guys for sure.
for sure. they moved to the bullpen, they become Wade Davis or whatever. but they still ended up being pretty good. And the track record for guys whose stuff is just this good. Like it's pretty encouraging. So I, it is, I know it feels like a long time, but when you like, go back and look at.
Skubal and like Sandy Alcantara, it's like, Oh yeah. Like Sandy Alcantara came up and then he could not really crack the rotation consistently for two years. And Skubal had like ERAs in the fives and above for multiple years. And I just think that it's going to be okay. Like you tinker, you find it.
This guy's so talented. it's not ideal for this year is like the team is, has, playoff aspirations and some of the key parts of the offense are on one year deals.
And, but I think he's going to be great.
So in terms of Bubba, I, at least personally, and I know I'm not alone in it, but also, I don't know if it's a major concern for me. I think there's been some issues maturity wise with him. but also aside from that, is there anything just looking at him that you think could just unlock that Bubba Chandler that obviously he could be just based on the stuff.
Like, is it a pitch mix thing, mentality thing, or just how he's attacking guys?
Yeah. I think the, just refining the fastball command is going to be the biggest piece of it. If we're like looking at, reasons to, can they find a way to lean into how hard he throws that like makes his breaking ball play?
Like what like stuff plus thinks it should play? Like, this is a guy who's, evaluation from my perspective was the changeup is the pitch that is going to be the best one for him because of how big his arm speed is.
And, his breaking stuff for me has always been more just like fine because of how hard it is, not so much because of how much it's moving. and then if you look at like what he's getting swings and misses on the last two years, like some of our leaderboards have changed on the site, which is really goofing.
I'm goofing my ability to look this up as fast as I used to be able to do. They're really great though. But yeah, like, his, the swinging strike rate on his slider, the last, actually this year, it's way better than it was last year.
and his changeup has backed up. So that's weird. And like, there might be something to do as far as digging into why that is. but yeah, we, 2025, the big league sample we had was, this is a comfortably plus change up in terms of eliciting swing and miss.
And the sliders more fringe average at 10% swing strikes. And then this year, like now the sliders changed and looking at the movement profiles of it, are they any different slider is a little bit different. It's got like a little bit more, but not much more like lateral movements, but pretty similar.
The changeup is pretty similar. Like there's nothing about the movement of these pitches. That's like tipping me off that stuff has changed. So to me, this is just like early days, he threw 104 changeups last year in the grand scheme of things. It's not that, it's not that many. I just think that this is a guy who needs reps and time, but the maturity thing, like that part of it, the handful of like Chandler big league starts that have just happened.
Happened to beyond for me this year, like outside of me working on the pirates list. Yeah. I could see that once it starts unraveling on him, like when he was here in Arizona, it spirals. There's not like a way he doesn't stem the bleeding at all. Like he's, he spirals. And yeah. So I, to me, that's, that is a poison maturity thing. And, maybe some of that will come, not just, bubble himself maturing as a person, but as the catching
situation stabilizes and he's been pretty good back there the last little bit, and maybe he gets more reps and, so I don't know how that's going to shake out, but yeah, I could, I definitely see what you're seeing there too. And, but as far as just like looking at his stuff and why some of the results on his secondary pitches have changed, I don't have a great explanation for that as we're, just as we're sitting here.
I'm just curious. I'm going to ask you in your perspective on this too, because he was probably included in this whole polarizing situations have with Carmen Mijinsky. And I say this because as I'm sure you're aware of Carmen Mijinsky goes out of the rotation into the bullpen. And a lot
of people were disappointed. Carmen was putting up numbers. Bubba isn't, we know this stuff.
You talk about refining it again, your perspective. Is this someone who like, do you think this would benefit him to stay in the rotation, to keep continuing working on this to get better? Or is something like the bullpen help these type of pitchers? You talk about Max Scherzer, you talk about, Skubal and
stuff. None of them really went to the bullpen. Scherzer did his rookie year for a little bit, but just curious. Yeah. I think, I think it can be done, but the workload piece of it is hard to manage.
Like, I think that when you ask a guy to yo-yo back and forth, like, Hey, we're just going to put you in the bullpen. And then next year, you're just going to be in the rotation again. I think that those
changes are harder to make than, it is to conceive of. it's going to be really interesting to see how the Mariners piggyback experiment goes. The Braves, I think I read earlier today that the Braves are going to toy with that as well. but if, I think the reverse is true
if bubble were on any like season long innings cap, then maybe at the end of the year, if you do make the playoffs, he is the guy who goes into the, into the bullpen and just breathes fire for an inning at a time. And just makes your bullpen like theoretically one monster
arm deeper, than it would have been. And I would probably be more comfortable in, if that were the situation, if like we're in the playoffs now and the pirates have made it that I would want bubble to be that guy coming out of the bullpen rather than Mlodzinski. Let's just pause and take an
opportunity to appreciate the fact that the pirates have more pitching that they know what to do with and have an issue like this crop up at all. is a positive thing. It's a good problem. Yeah.
But it definitely, you don't want it to create tension to the point where there's open discontent with, the guy who's effectively being, demoted, but
in Bubba's case from an inning standpoint, last year, it was a hundred innings in the minors and 30 innings in the big leagues, like the training wheels are off. so I think if you
want him to refine, how much more does he have to like learn at AAA? Like, do you option Bubba and let him start because you are then allowing him to work on the things that he wouldn't be able to
work on if he were in the big league bullpen, which is like, Hey, when you walk two guys get out of it, like take a deep breath and get out of it. Hey, the third and fourth time through the order, like let's pitch backwards off of your secondary stuff. Like those are the things you want him to
work on. And I think you're either, you're either doing that in the pressure cooker, the big leagues, or you're doing like a lesser version of it where, when he does end up walking two guys or he gives up like a tough luck single and then walks a guy, he's just pirates. It's,
they didn't feel the baseball. Right. They, but yeah, like, he can just rip 99 past these AAA guys more readily than he could the big league hitters. Like you're not really sharpening
the parts of him that you want to. So yeah, it's a difficult, if it's a difficult tightrope to walk, and that's on the manager and it's on the front office to get the players, to buy into whatever your decision is. And so regardless of what strategy is right, they didn't handle this in the best way
because while Mlodzinski got pissed and, ideally you handle it in such a way that he doesn't.
Yeah. I just want to note Kurt Schilling and I got in an argument this spring training and, he said that Bubba should be in the minors right now. So that's what he
has to say about that. Chill. Yeah. I haven't met chill. I, or neither electronically nor in person, but as a like Philly area kid and who would like those D backs teams growing
up. yeah, I, she'll carry some weight with me, even though like, he seems like a lunatic now. He seems like a crazy guy. More chicks than any of us.
So, that's right. Yeah. Yeah, that is true. shifting gears to another pitcher, but this one's not in the majors. He's now, he's, he, I guess he's now the number
one prospect in the pirate system right now. And that's, Seth Hernandez. I know when we talked in Arizona over the fall, like, again, like you were like, this is the high
school arm that you want to bet on. and you were interested to see what he looked like. I was reading one of your chats earlier this year, and I think, it was pretty clear to everyone that he was not being challenged very much in the Florida state league. He was just,
he was just absolutely destroying these kids. since then he's been moved up to the South Atlantic league. It's a very hitter friendly environment. He's a little, he's had a little
more rough patches there, especially when it comes to his command and his strike throwing ability.
But, I guess I'm just first impressions of Seth Hernandez as a pro, like how high is this guy's ceiling and what red flags are there to watch? it's enormous.
It's, upper nineties arm strength and a crazy change up and breaking stuff that is better now than it was when he was in high school. Seth had problems in high school on the showcase circuit where his fastball shape was more hittable than it is now. That's another
thing that is, that is better now than like some of the Seth Hernandez stuff from high school where it was like, yeah, it's a hundred, but like these high school kids are not missing it as much as they should. And, let's see how that trends over time. Like what we're learning with Andrew Painter
now is that sometimes over time, whether it has to do with, painters injuries or not, like just the way you finish throwing the baseball can change in a way that meaningfully impacts the
way it moves. And, in Hernandez's case, like he's such an unbelievable athlete. He gets so far down the mound. His fastball has that angle that, is flatter and can be uphill when he executes it at the top of the zone. And when you throw a hundred and they're doing that guys are
going to be underneath your fastball. So, that pitch is going to be a monster for him.
This changeup, I think is really going to be a huge deal. and his breaking stuff is better now. And there's, there are more than one breaking ball here that like he knows how to use.
some of his breaking balls have that like arm side bend to them that give him a second weapon against lefties. he it's the whole package is there. It's just about him
getting feel for how fast his arm moves and, refining feel for location. And just like we're seeing with Chandler now, that stuff is probably going to take some time as far as like,
the high school pitchers who I've covered in the 10 years I've been at fan graphs. Matthew Liberatore and like Dylan Lesko and, Noble Meyer and some of these guys,
like they don't have, they don't have this guy's stuff. This is a, this is just a different level of athleticism and physicality and just like exactly the type of body that you want a pitcher to have. And, every little thing, Lesko is the one where, his changeup
was equally as absurd as Sethi's is. And things have not really worked out for that guy. And some of that is like injury. And he came back and just like, could not throw strikes to the, to a point where it
was like yips more than just like this guy's command is bad. but just in terms of like how vicious Hernandez stuff is. And just like, it is, it is basically every box that you could want,
but like a teenage pitching prospect to check, pretty emphatically. And then he just like carries the risk with him that demographic of player does. Cause he's just playing Russian roulette with his ligaments every week. but yeah, he's super exciting. We definitely threw
caution to the wind when I, did the pirate system and obviously like, Brendan Glowski, who's the other full-time prospect writer at fan graphs. Now we hired him in November, he came from pirates pro scouting. So he like had to recuse himself from doing the
pirates list. And so it was just my baby. but when it comes to like, Hey, I want to put this guy on the top 100 and I want to like, put a 60 on him.
That's a conversation that we have to have. And Beej was just like, dude, look, yeah, every it's, as good, a young pitching prospect as there's been in some time. And it's really exciting, even though, yeah, there's
a reason he's not a 70 year and 80. And that has to do with just like young pitchers and their track record in general. You talk about how just vicious it is. And you see Seth throw triple digits pretty regularly. I feel like, do you think it just based on
mechanically and things like that? Do you see any more risk with him in general? Like, does he look like he's just an all out guy at all times? Like the arm speeds, obviously legit. You're right about it, but is there anything that just glares out? There's
like, Ooh, this, there's some, there's a good bit of injury risk here.
Sure. Yeah. his arm stroke is long and really more for command that's the thing that you watch him and you go, hopefully that will shorten up over time. just so that it's more repeatable for him, but yeah, pitching injuries,
some teams, I don't know if we're catching, doing their systems at the wrong time, or, if the injury issue across amateur and minor league baseball is just like bad that,
there are parts of it that when we were in like proto driveline days, when yes, all these players are doing this or more and more of them are doing some version of it, with weighted balls and using
applied science to maximize what your body is capable of. and sometimes I thought to myself, if you're becoming more mechanically efficient and if you're like lower
body is getting stronger and that's helping you throw hard, like, isn't that going to help you stay healthy maybe? And I just think that now we've had some time where these guys have had careers or not
as they've done this five, 10 years worth of like the driveline era of like a generation of player, basically, during this like driveline era of pitching development and still just like
the Orioles, so many guys injured and, I'm working on the raise list now. It's our last one of the 30 and their position players are like, I've got so much red in my spreadsheet.
Now. Like I have a phone call with a guy tomorrow just to be like, all right. And now what's Daniel Pierce's deal. And what's, what was Brendan Summerhill's deal and Tate and Gray's got loose bodies in his elbow that he had surgery for. How long is he going to be out? And, but I don't know, like,
I think that these athletes across pro sports, but baseball has its own, it's its own type of grind on your body and, injuries are part of it. It's not like football. I want these guys to be able
to play catch with their kids and brush their teeth without feeling pain. but I also don't think it's like Chris Benoit or, Dave, Dorison or anything like that, or, but,
but with Seth, it's just like, his arm is so fast. Is he going to get hurt? Probably. But also like Max Scherzer's delivery is as violent looking as any guy from the last 25 years.
And he's barely been hurt. Like it took him to like, it took him to like age 40 to start getting hurt, which is crazy to me. But Scherzer like posted every day for two decades, basically every fifth day for two decades with his delivery looking like that. So I think really like, we can't really predict it, but in all likelihood, yeah, like a bunch of these guys who throw this hard, it's not good for your like, it's not good.
I didn't think we'd have a Chris Benoit mentioned. I know, right?
That's from, that's, I've been listening to too much Dan Soder podcasts. Now I know about wrestling, even though I don't watch wrestling. I know about it just from like, because funny people, I like wrestling.
One more and the Arizona Fall League, you talked about how you thought he might be a very fast riser. And I think that's a question. A lot of pirates fans are asking as well. a lot of them want to hear this year in the bullpen, which I don't think is going to be reasonable, but yeah, he flew through Bradenton dominated there.
Now he's in Greensboro, the command, as Jim mentioned, is walking like over six per nine and such. Where do you envision his path? Like, what do you maybe think and see him as a big leaguer one day?
Yeah, I think, the chalk, the chalk, like roster timeline is he gets added to the 40 man after 2029 and then is in the mix in 2030. But the rate at which, he's already been promoted, he's tracking ahead of that.
So really the thing to watch is like the innings count. So he's at 51 innings. Now we're through, like roughly half of the season. So if he ends the season with like 100 innings, then we're only really like another year or two away from him pretty comfortably having what a modern starters annual innings total would be like demonstrated in his log.
So, it's pretty standard for like 20 to 30 innings to be the year over year increase for these guys. So if he finishes around 100 innings, it's not crazy that at the end of next year, like September call up time next year, or maybe more like that, like late August time so that you've retained rookie eligibility into the following year.
Right, exactly like that. And then you're in the mix for like, okay, prospect, pick incentives and all that other stuff. Those seem to be working, by the way, like as far as, changes to the CBA, teams that is having the intended effect.
So maybe that's like the, I think the optimistic, just throw him in the bullpen at the end of next year and he's not going to blow through his innings total. If you make the playoffs or anything like that, maybe I could see them having incentive being in position at the end of next year, where you say, this is one of our 12 best guys.
And our big league team is good enough that matters to us rather than the years of control starting at exactly the right time for having this guy for, as long as we possibly can push that stuff aside.
This is one of our 12 best pitchers and let's bring him to the big leagues. That's not crazy.
Moving on to the one other guy that you've got listed in the top 100 here, Edward Florentino, that next wave behind Griffin.
I always thought it was interesting looking at the two comparing the two last year, especially their time in Bradenton.
like Florentino was 18 last year, just like Griffin was and numbers wise, they were like exactly the same.
how, first off, do you think this guy can stay in center field and how much does that, like, if that is possible, is that put them on a whole other stratosphere?
Where do you end up seeing him?
And like, what's, what is his offensive upside?
Yeah.
The Florentino profile is super interesting because he's got this like glorious uppercut swing.
And so much of his contact is in that like optimal between, 10 and 30 degrees of launch window.
And so he is going to get to the power that he develops.
he's a pretty big 19 year old kid.
He's, like six, three, probably like two, 10 right now.
I don't think he's going to stay in center field.
I don't think he looks very good out there.
I don't think that's that big a deal.
It is why he's more toward the back of our hundred right now, as opposed to like in that area with the guys who project to do similar stuff on offense and play an up the middle position.
but, I like tinkered around with our hundred, like a little bit today, just because the Marlins list ran today and Carson Milbrand entered and stuff like Florentino's right there at 99.
right behind Jimmy Crooks with, the catcher with the Cardinals who has some of the same stuff where this guy's going to get to power, but he's a killer defensive catcher.
Florentino, injured earlier this year, he's 19 and a half.
He's in Greensboro, how that uppercut swing ends up playing against like better velocity and pitchers who can execute stuff a little bit better.
We're just going to see.
I know that, it's been like a, what a little over a month since he's back.
He's played 35 games in Greensboro.
he's striking out a good bit and his like triple slash line is not awesome.
The underlying stuff is still pretty positive, with like launch and, power.
And, but I think that there was definitely some, at least from what I could tell the little bit of social media lurking, I still do.
And definitely in my weekly chats where people are bringing, names to the chat where they're just like, Hey, you're not as high on whatever guy.
Florentino has tended to be in that mix for us because, of the, corner projection of some of like, the hit tool, not skepticism that he's like going to bust, but just that.
He wasn't a true talent, three 40 hitter, like two 90 hitter, whatever he was doing in Bradenton and on the complex.
Like, there were signs here that this guy's selling out for power means we think he's going to get to power, but it's probably going to be a slightly below average hit tool on a corner outfield defender.
And so we just think he's more like a good everyday player, like a two to three win player annually, rather than like one of these, four to five plus win guys.
but we like him.
but it surprised me if he ended up being a platoon guy, not really.
it's just, it can be easy to fall in love with some of these complex and a ball guys.
And as the quality of play overall, especially the pitching and a ball has gotten worse.
it's easier to get tricked by what some of these guys are doing from like a triple slash line standpoint.
we've got on the player pages now in, yeah, for the players who are at triple a or the guys who are in the Florida state league, where there is just uniform track man data at all of the ballparks.
Except for Daytona.
we just have like the expected Woba for these guys based on the quality of their contact.
And so even last year when Florentino was destroying, the Florida state league, we had like a three 19 X Woba on this guy.
so, against like a four 13 Woba that he was, that he was posting for real.
So that's one of those things that just tells you like, ah, maybe he's the quality of the contact here is not quite like a, all-star level guy.
and it's, you could see the stolen bases have already come down.
He's, it's not really that type of dude.
Yeah.
It's not really that type of guy where it's like, 30, no, like 2020, probably not, but like 2025 Homer guy who's in a corner and walking a lot.
Yeah.
It's more like that type of player.
That'll play.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That'll work.
We'll live with it.
I do want to talk about just a few other offensive players, some position players before we dive into like, I want to talk about just like guys that we can, who can help this team this year.
But before we do, let's hear from Cody real quick.
This episode is brought to you by IQ bar, our exclusive snack hydration and sponsor IQ bar, protein bars, IQ mix, hydration mixes, and IQ Joe mushroom coffees are the delicious low sugar brain and body fuel.
You need to win your day.
The ultimate sampler pack is a great way for you to try all IQ bar products and flavors.
You get nine IQ bars, eight IQ mix sticks and four IQ Joe sticks.
All IQ bar products are clean label certified and entirely free from gluten, dairy, soy, GMOs, and artificial ingredients.
With over 20,000 five-star reviews and counting more people than ever are fueling their lifestyles with IQ bars, brain and body boosting bars, hydration mixes, and mushroom coffees.
The ultimate sampler pack includes all three.
My personal favorites so far have been the almond butter chip and the iced tea lemonade hydration mix.
It's just really full of flavor.
I love starting my day with it.
And I couldn't imagine starting my day with anything else other than IQ bar products.
Right now, IQ bar is offering our podcast listeners 20% off all IQ bar products, including the ultimate sampler pack, plus free shipping.
To get your 20% off, text MLB to 64,000.
That's MLB 64000.
Message and data rates may apply.
See terms for details.
All right, Eric.
Give me an Eric's laugh at that.
That dub over.
I love it.
Yeah, that's so funny.
you mentioned Florentino being a guy that you got, you all are lower on than most than most other publications.
And, definitely something that I've noticed.
but on the flip side of that, someone that you seem to be higher on, Yohan de los Santos.
And I saw him for the first time this spring.
And, when I put eyes on him, I was like, Oh, this guy is, this guy is small.
but then you see what he's been doing and like the contact ability just seems to be incredible.
And he's super fast.
It seems like the pirates are like dead set on keeping him in the infield for now.
You guys have him projected as a, as a center fielder, which like, in my opinion, I think like that's where he could really excel.
But like, what is it about him that, as a 17 year old, like what's, what is like instantly stood out with him to have you put that 45 plus future value grade on him?
Yeah.
when I was working on the buckos list, the complex stuff had been going for long enough that how little he was swinging and missing was pretty obvious and like crazy.
anytime a guy's running like a single digit strikeout rate like this, it's different than just like perfectly fine, 15 to 17% range.
Like this is a different area.
and for DSL and like rookie level players in general, the individual trait that is stickiest, like that is actually stable and carries through.
It's not exit velos or anything like that.
Like it is really just your contact rate is like the thing for the DSL and complex level guys that is actually a skill that you can say, okay, this is, this is part of this guy's profile.
And some of that has to just like to do with umpiring at the DSL level and all sorts of stuff like that.
But, and they love Santos's case.
Yeah.
we did a lot of film work, just again, like elevating this guy to this degree.
It was like, Hey, let's just, can someone cross-check this for me?
Can someone, am I being irresponsible here?
And, this guy moves the barrel around when you're small, like he is small.
It's not like five, seven small.
He's five, 10.
and he's narrow, but he seems like a short five, 10.
And when you look at your guys, well, and I, Hey, as a five, 11 guy, I'm totally with you.
You're definitely six foot Eric.
No.
In the, with, I've got, orthotics that will probably, that probably pushed me up to six foot, again, ladies.
but he's five, 10, but like, he's a strapping kid.
Like he, to me, he looks like.
A pretty serious, like defensive back type prospect.
so I don't necessarily think he's going to be, they had to measure these guys.
Like, if he's playing in Bradenton, they have ABS, that these guys have to like be measured for real.
and maybe some of the kids who were in the DSL last year and we're like going to come up for extended spring training.
Maybe they weren't captured in MLBs annual measurements or something like that.
I, that's plausible.
but I feel pretty good about how strong he's going to be able to be.
I don't think he's so little and so slight that he's not going to have relevant physicality.
And then this like bat to ball thing is pretty special.
And again, like part of why he's speculatively projected to center field is because some of the tools that, we have access to through sourcing, like I've showed you guys
some of the synergy stuff before, true media is another one where like teams have access to, true media is like video log, which goes all the way down to the DSL.
And I can, when a guy is doing this statistically all, that's where it's like time to call in a favor because we have to see 30 swings from this guy to really see what it looks like.
And then like get some updated data and see what that looks like.
And this is really great.
Like this is, if they love Santos were a young for the class high school player, I feel like he'd be talked about in like the same way, Corbin Carroll was coming
out of high school where it's like, yeah, he's small, but he's really good and he's really fast.
And, where's he going to play?
Well, we don't know because, I don't think he can play the infield.
His hands are just not good enough.
Like he just drops the baseball.
It's just, he's, he just doesn't catch the baseball on the ground.
these high hoppers or skill.
Yeah.
Right.
So he'll fit in.
I think, I think like given the state of the infield across major league baseball right now, second base beyond the top couple of guys and third base is aging
that you want to do whatever you can to keep these guys on the infield.
They're just more valuable when you can do that.
But in my experience, when you're on the fringe, you don't end up playing there.
Billy Hamilton didn't, moves to center field.
Roman Quinn goes to center field.
it just tends to be that this type of player, especially when they're on the smaller side, ends up in the outfield.
right.
Mookie.
Yeah.
Mookie.
And like Mookie moved back shortstop and he's playing defense, but like has the beating that his body's taken from playing shortstop every day for two years.
Is that why he's hitting a buck 98?
Like maybe, so, whether or not that move has actually worked out, I think is debatable, but he certainly can play shortstop.
I think, De Los Santos and Wyatt Sanford, both are the two guys, two position player prospects in the system beyond Florentino, where there is pretty obvious everyday upside.
And certainly there's risk and the time value of this is part of the equation too, because future value, like it is a value grade ultimately.
but yeah, like as a, as a leadoff hitting center fielder, I think that's possibly, or I think there's going to be more power than you think, just looking at this guy, when you first see him and you're just like, Oh, he's little.
And then I just like, you get up on him and it's like, his shoulders look like this.
And, yeah, I was in Florida for some of extended, I was like in PA and Florida for like, a whole, like all of April, basically, going up and down the Gulf coast.
And, I, De Los Santos, I think is a, is a little bit more physical ceiling than you'd think given what his amateur report was, which was just like, this is a little fast guy.
And it's like, actually, like, I think there's maybe something else happening here that, if I'm right.
And there ends up being more physicality than you think the hit tool foundation is there to weaponize it like that.
Like he's not going to be one of these guys who, has to like, Oh, well then let's, is he going to hit enough?
Like, no, I think that part of it's already going to be there.
And just every bit of power he goes into, he's going to hit for because the contact piece of it is already, is already there.
Just so all I heard out of that was that De Los Santos, Mookie Betts, Corbin Carroll.
Corbin Carroll.
That's it right there.
But you also did mention Wyatt Sanford there.
And that's a guy that I know Jim's been a little bit high on.
personally, I think the swing and miss is a little bit of a problem, but you did write some good things about him there.
And it seems like he's really growing into that power.
Tell me what I should believe in him.
Well, it's weird.
Like he's one, honestly, where what to do with him is much more difficult to know because the way his profile has changed from last year to this year is really bizarre.
And I can only conclude having watched him that like Bryce to rang and a bunch of the brewers, like Jake Bauers, I'm convinced, like there are teams who are at least experimenting
with like giving everybody Julio Franco's bat where they're just like, here, swing the heaviest bat you possibly can.
And let's see how that goes.
Like, so you're going to hit the ball harder if you do this.
And so like Sanford, his contact rate last year and as a, and as a high school kid, was pretty good, like a standard deviation above average.
I think it was like in the 80%, like low eighties, like upper seventies, when you look at high school, Wyatt Sanford, and then, first full year, Wyatt Sanford, he had a contact oriented profile and now his contact rate has absolutely tanked.
And his power metrics are like sky high.
He has totally flipped what type of offensive player he is over the course of 12 months.
And, like guys break bats and then they have a different color bat.
Like, so what I'm saying is not, necessarily true, but it just looks like a guy who is swinging a much heavier bat than he was 12 months ago.
And the impact that it has had on his profile is now he's got like a hard hit rate up over 50% and his contact rate has tanked all the way down into like the low 60%, which is like
Gabriel Arias territory.
It's not really great, below what can be good unless you're, Joey Gallo type of territory.
And I don't really know how to interpret that.
The defensive piece of it for Sanford is still good.
He is tracking as an above average, future shortstop defender and that gives him a certain floor.
And then what is going to go on with his offense?
Like I really don't know.
but I do think that it's not done settling that the change from last year to this year is so extreme and I, like people can go read the full report.
Like it's meaty.
I still think that we have yet to settle on what this guy is going to do on offense.
And really what the way I have it projected is that everything will end up being a little bit closer to average.
I do have more power projected than, then contact it at this point, just because of like what it looks like right now.
But it is crazy.
Like I had, I've never seen some of the power stuff across the minors generally is just up across the board.
Like there's something going on with the ball maybe, or enough guys are, have changed the way like everyone's doing teacher men stuff now or whatever it is like enough guys, maybe enough guys are like training or swinging in a way that, all it might take is
like 20% of the players in the minors, like having using a heavier or whatever it is.
Like it doesn't necessarily have to be the baseball, but we think it could be, Brendan and I do anyway, just like the hard hit rates and everyone's max exit velocities like are up to ticks and, hard hit rates across the minors are up like three
percentage points.
And even with, even knowing that this change for Sanford is like so crazy that there has to be something else going on.
Like there has to be some other change that has happened here.
And so I still think that we're in this area where like Wyatt Sanford might, if he strikes out this much, like in perpetuity, then he's not going to be good, but it's just so weird and so bizarre.
I'm just where I have him is just valuing how strange this is and betting that things haven't settled here and we'll be, we'll stabilize as he gets a better feel
for like, whatever it is going on.
And again, I'm like mostly speculating.
It's just me watching him swing and what it looks like watching him swing.
It just looks like he is holding a heavier bat and he's just having a harder time controlling where it goes.
And I just think they're going to dial that in and this guy can play shortstop and it's really bizarre and profoundly interesting what's going on with Wyatt Sanford.
I didn't think we get a teacher man reference tonight either.
Yeah, man.
Hey, my algo, it's like, yeah, we're on the same algo.
It's baseball and it's just like, Hey, well, some of it is I have cousins who were in college.
And so it's just like, whatever stuff there, whatever there I get fed, whatever.
And it's sometimes I'm at a game and it's just like, Hey, that's my cousin in the swimsuit.
It's not, that's my cousin.
She's in a frat, she's in a, in a sorority at UCF.
Like I don't follow some rando who's at a frat party.
That's my cousin Liza.
One more guy I want to talk about before we get to like the folks who were right on the cusp of the majors.
what a, what a season he's having is this someone who one, can he play third base to like, how much is he going to start jumping up on lists if he continues
to hit like this?
And like, can you keep him in Greensboro any longer?
Like, do we got to move him to Altoona now?
I think that if he, I don't know, like another, after the all-star break, like if this just continues to this extent, then he has to go to Altoona.
it's so funny.
Like I was sky high on this guy before the draft last year.
Like I had Murph, I don't know exactly where I had him.
I had him in the back of the first round.
that is this year's, which I have to update still.
Come on, Eric, be better.
19th.
I had Murph last year and he was 73rd.
Yeah.
there are still like the stuff that was a problem at Fresno is still a problem under the hood.
there's more chase happening.
I know he's like, he's walking, especially since Greensboro, like his walk rates gone up.
there is still chase under the hood.
That scares me for, righty hitting corner guys who chase a lot.
They are dicey.
Michael Franco, like that's the archetype of player where it's like, ah, this is some years are good and some years are not.
and so that's in the mix for Murph.
I think he can play third base, but not well, like it's just one of those where we live with this guy playing third base for us because of what he's doing on offense type thing slash he plays first base.
if you have a better defender on the roster who you like to play every day, or, he plays third base.
And then if you're winning at the end of the game, he comes out and Jared Triolo does or Murph moves the first bit or whatever it is.
But, he's good.
I have the same grade on him as I did before the draft.
He's a big six, four, like good timing at the dish.
He can throw, like there's maybe he can play right field.
maybe he could be like a Pat Burrell-esque left fielder where he doesn't run well, but he will throw you out.
Like he runs to down into the corner to grab that would be double that you think is just like you're coasting in the second and he hoses you type of guy.
Like there are avenues.
I think he's going to be, this grade, this like 45, grade is like good role player who, maybe he has to come off the field against righties.
Like you pinch hit for him late in a big spot against righty or, he gets replaced on defense, not like a true every day, every inning player, but he's good.
he's another one where the data goons are like super duper in and I get it.
but I do think it's going to take double and triple a pitchers executing, breaking stuff against him before we start to see like what some of the problems in college, why he lasted until, the 73rd pick that's, there's still a reason for that.
but it is funny to me.
This does happen sometimes where, well, first where I'm like sky high on a guy before the draft.
and then the industry basically says no.
And there were, when you do it, like I do it for the draft where I'm less trying to publish an industry consensus and more trying to publish my opinion, this happens.
And, Behiva Alloy, I had ranked 11th last year and he went, 31st and Caden Bodine, I had 18th and he went 30th and, Misiorowski, I was like crazy
high on.
It doesn't, sometimes it's works and sometimes it's Peyton Graham.
I had Peyton Graham really high.
He's bad.
you had Henry Davis.
Really?
Yup.
So that was, what do you, and that's sometimes it's just like, who would you have taken?
Sometimes they go to a bad college.
Hey, who do you think?
But yeah, with Murph, it will be funny if suddenly like I'm the low guy on him, like just for having him 10th.
And some of these guys in front of him, like you said, like they're going to, they're graduating once I'm done with the raise and we can pull all the graduates off.
Like he'll be whatever it is sixth.
but, and he's good pick.
Like, I think we can firmly say that 12 months out, like that was a good pick regardless of how things go.
he's maybe a sneaky trade candidate for them.
If they do want to do like buy at the deadline, if you think that you want to like pump and dump this guy, like I bet they could, if they still, if they think that, yeah, he's
a first baseman and it's like sketchy plate discipline, then they should absolutely tell, whatever, tell Jonathan Mayo that he's awesome and then trade him.
Teams do that team.
I've been, Hey, like, no, I was like, Hey, I'm pretty sure Christian Campbell's not good.
And I had people up my butt being like, yeah, he's awesome, dude.
He's awesome.
And I was like, ah, I don't know.
You're like, yeah, he's awesome.
You're going to look like an idiot.
Like I'm in the red too.
So yeah, the Red Sox dude too.
At this point, Franklin, yes, he's awesome.
There are aliens, Eric.
They tell, they're just like, yeah, tell everybody there's aliens.
Okay.
Tell them.
What is our center fielder?
But, so yeah, go ahead.
It's hard to see you because El Gato.
It's off.
Yeah.
Oh, just shut off.
Oh, well, anyways, no, you tell about, prospects graduating and whatnot.
So, I want to talk to me maybe a lot about the near ready group here.
That's coming up.
I'm not sure if anyone's going to really graduate anytime soon, but like your Wilbur hotels, your Esmerlyn Valdez and Valdez is the password, which by the way, complete bar and you're right up about him.
Pronounce his name.
Pirates fans are not going to not know how to say his name when they had all those players and people I had to pronounce before, but Hunter Barco, Antwone Kelly, Khristian Curtis, Termarr Johnson.
So I want to ask you like, who do you think is going to have maybe like the biggest impact sooner than later, for the Pittsburgh Pirates who are maybe looking for some impact players right now in this roster?
I think the pitchers, I think stacking the bullpen with guys who throw a hundred is a good thing.
I think that, don't tell and Kelly, those guys, maybe Khristian Curtis, Khristian Curtis.
I do really like, I think he's going to be a fixture towards the back of the rotation pretty soon.
He's the guy who's on track to do to like that thing I mentioned with Sethi where, Hey, it's August 20th.
Are we sure this isn't one of our best 12 guys?
Let's bring him up.
Like that's the thing.
Khristian Curtis could be this year.
He's going to go on the 40 man after the season.
So if you think he's one of your best handful of guys and you're still trying to make a playoff push in August and September, then call him up.
He'll retain rookie eligibility.
Maybe he'll shove.
Maybe he'll be on top 100 lists next year, just because as a high confidence, fourth starter type guy, like we put top guys on the, on the Hondo like that every year.
so Khristian Curtis is maybe the one where, could he, could he conceivably be like, in a pirates playoff push rotation?
like the guy's Ashcraft is shoving and all that, like maybe not, but, in the bullpen as a guy who gives you length, who you'd rather have doing that than, Isaac Mattson or whatever, like maybe.
so I think those guys, I think like the password is going to be volatile.
He's chase prone.
He is going to have years where he frustrates you.
And then he's going to have a couple of years where he hits 20 bombs and plays like an okay center field.
how he fits with like cook and Valdez and some of these other guys, like Valdez puts together a nice at bat, he's patient, he has a real approach, he's flawed.
He's going to strike out a bunch and he's a terrible defensive player, but, he's something.
And I think he's about as ready as a 22 year old can be.
so I think that, any of those guys in like a platoon with Callihan or, at a, at a certain point it will be time and maybe that's, we're already there, to just be done with Marcell Ozuna, like father time is undefeated.
And you just take the fact that the O'Hearn signing is a win and Ozuna signing was not, and just know that like what you paid for those two guys combined O'Hearn on his own is outproducing and it's still, it's just a win.
but I think that whole group, the way they've built the farm system with depth, where they've just given themselves opportunities to find something.
it's working for them.
I think it's working for Miami a little bit too.
Rafael Flores just has that late blooming catcher look to him.
And obviously like you just, there's other guys, especially Andy right now, who you just want to give.
Yeah.
Andy.
Give them some runway and just see how it pans out.
But once you collect a ton of guys like this is what you give yourself the opportunity to do is find the guys who were just always going to bloom a little bit later and have that happen under your roof.
and as much as we want to talk about the Dodgers and money and, what it does for them, the start of their team being relevant again was scrappy, Justin Turner and
Muncie and Chris Taylor.
and so like giving yourself the opportunity to like tweak a guy who's in his mid to late twenties and find the right thing.
And now you have him for his half decade of team control.
Like I think they're in, they're in position to do that, with a, with volume.
I don't think Nick Yorke is anything.
Davis Wensdell can like play defense and that's why he's on the 40 man, but he's a, he's a fringe guy too.
but yeah, I think, I think that they're set up okay where they have pitching depth and they have like outs, like if I'm talking about prospects, like their
cards and poker, like they just have enough guys that I think that they can scrap together a real team.
And, I don't know.
I think, is there anybody else lower on my list?
That's like, well, I was going to say like the one, like the, like the obvious huge flaw on this team right now is the bullpen.
So like, Kelly, we've seen up for one game.
Don't tell we've seen in that role.
We've seen Bidwa get called up.
and then, a guy like Khristian Curtis, just reaching triple a.
And then even Derek diamond, having a really nice start to the season.
Like our, I like diamonds.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So like out of those guys, like none of them have real, like don't tell So tell us the one guy who I think has shown like some really good signs early on.
but yeah, like, I guess if you were to rank like those guys who could potentially help this bullpen right now, right?
Like Curtis, don't tell Bidwa Kelly diamond.
Like, if you just pick your top three there, like who would you put in the bullpen right now?
What would that look like?
I think diamond is the one where the way I have him ranked is in part because of how often he's hurt.
Yeah.
But in terms of what his stuff looks like, he and Bidwa are both like, you have power breaking balls and throw hard.
And that tends to play at least in a middle relief capacity.
Bidwa's command has always been bad enough that it's like round down on what you expect his role to be.
I have those guys back to back on the list.
I think diamond from like a talent standpoint is a little bit better just because the command piece of it, when he has been healthy, has been marginally better.
And obviously the way he's pitched so far this year is like absolutely lights out.
That was one where after this list published, the feedback was, Hey, good on you for having Derek diamond on there who was been left for dead for having been hurt so much.
but yeah, those, I think those guys, I think diamond Antwone Kelly is more a long-term thing than he is a right now thing.
I know that he was put on the 40 man and some of that has to just do with having protected a guy who throws this hard.
but he's got round down traits a little bit on his stuff.
Like, his fastball is playing like a below average pitch so far this year.
So he's, he seems to be a little bit further away.
And then I guess if there's like, so I would say diamond and Bidwa and definitely don't tell like would be at the top of the list of those three guys.
And then if there's a sneaky one, it's Matt Ager, who I do think looks like a starter.
Like he's enormous.
He throws strikes.
what would that guy look like if you just let him air it out for an inning at a time?
that would be pretty interesting.
I know that he's cooled a little bit the last like two or three times out.
He hasn't gone as deep in games and, but he's one where like, if you just let him cut it loose for an inning at a time, what might that look like?
But that's more of like a late season decision that you make than the thing you do right now.
Derek diamond might be able to help the bullpen, what in the next, if he pitches well at triple a, over the course of the next, three weeks, like what are we waiting for?
Let's let you, while this guy's healthy, he's 25.
Like, let's do this thing.
Yeah.
Love it.
some just high variance guys, before we wrap things up here, we've talked a lot about Tony Blanco jr.
back when we were in Arizona, he just took the, took the whole league by storm.
one of your knocks on him was his conditioning.
he's in Greensboro this year.
What's stood out to you.
Is this a guy who like, are you seeing any more positive traits out of Tony Blanco jr?
it's not so many strikeouts that it's definitely, it's not like an Elijah green territory or Quentin young territory where it's like 40 plus percent of the time.
it's going to be a slow burn.
He still is just so freakish, like six, seven to 50.
It's crazy power.
And it is crazy.
Yeah.
I just think there are guys who it's enough power that you can swing and miss as much as, you just like I said, Joey Gallo, when you look at the bottom of
the contact rate leaderboard, there are Aaron judges down there and show Hayatani is down there and Kyle Schwabers down there.
And it's just like, you have enough power that it doesn't matter how much you swing and miss you're dangerous in enough parts of this.
And that's the thing that's going to dictate how good he is can he be dangerous all over the zone or is he just going to be dangerous in the part of the strike zone that he swings through naturally and he doesn't really move the barrel around at all.
and I think when you're six, seven, and when you've been hurt as much as he has, we just don't know yet.
And it's crazy that we're already, we're it's, mid June and he's already played more games this year than he ever has in a single season before.
it, the conditioning thing.
Yeah.
Like when you're two 43 and you're like ankles and your calves are that skinny and all of your injuries are lower body injuries to there.
There's gotta be something done about that.
you can't just be like, ah, I don't know.
It's random.
Like, no, like clearly it's not.
let's try to do something different with this guy.
he looks, just on tape.
I haven't like gone to see him.
He's been healthier.
He's been healthy.
So that's a positive thing.
at the very least, it's just about like, how much power is he going to get to?
but yeah, there's a whole raft of guys in that like 40 plus tier in this system where you want to value what the upside is because of how much power that they have or, project to have.
And there's enough swing and miss going on that you have to consider them a low probability prospect.
And just like how you value a guy who has that ceiling and she was that right tail outcome as part of, their mix.
It's difficult.
it's one of the harder parts of my job.
There was like, I think it was a sub stack article that Ben Lindberg sent me before the season where someone studied my stuff.
Like, cause it's been 10 years at fan graphs.
And so like, I've written so many words and put so many, grades on players, individual tools, that like it's ripe for study.
And they found that like some of the guys at the very bottom, like the very bottom of our team by team lists, the hit rate, just like, do you make the big leagues or not is higher at the very bottom of the list.
And that's because like the uptown relievers and like fringe utility guys and third catchers and stuff like who are at double and triple a, I sneak them on there.
And then the guys like Tony Blanco and Daryl Morrell, and they have a higher chance of busting than Johnny Pareda does.
Johnny Pareda is going to play in the big leagues because he's a catcher who doesn't strike out at triple a.
Yoel Pozo is a catcher at triple a who doesn't strike out.
Like that guy's going to play in the big leagues at least a little bit.
So we sneak him on there and then, but you don't, you want to value a guy like Daryl Morrell who just signed for a couple million bucks more than you do the fringe catcher who's like hopped around waivers.
And that's like what's at play here with Blanco and this whole group of like Flores and plaz and Morrell and the relievers and Kelly and travieso to an extent where they
have a right tail outcome that is like, you're a nasty eighth inning reliever.
Who you'd love to have, or you hit, 30 bombs one year, like Chris Carter, and then go to Japan or whatever it is.
Like those are the outcomes for that, for that group.
And I have them tiered, like layered just based on the defensive fit.
Flores is going to catch.
He's flawed, but he has all those late bloomer characteristics because of his size and his, the way he's put together.
Like those guys break late.
Tyler flowers is a good example of what I think Rafael Flores jr.
Could do axi applause is more like the little powder keg.
Like he's not big like that.
He's squat, like fullback build guy, but it's just so much power and he's getting better on defense.
Daryl Morrell, man.
Like I wanted to do some irresponsible stuff with Morrell as far as ranking him.
Yeah.
Because when you put on the, he's so athletic, like, yo dude, like, I don't know how much power that guy's going to have.
It's crazy left-handed power for a guy who I think can actually play shortstop and it's just way more swinging and missing on the complex.
And is it advisable to absolutely like when they'll slam him as high as like I did De Los Santos and you're just the guys, the guys who can hit are the ones who tend to be good.
yeah, man, all those guys, Ronald Navarro, Ronald Navarro, like he might not ever throw strikes.
but he also has Josh haters fastball.
So, I'm going to, I'm going to want to value that guy more than I do some of the, like I love Easton Carmichael.
He can really play defense.
He's going to be a great backup catcher, but man, like Ronald Navarro might be a lights out closer.
Like he might be a guy coming into an all-star game at the end who you're just like, you got no chance.
So excited to see this guy against, three of the best guys from the AL or whatever, like that whole group from, Flores down through Navarro on the prospect list is like, who knows how things are.
They're extreme variance guys.
Yeah.
A couple of rapid fire questions before we let you go here.
just cause I've noticed it's been asked like four times by John already.
John wants to know, who's your favorite catcher yet to debut?
Oh, plaza is so much fun.
Plaza is so much fun.
Carmichael's, there's a chance that Easton Carmichael is so good at defense that he's just, he's that he really should be on this list where like, I've got deuce Gorson
or that he should really be like where Murph, like sandwich between Murph, Greg, and Hunter Barkley, he might just be the 30th or 40th best catcher in baseball because his defense
is that good.
Would it be fair to say that like, he's the guy that might be like the most likely to reach the major leagues over those guys.
He might be the guy on this list who is as big a lock to be a big leaguer as any of the other ones, because inventory at that position, like the guys back there, especially, and
I'm not one of these like, Oh, they all catch on one knee now and it's bad.
Everything's getting worse.
I'm not one of those guys, but, the one knee catching and receiving, you are more exposed and guys take a beating back there and you just need depth at catcher and the guys who
can play defense are the ones who play in the big leagues forever and ever.
And that's this guy.
So I would, yeah, I think like the, if we're doing like the bar graph that we'll do on the top 100 list where it's like the probability that of the outcome, like bell curve, Carmichael's got like no shot at being like a Buster Posey type or like a William Contreras
type of hitter, like Shay Langley or his type of hitter or something like that.
But he almost has like no chance of busting either.
Like just his ability to play defense at this, at this level on every aspect of defense, from framing to throwing to blocking, like is cranked up to nine or 10 and he's going
to be a damn good big leader for a long time.
It's just like, is, he's going to hit in the nine hole and, or is he going to be like one of the best backups or Martin Maldonado type of guy?
Like, how do you value that when guys like William Contreras do exist?
So, he's got to be a 40, but that's, he's going to play forever.
And then last thing I have for you is from, Anthony Murphy over at Bucs On Deck.
he wants to know a little bit about Carlos Tejera down in the DSL.
but also, biggest breakout guy from the other prospects of note.
And this is a good chance for me to just bring up, like, do we need to start getting excited about Lonnie white jr again?
I do think Lonnie that he for sure looks way better than last year.
and in years past, I, he was one where he, when I was working on the system, his performance had improved enough that I stripped everything down and was just like, let's start from scratch with this guy.
And, I just don't think he can play center field.
I think that's going to be the thing that ultimately makes it difficult for him to do anything other than have like a cup of coffee.
is that Lonnie is, he does strike me as just a corner guy.
yeah, Tejera, I worked on, he's in the DSL, he's, projectable.
He's like lanky.
There's definitely room for strength on his, on his build.
his swings, pretty explosive.
It's really noisy.
at the time I was working on this, I just wasn't confident in the hit tool piece of it enough to like elevate him to the main section of the list, but he's definitely of the guys on the DSL roster.
There were really just like two position players who I was just, who stuck out from film study.
And one was you, Andrew Santos, who's I think also the youngest guy on the roster.
shortstop again with good back speed.
And then Tejera was the other one where you could see he's six, two there's room and he's swinging hard already.
Those are the two guys who are just from like a week of games.
It was just obvious.
Like the tool, the showcase tools were there for those two guys.
Oh, how's Tejera doing?
Yeah.
24% strikeout rate in the DSL is pretty scary, but it's 10 games.
So like, let's see how it goes the rest of the way.
I do think that's of the guys in the DSL.
Those are the, those are some of the other names.
and then other breakout guys from the others of note, which is just like, I ranked 50 guys.
It just depends on how good the org is, how deep we go.
It just happened to be a nice, even round number in the pirate system.
50 guys is really good.
40 guys tends to be like the average farm system depth.
from the others of note, my favorite dudes, I like on, DSL pitcher to watch is on El Soriano, who I just, think delivery wise.
And he's walked a bunch of guys, him and Claudio, STLE are the two where like, they look most like starters to me.
the complex, those are probably my guys.
I really have to go back and watch Ming-Suan Zhang, who was just like, where do they find this guy?
Do you guys have like any sources in the org who you could ask like where they found Ming-Suan Zhang?
cause I just didn't know.
I can, yeah, I can, I can look around.
Yeah.
He's all right.
So he's pitched in two games.
He had not pitched in, he's walked a bunch of guys.
he's just a six foot seven Chinese guy, like playing baseball.
So that's crazy.
But, I don't, I knew nothing about him when I put him on here other than those things.
and I don't have the pitch data sitting in front of me right now.
It's actually like, it's on my other laptop, but the, I'm curious because it's like a six foot seven Chinese, 18 year old playing pro baseball and go into the DSL.
That's cool.
There are only ever like a handful of non Latino DSL players every year.
And they're invariably is like one or two Korean or Taiwanese kids.
And, an Australian guy or two, and maybe like someone, including the pirates, like traffic in Australian talent and, the occasionally European guy or African
player, the pirates do that too.
It's really cool.
And that, kudos to them, like playing your flag in some of these places where baseball maybe still could be a thing.
I don't know that China is necessarily going to be one of those places.
it's hard for Europe to be one of those places because there's only so much space there, but I think Africa is really interesting.
it does seem like more people in Africa are getting interested in playing baseball and the Dodgers have an academy there and the pirates have been, active there.
So it's really fascinating.
But I think that, yeah, if I had to, if I had to think Carlos Tejera is a good one of like the others of note, breakout picks.
And then, on all Soriano, the lefty who's on the complex right now is the other one where I liked him on tape, but he's not throwing strikes.
So Robinson Smith, that's another good one.
Robinson Smith is an Australian, pitcher whose mom was an Olympic swimmer.
And now she's on like, she's like a CEO of a company and is on the board of like several other companies.
pretty interesting family and Robinson Smith's like six, four and has real arm speed and he's raw, but that, he's six, four and he's got a good looking delivery and real arm speed.
And, his mom was an Olympian.
So there's some of that stuff going on and that's going to be interesting too.
Those are, those are, I think my complex guys who might break out.
It's like the old Madden, like create a player where you're just picking parent.
Oh, that's right.
What years would that have been?
That would have been like in 10 to 12 ish.
I feel like, right.
Yeah.
In that ballpark.
Probably my game cube still works.
So I still fire up Oh five.
You got to rock when I drink cast every now and then.
Love it.
There you go.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I run that deep cross with Randy Moss and the dream cast, like my cousin would.
And just, we'd all be getting mad at him.
Just like, Hey, like, there are other plays than Randall Cunningham, Randy Moss.
Well, maybe you need to join some NCAA league and then you get to have some real fun.
There you go.
Hey, ladies, adult gamers.
Exactly.
We have an opening commission.
We have a lot.
Yeah.
We have openings.
You can always join our league.
No hate yourself, but you could join.
It would, it would take me.
I like, I don't have a system beyond my game cube and my ex-wife.
Left the Wii U, which I don't think, I think it's just bricked at this point.
I was just like, no, I'm going to play breath of the wild.
I'm done with all these lists.
And I haven't still.
but yeah, I think that thing is just bricked now.
But yeah, I just still, I'm just playing MVP O five and mad and I'm just running a muck with, Ed Reed and Sean Taylor.
Sean.
All right, Pete.
I'll say this.
Like it does.
It never got better than MVP O five.
Yeah.
That was the peak.
I think you're right.
I think the physics engine on MVP O five is still just like, if it was, it was amazing.
It was, it's still, it still amazes me, tonight.
I don't think, I don't know what I'm going to do tonight, but you guys want to talk about the draft stuff before you split or you guys tapped out.
No, let's get your thoughts on that.
So I guess today, major league baseball submitted, another proposal to make high school players ineligible for the draft two years of college before they're eligible.
and then on top of that, an international draft also taking the draft from 20 to 12 rounds.
So yeah, some pretty wide sweeping changes being proposed in this next CBA, which it's crazy to think that like, I'm just looking at like Konnor Griffin, right?
Like Konnor Griffin just turned 20.
If this rule would have been in place, Konnor Griffin would be probably in home in Omaha right now playing for LSU.
I don't know if LSU is there.
I haven't been paying attention.
They're not.
They had a terrible season.
Bad year.
Yeah.
They had a bad year because if Griffin would have gone to LSU, right.
And he would have led them to Omaha.
So we could, we could change that narrative.
but yeah, like that's just crazy to think about that.
if this goes through, you're looking at Konnor Griffin, Konnor Griffin's playing college ball right now.
Yeah.
the knock on effects, if everything that the owners proposed today and really when we first started getting the inclination that the, they're negotiating now and like
Evangelic did reporting, pass and done reporting, that they had started to bandy about figures.
it was clear in some of the financial math that was put out there that MLB's proposal, what all of the details of the amateur stuff had not yet been public.
It was clear that whatever they were thinking had to be drastically different than what we have right now in terms of just how much bonus money gets spent every year.
and it had to be like halved.
So when we got these details today, and there were rumblings earlier in the week that we were going to get details on this stuff, today or tomorrow.
yeah, like if all of these changes are enacted and they might not be, that's just a bargaining chip.
As you guys mentioned, like before we hopped on, it's a thing to, fight about, the number of knock on effects to some of this stuff.
Like we get to have a whole episode, just talking about that.
Like think about if you're the, if part of how you make money is because you work for perfect game and now high school kids can't get drafted.
How do you feel right now?
If junior college game sucks, perfect game, right?
Like, and there are people who work for perfect game who are great.
And, but travel ball and travel sports, like generally it sucks.
It sucks.
My cousin's kid wrestles seriously and he's deals with like the, their version of that too.
Like it all, it sucks.
Hey, you sucks.
Travel ball sucks.
All of a sudden the, so like some of the stuff here, Hey, it might be cool.
If people cared more about college baseball, it may be is more natural for our culture to care about Florida state and Alabama.
than Bradenton pie marauders.
Maybe like, some of it is going to be a bummer.
I think some of it is weird asking like, who's going to file, who's going to file the first lawsuit to say like, Hey, I'm of age.
I could be drafted.
I could be drafted if, there's a war that requires a draft and I can't go play professional baseball.
Like there are going to be lawsuits.
There's going to be, some of that stuff.
some of it is sad.
I'm worried about the disparity between like, they've been moving, they've been moving the ball in this direction on the amateur side for a long time.
Guys like, back to Steven Strasburg, Steven Strasburg signed a major league contract.
Like you can't do that anymore.
Like it's just, it has inched like this.
Think about how much money you on Moncada signed for.
And then the Red Sox paid a hundred percent of that amount as a tax to major league baseball, Luis Robert and Shohei Ohtani signed like months apart.
And Shohei got like three mil and Luis Robert got like 40 mil because the rules changed.
And like, this is how things have been inching like this for a long time because the players union does not, at the end of the day, like their incentives are, Hey, we're all in the players union.
We've all been drafted already.
None of this really matters for us.
So why don't we concede this to the owners in exchange for this other stuff?
And so I don't think that the proposal that we got today is necessarily going to be enacted a hundred percent.
They're going to fight on some of this stuff because when you're a high school kid, and I thought, by the way, JJ Cooper did a great, like, I have notes from the details of the proposal on like, well, what, then what happens to the junior college baseball?
It's dead.
What happens to some of the minor league affiliates now that, the international kids are basically the only ones who are going to play on the complexes anymore.
Like what the gap between and all, there are all kinds of impacts like that, we could spend a lot of time sitting and thinking about JJ's piece today does not leave a whole lot of meat on the bone for discussion.
Like he reports the details of the proposal and then does a hell of a job, like bullet by point by point, just like squeezing the juice out of the whole lemon about like, and Hey, did you like Ken Griffey Jr.?
Well, he's not, you don't have a 19 year old phenom anymore because the kids can't sign until they're 20.
So, from a, from a baseball ecosystem standpoint, when you're talking about scouts and their wellbeing and, colleges, and it's like, it's a whole bunch of different things in all kinds of different directions.
I do like the idea of college baseball being more important.
I don't know how much, like ESPN is not going to have a draft broadcast this year for baseball.
Cause it just hasn't done well enough for them to do it again.
is that going to change?
I don't know, but I think that there's a shot for it to change.
I don't know if it's worth not having 19 year old Ken Griffey Jr.
And Mike Trout and Bryce Harper and, Adrian Beltre, like, eliminating what it means to our culture, our sport loving culture to have that, be a thing when it can't be a thing in any other sport.
Really?
it would be a bummer to lose that.
I think.
I think one of the counterpoint here.
I'll go ahead.
I was going to say, when Manfred introduced more or less like the baseball one initiative, like you said, you've seen like this going down this path.
And nowadays, let's be honest.
some of these major league facilities, especially in the lower levels are just trash and in comparative to a lot of the colleges, like, do you look in the sense too is like, you know what?
Sometimes maybe for the kids, like it might be better going these places because the way they have their facilities set up and whatnot, opposed to like major leagues, or modern leagues, more or less.
They got their own pitching factories going on there.
They got some outstanding facilities.
Like maybe some of these guys would be better off going to college and going through their development and then getting to the majors.
It's possible.
Yeah.
I think, some of the teams, some of the pro teams view the minor leagues as an expense and some of them view it as an investment.
And some of the college programs are big on baseball or they have enough football and basketball money floating around that they get to have the stuff you're talking about.
Like Wake Forest, wake doesn't wake football program.
I'm sure that it does well relative to their other sports in terms of like generating revenue.
and certainly their basketball team does, but like wakes pitching lab is as good as you'd find it at any facilities.
I think that, from major league baseball's perspective, I think that what's better for any individual kid is just like so specific to that kid.
that, the environment at college might be better or worse for them to be prominent in, or, I don't think an NIL money in baseball is not really a thing.
The transfer portal was a big deal, but NIL money is not like Tommy white getting money from raising canes because he had, he hit a lot of home runs as a freshman.
Like who cares?
and LSU season this year is one of those like, Hey, see, but like getting kids to transfer and building a team that way is a big deal, but I don't necessarily think that like doing it with money is a real thing in baseball.
but yeah, I think, I think that from major league baseball's perspective, this proposal is about Juan Soto's contract and Manny Machado's contract and Bryce Harper's contract.
When you debut at 19 and you're a free agent at 26, your contract is gigantic.
If you can't be drafted until you're 20, well, you're not going to be free agent until, you're 29.
That's if you move fast and those guys are minor league teams, right?
Right.
Well, part of the proposal today is, and we promise we won't reduce how many minor league affiliates there are.
We promised today.
Until 2030, right.
or maybe it's, maybe it's in 2030, we won't ask you to do it.
So, I don't know.
there's the, to me, it is a, the biggest aim with this proposal is how can we avoid a contract like Juan Soto's?
And as well, if they can't debut at 19 and they can't be free agents at 26.
So let's make, let's try to figure that out.
But, and then there's all this other window dressing and some of, some of what, major league baseball will claim is right.
It might be better for interest in the draft and the, to be propagated by the fact that you care about Michigan and Ohio state baseball now.
but I think that like the math, the way the math works out, like the players association, there's, that's the one piece of this that actually impacts them is how much money you can make with these apex free agent contracts is like a thing.
The union cares a ton about way more than how much money, the best Dominican prospect gets every year, which is a thing that over the course of the last, 20 years, they've felt free to say, ah, that doesn't really impact what we think about the CBA negotiation.
You can have Steven Strasburg's contract, whatever, just like give Paul Skenes's $9 million rather than, whatever $30 million deal Strasburg signed, like fine, we don't care.
But when you're like, ah, we can't have this $700 million contract anymore because the guy's 29 now rather than 26.
Well, now we have a problem.
And if I were, the international kids should be pissed because during COVID they pushed their signing day six months and now they want to move, they want to take a year off basically from international.
And again, like would having international draft solve some real problems so that kids and teams aren't entering into multimillion dollar verbal deals when the guys are 12 years old?
Like that's grotesque, it's grotesque.
And so having international draft gets rid of that and that's good.
And it also removes the agency of the players to be able to pick who their employer is, which isn't good.
So, it's a mixed bag and I think that there are going to be things to be excited about and probably things to be pissed about regardless of what deal.
They ultimately strike around this stuff and I look forward to the game within a game parts of it.
Like, think about how many, think about how many, 20, 28 high school graduates, if this is enacted are going to reclassify at 2027.
And then, so they can sneak in and then think about what teams, how they might behave if they're just like, well, if the draft is going to suck for the next couple of years while we wait for, while it's only college players, basically.
Then what if we blow our draft pool out this year?
Like there's going to be some of that stuff going on.
That'll be fun.
But mostly I hope that we get to kangaroo junior is the one where I just like, I can't get over how major league baseball is like, yeah, that's fine.
He can, he can just be up at 22 or whatever.
Like what guys, like, why would you want to miss out on the three or four years that these to make special, like that's part of what makes these guys, what they are is that they're doing this type of thing at, Mike Trout's doing this at age 20.
Like, holy crap, that's part of what makes him Mike Trout.
And I would never, I don't think I would ever want to lose that as a, as just a baseball fan.
Well, I think I read something today where it's like one, like really cool thing about baseball is that like, if you're watching a 19 year old major league baseball player, like there's a good chance you're watching a future hall of famer.
Yeah.
Like, and so like, that's like really cool.
and yeah, like that just goes away now.
Like there is no, sorry, Wilson better meet.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Sorry.
Wilson better.
Yeah.
Well, he's one of those guys where it's like, wasn't better meet 19.
There's a couple exceptions, but yeah, for the most part, like those guys who debut that quick, they are, they're good.
They're really good.
Well, we've been here an hour and 43 minutes talking about ball.
So it's been a while.
So I appreciate you, Eric, for coming on.
It's always a really fun time having you.
Yeah.
I love talking with you guys.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I love it.
Appreciate you there, Eric.
real quick though, the Paris tomorrow, it's a late game.
According to FanDuel, they are minus one 30 against the Colorado Rockies.
I'll be on tomorrow's post game show with, I believe Neil.
So pop on.


Comments· 0
Should the Pirates sell high on Murf Gray at the trade deadline?
No comments yet — be the first to weigh in.